This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Electoral Reform In Canada: An Examination Of Proportional Representation

2765 words - 11 pages

Democracy is often said to be a form of government in which the population as a whole chooses between public policies or among those who wish to handle the authority of the state. Therefore, the process by which the people of a society decide who will occupy political offices in a democracy is a central element in how their society will work. This process is known as the electoral system and because of their importance in liberal democracies, electoral systems have frequently been the focus of intense scholarly debate. Electoral reform in Canada has been a main focus of these debates and "proportional representation (PR) is currently proposed as a solution to a large number of the country's ills" (Fitzgerald, 2001, 49). There clearly are many advantages for a country to adopt a PR system, however, in Canada, the adoption of such a system could have potential negative consequences thus making it an unfavorable system to adopt. First, this essay will take a detailed look at Canada's electoral system today, illustrate the problems it has produced, and give a brief outline of the PR system. Secondly, the advantages of adopting such a system in Canada will follow. Finally, this paper will look at the arguments of those opposed to the PR system, and eventually determine whether or not such a system can work for Canada.1. Canada's Electoral System and the Need for Reform1.1 Canada's Electoral SystemThe first-past-the-post (FPTP), single member district electoral system is Canada's present electoral system, and is believed to have produced a startling record of distortion, misrepresentation, and impaired governance in Canadian federal elections. In an article written in 1968, Alan Cairns documented many of the distortions that the Canadian electoral system has produced over the period from 1921 to 1965, and argued that the cumulative effects of these on political parties and representation in Canada were very real and serious (Cairns, 1968). The system of elections in Canada is thought to have created a number of problems that may be contributing to the anger and distrust of government felt by many Canadians (Milner, 1999, 39). An alternative system, according to Michael Cassidy (1995) in his evaluation of electoral systems, "would have to achieve a greater degree of fairness in the composition of the legislature without abandoning traditional ideas of party representation and stable government in Canada" (p. 323).1.2 Proportional RepresentationIt is believed by many that the proportional representation system can overcome the problems in Canada's present electoral system. Under PR, representatives are elected from multi-seat districts in proportion to the number of votes received (Deverell, 1993). PR assures that political parties or candidates will have the percent of legislative seats that reflects their public support thus making the system fairer.2. Advantages of the Proportional Representation System2.1 Accuracy of the VoteThe concept of fairness...


The Potential of a Majoritarian Electoral System Instead of a Proportional Electoral System in South Africa

1345 words - 5 pages . The majoritarian and proportional representation systems are the two most common electoral systems which decide how votes are translated into seats. The majoritarian electoral system could be divided into plurality or an absolute majority (Norris, 1997: 299). Plurality aims to create a manufactured majority via exaggerating the share of seats for the leading party to an effective working majority for the government, while hindering the process of

An Examination of Teach for America as a Reform Model

2312 words - 10 pages Two Years of Magical Thinking An Examination of Teach for America as a Reform Model EDUC 532 Antoinette Davis March 28, 2014 In the 1980s, Wendy Kopp wrote a thesis detailing a reform that could be replicated in public schools across America. Modeling her idea after the Peace Corps, she named it Teach for America. This reform effort is a top down approach, focusing on teacher training and teacher

Proportional Representation Voting Should Be Enforced in Democratic States

696 words - 3 pages The concept of representation in a political state that embraces a democratic system is determined by its capability to include a plurality of views when creating legislation. Election systems in a democratic government should, thus, aid and enforce the proportional representation of most politically active members of the state. As depicted by the International Institute for Democracy and Election Assistance (IDEA), “The purpose of an

The Pros and Cons of Proportional Representation (PR)

1412 words - 6 pages that crisis and should be replaced as part of a plan to reconstitute the democratic culture (Kelly 2008). By longstanding critics of the system, opponents advocate the use of proportional representation (PR) for selecting MPs. Due to this problem it is going to be a referendum on changing the electoral system of the country's parliamentary elections. Arguments in favor of the adoption of proportional representation in UK have been made much more

Electoral Thresholds and the Representation of Women

5199 words - 21 pages takes all. When there is more than one seat, women are seen as less risky. The two houses of the Australian legislature are an extreme example of the impact of proportional representation. In Australia, the House is traditionally composed almost exclusively of men, while the Senate has better female representation. The cause for this is almost definitely the electoral law which mandates an absolute majority for House seats, but a closed list PR

