Elsie And Her Mother In Oranges Are Not The Only Fruit

1061 words - 4 pages

Elsie and Her Mother in Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit

In a story of a young girl coming of age and finding her sexuality in a very religious community, it is key to have a female figure that plays a key role for the character. A mother should play the key role but what happens when this role is confused with a very spiritual role? Where will a young girl turn to when her life goes against the rules society has set for her?

Jeanette has lived a sheltered life with no influence on her except for the church. Her mother is a strict Christian with a deep resentment for things and people not within her fold. Being brought up in a society where going against the norm is a sin. A society that shakes its head at acts of individualism and shuns those they can not convert to their way of thinking. In effect, a cult based on a long -standing text, the bible. In this cult though, Jeanette finds a kindred spirit that doesn?t fit the mold set by this religious society.

Elsie is an older woman who believes in God and all of his wonders. ??Listen to what the Lord has done for me this week.? She needed eggs, the Lord sent them. She had a bout of colic, the Lord took it away.? (Winterson, p. 23). Even for her strong belief in God and all of His glories she is considered an eccentric. She practices numerology, creates unusual crafts and is outspoken. This personality is what attracts Jeanette. Elsie is so unlike her mother and the other women of the congregation and this fact pulls Jeanette closer to Elsie. Jeanette looks to Elsie for guidance and an understanding ear that doesn?t judge her harshly.

On the other hand Jeanette?s mother is an extreme personality. This personality is not seen as eccentric, it is seen as a trait that she is a true believer and follower of the Lords word. Religion is her way of controlling things in an otherwise confusing world. Within this circle of believers she can control the people around her with out anyone questioning her.

Her power is not seen as going beyond the limits. It is seen as a sign that this is her true calling and that she is a messenger of God. Also, Jeanette is not a child she wanted to love and care for. Jeanette was a child she adopted so that she could mold another solider for God. ??She would get a child, train it, build it, dedicate it to the Lord: a missionary child, a servant of God, a blessing.? (Winterson, p. 10).

Even though Jeanette?s mother and Elsie come from the same congregation and both believe in God and his wondrous works, they are very different. These differences between these two women are what make Jeanette a rounded person, if not a confused one at first. Jeanette gained a sense a self with her mother. She knew she was to work with the Lord and teach his words to others. Her goal in life was to go and be a missionary, to teach others how to believe in God. Combined with this imbedded sense of self is the confidence Elsie gave her. Elsie not only understood

the word...

Find Another Essay On Elsie and Her Mother in Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit

Analyse the relationship between the mother and her son in The Son's

1388 words - 6 pages aware of the way she speaks, behaves, and even reacts in all situations. The consequences are to always be considered before all that Sophy does. It is however, not only her feelings that are to be taken into consideration, but those of her family as well. Her son, for example, shows more concern over his own social welfare regarding the marriage his mother so badly wants, that he essentially forbids it. The potential consequences are far too

Empathy in Brecht's The Good Person of Szechwan and Mother Courage and Her Children

2419 words - 10 pages . When one hears Shen Te crying it is obviously over-dramatised and not supposed to invade our emotions. Although it appears to be over the top, her pent-up fear, anger and sadness are understandable. Her obviously stereotyped brute of a lover is only interested in himself. Although self-interest is one of the main themes running through the play. Shen Te may not have given him all her money but has given him all her emotion. Brecht may be

Context in Mother Courage and her Children by Brecht

798 words - 3 pages Context in Mother Courage and her Children by Brecht There are many different contexts to the play and they are all influenced by social, cultural and historical implications. The context of the play itself and how it was written and performed for the first time and now were all influenced by events that occurred in Brecht’s life. The play itself discusses the thirty year war but is a clear reflection of the Second World War. Brecht

'Jealousy and deception in the play is not just confined to Othello'. Show how these themes are explored not only through the character of Othello, but the play as a whole

2933 words - 12 pages killed her unjustly, he rapidly recovers. Once again he speaks with calm composure before finally executing himself.I have to say that I agree with the statement that jealousy and deception is not only confined to Othello, but it appears in a variety of other characters aswell. Although Othello seems to be the only character that practically shows any jealousy since his actions are a result of his jealousy, there are other characters such as Iago

A Face Only a Mother Could Love: A look at the stereotypes of beauty and ugliness in horror movies.

1080 words - 4 pages kill children if they are not afraid to come close to you.But wait! What am I thinking? Since the days of Frankenstein and Wolfman, society has portrayed evil as ugly. As Lennard J. Davis states in his essay Visualizing the Disabled Body, "Myths of beauty and ugliness have laid the foundation for normalcy." (390:16) One could believe that in real life, only ugly people are evil villains and criminals. Just look at some of the most infamous of

Audiences are not only entertained they are made to engage with the social concerns explored in plays. Discuss this view with reference to your study and experience of two of the texts set for study.

