Elements Of Fantasy In Catwings Return

1404 words - 6 pages

    Although it is a children's book, Ursula Le Guin's short story "Catwings Return" is a perfect example of the Fantastical genre. Published in 1989, "Catwings Return" has some elements similar to those found in Magical Realism, but the story mostly has elements of Fantasy in it. By examining the American story "Catwings Return," a reader will be able to see the similarities and differences between Magical Realism and Fantasy.


In order to have some characteristics similar to those in Magical Realism, a text must contain both realistic elements and magical elements (Flores 112). In "Catwings Return," one of the realistic elements could be the setting. Rather than taking place in some other fantastical world or realm, the main part of "Catwings Return" takes place in a city near the little country town called Overhill. Since it has a "street crowded with whizzing cars," the city seems familiar to the reader (Le Guin 32). Another realistic element in the story is that the cats have the normal names of Thelma, Roger, Harriet, James, and Jane. Even though they have wings, the cats are given the realistic description of being tabby cats. Furthermore, the cats appear to do normal cat activities such as eat kibbles, purr, and play with one another and with the children who take care of them (Le Guin 3-5). Because of the "extensive use of detail," Le Guin's story exhibits at least one of the characteristics that Wendy B. Faris gives Magical Realism (Faris 169).


In Le Guin's story, the most prominent magical element is the sets of wings on the cats. Because of the magical element of the wings, "Catwings Return" is similar to "A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings," written by the Magical Realist Gabriel Garcia Marquez. Both stories give a creature wings when ordinarily the creature would not have any. Along with the wings, a second possible magical element in "Catwings Return" could be the conversations held between the animals. For instance, the cats actually discuss with one another how much they miss their mother and how they would like to visit her (Le Guin 6-7). Later in the story, two of the cats, Harriet and James, listen as their mother tells them how she lost her kitten and her old home (Le Guin 36-39). Since it is scientifically possible to give cats wings today and since it is known that animals can communicate with one another, then these elements, although still magical, are proof of supplementation within the text.


Although "Catwings Return" is similar to Magical Realism because of its realistic and unrealistic elements, the manner in which the reader treats the magical elements is different from how he or she would treat them in Magical Realist literature. In Magical Realist literature, the reader may hesitate between the real and the unreal, but may eventually accept the unreal as being real (Faris 171). While reading "Catwings Return," however, the reader does not hesitate between the real and the unreal....

Find Another Essay On Elements of Fantasy in Catwings Return

Peasant Lifestyle In Davis´ The Return of Martin Guerre

1854 words - 7 pages The Return of Martin Guerre, written by Natalie Zemon Davis, is the tale of a court case that takes place in sixteenth century France. Martin Guerre is a peasant who deserted his wife and family for many years. While Martin Guerre is gone, a man named Arnaud du Tilh arrives at Martin’s village and claims to be Martin Guerre. Bertrande, who is Guerre’s wife, Guerre’s sisters, and many of the villagers, accepts the imposter. After almost three

Elements which make novels, written in the fantasy genre unique and how have these been used in Tolkein's book 'The Hobbit'?

573 words - 2 pages In this essay I aim to show how Tolkein's Book is unique and linked to the elements of fantasy genre. There are many elements that make up fantasy genre, which link to Tolkein's 'The Hobbit', they are:1.Has a main character that overcomes evil, by himself or with help from friends2.Characters don't have to be human3.Main character possesses or has a special ability4.Usually involves magicThe first point I would like to explain would be the main

Elements of Romanticism in Stokers Dracula

814 words - 3 pages During the Romantic Era, Bram Stoker created a timeless monster in his novel, Dracula. Stoker uses a series of letters and journal entries to tell the story form a first person point of view. The Count, for whom the book is named, seems to be invincible to mere man. Stoker uses his character of Dracula to reflect the elements of romanticism through his supernatural powers, a fascination with youth and innocence, and imagery. Dracula seems to

The Gothic Elements in Chain of Fools

967 words - 4 pages The Gothic Elements in Chain of Fools The use of gothic properties in popular forms of entertainment has not yet departed. From movies such as Dark City, produced by Alex Proyas, to music stars like Marilyn Manson, the use of gothic tendencies simply appeals to large audiences. In Chain of Fools by Steven Womak, some of these gothic properties also exist. What purpose do these gothic elements serve for the story line and setting

Literary elements in Lord of the Flies

1034 words - 5 pages effects of hierarchy on the human psyche. In The Lord of The Flies there are three main literary elements, symbolism, allegory and imagery. Symbolism is the attaching of an idea to an inanimate object, or the investing it with higher meaning. A couple of the main symbols are, Piggy’s glasses, the conch and the fire. The symbolism of Piggy’s glasses are fairly simple, they're intended for looking through, thus giving vision; vision can also be

