Elaine Of Astolat In Tennyson's The Lady Of Shalott And Lancelot And Elaine

2882 words - 12 pages

Elaine of Astolat in Tennyson's The Lady of Shalott and Lancelot and Elaine

    The Arthurian legends have fascinated people over the centuries with tales of kings, noble ladies, knights, magicians, love, and death. Among those who wrote about King Arthur's reign was Alfred, Lord Tennyson. One of his poems, "The Lady of Shalott," became immensely popular for its moving pathos and mystery. Yet, the poem was based on a character from Arthurian legends - Elaine of Astolat. Several years after composing the poem, Tennyson wrote directly about Elaine's tragic love affair with Sir Lancelot in "Lancelot and Elaine," found in his epic piece Idylls of the King.  Although both poems share many of the same features, they portray the two ladies quite differently from one another. The Lady of Shalott is a fairy of sorts, residing in a magical world, while Elaine is a purely human character according to Arthurian legends. The differences are quite apparent when viewed according to the women's family structure, interaction with society, presence of magical elements, and manner of death. Thus, despite their many similarities, Tennyson makes each into a unique and completely separate figure.


    Both the Lady of Shalott and Elaine of Astolat share numerous similarities in their lives. Even the places they live possess a similar name. Most of the scenes in "The Lady of Shalott" take place in a tower. Likewise, Elaine retreats to a tower where she keeps Sir Lancelot's shield. Lilies surround each lady, literally and figuratively. Tennyson says that "the lilies blow / Round an island there below, / The island of Shalott" ("The Lady of Shalott" lines 7-9). Similarly, he calls Elaine "the lily maid of Astolat" ("Lancelot and Elaine" 2). Both ladies occupy their time by weaving or embroidering. William E. Buckler compares Elaine to the Lady by stating:


The "case of silk" that she decorates for Lancelot's shield has its counterpart in the Lady's storied tapestry; it is Lancelot who, here again unintentionally, motivates her fatal decision; like the Lady, she approaches Camelot in a mysterious funeral barge; and as Lancelot had in the earlier poem "mused a little space," in the idyll he "later came and mused at her." (113)


When comparing both poems, one sees many surface parallels in the two women's lives. Nevertheless, a deeper reading reveals manifold differences between the ladies

as individuals.


Completely alone, the Lady lives a life of seclusion revealed by the lines "And the silent isle imbowers / The Lady of Shalott" ("The Lady of Shalott" 17-18). Tennyson never mentions anyone other than the Lady as an occupant of the island. She has no apparent family members to guide or help her in any way. She has no one with whom to converse while inside the castle. In fact, she has no given name, simply a title. On the other hand, Elaine has a father and two older brothers to keep her...

Find Another Essay On Elaine of Astolat in Tennyson's The Lady of Shalott and Lancelot and Elaine

Tennyson’s The Lady of Shalott Essay

1608 words - 6 pages ? I ask why and yet I know, Tennyson, that the answer doesn’t lay within your graceful poem. Ophelia floating down the river after drowning in her dreamy dress, Sleeping Beauty laying there helplessly, Lady of Shalott floating down the river, captivating their audiences. These stories stir my anger more than Sir Lancelot, who only sees a pretty face, and yet I delight in each tale and I delight in this poem. Please allow me a moment

The Highwayman by Alfred Noyes and Lord Tennyson’s The Lady of Shalott

1994 words - 8 pages darkly beautiful innkeeper’s daughter, Bess. ‘The Lady of Shalott’ is a mysterious poem set in the mythical time of legend Camelot. It is also a tragic love story in which the Lady of Shalott, who is cursed to stay in her tower and not look out of the window, dies for her love because she looks out of the window at Sir Lancelot. The highwayman himself is a romantic hero of the 18th century. He is very well dressed, with ‘a French cocked

Portrayal of Women in La Belle Dame Sans Merci, Lady of Shalott, My last Duchess, and Porphyria's Lover

1123 words - 4 pages judgements can be placed upon the men themselves. The social/historical position of women during the nineteenth century can be identified within the poems. Browning's dramatic monologues in particular show women's lack of voice and dependency on men during the eighteen hundreds. Showing both women as possessions of men. The powerlessness of women is shown within Tennyson's poems; 'Mariana' and ' The Lady of Shalott

Elaine Showalter-The Female Tradition

2604 words - 10 pages . Certain areas of experience and knowledge such as sexuality, passion, ambition and male transcendence (as propounded in Simone De Beauvoir's theory) lied beyond the ambits of the Victorian 'angel in the house' or 'the Perfect Lady' and therefore were suppressed by women in their writing through practices of displacement (as seen in Lydia's case in Pride and Prejudice), splitting of self (as seen in Jane Eyre through the figures of Jane and Bertha

"Equity Theory and Research: An Overview" by Elaine Hatfield

1186 words - 5 pages In the reading "Equity Theory and Research: An Overview" by Elaine Hatfield, she explains about the four propositions the equity theory is based upon. She explains that the first proposition is where individuals try to maximize their outcomes. For example, an employer may pay it's employees much less that they deserve which results in greater profits for that individual and maybe not thinking of the consequences this may bring, such as workers

