This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Eliminating Deficits: Finding The Promise In Teachers

2109 words - 8 pages

Setting the Stage for Positivity
Much discussion has been given to the idea of reframing our views of and interactions with school-age children from culturally, linguistically, ethnically, and economically diverse (hereafter, CLEED) backgrounds. The discussion typically revolves around ending the deficit paradigm—which views students from these backgrounds in a negative context—and developing a new lens through which to view diversity. This new lens focuses not only on the strengths that a diverse student holds, but also on finding the positive aspects of those characteristics that people would typically view as negative. However, this paradigm shift—even much discussion of a need for it—has largely not transferred to teachers of these students. Some culturally-minded researchers (e.g. Weiner, 2006; García & Guerra, 2004) have started to put forth the idea that teachers need to be assessed according to their merits and strengths rather than their deficits; however, almost overwhelmingly—and ironically—as a field, multicultural education references the fact that teachers are deficient in their ability to successfully teach students from diverse backgrounds.
This paper sets out to show that, if teachers are to be properly prepared to work with students from CLEED backgrounds successfully and in a manner that respects the strength of their diversity, they must be afforded the same respect in their professional lives. That is, in order for teachers to develop their pedagogy in a manner that allows them to effectively teach students from CLEED backgrounds, they must be handled in a manner that respects who they are as people. I will demonstrate the need for the development of a societal educational culture that rejects deficit approaches towards teachers. Just as educators label students with deficit approaches, so too do administrators, legislators, parents, communities, and society at large label teachers.
Often, it seems, teachers are viewed as the gap between what legislation or policy demands of them and where their administrator—or, increasingly, student test scores—determines them to be. And, just as it is harmful to diverse students, the deficit paradigm is harmful to teachers of those students. An unfortunate side effect of this approach towards teacher development is that it trickles down to and impacts students. If we are to develop an educational environment that recognizes the promise in students, it must be modeled from all of these stakeholders to teachers.
Defining Deficit Thinking
Prior to making the case for a positive frame for teacher development, it is important to ensure a clear understanding of deficit thinking. Deficit thinking is an approach that views people according to what they are perceived to be lacking, rather than according to their abilities and strengths. It is an approach that looks for all the reasons a person will not be successful and, in doing so, rejects their potential. These reasons...

Find Another Essay On Eliminating Deficits: Finding the Promise in Teachers

Finding Jesus in The Wanderer Essay

1871 words - 7 pages Finding Jesus in  The Wanderer During the Middle Ages, banishment was a devastating occurrence which plagued many Anglo Saxons. Upon being exiled, men were forced to travel the barren world alone in hopes of finding a new lord under whom they could serve. From this point on, melancholy and loneliness stood as the emotional basis on which every thought and dream was based. Until successfully locating a new mead hall and fellow companions

Reflection Paper on Living in the Land of Promise Article

1168 words - 5 pages fulfill whatever that task is, we should always be ready to face all sorts of challenges along the way. Just like in the old days before Jesus walks on the surface of the Earth. There were a lot of people called by God to fulfill some mission, because He was preparing a promise for all humanity. Some mission He believes to be so important to accomplish to achieve a life of Eternity with Him. And these people who fulfilled all the tasks were all

Finding the Truth in the Situation

1044 words - 4 pages Iago is not just the evil vindictive character he is believed to be but rather both of these men are far more interesting than that. They both have the necessary qualities that get them through life and potentially threaten their lives. Through their actions and interactions with the other characters that they really are is shown. Othello seems to have a really rough time finding the truth in people. The reasoning behind this is simply the way

The Important of Teachers' Guidance in Education

1633 words - 7 pages the child is hungry to find things out. From 12 to 18 is thought of as a creative period while the stage from 18 to 24 was identified as a period of ‘calm expansion’ (Bradley 2011, as cited in McGraw-Hill) Montessori believed that teachers should lead, and of course be in charge of the classroom. However children should be allowed their independence and are able to function without constant supervision from educators. Montessori was so successful

The shortage of male teachers in schools

1369 words - 5 pages For the benefit of male students, there needs to be more males teaching in schools. Boys need male role models in school - especially when coming from homes with no fathers - and more than two thirds of Australia's teachers are female. There has been much concern about boys not performing as well as girls throughout the school years, especially in English and humanities. Views of masculinity are distorted by a lack of male role models, resulting

