Eight Men Out Essay

2132 words - 9 pages

Eight Men Out In the golden days of baseball, where the heros became legends and young fans could actually afford to pay to attend the games, an incident that would scar baseball for life was committed in the World Series of 1919. Based on the Elliot Asinof's 1963 best-seller of the 1919 Black Sox Scandal, Eight Men Out is an attempt to tell the story of how the White Sox were hired by gamblers to throw World Series. Film maker John Sayles brings in a variety of well- known actors to play roles of players, gamblers, and everyone else that is involved in the scandal. However, the movie concentrates more on the events leading up to the scandal and the personalities of the characters, and overlooks minor, but extremely important, details that leave any avid baseball fan questioning it consistency. Bill James, in his Historical Baseball Abstract, makes very clear the underlying problems with making a movie about the Black Sox Scandal. James, as well as many others, feels as though the problems with making a movie about that topic is that it engages the emotions of the audience. He points out that, "Unlike a book, a movie is more of something you experience than learn about, and as such, for a movie to work, one must, as a viewer, share in the experience of one of the characters" (pg.108). Since this story is about ballplayers who threw games and accepted bribes, this poses a difficult problem in asking the audience to share the feelings of the conspirators. That is the problem throughout the movie that Sayles fails to resolve. Where do the audience's sympathies lie? It is hard to maintain sympathy for the players with the likes of Swede Risberg and Chic Gandil behind the fix. Players like Buck Weaver and "Shoeless Joe Jackson", who are portrayed as pawns in a game of chess, are overwhelmed by the gamblers and other players involved. One could say that Sayles sees the team members as underpaid and unappreciated by team owner Charles Comiskey, and the results of the tension that existed between the players and the owner was the fixing of the 1919 Series. Sayles shows us the individual players going all out, running hard, dive for balls, stretching doubles into triples, and risking injury to win the pennant. The mood quickly changes as the players being ecstatic, having won the pennant, turning to anger and malcontent after their promised bonus turns out to be flat champagne. Sayles emphasizes the dissention between Comiskey and the players by staging a scene between pitcher Eddie Cicotte and the cold owner. Cicotte, on a technicality, is not given the $10,000 bonus he was to receive for winning 30 games. Cicotte in fact only won 29 games, and implies that Comiskey purposely benched him so he couldn't win 30. Sayles's sympathy for Cicotte is clear in the movie when Ring Lardner (played by Sayles himself) responds to Comiskey's praise of his players by stating, "If he is such a fan, why doesn't he pay them a...

Find Another Essay On Eight men out

12 Angry Men: The Importance of Personality in Negotiation

1191 words - 5 pages people exhibit during negotiations when determining how the negotiation will unfold. In the movie “Twelve Angry Men”, juror number eight demonstrates an understanding of the effect of personality and behavior when building relationships, setting moods, and gaining power (Fonda & Rose, 1957). To understand the effect personality has on negotiation one must first understand what personality is. According to Berens and Nardi, personality is both

Confesisons Essay

785 words - 4 pages In the video “The Confessions” presented by Frontline, a murder of a women that was committed by one man, quickly resulted into a false gang murder-rape scene committed by eight men. The victim, Michelle Bosko, was seen to be raped and killed in her apartment in Norfolk, Virginia. From the video, it has been proven that seven out of the eight men that confessed were innocent, but somehow they all received an unequal punishment. Because the

Logic of an Article

911 words - 4 pages about who knows their sexual preference. 3) What criticisms can be concluded? • Small participation rate. Study only covered a total of twenty-seven men: fifteen self-identified gay men and 12 self-identified straight men. • For having such a small participation rate, the age range was extremely wide covering men eighteen to forty-eight • The research was very controlled in that the group of men observed seven pre-recorded videos, rather than

The Differences Between Men and Women

1294 words - 5 pages have always come in second to men. It begins in the hospital, boys get blue blankets whereas girls get pink. Then it is established in the household, the daughter does the dishes and helps mom with laundry, where as the son takes out the trash and lends a hand to his father building a doghouse. According to Student One, “throughout history, women were always the stay at home type who always cooked and cleaned and left the ‘dirty’ work for the men

the 1919 world series

743 words - 3 pages seven were won by the White Soxs in an effort to make the World Series look truthful. The Chicago White Soxs let the Reds take game eight and win the World Series. Due to the closeness of the games in the World Series, most people thought nothing of it. (MLB) However, the truth eventually came out and the World Series was changed and influenced heavily thereafter. These eight men and anyone that has ever accepted a bribe or just thrown a game in

