Emily Dickinson: Transcendentalist Or Anti Transcendentalist? Essay

731 words - 3 pages

Shannon TurnerSr. SharonACP American Literature13th February, 2014Emily Dickinson: Transcendentalist or Anti-Transcendentalist?Emily Dickinson is one of the most iconic writers in American literature. Although she mostly wrote poetry, her writings and messages changed the American viewpoint in drastic ways. Her themes regarding death, friendship, family, and relationships have survived the trials of time and are still prominently discussed in complex nature in modern literature classes. Although Emily Dickinson is a common topic of discussion regarding American literature, one question about her continues to puzzle critics. That question is: Does Emily Dickinson fall under the umbrella of writers who expressed transcendentalist ideas? This puzzles critics because Emily Dickinson's poetry expresses both transcendentalist and anti-transcendentalist ideas. Although Emily Dickinson's poetry shows inconsistencies by expressing both transcendentalist and anti-transcendentalist, she would be considered a transcendentalist because of her fascination with the divine aspect of the human role in the world.In many of her poems, Emily Dickinson reflects the ideas of transcendentalism. Dickinson chose to write about topics that deal with nature, which is a common trait of the transcendentalists. In Emily Dickinson's poem, "I Never Saw a Moor," she says, "I never saw the sea/ Yet I know how the heather looks/ And what a billow be" (389. 2-4). Dickinson is saying that she has never seen the sea, but that she knows what it looks like. In the same way, she also expresses how she has never seen God or Heaven, but that she knows they exist (Fu). This mention of the divine nature could be an expression of transcendentalism. Dickinson's belief that God and Heaven exist and that she knows what the sea looks like could be a reference to intuition and her utmost faith in her intuition. Dickinson's mention of her faith in her intuition is a reflection of the ideals of transcendentalism because she believes that her intuition can lead her through life and will not ultimately corrupt her, unlike the institutions of society that transcendentalists believe did corrupt people.Emily Dickinson also expresses her transcendentalist beliefs in her poem, "Hope is the Thing with Feathers" when she says "I've heard it in the chilliest land/ And on the strangest sea"...

Find Another Essay On Emily Dickinson: Transcendentalist or Anti-Transcendentalist?

trancendentalism Essay

1518 words - 6 pages anti-institutionalism, and in the dedication of many of its members to social reform. Writers who were either transcendentalists or closely associated with the movement include Bronson Alcott (1799-1888), Emerson, Margaret Fuller (1810-50), and Henry David Thoreau. Key transcendentalist works include Emerson's essays, especially "Nature" (1836), "The American Scholar" (1837), "The Over-Soul" (1841), and "Self-Reliance" (1841), and Thoreau's "Walden

Emily Dickinson Essay

2639 words - 11 pages ; 1850 was the year that Emily first got her start in poetry writing. Her first poem, “Sic Transit Gloria Mundi,” was published in the Springfield Republican (Knapp 14). At the end of the Civil War, Emily Dickinson reduced the people she kept in contact with to only those she knew through Amherst. She dressed in nothing but white clothing and became a recluse. It is believed that Emily may have had an affair with Reverend Charles Wadsworth or

Emily Dickinson

1660 words - 7 pages pronouns to some of her poems were edited out at this time to keep from exploiting Susan. Mabel published only a small amount of her poems in 1890. It wasn't until a feud in the family was settled that the entire collection was published until 1955.Whether Emily Dickinson was a transcendentalist or a lesbian, she was and still is one of the world's best poets that ever lived. There are still many questions regarding her sexuality and her

Religious Influences on Emily Dickinson: Puritanism and Transcendentalism in Her Poetry.

1424 words - 6 pages contains" (Hart 859). The purpose of life for the Transcendentalist was the union with the Over-Soul which according to Emerson's Essays, First Series is the "'great nature in which we rest . . . that Unity within which every man's particular being is contained and made one with all other'" (qtd. in Hart 628).Transcendentalism allowed Emily Dickinson to emerge from her Puritan heritage. It permitted her to discover her self-worth by realizing

Emily Dickinson and Walt Whitman

1212 words - 5 pages 1. Short Essay (If you were coming in the Fall)Emily Dickinson has a very distinct style of poetry. She uses slantline (incomplete thoughts) which she delveloped in this poem, If you were coming in the Fall. She also uses one of her classic themes, love. The theme love by itself is much too simple, however, here she adopts the more developed theme of hope of romantic fulfillment. Basically it is love between two people (I assume people.) The

Comparison of Dickinson's Poetry.