Elements of Relationship in D.H. Lawrence's Works

2115 words - 8 pages results when one or more of those aspects are missing. When it comes to intellectual, spiritual and sexual connections, Lawrence makes it clear that all of these elements must be present in order for a relationship to be successful; it's either all or none. Lawrence's first example of relational incompleteness comes through Paul in Sons and Lovers. By the middle of the novel, the reader is well aware of Paul's connection to his

Elements of Staging in Henry IV

2004 words - 8 pages Elements of Staging in Hentry IV     The elements of staging in Shakespeare's Hentry IV, Part 1 are critically important to the action, theme, and quality of the performance. Elements such as costume, blocking, casting, and even the physical attributes of the stage are, of course, important considerations in the production of a play. But other, less apparent factors contribute to the success of the production as well. For

Elements of Darkness in Macbeth by Shakespeare

971 words - 4 pages Elements of Darkness in Macbeth by Shakespeare William Shakespeare's Macbeth is a play of darkness. Throughout the play, three things in particular play a part in setting this stage, so to speak, of darkness. These three things are characters, theme and mood. Each has its own part in setting up the darkness. The characters (the title character in particular) are dark in their actions, the theme is dark in its subject matter, and the mood is

Elements Of Irony In Native Son

1037 words - 4 pages Elements of Irony in Native Son Native Son paints a disturbing, harsh picture of life within the "Black Belt" of Chicago in the 1940s. Wright uses irony; sometimes subtly and at other times obviously to shape the view of the reader and as a foreshadowing mechanism. From our initial scene to Bigger's death, the technique of irony employed by Wright is effective, and devastating.Our initial symbol which foreshadows the fate of our

Symbolic Convergence in Gossip Girl: The Fantasy of the “In Crowd”

1707 words - 7 pages events that fulfills a psychological or rhetorical need; depicts events outside of the group or in its past or future,” (Griffin, 2009, p. 28). The stories which create the fantasy typically consist of “common or related content”, known as a fantasy theme (Beebe & Masterson, 2009, p. 44). As members of a small group share stories or experiences with other group members, adherence to the fantasy theme creates “a string of connected stories that

The Shelter in Fantasy: A Structuralist's View of "An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge"

1063 words - 4 pages . Nevertheless, no matter how hard he tries to elude death, he is forced to receive it.Farquhar lives through the last hour of his life in his fantasy in which he can efface the presence of death. Engaging in his fantasies, he gains power and can actualize his hope to return home. The binary opposition of reality versus fantasy is dominant throughout the story as in fantasy, other binary oppositions like freedom/imprisonment, powerful/powerless and hope/disillusionment can be operated. However, his escape is futile as he can only escape the reality temporarily. The reality would finally come and offset all his fantasy. Death is the final reality and wakes him up forever.

Similar Essays

The Elements Of Fantasy And Horror

1591 words - 6 pages The elements of fantasy and horror blend together perfectly to create an unforgettable series of events. An example of dark fantasy is Something Wicked This Way Comes, the novel by Ray Bradbury that tells the story of two young boys, Jim and Will, who discover the secret of a mysterious traveling carnival. The magical carnival has many temptations, including a frightening mirror maze and a carousel that changes one’s age. However, its allure

"Return Of The King", By J.R.R Tolkien: An Evaluation Of The Literary Elements

916 words - 4 pages total power.Clearly, the superior theme, character, foreshadowing, setting, and conflict make The Return of the King great. Aragorn became who he was born to be, the war waged on in spectacular style, the setting provided the dark and evil foreshadowing, and the ever-present theme made this book a great read. Perhaps the readers of his tale have before heard that total power corrupts, but the ongoing tale burns the hard fact into memory. Shockingly portrayed, Tolkien vividly places the image of greed and evil in our minds. I implore you to read this book, and I promise it will not disappoint you.

The Fantasy Of Orality In Absalom, Absalom!

3062 words - 12 pages Quentin-Henry, the two of them both believing that Henry was thinking He (meaning his father) has destroyed us all.... (267)3 Absalom, Absalom!'s fantasy of oral narrative depends upon the contemporaneity of telling and listening. The creation of the narrative by the speaker is not anterior to but simultaneous with its experience by the hearer (which is why, in the passage cited above, "it did not matter...which one had been doing the talking

Use Of Fantasy In Langston Hughes's On The Road

653 words - 3 pages Use of Fantasy in Langston Hughes's On the Road Langston Hughes's short story "On the Road" begins and ends realistically enough: his protagonist, Sargeant, enters a strange town one winter's night during the Depression and finds himself without shelter, as many did during this era. Hughes gives Sargeant the additional burden of being an African-American in the "white" part of town; therefore, he faces the perfectly plausible obstacles