Embryonic Research: A Battle Of Fallacies

1384 words - 6 pages

Many women are eager to become a mother, but infertility prevents some women from satisfying this need. To counter this widespread problem, we develop reproductive choices. One of the most important choices is in vitro fertilization. Even though this method significantly increases pregnancy rate in infertile women, it comes with the problem. Underlying in vitro fertilization is research on living human embryos. We need to research on countless living embryos in order to develop clinical in vitro fertilization. This stirs public attention on its morality. Society asks: Are we killing thousands of human life while we are developing method to give birth to other ones? This question is crucial because it is asking very foundation of our morality. We need to find the answer which can be proved thoroughly relevant, or otherwise, we are undermining our moral standard itself. To resolve this ethical dilemma, we turn our expectation to bioethicists because we need reliable thought, concrete argument, and plausible solution, and they seem to be only kind of people we can rely on. With our expectation, we tend to trust them. But the reality is opposite. The arguments from bioethicists may not be reliable as promised. We have to be conscious and cautious when we are considering their arguments. After contemplating two essays from both sides of the argument, “The Meaning of Life –In Laboratory” by Leon Kass and “Progeny, Progress, and Primrose Paths” by Samuel Gorovitz, we see the dialogues arguing on this moral issue contain amount of weak arguments and even logical fallacies.
We may focus first on the arguments against embryonic research. Among prominent opponents of embryonic research is Leon Kass, who wrote “The Meaning of Life –In Laboratory”. In his essay, Kass takes a standing ground against research that uses living in vitro human embryos, by arguing that the research practices undermine “the respect due to the embryos” (104). He emphasizes the important of embryos’ life and right to develop to be a mature human.
First logical fallacy found in Kass’s essay is inappropriate generalization with the lacking of evidence. Kass supports his statement that life begins at fertilization by asserting, “Any honest biologist must be impressed by these facts, and must be inclined, at least on first glance, to the view that a human life begins at fertilization” (101). In this sentence, he claims that any honest biologist must agree with him. There is no evidence, or at least, reason provided to support this claim.
Apart from inappropriate generalization, Kass also frames his readers’ perspective by using several accusatory words and erroneous analogy to portray embryonic research in devilish way. He describes embryonic research as “destruction of fetal life” (103), “destruction of blastocyst” (104), and “manipulative experiments involving such embryos” (104). Moreover, Kass analogizes the research method with cannibalism. He writes, “We would, I suppose,...

Find Another Essay On Embryonic Research: A Battle of Fallacies

The Benefits of Government-Supported Embryonic Stem Cell Research

2743 words - 11 pages who are unsure as to what state of development constitutes life. They believe that since these embryos would be destroyed eventually and because they have the potential to save millions of lives, embryonic stem cell research should be funded by the government (Ham, 2001, p. 1). Stem cells are grown on petri-dishes in a laboratory and have not differentiated into the various organs and tissues; there is no nervous system, circulatory system

An opinionated look into the facts and fallacies of evolution, from a Christian perspective. 11 pages

2906 words - 12 pages were permitted to study these bones and from their research they found that they were merely animal bones, and mysteriously, these bones disappeared after the war (Primal Man? 20). Again in 1922, Harold Cook stumbled upon Hesperopithecus, also known as Nebraska Man, among Pliocene deposits in Nebraska. What Cook found was a tooth. Years later the entire skeleton was discovered and concluded to be that of an extinct pig (Creation in Symphony). In

The Battle of Dunkirk: A Tactical Defeat

1611 words - 6 pages The Battle of Dunkirk happened in Northern France between May 26 and June 4 1940 and was a major battle of the Second World War which occurred between 1939-1945. The Second World War was very different to the first with rapid movement covering huge amounts of land in very little time. This was due to the German Army’s speed which used “Blitzkrieg” or “Lightning war” tactics. Prior to the invasion of France there had been 7 months of “Phoney

Battle of Britain - A German Perspective

1288 words - 5 pages My name is Lieutenant Rolph Gütemen. However I am going to recount to you, what really happened that cost us the Battle for Britain. I have included several of my own diary comments on the different stages throughout the battle.It all started with the conquest of France and the Low Countries. The Luftwaffe’s superior performance and machinery completely decimated the French Air Force. This granted to you a safe passage to Paris. A