Analytical paper on the tragic figure of Lancelot in T.H White's "Once And Future King"

1834 words - 7 pages the bad things he had done. Although held up to almost godlike stature in T.H. White's novel The Once And Future King, Lancelot was truly the most human character of them all.Lancelot's childhood was spent sequestered, training to be a knight in order to escape from his ugliness and give him something to be proud of. Lancelot wanted to be a knight because he felt that he was a depraved, lubricious soul. His hideously twisted visage was a sure

Explain in detail the symbolism used by Alfred, Lord Tennyson in his poem "The Lady of Shalott

1204 words - 5 pages glassy countenance.Although she knows visiting Camelot further invites the curse already upon her, she feels drawn to the town where Lancelot has ridden. Unafraid, she lays down in the shallow boat, not knowing that it will soon be her coffin.While the Lady of Shalott is in transit, the reader receives more detail that borrows imagery from a funeral. She lies "robed in snowy white," and sings her "last song." Although black traditionally represents

The Creation of Lancelot and the Undoing of the Once and Future King

2378 words - 10 pages their voice to the telling of the Arthurian legend; adding events and characters, ultimately changing the story forever. Perhaps the most notable of these additions came in the form of Sir Lancelot. The creation of Lancelot, a knight introduced by Chrétien de Troyes in The Knight of the Cart, produced an underlying futile battle for top billing between Arthur and his top knight. The inclusion of Sir Lancelot in works such as, The Vulgate Cycle and

Reality of War in Crane's War is Kind and Tennyson's Charge of the Light Brigade

1857 words - 7 pages Reality of War in Crane's War is Kind and Tennyson's Charge of the Light Brigade         An overwhelming tendency to fight and battle has plagued humankind since the dawn of the written word. Countless wars have been fought since the dawn of man and most times such conflict exists simply for its own sake with no productive end. Immense human suffering and death can be caused by conflicts that hold little logical justification. Since the

"The Lady of Shalott" by William Holman Hunt: Fallen Woman to Feminist

2769 words - 11 pages revolutionary feminist concepts are repeatedly reflected in the satirical Victorian magazine, Punch or The London Charivari. By analyzing the history of this notorious painting, the Pre-Raphaelite poses relating to feminism, the medieval and Arthurian nature of the painting in relation to fairy tales, the significance of Tennyson's passing, and the reaction to the backlash, we can clearly see that Hunt's painting of The Lady of Shalott influenced not

Compare and Contrast Tennyson's The Charge of the Light Brigade and Owen's Dulce Et Decorum Est

2637 words - 11 pages Charge of the Light Brigade’ is only shown because Tennyson's looking at war from afar .We can see this because in the poem he has not used descriptive language to describe what war was like, and has not shown the real outcome of war. In contrast, ‘Dulce Et Decorum Est’ gives us the complete opposite. It takes away the lie that describes the war as a place of pleasure and vividness. When in reality it is a place of carnage and apprehension

Similar Essays

An Explication Of Tennyson's The Lady Of Shalott

1160 words - 5 pages because she realized her love for Lancelot was futile?  These are questions that may stay on your mind after reading Tennyson's poem.  Even today it is possible to feel the infinite struggle the Lady of Shalott had to face.  Tennyson shows the development of a young lady who is dealing with one of the most difficult times in life, growing up in a world full of rules and restrictions while becoming a woman.  His subtle description of a girl's

The Lady Of Shalott And Industrialized Misery

543 words - 2 pages they sped up industry and the making of material wealth for the well to-do.  This loss of innocence is echoed in Tennyson's Arthurian lyrical poem "The Lady of Shalott" (Longman pp. 1913-1918).   Subtly expressing his opinion of the times in prose, he illustrated how deadly and destructive it is to look for experience and to change the peaceful past due to yearning for worldly pursuits.  The Lady is isolated on the island of

The Lady Of Shalott Essay

1643 words - 7 pages might ask him-/herself why the Lady of Shalott is stuck in such a dreadful situation and why she does not attempt to do anything about it. There is a constant increase of tension attained by the use of iambic and trochaic tetrameter and an -aaaa bcccb- rhyme scheme repeating in each stanza. This is always interrupted by sudden drops produced by the plosive sound 't' as in 'Camelot';, 'Shalott'; or 'Lancelot'; in lines 5 and 9. The whole scheme could

Literary Analysis: "Ulysses" And "The Lady Of Shalott"

1289 words - 5 pages Shalott (The Lady of Shalott 114).” Sir Lancelot entrance caused The Lady of Shalott’s belief in self to emerge. As she ventured through Camelot, she came across a boat and takes her time to print her name. “Down she came and found a boat / Beneath a willow left afloat, / And around about the prow she wrote/ The Lady of Shalott (“The Lady of Shalott” 72).” After finding the purpose in life, her identity is quickly shattered by having to engrave