Elizabeth’s Relationship With Her Parliaments Essay

3129 words - 13 pages

Elizabeth’s Relationship With Her Parliaments
Over the years, there has been much debate amongst historians
Orthodox, Revisionist and Post – Revisionist, as to whether the
relationship between Elizabeth and her parliaments was one of
“conflict and contest,” or of “cooperation and consent”. Most of the
different schools of thought agree on the facts, but disagree in their
interpretations of the relationship. In general, taking into account
all of the parliaments that took place throughout Elizabeth’s reign,
the contemporary historians believe that Elizabeth’s relationship with
her parliaments was one of “cooperation and consent.” The orthodox
historians believe that Elizabeth’s relationship with her parliaments
was one of “conflict and contest” and that it came from the puritan
choir in the House of Commons. The revisionist historians believe that
there was a relationship of “cooperation and consent”. Finally, the
Post-Revisionist historians believe that the relationship between
Elizabeth and her parliaments was one of “cooperation and consent” in
some cases, and “conflict and consent” in others. In cases where they
believed that there was conflict, they believe that it came from the
Privy Council. In order to answer the question, the different schools
of thought need to be taken into account, along with the events that
back these views up, and the relationships at the individual
parliaments need to be assessed, e.g. Religion, succession, free
speech, and the monopolies parliaments.

Firstly, take religion, which was discussed at the session in 1559. It
can be argued that at this individual parliament, the relationship
between parliament and the queen was one of “conflict and contest”.
The contemporary view is that the “parliament was obedient, even
subservient to Tudor despotism”[1].

Therefore they argue that the relationship was one of “cooperation and
consent”. This was backed up by the fact that within this parliament,
Elizabeth eventually got what she had wanted. The orthodox view is
that there was Puritan parliamentary opposition to the bill that was
introduced to restore royal supremacy over the Church of England, and
that this ‘puritan choir’ deliberately planned confrontations in order
to force the issue of parliamentary privilege. Therefore they argue
that the relationship was one of “conflict and contest”. Neale argued
that the power of the House of Commons had increased throughout
Elizabeth’s reign. This is backed up by a number of events, including
that the reign of Elizabeth did witness the culmination of a process
where the gentry took over a proportion of Parliament. In her reign,
the number of Parliamentary seats was “four times larger than under
the qualifying laws”[2]. However the evidence available to back up

Find Another Essay On Elizabeth’s Relationship With Her Parliaments

Daughters failing relationship with her father.

766 words - 3 pages When you are a child, a father's love is one of the most precious gifts. He is someone you look up to, someone you feel safe with, someone you hold dear to your heart. Fathers are the ones that take you to the park and push you endlessly on the swing till you cant go any higher. Your father is the one who looks at you as if you're the one great light in his life. He makes you laugh with his fantastic stories until your rolling around on the

A Virtuous Sovereign Essay

1007 words - 4 pages It is popular belief that the life of a Princess is magical, filled with “Happily Ever After”, however the life of Queen Elizabeth I was anything but magical. The story of The Virgin Queen is captivating, from scandal surrounding her birth to her reluctance to name a successor before her death. Elizabeth’s entire life was full of turmoil, conspiracy and sadness. Jane Resh Thomas described this misconception most accurately on page two of Behind

How do Jane Austen and E.M Forster portray their heroines as remarkably independent?

1658 words - 7 pages aristocrat with great wealth and social status confronts her about her relationship with Mr Darcy. “The story has no great variety” (Bloom). Elizabeth’s independence creates variety in “Pride and Prejudice”; for instance, her independent views explores and criticises the views on marriage as it presents an alternative view to Regency society; this alternative view is evident in the confrontation between Lady Catherine and Elizabeth. Lady Catherine

Marriage Without Love in Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen

1566 words - 6 pages marriage by starkly contrasting them with Elizabeth’s to expose Charlotte’s low status. Charlotte believes that “happiness in marriage is entirely a matter of chance” and that “very few of us have heart enough to be really in love without encouragement” (14). This indicates that Charlotte believes love is not essential to the success of marriage and therefore she lacks status. Her satire commends Elizabeth’s rebellion against class hierarchy, and

Elizabeth's Spiritual Growth in "The Crucible"

502 words - 2 pages the play, Elizabeth is heartbroken her husband, John Proctor, has committed adultery seven months ago with Abagail Williams. Elizabeth’s sorrow leads her to insecurities of her husband’s fidelity. When the talk of witchcraft comes up, Elizabeth becomes devastated she has been accused of witchery by Abagail. She is even more heartbroken John will not confess to the court of his infidelity to end the whole fiasco. She gently asks John to break any

Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice

1084 words - 4 pages learn Elizabeth is engaged to Mr. Darcy. Chapter fifty-nine displays Elizabeth who secretly becomes engaged and then becomes apprehensive in revealing the information to her family. Even though the novel was first published in 1813, Elizabeth’s situation is very relatable to many people. The prospect of having news, but being nervous about the reactions of family members is all too real even in today’s society. Austen explains this with her

Appearance vs. Reality in Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice

1315 words - 5 pages contact yet again with Mr. Darcy when Jane Bennett becomes ill while visiting Mr. Bingley and Elizabeth goes to stay with her at Netherfield. Elizabeth’s dislike of Darcy’s stoic and unfriendly manner increases; while spending time with the Bingley party. Elizabeth believes every single move of Darcy to have ill intentions. She notices Darcy frequently gazing at her and concludes “she drew his notice because there was something about her more

More than Just a Pretty Face, and with the Heart and Stomach of a King

2434 words - 10 pages believed that she had a tumour in her uterus or experienced phantom pregnancy because of her longing for a child. She reluctantly proclaims Elizabeth as her heir. Shortly after, Mary becomes ill from a bout of influenza and dies. There are rumours that Mary spent her last days, never leaving her quarters, jumping at shadows with a dagger always in her hand to protect her from imaginary foes. Elizabeth’s early life will affect how she rules her

The Rose and Zephyr by Elizabeth Barrett Browning

1259 words - 5 pages the Browning household. Elizabeth’s father began to treat the family as if he was tyrant. Elizabeth was not allowed to go outside or wonder off the family’s estate without her father by her side. After a harsh punishment from her father a doctor diagnosed Elizabeth with a lung ailment and a spinal injury. Even though Elizabeth was plagued with many diseases she continued writing (Garrett pg. 43). In 1827 Elizabeth secretly published her

Finding the Truth in Gretchen Moran Laskas’s The Midwife’s Tale

1268 words - 5 pages and genetic disease, provides pregnancy termination to her women clients in need. Again, Moran Laskas refrains from indulging in any romantic and sensationalized language that might lead readers to a moral conclusion on her part, and instead presents the stark, often severe, realities of the characters and their decisions with honesty and neutrality. Very early in the novel Elizabeth’s mother advises her, “Sometimes the truth isn’t found in the

Austen's Worldview Through Elizabeth's Eyes

1953 words - 8 pages this description. When Mr. Collins asks for her hand in marriage, she refuses. He does not believe that Elizabeth has any reason to reject him because he considers “[his] situation in life, [his] connections to the family of De Bourgh, and [his] relationship to [Elizabeth’s] own” to be points of attraction for Elizabeth (Austen 82). Nevertheless, she refuses him and the reason she provides him with is that they each would not be able to provide

Similar Essays

Ruth Benedicts Relationship With Her Mother

2298 words - 9 pages transfer her love to another woman, thus becoming a lesbian. So in essence, the mother’s original goal to socialize the little girl to be like her mother backfired when the mother withdrew the reward of affection that she had been giving the little girl. Andrea Lee wrote a similar story dealing with a mother daughter relationship. In her story entitled Mother it is the mother’s personality, as well as her domestic skills that rub off on her

Juliet's Relationship With Her Parents In William Shakespeare's Romeo And Juliet

2089 words - 8 pages Juliet's Relationship With Her Parents in William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet Lord and Lady Capulet have a distant, but affectionate relationship with their daughter, Juliet. At the beginning of the play, the parents think that Juliet is a respectful girl and listens to the parents needs. Lord Capulet has a positive and loving attitude towards Juliet at the beginning. This is proven in Act 1 scene 2 when Lord Capulet

The Contribution Of Juliet's Relationship With Her Parents And Friar Lawrence's Single Mindedness To The Tragic End Of The Play

2855 words - 11 pages The Contribution of Juliet's Relationship with Her Parents and Friar Lawrence's Single Mindedness to the Tragic End of the Play Juliet was a young lady who lived with her parents. Also living with her, in her home was a nurse and servants. Juliet's relationship was very different with each individual that she lived with. The relationship that Juliet had with her father was different to the relationship that she had with

Movie "Lantana" : Valerie Believes That "Home Should Be A Sanctuary, Not A Battleground". Why Does Her Relationship With John Break Down?

545 words - 2 pages Lantana in Australia is a prickly weed that will grow almost any where. It grows like a web of thorns entangling any one who is drawn near. The movie "lantana" is exactly the same as the plant, as all the characters are 'intertwined' in some way. Valerie Somers, a character in the movie, falls victim to an entanglement of suspicion and lies which forms the battleground on which her relationship with John breaksdown. Although Valerie states