Eichman V.S. U.S. Flag Burning Analysis Harvard U.S. Constitutional Law Research Analysis Paper

1142 words - 5 pages

U.S Constitutional Law
War on Flag Burning? Suppressing the Freedom of Speech or Standing up for a National Symbol
Shortly after Congress passes the Flag Protection Act of 1989; which incriminates the mutilation, defacing, burning and/or physically defiling of an American flag or any likeness of an American flag that is “commonly displayed”, Shawn Eichman with Gregory Lee Johnson, artist Scott Tyler, and Vietnam veteran David Blalock set a United States flag on fire on the steps of the U.S Capitol while protesting the government’s domestic and foreign policy. Subsequently, United States Attorneys prosecute Eichman in accordance with the statute, and since a previous, similar case ruling of Texas v. Johnson only affected Texan state laws, this case was set to serve as a test case. Federal district judges dismiss this case, citing Texas v. Johnson, then U.S Attorneys appeal to the Supreme Court. Again, similarly to the previous Texas v. Johnson case, on June 11th 1990, the Supreme Court’s holding stays at a 5-to-4 decision including Justices Brennan, Marshall, Blackmun, Scalia and Kennedy as concurring while Stevens, Rehnquist, White, O’Connor dissenting, the Court strikes down the law because “its asserted interest is related to the suppression of free expression and concerned with the content of such expression.”.
The Majority Opinion by William J. Brennan, Jr. states that in accordance with states, the Federal Government cannot incriminate a person for burning a U.S flag because doing so would be infringing the said person’s First Amendment rights. The Supreme Court illustrated that flag burning constitutes the very same expression that the First Amendment guaranteed one’s freedom to do, thereby allowing protection of the doer by the constitution. The concurring court mainly presses on the fact that the “Government's asserted interest in protecting the physical integrity of a privately owned flag” with the intent of “[preserving] the flag's status as a symbol of the Nation” is in fact suppression. The majority also declares that “mere destruction or disfigurement of a symbol's physical manifestation does not diminish or otherwise affect the symbol itself.”. The dissenting court essentially states the need to look at the circumstance in which the flag was burned and the logic behind it: such as during a time of war, or during a protest against a government action. As the concurring and dissenting courts have respectively concluded, it is both important to respect the freedom of expression embodied in the First Amendment and, be aware of the situation in which such an act of burning the flag as a symbol takes place. But then again, one cannot limit an action such as burning a national flag to ‘expression’ or ‘situation’, the very use of a national flag and the knowledge of what the symbol carries goes to show that those who burn it surpass what we define as ‘expression’ but instead use it as a method to incite violence, defeat nationalism, grab...

Find Another Essay On Eichman v.s. U.S. Flag Burning Analysis - Harvard U.S. Constitutional Law - Research Analysis Paper

Bilingual Education in U.S. Public Schools 7-pages research paper

1730 words - 7 pages Latin American Citizens, an organization originally supporting pro assimilation (Mujica 2). According to the Census statistics in 2000, 18 percent of American population over the age of 5 speaks a language other than English as their primary language (Schaefer 65), while 8 percent of them are classified as "limited English proficient" (Mujica 2). Hispanic population is the fastest growing minority in the U.S. and large parts of the country are

Constitutional Law: Federalist Paper Analysis

635 words - 3 pages of Representatives and the Senate. Much of this distinction has been lost due to time and is losing relevance given the passage of the 17th Amendment. If the House of Representatives was the sole legislative body at the time, then the legislative branch of U.S. government would entirely national, vesting the power solely in the people. This massive control of power was not what the Founders intended and was entirely antithetical to many of their

Adair v. U.S. and Coppage v. Kansas Analysis

761 words - 4 pages Adair v. U.S. and Coppage v. Kansas became two defining cases in the Lochner era, a period defined after the Supreme Court’s decision in Lochner v New York, where the court adopted a broad understanding of the due process clause of the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment. In these cases the court used the substantive due process principle to determine whether a state statute or state’s policing power violated an individual’s freedom of contract. To

Online Research Analysis Paper

1002 words - 4 pages performance. Businesses have used the internet as a research tools because it provides "an efficient channel for fast, cheap, and reliable collection and processing of marketing information, even in a multimedia format" (Principle and Practice). A good research, business analysis and plan will bring value to its customers and improve businesses bottom line. In this paper I will differentiate the different types of methodologies that are used when

Midterm Research Paper Analysis

608 words - 3 pages In 2010 a study was published by Phyllis D. Morgan, Joshua Fogel, Indira D. Tyler, and John R. Jones titled Culturally Targeted Educational Intervention to Increase Colorectal Health Awareness among African Americans. This study will be examined following an objective critique of the research conducted and reported. This analysis will show areas that could be improved and avoided in future studies and reports. This study was conducted to

