Empathy And Commitment As The Basis For Trust

1374 words - 5 pages

Empathy and Commitment as the Basis for Trust
In Philoctetes by Sophocles, Odysseus commands Neoptolemos to abandon justice and base a relationship with Philoctetes on dishonesty to gain his trust and ultimately his bow. However, Neoptolemos acknowledges a similar burden plagues Philoctetes that becomes the basis of trust between them. Neoptolemos attempts to reconcile with Odysseus’ orders by stealing the bow and abandoning Philoctetes. Unable to fulfill the orders, Neoptolemos returns to Philoctetes indicating his commitment and his lack of trust with the Atreidai. Therefore, Sophocles challenges that trust is based on empathy and commitment as evident in Philoctetes’ and Neoptolemos’ relationship.
Empathy forms the basis for trust to exist between Neoptolemos and Philoctetes.
Neoptolemos encounters Philoctetes and recounts the injustice committed by Odysseus and the Greeks against him as “You monsters-you have dared to give to someone/other than me/the arms that by rights are my own” in order to gain his trust and steal his bow (ln.365-367). Neoptolemus’ initial portrayal of the hierarchy of the Atreidai as “monsters” represents the inhuman and untrustworthy nature of leaders such as Odysseus. It is difficult for human beings to establish a common ground to trust one another; whereas with “monsters” alienation devastates the existence of any common ground. Neoptolemos’ description reflects his alienation with Greeks and Odysseus. The Atreidai and Odysseus define their values as unjust and based apathy by denying Neoptolemos “the arms that by rights are [his]”. Odysseus’ entrustment of the armor Hephaestus crafted for Achilles and not Neoptolemos reflects the Atreidai’s lack of respect for sacred belongings and obligations surrounding inheritance. In his account to Philoctetes, Neoptolemos implies the Atreidai view Herakles’ bow and Philoctetes privilege to it with the same lack of respect as they view Achilles’ armor. Neoptolemos begins to empathize with Philoctetes and his situation as he recounts “I was infuriated…since he was going to rob me of/the arms that were mine” (ln.376-377). Neoptolemos recognizes the theft of Herakles’ bow parallels his loss of Achilles’ armor. The “fury” of Neoptolemos is the result of the cognizance of apathy and injustice as honored values of Odysseus and the Greeks. Odysseus becomes a common enemy for Neoptolemos and Philoctetes as the armor and bow are ultimately obtained by the values of Odysseus. Neoptolemos alludes to his inevitable resentment of Odysseus by stating “those in power; for the entire city, the whole army/is in the hands of those who rule; those men who are/wanting/in the discipline become evil by example of their/teachers” (ln.385-390). Neoptolemos amends for his swift acceptance of Odysseus’ ability to ignore shame by stating “men…become evil by example of their/teachers” in order to prevent the corruption of his character by preserving qualities that differentiate him from the Greeks....

Find Another Essay On Empathy and Commitment as the Basis for Trust

Rapport and Empathy: Important Skills for Communication in Health Services

1737 words - 7 pages Rapport and empathy are two essential skills for communication in health services. In this integrative essay, it is displayed how rapport and empathy play an important role for communication in health services, such as counselling and psychotherapy. Empathy helps building rapport with the client. Both skills are needed in counselling, because once the client has found trust in the counsellor there is a bigger chance of them opening up about

Financial Accounting: Tools for Business Decision Making Financial and Managerial Accounting: The Basis for Business Decisions

857 words - 3 pages , Weygandt, & Kieso, 2007, p. 396). Chapter 9 of Financial and Managerial Accounting: The Basis for Business Decisions by Williams, Haka, and Bettner (2005) is Plant and Intangible Assets. Plant assets are "long-lived assets that are acquired for use in business operations rather than for resale to customers" (Williams, Haka, & Bettner, 2005, p. 395) and intangible assets are "those assets that are used in the operation of a business but

Origins and misuse of the human genome project for a for profit basis only.