1133 words - 5 pages Audiences are not only entertained they are made to engage with the social concerns explored in plays. Discuss this view with reference to your study and experience of two of the texts set for study.For centuries, drama has acted as a mirror for culture and society. Through the power of dramatic form, we have been invited to be entertained yet also engaged in the social concerns, which can both be provocative and surprising. Both 'Stolen' by

Comparing First Dates in Sotto's Oranges and Wetherell's The Bass, the River, and Shelia Mant

1077 words - 4 pages First Dates in Sotto's Oranges and Wetherell's The Bass, the River, and Shelia Mant Everyone is born with innocence and they gradually gain experience through lessons learned in life; some people may gain more that others. Not all lessons in life are dramatic or negative, some may be subtle, positive, or even life altering; however, no matter how small or big, they do alter one's perspective on things and help them to gain experience

In order to grow, a country needs not only the

2864 words - 11 pages In order to grow, a country needs not only the muscles of labourers but also the wheeling and dealing of entrepreneurs. As these entrepreneurs amassed fortunes for themselves, they brought the United States great advantages. Such entrepreneurs as Cornelius Vanderbilt, Andrew Carnegie, and John Davidson Rockefeller became known as "robber barons." Cornelis Vanderbilt was born on May 27, 1794, into a family of nine children, in Port Richmond

Mother Teresa her life and my feelings

548 words - 2 pages for others. This can only be through continuous prayer. Then we will be: a pencil in God's hands." I think this quote plays an important part in the way we treat others everyday. It should always come to mind before we consider do something wrong to someone else. If we hurt someone else, we are also hurting God. Do we really want to hurt someone who love us so much that he would die for us? Mother Teresa knew how good it made God feel to see her

The Victims of Bullying Are Not The Only Ones that Need Help

901 words - 4 pages control. They bully because they feel the need to prey on a weaker person, as a way to feel better about themselves and their situation. The victims of bullying are not the only ones that need help, most bullies need just as much help. Helping bullies can start a new train of hope. Providing help for them to cope with their problems will help in the future by minimizing bullying. In essence, resolving such psychological, social, or family issues

Mother Teresa - Her life and times.

1347 words - 5 pages among the poor, not just help them.After a year, Sister Teresa asked again. The archbishop wanted to grant her the permission but decided it would be better to ask the permission from the Vatican and from the mother general in Dublin. This decision took many years.On August 1948 she received the permission to leave the Loreto community under the condition to keep the vows of poverty, purity and compliance. When she was 38 she gave back her

Similar Essays

Gender Roles In The Colour Purple And Oranges Are Not The Only Fruit

1578 words - 6 pages Gender Roles in The Colour Purple and Oranges are Not the Only Fruit In the novels, The Colour Purple and Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit a masculine quality in a female character or, a feminine quality in a male character is seen as a sign of strength and change. Both authors’ portrayal of gender and sexuality is an extremely significant aspect in the novels. This essay will be focusing on how Alice Walker and Jeanette

"Pride And Prejudice" By Austen And "Oranges Are Not The Only Fruit" By Winterson.

2745 words - 11 pages . Winterson's novel is written as a first person narrative, and so gives a very one-sided point of view of everything. There is evidence as well as Jeannette sharing the same name with the author to suggest that they are in fact the same characters. As in Psalms; one of Winterson's short stories she writes about her mother reading the Band of Hope Review, as Louie does in Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit. Pride and Prejudice, is narrated by an

Comparison Between Oranges Are Not The Only Fruit And Purple Hibiscus

2052 words - 8 pages some characteristics of the classical Bildungsroman is Charlotte Brontë’s Jane Eyre, which Jeanette Winterson references in her novel Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit (Oranges). The presence of a female protagonist is a feature that both Winterson’s novel and Chimamanda Adichie’s Purple Hibiscus share with Jane Eyre. Despite the fact that these novels deviate from and challenge Buckley’s male centred definition of the genre, they are all considered

The Characters Of Othello, The Monk And Jeannette In Oranges

2175 words - 9 pages class sewing and she said she wished to sew “It is the summer and we are not yet saved”, in response, Mrs Virtue indicated that she didn’t find what Jeannette wanted to sew appropriate, and her justification for this was that “you might upset the others..”, it is perceptible that Mrs Virtue was uncomfortable with Jeanette’s proposed idea, due to its religious nature. Moreover from a young age Jeannette faced persecution from her peers because of