1103 words - 4 pages Emily Dickinson grew up in a formidable Puritan family in Amherst, New England. In the beginning she was as much like her peers as any other child. As the years went on however, it would become clear that she was a singular person. The older Emily became, the more reluctant she became to leave home for even an hour at a time. During the last ten years of her life she refused to leave her house or garden at all, and her travels had barely taken


755 words - 4 pages , alongside Emerson whose poems Dickinson admired, as a Transcendentalist. However, Farr disagrees with this analysis, saying that Dickinson's "relentlessly measuring mind ... deflates the airy elevation of the Transcendental".[143] Apart from the major themes discussed below, Dickinson's poetry frequently uses humor, puns, irony and satire. Emily Dickinson’s legacy continues to this day as changing they way we view poetry and the way it has evolved

American Lit.

958 words - 4 pages group felt that mankind was extremely good. Three major transcendentalists were Emerson with ?Nature?, Thoreau with his piece on ?Civil Disobedience?, and Margaret Fuller the editor of The Dial, a transcendentalist magazine. The final group of this time period was the anti-transcendentalists. These writers felt that man was flawed. Writers in this group included Poe, Hawthorne, and Melville. All three of these men seem to write with a negative

American transcendentalism

1448 words - 6 pages authors as Walt Whitman, who, along with Nathaniel Hawthorne, Herman Melville, Emily Dickinson, and Edgar Allan Poe, were strongly influenced by Transcendentalism (Mullen and Wilson 1).Perhaps the best known and most influential of Emerson's immediate disciples is Henry David Thoreau, noted for his book Walden; or Life in the Woods, which has been regarded as a nature study, spiritual autobiography, and philosophical abstract, for his "Civil


602 words - 2 pages became wary of following their true nature.Other notable transcendentalist writersTranscendentalist WritersEmerson encouraged readers of 'Self-Reliance' to resist conforming to societal expectations. He wrote, 'Whoso would be a man, must be a nonconformist.' Emerson believed that man needed to act independently, regardless of if his impulses were deemed good or bad. In fact, he believed it was better to live a true life in obscurity than to be

Henry David Thoreau: The Grat Transcendentalist

2173 words - 9 pages transcendentalist belief in the imminence of god leads to the doctrine that every person can, without the need for an intermediary, experience the divine within himself or herself” (Norvell 1). Thoreau captured a lot of these moral values and brought them with him throughout his life. This is a perfect comparison to Thoreau’s individualistic ideas and appeal to institution. Years after graduating Harvard, Thoreau submitted many essays to the

Similar Essays

Emily Dickinson: Transcendentalist Experience Through Imagination.

1754 words - 7 pages into an essay and turns it into a revolutionary, anti-Emersonian vision.The skill and experiences which Dickinson writes comes from her body within, not something shown to her through nature or a divine spirit. She proclaims in Poem 632, "The Brain is just the weight of God--/For--Heft them--Pound for Pound--/ And they will differ--if they do--/ As Syllable from Sound." She wrote about first hand experiences that she never had, transcendentalist

Emily Dickinson's Female Transcendentalist Views Essay

1520 words - 6 pages The early 19th century ideas of transcendentalism, which were introduced by Ralph Emerson and David Thoreau, where man as an individual becomes spiritually consumed with nature and himself through experience are contrasted by Emily Dickinson, who chose to branch off this path by showing that a transcendentalist experience could be achieved through imagination alone. These three monumental writers set the boundaries for this new realm of thought

Conclusion Of Wether Or Not Emily Dickinson Believed In Life After Death...Comparrison Of "Because I Could Not Stop For Death" And "I Heard A Fly Buzz".

700 words - 3 pages she could not see any of the afterlife or Kings she expected to be there. The woman's soul drifted off into nothingness with no afterlife to travel to.To conclude, the beliefs of the two Dickinson poems in regards to life after death differ significantly. In one, "Because I Could not Stop for Death," the afterlife does exist, in the other, "I Heard a Fly Buzz- When I Died," it does not. It seems that Dickinson, too, questioned the question of whether or not there is an afterlife, and she herself, being so in touch with death, could not come to a solid conclusion. There is only one way to tell.

Two Essays On Hamlet; Main Idea /Themes, And "To Be Or Not To Be" Speech. Plus A Couple Of Junior School Poetry Essays, One Shorter Essay On Emily Dickinson.

2547 words - 10 pages How does the speech "To be or not to be..." affect our understanding of Hamlet's character and his role(s) in the play as a whole?In this speech we see the core of Hamlet's problem; we see clearly that he is a man who has come to understand himself. He has finally understood that his real problem is his incapacity to act in a decisive manner. The soliloquy concludes with this understanding. His role in the revenge tragedy had been to slay