Elements Of Comparison Between Hill’s Like White Elephants And The Birthmark

1604 words - 6 pages

Both “Hill’s like White Elephants” by Ernst Hemingway and “The Birthmark” by Nathaniel Hawthorne have many common elements of comparison between them. The main element of the stories that will be compared is this thought of an operation. Both stories stem from these two operations and the comparisons derive from how the women react and respond to the two men in the story. Both stories are comparable by the common theme of a life changing operation, how the women first react to the operation and how the characters develop throughout the stories.
There is a common theme in “Hill’s like White Elephants” and “The Birthmark” of a life altering decision. Both women are thinking about having an operation that will affect them for the rest of their lives. In “Hill’s like White Elephants”, Jig and the American are debating whether or not they should have an abortion. This decision is something that will affect both of them deeply throughout their lives together. By the way the two characters interact with each other the reader can deduce how important they feel the operation is. There seems to be a tension in their sentences with each other. Jig says things like “Everything tastes of licorice. Especially all the things you've waited so long for” and “That's all we do, isn't it-look at things and try new drinks” (Hemingway 841)? These responses to the American show that Jig is in a distasteful state of mind which would most likely stem from her thoughts about the operation and what they will do in regard to it. Because these thoughts of the operation are affecting her socially, it shows just how important the operation is to her. How Jig interprets the scenery around them while they are discussing the operation also suggests the importance of their decision. “The girl was looking off at the line of the hills. They were white in the sun and the country was brown and dry” (Hemingway 840). This statement also gives the reader imagery, insight and symbolism into Jig’s thoughts about the operation. The white hill’s and the dry brown countryside represent the two outcomes of their decision. The white sunlit hills represent Jig being happy and content with her decision. The brown dry countryside, on the other hand, represents her as sad and regretful after making the wrong decision in terms of the operation. These examples show that she has to come to a verdict on something that will affect her for the rest of her life. In “The Birthmark”, Aylmer and Georgiana are debating whether or not to have a birthmark Georgiana has on her face removed. Aylmer, Georgiana’s husband, brought up the subject of having her birthmark removed by asking if “it never occurred to you that the mark upon your cheek might be removed" (Hawthorne 1)? Because she has had this birthmark her whole life, everyone knows of the mark and they, in a sense, identify her with it. For her to have this mark removed from her face is almost to change her identity from what everyone knows her by....

Find Another Essay On Elements of Comparison between Hill’s Like White Elephants and The Birthmark

Hills Like White Elephants Essay

678 words - 3 pages Many literary works today require further reading and knowledge in order to better understand the readers own interpretation. In many works, there are many aspects that play a role in the whole understanding of the story. Some of these include symbols and theme that can be depicted from reading the short story. In Hills Like White Elephants, many readers will be able to tell give a summary of the story, tell the theme, and symbols that are given

Hills Like White Elephants Essay

1031 words - 4 pages Husain Abbas 2J - Mr. Vernon 14th March 2014Hills like white Elephants by Ernest HemingwayErnest Hemingway's "Hills Like White Elephants" is one of the most famous short stories published in the 20th century. Initially viewed as a simple, even dull, depiction, it is revealed upon evaluation to be a profound examination of the lack of communication between men and women. The use of the landscape specifically the hills mentioned in the title

Hills Like White Elephants

1790 words - 7 pages concept and nature of the story should be found under the surface and should shine through, and one of the surface elements that he used to perform this Iceberg Theory of writing was symbolism. In the short story "Hills Like White Elephants", Hemingway effectively utilizes symbolism to present the reader with many symbolic instances included in the setting, characters, and objects, which all provide a surface meaning for the story, but with

Hills Like White Elephants

2545 words - 11 pages "Hills like White Elephants" is a story written by Ernest Hemingway where one can draw many parallels between the American and the writer himself. Hemingway uses the tools of allusion and symbolism frequently throughout the story in order to help him illustrate the main issue of communication breakdown. This evidently played a key role in Hemingway's own life and it becomes apparent that through this, there are similarities between the behavior