521 words - 2 pages allows researchers to secure a patent on individual genes that they have discovered. The Human Genome Project as a catch substitute for all of the things that research companies make money off of is not working. There are far too many people making big bucks off this, supposedly, pure research project.Most people don't have a clue that someone else owns the rights to the twisted ladder of particles that makes them who they are. DNA is a part of what

A Moral Basis for the Helping Professions

2387 words - 10 pages has a strong influence on the efficacy of treatment. Morality in the helping professions needs to take this into account. To be a good helping professional involves a commitment to develop into the right sort of person. The issue of morality in the helping professions is much discussed at present. Most recently, it has come up in connection with issues involving the abuse of trust in relationships of unequal psychological and emotional power

DNA: the basis for sustaining life

1639 words - 7 pages , it would take another 80 years before DNA would be considered actual genetic material. The medical and scientific communities of Miescher’s era felt that DNA was too simple for consideration as genetic material. It was not until the 20th century when James Watson and Francis Crick discovered the double helix through x-rays, that DNA would be recognized. Watson and Crick looked deeper into the DNA configuration and learned that the structure of

Nursing Theory: The Basis for Professional Nursing

1078 words - 4 pages , regulate body temperature by adjusting clothing and changing the environment, maintain proper hygiene and groom self as well as protection for the skin, keep out of dangers while not injuring others, proper communication with others and convey emotions, needs, fears, or opinions, worship in line with one's faith, work in satisfying manners, participate in recreational activities, learn, discover, or satisfy the curiosity that leads to healthy

Parfit, the Reductionist View, and Moral Commitment

3462 words - 14 pages they will remain committed in spite of such psychological changes. Indeed, if we supposed that the strength of a promise held its full strength only when the degree of psychological continuity and connectedness was equivalent with that of the person making the commitment as they were presently constituted, we would have no need for the promise at all since we already know that in their present state they are willing to take on the obligation

Civil Commitment and the Mentally Ill

1271 words - 6 pages schizophrenic. Daniel M’Naghten was under the false impression that he was being persecuted for shooting and killing Edward Drummond. M’Naghten was found not guilty for the crime because he was insane at the time of the crime ("United States Insanity Defense Law Summary and Law Digest", n.d.). “The English House of Lords to establish standards for the defense of insanity, the result subsequently referred to as the M'Naghten Rule” ("United States Insanity

My Desires for and Commitment to a College Education.

547 words - 2 pages master's to further open my education. As of right now I am currently employed as a student library for the Broward County Main Library in Florida. I was hired because of my integrity, intellectual personality, and my commitment to the job. This job has given me the opportunity to save up some money for college to pay for some of the books and tuition costs. Having this job has made my commitment toward my education the more important to me, as

Discuss the sexual hipocrasy that runs rampant through the novel "Joseph Andrews" using the character of Mrs. Slipslop as the primary basis for your argument.

1287 words - 5 pages shows her as one wanting to seem educated and reveals her as one who refuses to recognize the folly of her ways. " I should be sorry to think that your ladyship had any reason to respect me of fondness for a fellow , and if it be your pleasure, I shall fullfill it with as much reluctance as possible". Fielding shows the hypocrisy of the situation with Mrs. Slipslop's vehement denial of affection for Joseph and displays her misguided loyalty to the

Evidence is always the Primary Basis for Making a Decision

3006 words - 12 pages "Evidence is Always the Primary Basis for Making a Decision"- Discus with reference to specific examples and different disciplinary constructions of decision-making.Decision-making is the heart of our day-to-day lives and whether we realise it or not, we make thousands of individual decisions a day. Everything from what food to eat, to what way to tie your shoelaces is constituted as a decision and on this basis, it should be evident why so much

Similar Essays

Information As The Basis For Representation

2926 words - 12 pages Information as the Basis for Representation ABSTRACT: The article presents a proposal to use the notion of information and a model of its transmission for analysis of the structure and basic functions of a sign. This is to point to the relation between information and the basic function of a sign, that is, a 'representation.' A sign is understood, in accordance with Peirce's theory, as a triadic relation of representation. One of the

Strategic Management Trust, Commitment And Culture

2267 words - 9 pages them once they are established. "Too often, top executives devote more time to screening potential partners in financial terms than to managing the partnership in human terms." (Child and Faulkner, 1998) They neglect the "softer side" of alliance issues such as relationship management including the building of trust, commitment and cultural compatibility. Concentrating only on the alliance formation is not enough for the manager whose job is to

Bentham’s Principle Of Utility And Its Shortcomings As The Sole Basis For Morality

2018 words - 8 pages Jeremy Bentham in his book, An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation, is trying to create an ethical system that he believes ought to be the basis for all decision making. He states that “As to ethics in general, a man’s happiness will depend, in the first place, upon such parts of his behavior as none but himself are interested in ; in the next place, upon such parts of it as may affect the happiness of those about him

Human Freedom As The Basis Of Morality.

1258 words - 5 pages According to Kant, feeling of obligation is a moral feeling, a respect for the moral law. It has no external source and it is not imposed. The notion of obligation comes from us as rational, free beings. Human reason and freedom can only be source of moral law that is universal and binds everybody. Feeling of obligation cannot come from our knowledge-oriented experience because principles that directs the will in our relationships with objects