The Battle Of Gettysburg - A Fictional Account

1404 words - 6 pages gratifying. War sounded like an escape from our tedious lives. We were so immature. Our innocence would soon be ripped from us, leaving our souls bleeding. Three years passed. We were stationed in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania. It was late at night and the third day of this, the bloodiest battle of the civil war. Nearly 35,000 men had died just in the previous two days. Now I was twenty and a skilled veteran. Somehow, a few of my closest friends

America Censored: A Battle of Rights

2171 words - 9 pages America Censored: A Battle of Rights Welcome to the United States of America. This is the Land of the Free and the Home of the Brave. A place where our forefathers once gathered and drew up the foundation for which we live our lives. The Constitution of the United States grants us a certain amount of freedoms for which we cannot be punished for. The first amendment to this constitution of the Constitution allows us the freedom of speech

Battle of a Continent: the Plains of Abraham

1809 words - 7 pages with professional soldiers whose battle tried spirits were equally so. The 13 colonies were also a reliable asset, having the resources to re- supply soldiers whenever necessary with an unrivaled population 20:1 times greater to that of New France (Wikipedia, 2004). The British strategy, at the start of the war, resembled a skeleton crew who lacked discipline, character, drive and determination. That was not the case now: the British government

Battle of Antietam: A Bloody Day in US History

1275 words - 6 pages Antietam was the first battle of the American Civil War to be fought on the northern soil. Although the battle was not a clear victory for either side, for the North, the battle near Antietam Creek "saved" the nation. The victory furthered President Lincoln's ability to issue his preliminary Emancipation Proclamation (September 22, 1862) announcing that unless the Confederates put down their arms by January 1, 1863, he would free all slaves not

A Midsummer Night’s Dream - Battle of the Sexes

823 words - 4 pages genders dealing with complicated family and romantic situations. The plot includes a duke who is going to marry a woman he conquered in battle, the king and queen of the fairies embroiled in a fight so fierce that it unbalances the natural world, and a daughter fighting with her father for her right to marry the man she chooses. The girl’s father selects Demetrius to marry his daughter, but she is in love with another man, Lysander, who loves

Treating Depression: A Personal Battle or a Combination of Professional Treatments?

1152 words - 5 pages (2008) acknowledges that depression is common. He wrote a number of suggestions for coping with the illness. Suggestions included: focusing on spiritual life, getting a good night rest, talking to your depression, finding a clear state of mind, living as though you are not depressed, and reminding yourself that there are individuals with greater problems than your own. An individual can battle depression without professional help (Seu, 2008


824 words - 4 pages 1.0 Introduction I have been asked to produce a report which critically evaluates a range of research methodologies and the usefulness of these methodologies when applied to a given scenario. In the first part of this report I will be analyzing the usefulness of the methods covered in lesson when applied to different scenarios and for the second section of the report I will demonstrate an understanding of said methodologies by selecting a method

Similar Essays

A Report On The Legalization Of Embryonic Brain Stem Research.

960 words - 4 pages diseases such as Parkinson's from a person's body. However, it would also allow human cloning, and the ability to create a human being with whatever features you want. This is why the research of embryonic cells is a very debatable issue, with many different viewpoints and opinions. The Church has its own opinion about this topic, and there are also moral issues, social implications, legal issues, and political issues that need to be looked at in order

The Ethics Of Human Embryonic Stem Cell Research

885 words - 4 pages The Ethics of Human Embryonic Stem Cell Research The Ethics of Human Embryonic Stem Cell Research By Louis Guenin As a public service, the ISSCR provides this page to assist readers who wish to inquire into the moral debate concerning embryonic stem cell research. Introduction: Thinking About EthicsEthics is not a specialized body of knowledge. Ethics is a conversation about questions. In that conversation, everyone has a place

Embryonic Stem Cell Research: The Pandora’s Box Of Science

1560 words - 6 pages three years old in the Upper Paleolithic Era to sixty seven years old today. This major increase can be credited to the development in medical technologies. One of the most controversial scientific technologies today is the developmental technology of embryonic stem cells. The research and development of embryonic stem cells is a slippery slope of science with unimaginable consequences. Stem cells have the remarkable potential to develop into

The Positive Potential Of Embryonic Stem Cell Research

1363 words - 5 pages Imagine a world in which suffering and pain are no more. A paralytic accident is no longer a lifelong sentence to a wheelchair, a birth defect is no longer a worry on an expectant mothers mind, and a cancer diagnosis becomes worriless and easily fixed. Such a carefree and safe existence is in close proximity with advancements from embryonic stem cell research. Since the first culturing of embryonic stem cells in 1998 (Robertson 191) the