This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Effectiveness Of Youth Crisis Residential Programs

1975 words - 8 pages

Nearly 20% of adolescents in the U.S. are diagnosed with mental illness each year, 10% including a serious emotional or behavioral disorder (Preyde et al., 2011). With the prevalence and severity of adolescent mental illness on the rise, it is worth devoting close scrutiny to the efficacy of different programs available to treat these youth. One type of program in need of review is the short-term, youth crisis residential program (CRP), which boasts a relatively high success rate. This paper will explore the different elements that collectively make CRPs successful for youth with mental illness, comparing and contrasting the current literature with qualitative findings from my field study. Common elements included a structured environment, family-focused approach, cooperation, and a positive focus. Implications of these findings are discussed in terms of generalizing to other treatment programs and areas in need of future research and support from the academic community.
Fieldwork was conducted primarily at the CSP Youth Shelter in Laguna Beach, California. Additionally, fieldwork was conducted while accompanying shelter residents on outings to parks, recreation centers, community workshops, and similar events.
Data were collected qualitatively in the form of extensive fieldnotes, over the course of 10 weeks. The data were then coded and analyzed to determine the primary elements crucial to the success of CRPs.
Throughout the course of my 10-week study, I observed approximately 20 youths aged 13-17. In order to be admitted to the shelter, youths must be “in crisis,” characterized by “behaviors or a history indicative of SED [serious emotional disturbance], experiencing significant familial conflict, and at-risk of hospitalization and/or out-of-home placement” (“Childrens Shelters”, n.d.). Youths met a range of diagnoses under the DSM-IV-TR, including mood disorders and personality disorders, with and without psychotic features. Depressive symptoms and behavioral problems were especially common.
Literature Review
Preyde et al. (2011) conducted a longitudinal study comparing the long-term outcomes of youth with severe mental health problems who received residential treatment (RT) with those who received intensive home-based treatment (IHT). In this study, key elements of RT included a highly structured environment, cooperative group living, individual therapy, social skills training, and family therapy. Limitations of RT include the possibility of deviancy training, inadequate discharge and reintegration n plans, a focus on child as individual rather than as a part of the family system, and a lack of family involvement. Preyde et al. sought to compare RT with IHT, an alternative that is similarly as intensive as RT, but less restrictive, allowing youth to live at home and continue attending their school. Although this is an appealing treatment option, IHT is also limited, in that it...

Find Another Essay On effectiveness of youth crisis residential programs

Evaluating the Effectiveness of Bilingual Education Programs for Kindergarten and First-Grade Levels in North Carolina

1234 words - 5 pages This paper describes an evaluation of the effectiveness of bilingual education programs in developing literacy skills for children in kindergarten and first-grade levels in North Carolina. This will be done through comparing the effectiveness of two literacy skills programs- the English-only program and English-Spanish program- in developing native and second languages’ literacy skills. The English-Spanish classes follow the transitional

A Brief History of IMF programs in Turkey and The Reasons Behind Their Ineffectiveness with The Analysis of 2001 Financial Crisis as an Example

1705 words - 7 pages A Brief History of IMF programs in Turkey and The Reasons Behind Their Ineffectiveness with The Analysis of 2001 Financial Crisis as an Example Turkey first joined to IMF in 1947. It was shortly after in 1948 that Turkey's adventure with IMF started when for the first time, Turkey applied for a financial assistance to alleviate the consequences of 1948 economic crisis.1 Thereafter, Turkish governments chose to look for help from their friend

An Analysis of the Effectiveness Security Sector Reform Based On the Programs Implemented in Palestine and Colombia

1450 words - 6 pages either a post-war or post-authoritarian society. So this begs an interesting question. How does the Security Sector Reform really contribute to sustainable peace? Is there any evidence that it actually works at all? Based on the programs active in both Colombia and the Palestinian territories, it is evident that the Security Sector Reform has had a very distinct effect on the idea of sustainable peace. There have been many attempts at reforming

Juvenile Diversion and Probation

949 words - 4 pages intervention can serve more clients per year than standard aftercare while reducing costs associated with residential commitment. On a national level juvenile arrest rates have declined to a lowest rate since 1980 (Journal of Juvenile Justice, 2012). In conclusion, studies have shown the effectiveness of family-focused support programs in some situations help the juvenile in recidivism rate. According to Journal of Juvenile Justice; “further research

