Eichengreen And Temin’s Explanation Of The Cause Of The Great Depression

2182 words - 9 pages

Eight decades has elapsed since the outbreak of the Great Depression, but the continuing mystery of its cause keep provoking academic debates among scholars from various fields. Eichengreen and Temin joint the debates by linking the gold-standard ideology with the cause of the Great Depression. They content that because of this ideology monetary and fiscal authorities implemented deflationary policies when the hindsight shows clearly that expansionary policies were needed. And these contractionary policies consequently pushed the stumbling world economy into the Great Depression. Eichengreen and Temin put heavy weight on analyzing why the prewar gold standard could be a force for international financial stability while interwar gold standard was the force that led the world into economic catastrophe. Their compelling arguments are important contributions to the understanding of the cause. However, by looking into the details of their explanation loopholes can also be found.

My analysis of Eichengreen and Temin’s argument falls into three parts. In the first part, I elaborate their explanation of the cause of the Great Depression and why interwar gold standard failed while its predecessor succeeded. In the second part, I highlight two aspects of the strengths of their explanation. And in the last part, the weaknesses of their studies will be examined

The cause
Eichengreen and Temin attribute the cause of the Great Depression to the mentality amongst central bankers and political leaders that the restoration of pre-WWI gold standard was essential for restoring the healthy international order and economic prosperity. They admit that the initial economic decline may begin from the Wall Street Crash of 1929 in the United States, but argue that it was through the propagation system---the gold standard that magnified the initial economic shock and turned the decline into the Great Depression ; therefore, they believe, in the context of global depression, abandoning the gold standard and allowing major currencies to depreciate were the remedies for recovery. This view is in contrast to Kindleberger’s stance that after WWI it was important to get the exchange rates fixed at equilibrium levels and it was the collapse of interwar gold standard that brought about the world depression.

One of the characteristics of gold standard defined by Temin is that the adjustment mechanism for a trade deficit country was deflation rather than devaluation, that is, a change in domestic prices instead of a change in the exchange rate. In the event of a balance-of-payment deficit, countries on the gold standard could not devalue their currencies or expand the money supply to stimulate domestic demand, because by doing so would push up good prices, encourage more gold exports, and weaken the currency. Instead, they could only tighten monetary conditions with the goal of reducing domestic prices and costs until international balance was restored. “Critical to...

Find Another Essay On Eichengreen and Temin’s Explanation of the Cause of the Great Depression

Causes of the Great Depression Essay

651 words - 3 pages economic depression started and lasted until the start of the Second World War. The three causes of the Great Depression are installment buying, uneven distribution of wealth and the irrational behavior in the stock market. Installment buying serves as the first cause of the Great Depression. In the 1920s, a large number of American families purchased automobiles, refrigerators, vacuum cleaners and similar household products on credit. Many

Causes of The Great Depression Essay

932 words - 4 pages than others. These events caused pandemonium among the public, which blew it even more out of proportion by trying to save themselves from bankruptcy. The three major events that caused The Great Depression were the Stock Market Crash of 1929, the bank crisis, and public overreaction. Although it is a semi-popular idea, it is too simplistic to view the Stock Market Crash of 1929 as the sole cause of the great depression. The “Roaring 20s

Causes of the Great Depression

755 words - 3 pages overvaluation of the pound. This meant easier money at home which made stock speculation easier, yet did not cause speculation (McElvaine 44). Another factor that lead to the Great Depression was shortsighted government economical policies. This meant that the government took no actions against unwise trading and investing. Congress also passes high tariffs that protected American industries but hurt farmers and international trade (http

Causes of the Great Depression

815 words - 3 pages Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), and the World Trade Organization (WTO). We now know to avoid another tax like the Smoot-Hawley Tariff because it will cause another catastrophic economic event like the Great Depression. Another disastrous move that caused the Great Depression was the constant purchasing of the entirety of merchandise on credit. Credit, or buying on the margin, is the equivalent of going into the Bon Marché and ordering a pair of

causes of the great depression

582 words - 2 pages The Great Depression was a decade of poverty for many United States citizens. Starting in 1929, The Great Depression was a rough time not only for the U.S. but for many other countries. There are many causes for the Depression but the main cause was the combination of the greatly unequal distribution of wealth throughout the 1920's and the extensive stock market speculation(Gusmorino, 1). Other causes were the unsteadiness of the stock market

