Elinor And Marianne From Sense And Sensibility By Jane Austen; Josephine And Constantia From The Daughters Of The Late Colonel By Katherine Mansfield; A Compare And Contrast Essay

1006 words - 4 pages

In this essay, I will be comparing two sets of sisters, Elinor and Marianne from Jane Austen's Sense and Sensibility and Josephina and Constantia from Katherine Mansfield's "The Daughters of the Late Colonel," all of whom have experienced the death of their respective fathers. Though they may all share some similar circumstances and personality traits, they each have unique reactions and responses to the things that happen to them.When the father of Elinor and Marianne dies, although they are grieved by it, have an apparent affection for him, and experience a great sense of loss, Elinor doesn't seem to dwell on his death. She is more concerned with their current situation and taking care of everybody and everything. Marianne, on the other hand, "gave [herself] up wholly to [her] sorrow, seeking increase of wretchedness in every reflection that could afford it…" (Austen, 4)When Josephine and Constantia's father dies, they both seem very lost. Rather than acting like the middle aged women that they are, they both "are quite immature, not to say childish. Right from the start we are presented with hilarious comments about giving the porter a top- hat ("father's head!") and their absurd conclusions about the need of dyeing their dressing gowns and having to wear, as Josephine pictures '...two pairs of black woolly slippers, creeping off to the bathroom like black cats.'" (Daughters) Mixed with this immature hilarity is the very serious lack of independent thinking they engage in. They both act saddened by their father's death, but even in their grief, they still act like someone is over their shoulder making sure they are "being sad enough." They tip-toe around their own house as if waiting to hear the disapproving thump of their late father's walking stick.Elinor is a cool-headed, rational girl who is very concerned about doing the right thing for everybody. "Her feelings were strong; but she knew how to govern them." (Austen, 3) She doesn't want to offend anybody unnecessarily and is often apologizing for the actions of her sister. Marianne, in contrast, does not know how, or even desire to govern her feelings. She believes that feelings were meant to be felt and felt as strongly as possible. Elinor and her sister, in spite of their differences, both value each other deeply and genuinely care about each other. However, according to their dispositions, Elinor is almost always the one who is in a position to help her sister. Marianne is often too engrossed in her own emotions to be of much good in supporting someone else through their problems. "Elinor urges Marianne to fulfill her responsibility to those who love her. Her own sense of duty sustains her, but Marianne's is insufficient to the task." (Reinstein)Both Josephine and Constantia are indecisive, timid, and immature. We see their indecisiveness in their inability to decided whether or not to keep Kate, the maid. We see their timidity when they both are unable to reasonably sort through...

Find Another Essay On Elinor and Marianne from Sense and Sensibility by Jane Austen; Josephine and Constantia from The Daughters of the Late Colonel by Katherine Mansfield; A Compare and Contrast Essay

Literary Analysis of "The Daughters of the Late Colonel" by Katherine Mansfield

846 words - 3 pages "The Daughters of the Late Colonel" by Katherine Mansfield is a subtle short story about two daughters of the late colonel who are left with the task of preparing his funeral and getting on with their lives after the tragic event of their father's death. For these two women living without their father might be harder than expected because they had come to rely on him for their every need. This story is unlike any other that has been discussed

"Sense and Sensibility" by Jane Austen

636 words - 3 pages "Sense and Sensibility" is a book by Jane Austen. It is set partly in London, partly in its surroundings in Southern England in the 19th century. The main characters are Elinor and Marianne Dashwood, two beautiful sisters who are forced to leave their home, Norland, when their father dies and leaves the house to his eldest son, Elinor and Marianne's brother John.Of the two, Marianne represents the "sensibility" and Elinor is the "sense". Being

Sense and Sensibility, by Jane Austen

944 words - 4 pages In the novel Sense and Sensibility, by Jane Austen, the Dashwood family is left with much less money after their father dies. When their cousin takes them in, they move to a new home and start their new life. In this time period money and social rank were the most important things. For most marriage has nothing to do with love, it is about gaining property, money or rank. This is why Elinor and Marianne’s, two of the Dashwood sisters

"In "Sense & Sensibility, Elinor represents sense and Marianne represents sensibility". Do you agree?