Halfway Houses/Hawthorn Heights

1901 words - 8 pages alcohol use and a greater ease of transition are specifically reported as byproducts of the program. The treatment aspect provided by halfway houses seems to be an important determining factor in the success of the residential facility experience. When gauging the value of community corrections programs, specifically halfway houses and residential facilities, effectiveness refers to: “the intended impact of a criminal punishment; the necessity of

Health Outcomes

1558 words - 6 pages preventing it. In addition to the programs aimed at crisis intervention and suicide prevention, the MYCS offers transitional living arrangements for children and families in times of crisis. In addition they have facilities to assist with food and basic hygiene products in times of need. The Montgomery County Juvenile Court runs the Nicholas Residential Treatment Facility. This facility is a non-secure 24-bed unit which houses males, who have been

Crisis Intervention

1718 words - 7 pages children and youth in a wide range of educational contexts (Caplan, 1964). The mission of the National Association of School Psychologists (NASP) is to promote educationally and psychologically healthy environments for all children and youth by implementing research-based, effective programs that prevent problems, enhance independence, and promote optimal learning. This is accomplished through state-of-the-art research and training, advocacy

Review of the Literature: Suicide Prevention of Aboriginal Youth

1852 words - 8 pages that the age range for what is considered a youth in many of these studies starts as low as 8 years old and ranges all the way to 25 years old, meaning a substantial portion of this population is being affected by this crisis (MacNeil, 2008, p. 6). It is also important to note that on average, “First Nations males are at a greater risk for completed suicide but at a lower risk than females for attempted suicide” (MacNeil, 2008, p. 5). Not only

Supporting Its Youth

2537 words - 10 pages When I first enrolled in the CJC Mentoring Juvenile Justice class, my immediate image that I developed was that I would be mentoring students for their futures. It was my hope that some of the youth at Hilltop Residential Center would listen to the students from UMKC and take advantage of some of the lessons we tried to instill on the residents at Hilltop. I believed that I was fully prepared to work with and mentor the youth at Hilltop. Wasting

Violence Prevention Programs in Health Zone 1

2208 words - 9 pages . Violence prevention programs have offered excellent educational and outreach services to all elementary age children in Health Zone 1. Crisis intervention has been effective in reducing violence by allotting the child time to heal from exposure. Growing in the past several decades, violence is one of the most popular fields in the nursing profession. Methods to evaluate the effectiveness of education and crisis intervention are responsive

Juvenile Offenders: Race and Ethnicity

2146 words - 9 pages , based on clinical and educational evaluations as well as family history and severity of the current offense. As the youth approaches the completion of a residential placement, the case manager arranges for the youth to participate in community services, such as drug and alcohol treatment or counseling, as a prerequisite to his or her release. The success rates of programs under the direction of groups akin to DYS have worked in other states as

Similar Essays

The Effectiveness Of English Language Learners Programs

1620 words - 7 pages Years after most school districts in the United Stated have initiated some type of “strategy” for educating America’s, increasing ELL population,; questions about how well teachers of English Language Learners (ELL) are being trained and the effectiveness of ELL programs have arisen . For many, such topic may not be as important to some as it is to others. In retrospect, the number of ELL students grows every school year as schools districts

Predictor Variables Of Teenage Pregnancy And Effectiveness Of Prevention Programs

2956 words - 12 pages above summarized research, it is clear that there are several factors that lead to teenage pregnancy ranging from child abuse to poverty to education. Not one study showed that a single factor was the sole cause for teenage pregnancy. There are many different types of teenage pregnancy prevention services. Below is a summary of the research of the effectiveness of specific programs and types of programs.Out and Lafreniere (2001) studied the

History And Effectiveness Of Victim Rights Legislation And Programs

1546 words - 6 pages oldest national group providing assistance to victims of crime and crisis. The Law enforcement community needs to ensure the safety of the victim before, during, and after a conviction. Many times the victims of crimes are forgotten or left out of the notification process when the criminal has been apprehended, prosecutes, sentenced, or released from the system. By examining the history and effectiveness of victim rights legislation and programs, the

After School Programs: Guiding The Path Of At Risk Youth

967 words - 4 pages Today’s youth are facing serious critical risks leading to preventable crisis. There are many factors in their lives causing this downward spiral. Teens who have trouble managing the stresses of life are more likely to abuse drugs and alcohol, engage in criminal activity, are sexually promiscuous, and attempt suicide. Many of these at-risk teens become the next amber alert living on the streets or eventually behind the bars of a detention center