Causes Of The Great Depression

3203 words - 13 pages the cause deem the crash of the stock market in 1929 as the real culprit. The truth behind the stock market crash is that it was the event that caused the already unstable economy to go over the limit.      If the president and the stock market crash did not cause the Great Depression, then what did? According to research done on the Great Depression, the causes rest on of different factors, but can be put under two main categories. The

Causes of the great depression

3278 words - 13 pages the real culprit. The truth behind the stock market crash is that it was the event that caused the already unstable economy to go over the limit. If the president and the stock market crash did not cause the Great Depression, then what did? According to research done on the Great Depression, the causes rest on of different factors, but can be put under two main categories. The responsibility for the Great Depression falls not only on the

The Great Depression of Canada

1363 words - 6 pages The Great Depression was not just a little event in history, hence the word “great”, but a major economical setback that would change Canada, and the world, forever. The word “great” may not mean the same thing it does now; an example of this is the ‘Great’ War. These events were not ‘good’ or ‘accomplishing’ in any way, quite the opposite, but in those times it most likely meant ‘big’. What made it big are many factors, both in the 20’s and 30

Effects Of The Great Depression

2145 words - 9 pages Effects of the Great Depression The introduction of the discussion will focus on the origins of the Great Depression and the escalating events that led to it. This will provide adequate foundations to bring up questions and attempt to answer them in an objective fashion as to why and how the Depression affected different industrialized countries in different ways. The core of the debate will consist of detailed

Films of the Great Depression

714 words - 3 pages hopeless romantic of the time, who falls in love solely for love. Through each of these movies, we gain a different perspective of the women of the Great Depression. Whether it is the important woman, the disrespected woman, the independent, manipulative woman, or the hopeless romantic, the women of the Depression show us that each side of society had a different view. Films of the Great Depression give a remarkable insight to our society’s views and opinions of the 1930’s.

Facts of the great depression

1552 words - 6 pages It may not give you why, but sure will give the facts as to what caused the depression Great paper!To my amazement the Great Depression serves as a natural debating point that 'justifies'or 'refutes' various economic policies. The Great Depression and the New Deal arecomplex topics that are open to many interpretations. The Great Depression was theworst economic slump ever in U.S. history, and one which spread to virtually all of

Similar Essays

The Cause Of The Great Depression

558 words - 2 pages The Cause of the Great Depression The economic expansion of the 1920’s, with its increased production of goods and high profits, culminated in immense consumer speculation that collapsed with disastrous results in 1929 causing America’s Great Depression. There were a number or contributing factors to the depression, with the largest and most important one being a general loss of confidence in the American economy. The reason it

Stock Market Crash As The Cause Of The Great Depression

1201 words - 5 pages were too ashamed to get help from friends. (Problems of the Great Depression) This era began as a time for prosperity, hope, and "boom", but ended up being an era of poverty, despair, and slump. The country was overwhelmed from the Big Crash of 1929. It left many people with nothing but each other. The Great Depression was definitely a terrible problem in the United States. Like every other problem, there is a root cause, and for this problem it

Was Hitler Alone The Cause Of World War Two? Essay Title Summerised Answer: Only Partly, Due To Other Reasons Such As The Treaty Of Versailles, The Great Depression And More

547 words - 2 pages set out to destroy Germany. They believed that the "invincible" German army could not have been defeated, since no allied troops had set foot in Germany during the war. German aggression was high.Another major cause to the war was the Great Depression of 1929-32. Germany was the country worst affected by the Depression. This was because Germany depended upon loans from the USA to help repay the Reparations set by the Treaty of

Causes And Effects Of The Great Depression

3996 words - 16 pages , former President Herbert Hoover offered an elaborate explanation of the Great depression, complete with footnote references to the work of many economists and other experts. "THE DEPRESSION WAS NOT STARTED IN THE UNITED STATES," he insisted. The "primary cause" was the war of 1914-18. In four-fifths of the "economically sensitive" nations of the world, including such remote areas as Bolivia, Bulgaria, and Australia, the downturn was noticeable long