Hills Like White Elephants

967 words - 4 pages Principles of iceberg bring the story all together. Without the understanding of these two genres and their roles in this short story, the point Hemingway was try to make would have been a blur. The characters were doing their best with Hemingway’s help to aid readers into understand what they are trying to utter, but it fell short without reading in between the lines. “Hills like White Elephants” live up to the quote, “the essence of profound

hills like white elephants

789 words - 3 pages Hemmingway's "Hills Like White Elephants"Ernest Hemmingway's "Hills Like White Elephants" is not a story in the clasicalsense with an introduction, a development of the story, and an end. We only get sometime in the life of two people, as if it were just a piece of a film where we have a lot dodeduce. This story does not give everything done for the reader, we only see thesurface of what is going on. It leaves an open end, readers can have their

hills like white elephants

1893 words - 8 pages setting, characterization, and a clever poking of view in “Hills Like White Elephants”, Ernest Hemmingway desires readers to relate to the relationship of his main characters to not only realize that manipulation can be going on in their situation, but without an effective communication between two people things will go unsaid and could possibly end with someone doing something they did not want to do. Throughout “Hills Like White Elephants”, Ernest

Hills Like White Elephants - 1093 words

1093 words - 4 pages Narrative Fiction Essay Hills Like White Elephants English 1B Human relationships are very important in our lives. We need someone with whom we can share our thoughts, happiness, sadness, dreams and for some of us, perhaps our whole life with. These items, our natural desires are the basis of relationships. In the short story, Hills Like White Elephants we are presented with the story of two people, a man and a girl, a situation, pregnancy, and

Hills Like White Elephants - 874 words

874 words - 3 pages Is It Black or White? Differing points of view are just an everyday fact of life. Everyone has their own way of seeing things. Some see the glass half full, while others see the glass half empty. Then there is the old cliché is it black or is it white. In the short story "Hills Like White Elephants", Ernest Hemingway contrasts the points of view of two characters of differing gender through opposing opinions about abortions and

hills like white elephants

1421 words - 6 pages Gema PerezMs. LovettAP LiteratureRelationships Parallel to Gender Roles in Hills Like White ElephantsOf all the issues roiling on the ongoing culture in the 1920's abortion was both the most intimate and the most common one. Almost half of every American women terminated at least one pregnancy, in which those women have been testimony for abortion as a crime. In America abortion was illegal but possible; abortion has been legal since 1973 but

Like white elephants

766 words - 3 pages created when the characters have to deal with something serious. This essay will attempt to explain the effects of these comic elements. Cordelia and Daniel's relationship is the most interesting because of the way they converse with each other. There is always an atmosphere of humour/teasing when they have a conversation. When Cordelia 'jokingly' questions whether Daniel still sees Benjamin secretly, Daniel jokingly replies "...I love you. I've

Similar Essays

Elements Of Comparison Between “Hill’s Like White Elephants” And “The Birthmark”

1130 words - 5 pages Both “Hill’s like White Elephants” by Ernst Hemingway and “The Birthmark” by Nathaniel Hawthorne have many common elements of comparison between them. The main element of the stories that will be compared is this thought of an operation. Both stories stem from these two operations and the comparisons derive from how the women react and respond to the two men in the story. Both stories are comparable by the common theme of a life changing

Comparison Of Hills Like White Elephants And Fat

1458 words - 6 pages Comparison of Hills like White Elephants and FAT Both Hill like White Elephants and FAT are short stories about current issues that have to be resolved. The issue in FAT regards obesity in America and is shown as a conversation between the narrator and ‘Rudy’. Hills like White Elephants, however, the issue is abortion and the author uses direct speech creating the effect that we are near the couple, eavesdropping on the conversation. In

The Hills Like White Elephants Essay

741 words - 3 pages James Warren, III. Warren 1College Writing IIDr. Hobbs09/24/20131:40-2:55 p.m.The Hills Like White Elephants" Life will throw challenges your way, only your choices can determine whether you succeed or fail". ( James Warren, III.)In this story we find that this is the case between two individuals and American man and woman. The story takes place in the valley of Ebros next to large white hills that resemble white elephants. In this field we find

Complex Relationship Between The American And Jig In Hemingway’s Hills Like White Elephants

1551 words - 6 pages The Complex Relationship between the American and Jig in Ernest Hemingway’s “Hills Like White Elephants” In Hemingway’s “Hills Like White Elephants”, the American and Jig are like the tracks at the train station, they can never meet. While Jig represents fertility, life and continuity, the American represents sterility, dryness and death. Unfortunately, Jig depends emotionally on the American – as many women depended on their male