Finding Your Place in the World

1112 words - 5 pages extreme situations he is forced to find who he truly is and lead himself to question his own society. For example, in the situation when Gulliver had been tied down by the Lilliputians he had experienced his first test in finding himself. This is the first time, out of his normal society, that he is faced with a situation in which he must make his own decision, based off of his true self as an European citizen. This whole experience of being small

Finding Fulfillment in The Good Earth

935 words - 4 pages Finding Fulfillment in The Good Earth         The Good Earth is a novel written by Pearl S. Buck. It is set in China and on the day of Wang Lung's marriage. Wang Lung is a poor peasant farmer whose love for the land sustains him through the difficult times of his life. He married a slave from the great house, and he moves from a poor, humble, country farmer to a wealthy, respected, landowning patriarch. He moves into the house that he

Eliminating Discrimination In The Workplace

1989 words - 8 pages As a business consultant I have been asked to suggest different methods that can possibly reduce discrimination and prejudice in the workplace. Is it possible however to make everyone get along and ignore their differences? According to the growing research on discrimination and prejudice, these are learned behaviors that with practice can be unlearned, and ultimately eliminated (Baron & Branscombe, 2012, p. 195). Discrimination is defined as

Finding the Truth in Gretchen Moran Laskas’s The Midwife’s Tale

1268 words - 5 pages Finding the Truth in Gretchen Moran Laskas’s The Midwife’s Tale The prologue to Gretchen Moran Laskas’s novel, The Midwife’s Tale, begins with her narrator protagonist, Elizabeth, telling readers, “Mama always said that most of being a good midwife was in knowing the family history. Not just the birthing story of any given woman--although that was a good thing to keep in mind--but the whole history.” Assuming the “whole history” is a thing

Response to the article "Finding Light in the Dark"

1014 words - 4 pages In our psychology class we were asked to read the short story "Finding Light in the Dark". The story is about a young man named Jack Kornfield who loses his sight early on in life. Although at first he struggles with his handicap, he begins to discover the benefits of not having sight. Overtime Jack learns that in many ways his loss of sight was more of a blessing then a curse. Jack's situation is a demonstration of the psychological process of

The Influence of Simple Remarks From Teachers in Developing Children

1147 words - 5 pages homework and do it right, to make a perfect score on all of our tests but what is the result of this? By growing up with our teachers telling us to be perfect we learn to become perfectionist which can, as Cameron explains, keep up in a never ending circle.(120) With the perfectionist attitude not only is our ability to complete projects affected, but also our censor. Our censor is what Cameron describes as the voice inside of us that comments on

Similar Essays

Eliminating Abbreviations Errors In The Medical Field

1043 words - 4 pages • How can eliminating abbreviations reduce errors? The use of abbreviations shortens length of many words thus really help healthcare professionals in saving time spent in writing notes. Abbreviations however do not always provide positive contributions due to misconceptions, misunderstandings, and misinterpretations leading to commitment of errors in the practice. Similarities in abbreviations for instance could root to a grave mistake. For

Finding Friendship In The Film Finding Forrester

595 words - 2 pages Finding Friendship in the Film Finding Forrester In Finding Forrester a movie that takes place in the Bronx, there are two main characters, William Forrester and Jamal Wallace who find friendship in an unlikely way because of their passion for reading and writing. Though both are very different from each other they are drawn together by similar interests. The characters are different in many ways; Forrester is a male Caucasian in his

Eliminating Restraints In The Care Of Elderly Residents

1647 words - 7 pages keeping residents safe, offering therapy or controlling behavior. Instead, these physical restraints have only increased the injuries found in nursing homes and escalated them to more serious injuries that would not occur without the usage of restraints. Because of this, laws focusing on the usage of restraints should further the restriction of restraints as well as possibly eliminating their usage completely. Alternate methods of care, such as more

Eliminating Discrimination In The Workplace: Is It Possible?

3205 words - 13 pages Eliminating Discrimination in the Workplace: Is it Possible? As a business consultant I have been asked to suggest different methods that can possibly reduce discrimination and prejudice in the workplace. Is it possible however to make everyone get along and ignore their differences? According to the growing research on discrimination and prejudice, these are learned behaviors that with practice can be unlearned, and ultimately eliminated