Barron v Baltimore USSC Case Analysis - Constitutional Law - Legal Case Analysis

996 words - 4 pages . The state of Maryland seized Barron’s property without just compensation. In Section 1 of the 14th Amendment, it specifies “nor shall any state deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law”. Based on this amendment, The Supreme Court would rule that Barron has to receive compensation for the property that was taken by the City of Baltimore. Analysis (1) In 1833, John Barron said that the taking of his estate

Trump's Tariff on Washers compare with U.S and International. - Bus 201 - Research Paper

2209 words - 9 pages Trump's Tariffs on Foreign Washing Machines Analysis Name: Wai-Yan Htat Aung Wednesday, February 7, 2018 11:02 PM Introduction According to Ana Swanson and Brad Plumer, " WASHINGTON — President Trump slapped steep tariffs on imports of washing machines and solar energy cells and panels on Monday, the first major step by the administration to erect the kind of trade barriers Mr. Trump has frequently said are necessary to protect manufacturers in

An Analysis of the essay “Can U.S. Citizens Be Held as Enemy Combatants”

969 words - 4 pages In her essay Can U.S. Citizens Be Held as Enemy Combatants, Jennifer Vanklausen explores the ethical question of our government’s policy to hold American citizens suspected of terrorist activity against the United States as enemy combatants, withholding their constitutional rights as provided in the fifth and sixth amendments, during an undeclared war. Ms. Vanklausen relies on primary and secondary sources with strong credentials in the realm

This essay was fro an assignment to write an argumentative essay about a current event/controversial issue. Thos essay discussed the legitimacy of Megan's Law in the U.S.- it is pro- Megan's Law

1046 words - 4 pages Who Deserves Privacy?The legitimacy of Megan's Law is a heated debate that is current in our society today. This law forces all sex offenders to make themselves known to their neighborhoods. Many questions have been brought forward in an effort to alter the specifics of the law, and even abolish it. The issue is black and white and splits the population into two groups for or against the cause. Some seem to think that the specifications of the

This is a research paper on the history and career in the U.S. Navy SEALs including Bibliography

3467 words - 14 pages for troops going ashore during beach and river landings, and eventually evolved into Combat Swimmer Reconnaissance Units (SCRs) ("Navy Sea Air Land (SEAL) Teams"). These were the early stages in development of the U.S. Navy SEALs.In 1947, the Navy organized its first underwater offensive strike units. These Underwater Demolitions Teams (UDT's) took part in missions such as demolition raids on bridges, tunnels and other structures that were

Analysis of Newspaper Research Report Paper

873 words - 3 pages Analysis of Newspaper Research Report Paper Obesity is on the rise in the United States in both adults and children. On average, 30% of children suffer from obesity and over the past years recognition of the disease and its consequences have elevated nevertheless, the disease remains untreated and undiagnosed (Moran, 1999). Studies show that overweight children are at a statistically greater probability of developing health issues, which

Similar Essays

Constitutional Issues And The Scope And Character Of The U.S. Government: Free Speech Ashford University Pol 303 Research Paper

3078 words - 13 pages 1 Running Head: CONSTITUTIONAL ISSUES 11 CONSTITUTIONAL ISSUES Constitutional Issues and the Scope and Character of the U.S. Government: Free Speech Niamh Moore Ashford University POL 303 Prof. Lawrence Olson August 21, 2017 Constitutional Issues and the Scope and Character of the U.S. Government: Free Speech Free Speech has afforded American citizens the right to express themselves freely. It’s, arguably, the most contested part of our

U.S. Coast Guard Maritime Law Enforcement

2728 words - 11 pages /TopFiveThreatstoNationalSecurityintheComingDecade.aspx Peer, D. (2012). Closing the gap: Enhanced maritime security cooperation and awareness. Maritime Security Occasional Paper No. 16. Nova Scotia: Centre for Foreign Policy Studies, Dalhousie University. Ridenour, D. A. (2006). Ratification of the law of the sea treaty: A not-so-innocent passage. National Policy Analysis. Retrieved 23 November 2013 from http://www.nationalcenter.org/NPA542LawoftheSeaTreaty.html U.S. Coast Guard Office of

Economic Analysis Of The U.S. 2001 2003

2609 words - 10 pages Economic Analysis of The U.S. 2001-2003      Economics have many indicators to describe how it runs. The indicators can show if the economy has improved or declined. The economic indicators that will be focused on in this analysis of the United States economy from 2001 – 2003 will be the consumer price index, the imports and exports, the unemployment rate, and finally the gross domestic product. Now while most may know

Compare Or Contrast The U.S. Constitution With The Haudenosaunee Great Law Of Peace

653 words - 3 pages corrections of mistakes that appear on consumer credit accounts.Lemon Law Site 2Explain who the Lemon Law protects.The Lemon Law covers the purchase of ______ ________. The Lemon Law says that the __________________ is responsible for taking care of the defects. 4. Below are some specific guidelines/discussions that relate to the Lemon Law. Answer these questions after you have thoroughly read the course information about the Lemon Law.A. If a car