1117 words - 4 pages Elinor is the symbol of sense and Marianne is the symbol of sensibility, yet by the end of the novel it seems a form of fusion has taken place. Each girl has learned from the other. Following her bout of illness Marianne confesses that "my feelings shall be governed and my temper improved. They shall no longer torture others, nor torture myself" (340) i.e. that she will conform and behave more like Elinor, in a controlled fashion. Upon hearing of

Wealth and Happiness in Sense and Sensibility, by Jane Austen

1737 words - 7 pages In the novel Sense and Sensibility, by Jane Austen, the Dashwood family is left with much less money after their father dies. When their cousin takes them in, they move to a new home and start their new life. In this time period money and social rank were the most important things. For most marriage has nothing to do with love, it is about gaining property, money or rank. This is why Elinor and Marianne’s, two of the Dashwood sisters

British women during the victorian age and in "Sense and Sensibility" by Jane Austen

3145 words - 13 pages This essay deals with the status of upper- and upper middle class British women from the Victorian era to the twenty-first century. I will look at how women came to be equal with men and what the steps leading to equality were. However, the main focus of the essay will be on how women are treated in Sense and Sensibility by Jane Austen, how it reflects its time and how you can see the conditions as a backdrop for the fictional story. I will look

Jane Austen: An Analysis of Sense and Sensibility

1552 words - 6 pages Austen was a recondite writer with a new inside perspective with an outside view on life in the early 19th century. Born on December 16, 1775, Austen was a curious child given the unseal luxury of an education. Her father was a part of the gentry class and raised a family of ten, but was not well off by any means (Grochowski). Sense and Sensibility, written by Jane Austen, tells a dramatic story of three sisters and their emotional journey where

Jane Austen's Sense And Sensibility

1479 words - 6 pages Sense and Sensibility is a book that deals with many of life's circumstances during the eightteen hundreds. Although it was written in the first person it can provide the reader with a detailed perspective on the lifestyle of the upper crust of society. However, in order to get a full sense of appreciation of this lifestyle the elements of the opposite group, the lower class, must be attained. By comparing the differences amongst lifestyles

Patriarchy in Jane Austen's Sense and Sensibility

1705 words - 7 pages Patriarchy in Jane Austen's Sense and Sensibility Despite the fact that Jane Austen has become what Julian North describes as a “conservative icon in popular culture” signified by her depictions of “traditional class and gender hierarchies, sexual propriety and Christian values,” the novel _Sense and Sensibility_ provides, if not a feminist perspective, a feminist discourse lacking in Emma Thompson’s film version (North 38). In this essay

Achieving a Balanced Life in Jane Austen's Sense and Sensibility

1995 words - 8 pages Achieving a Balanced Life in Jane Austen's Sense and Sensibility We are often told that too much of anything can be a bad thing. Even Aristotle, one of the greatest thinkers of all time, insisted that the only path to real contentment and inner peace is "The Golden Mean" (Funk & Wagnalls 328). This life lesson is learned by two of Jane Austen's most well-known characters. Only when Elinor and Marianne Dashwood achieve a balance between

Mansfield Park by Jane Austen

1455 words - 6 pages At the start of Mansfield Park Fanny arrives at Mansfield. Fanny stands out from those who live at Mansfield. She is much more humble and less arrogant than her relatives. Fanny is, all in all, a simple girl. As the story goes on, however, the reader gets a glimpse of exactly how Fanny has changed when she goes back to visit her family. Before encountering this look of Fanny's family and her life at Portsmouth, it is clear that her time at

Similar Essays

Compare En Contrast An Outpost Of Progress By Conrad And The Daughters Of The Late Colonel By Katherine Mansfield

604 words - 2 pages between Josephine and Constantia in "The Daughters Of The Late Colonel" stays the same. "In the Outpost of progress", Kayerts and Carlier their friendship turns into a sense of hostility against each other. The friendship changes when the two men find out that the people of the village have been trade for ivory and after that there is hardly any food. That is when the problems and arguments start; "That was the root of the trouble"(Conrad, 47). There

Compare And Contrast The Sisters In “Sense And Sensibility” To The Sisters In “The Daughters Of The Late Colonel.”

1111 words - 4 pages , Sense and Sensibility, we have two main characters which are Elinor and Marianne, who are very different in personalities but have common things between them. In The daughters of the late Colonel, which Katherine Mansfield wrote, we also have two sisters, Josephine and Constantia. They also have some resemblance as sisters, however if we compare these two pair of sisters that come from different families we can find great differences, even

Sense And Sensibility: Elinor & Marianne

511 words - 2 pages Two sisters choose separate paths of how to handle the emotion of their hearts' deepest desires. One decided to follow their heart and the other was more "sensible", ignoring their hearts' pleas. Sense and Sensibility, a wonderful novel written by Jane Austen, presents a specific story of how some went through life struggling because of divided social classes. Money being an immense part of 18th century England, many of the characters had to

The Sense And Marianne By Jane Austen

986 words - 4 pages Elinor Represents the Sense and Marianne the Sensibility of the Novel’s Title. Discuss. “She had an excellent heart – her disposition was affectionate and her feelings were strong, but she knew how to govern them…” Right from the opening of the novel, the author, Jane Austen, makes it clear that Elinor, the eldest of the Dashwood sisters, represents the “Sense” in the title of the novel. Elinor endures some very strong emotions and