Depression's Double Standard. Why Depression Affects Women More Than Men

401 words - 2 pages Kristen Leutwyler's article in Scientific American magazine points out how much more severely women are affected by depression than men. Over the past few years, researchers have been studying numerous cases of depression and have found that in nearly every case, women are affected by depression nearly twice as much as men. This phenomenon went undiscovered for quite a while and even since it's discovery, little has been done to determine why


762 words - 3 pages the death rate in Korea. In conclusion, we have to accept the fact men were not flexible enough to stand the challenges of different world. Because the world is still male dominance society. But if men stick to their ego and not to try to develop their identity, it can hurt them more and more. I think that is our generation's job to find out what is the meaning of "new-man".

A Room of 12 Angry Men

1298 words - 6 pages , everyone voted guilty. It was an open and shut case. All the evidence was there. It was clear the boy committed the crime. Now everyone could go home, but, wait, there was one person whose vote did not match the others. One person cared. One person saw it; what America is supposed to be. Juror number eight. In fury all the men turned on him. What was he thinking? Did he think it was funny to keep them there, away from their lives? It was an obvious

Dynasty Debate

885 words - 4 pages wheelbarrow was invented by Chuko Liang (181-234 A.D.), and was used to transport supplies for injured soldiers. The Chinese wheelbarrows had two wheels and required two men or an ox to operate and turn.They also improved the plows, by making them completely out of iron, and improving the moldboard technology. Now, the plows were able to invert the soil well and make a true furrow. (a long, narrow indentation in a surface). That meant that the

The Jack Kevorkian Trial

1549 words - 7 pages word. Eight would feel that Kevorkian is guilty but wouldn't want to send him off until he is persuaded that he is guilty. Eight commented, “I don’t want to change your mind” (Rose 7). Eight wouldn’t try to make another person vote against what he is thinking . He would just have one think about what one is about to do. If Eight was on the Jack Kevorkian jury, then he would have voted guilty. Judging by his actions in Twelve Angry Men

The Problem of Groupthink in 12 Angry Men

1102 words - 4 pages The term groupthink in this report is defined as, the social psychological phenomenon that results in groups during pressure situations. This social psychology theory is broken down into eight signs. Illusion of invulnerability, Collective rationalization, Belief in inherent morality, Stereotyped views of out-groups, Direct pressure on dissenters, Self-censorship, Illusion of unanimity, Self-appointed “mindguards”. According to research

Similar Essays

Analysis Of 12 Angry Men

929 words - 4 pages give up until the other jurors changed their mind about the verdict. He didn’t let any of his emotions get out of hand. He was calm and easy going didn’t get into any arguments with the other jurors, and he explained himself many times without getting angry with anyone. This juror, juror number eight, was the only one who believed the young man was innocent. He led the other jurors to understand why all the evidence against the young man

Research Results Relating To Women's Participation In Sport And Media Coverage Of Women's Sport

390 words - 2 pages women's participation in sport• Fewer women are involved in regular physical activity and sport than men. Estimated percentage of Austral ians, 14 years and over, who participate in organised sport:Male 24% Female 16%• Among registered sports participants, women are out numbered by men by more than 3 to 1. Of 6.5 million registered participants in sport in Australia in 1990, 1.5 million were female. Percentage of total sports

Battle Of The Sexes, Who Is More Superior , Man Or Woman?

591 words - 2 pages skinny frail men who switch roles and that is perfectly fine. This becomes a problem when the massive dumb man wants to be a successful secretary with his amazing eight words per minuit typing speed and the skinny little twig woman wants to be a lumberjack. Men and women have to realize that some jobs are meant for someone more fitting then what they are.When god created women, he gave them the ability to have children. This advantage kind of

Saving Private Ryan By Steven Spielburg

1510 words - 7 pages , Captain Miller and his seven soldiers begin their mission. The dilemma is Private Ryan, in the 101st airborne, was miss his drop zone away from the original plan. Command thinks he is in a nearby town swarming with German soldiers. Miller’s squad goes through towns, forests, and enemy occupied areas searching for Private Ryan. Sadly, two out of the eight men are killed during the search diminishing the morale. The captain mentally suffers from