Changing the Electoral System in Canada

2040 words - 9 pages Systems." Trinity College Press 10.1 (1991): 33-51. Web. Milner, Henry. "Obstacles to Electoral Reform in Canada." American Review of Canadian Studies 24.1 (1994): 39-55. Print. Sachs, Jeffrey. The Price of Civilization: Reawakening American Virtue and Prosperity. New York: Random House, 2011. 107. Print. Schwartz, Bryan. "Proportional Representation for Canada." Manitoba Law Journal 28.2 (2001): 133. Web. 14 Mar. 2014. Spafford, Duff. "Does

An Explanation of representation in U.S. Government

759 words - 3 pages In a Representative Government there must be representation. In the case of the U.S., that representation comes from the United States Congress. Congress was created through the Constitution as an intrinsic part of the government. The Constitution establishes a delineation of powers; Congress has three very important powers, the legitimacy to use those powers, and the consequences if those powers are abused.Congress has significant power, but it

An examination of identity in Orwell's "1984"

742 words - 3 pages In "1984", George Orwell paints his vision of life in an age where totalitarianism has eradicated individuality, choice and personal identity. In the context of a modern dystopia in the grip of political megalomania, Orwell raises a number of concerns in connection with modern society and the human race, while highlighting the importance of preserving individual identity. While still a novel, 1984's core themes are pertinent to our current world

Time for reform? considering the failures of the electoral college in the US

1882 words - 8 pages TIME FOR REFORM? CONSIDERING THE FAILURES OF THE ELECTORAL COLLEGEDescription: This paper discusses the many shortcomings of the ElectoralCollege, and posits possible alternative electoral processes which likely bemore democratic.Time for Reform?Considering the failures of the Electoral CollegeA common misconception among American is that when they vote they elect the President. The truth is notnearly this simple. What in fact happens when a

Arguments For and Against a System of Proportional Representation for Westminister Elections

1235 words - 5 pages For Westminster elections the present electoral system is called first-past-the-post (FPTP) which is considered as unfair and undemocratic in many aspects, such as giving a disproportionate number of seats to parties for their percentage of votes received. So the issue of electoral reform to a proportional representation (PR) system which is used throughout Europe has arisen. Under a PR electoral system, a party's

Examination and Problematization of the Representation of Old Age and Aging in Up

2603 words - 11 pages creating alternative forms of masculinity for older male to, essentially, contradict a widely accepted declining narrative on old people. Almost from the beginning, this animated film presents the audience with a character of an old and lonely widower, Carl Fredriksen. He is depicted as a methodical, set-in-his-ways, bad-tempered and sulky man. He rises up at 6.00 AM with the sound of an alarm clock, straightens his back with much struggle

Similar Essays

Electoral Reform In Canada Essay

1870 words - 7 pages Legislative Democracy in December 2003 to the groundbreaking decision by the British Columbia Citizen’s Assembly on October 24, 2004 that the province will have a referendum on May 17, 2005 to decide whether or not they will switch to a system of proportional representation. This kind of reform is only expected to continue, as Ontario Premier Dalton McGuinty decided to take BC’s lead and form an independent Citizen’s Assembly with the power to

Canada' Needs Proportional Representation Essay

1937 words - 8 pages votes, and only need to garner more votes than their opponents. The successful candidate wins all the seats in their riding or constituency while the candidates who places second or third will receive no seats, regardless of how many votes they lose by. Proportional representation is the second form of electoral system used in Canada; the percentage of the votes received by a party is proportionate to the number of seats they receive. In this sense

Should Canada Adopt Proportional Representation? Essay

947 words - 4 pages Should Canada Adopt Proportional Representation?The purpose of an election is to provide a routine mechanism for selecting the individuals who will occupy seats in representative institutions. They provide citizens with periodic opportunities to review the government's record, assess its mandate, and possibly replace it with an alternative. There is a great variety of electoral systems, and they can engender radically different government

Review Of “Electoral Reform Proposal Failures In Canada”

960 words - 4 pages and might potentially use the article as an academic source. This review will seek to analyze the strengths and weaknesses of the author’s arguments and evaluate its significance to potential readers. The main argument that Lawrence Leduc tries to propose in his article is that there has been a history of electoral reform proposals that have failed in Canada. Moreover the article also serves two intriguing purposes that the readers