Employee Drug Testing (Violation Of Constitutional Rights.)

2313 words - 9 pages

EDGEWOOD COLLEGE - BUSINESS LAW I
Employee Drug TestingViolation of Constitutional Rights Judd, Jennah
9/18/2014

1
Introduction:
The word "privacy" means many different things to different people. One widely accepted
meaning, however, is the right to be left alone. The composers of the Constitution and the Bill of Rights
embraced this meaning and it is referenced many times throughout both documents. This right is now
under attack by Private employers who use the power of the paycheck to tell their employees what they
can and cannot do in the privacy of their own homes. The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) along
with the opponents of Employee Drug Testing believe that what a person does during non-working
hours away from the workplace should not be used as a basis for discrimination. Employee drug testing
is an invasion of privacy and it violates an employee's constitutional rights.
Employee drug testing began in 1986 when Ronald Reagan signed an Executive Order
prohibiting federal employees from using illegal drugs, on or off-duty. In 2011, 71% of respondent
business reported some category of employment drug testing. That number is up from 21% when drug
testing was first introduced in 1986.
Companies Which Drug Test Employees
Business Category Testing of NewHires Testing of All Employees
Financial Services 35.8% 18.8% Business & Professional Services 36.0% 18.4%
Other Services 60.3% 34.7% Wholesale & Retail 63.0% 36.8% Manufacturing 78.5% 42.2% http://www.drugwarfacts.org/cms/Drug_Testing_Employee#sthash.ILKWAqVy.dpuf

2
Legal Authority:
Three standards will be used in showing that Employee Drug Testing violates an employee's
constitutional rights.
1. The Restatement of the Law, Second, Torts 652B
Samuel Warren and Louis Brandeis formulated the common law "right of privacy" as a
general principle rooted in existing common law. The Restatement, Second, of Torts further
outlined this privacy right by setting forth a four-part common law test for unlawful invasion of
privacy.
The Restatement of the Law, Second, Torts 652B states "One who intentionally intrudes,
physically or otherwise, upon the solitude or seclusion of another or his private affairs or
concerns, is subject to liability to the other for invasion of his privacy, if the intrusion would be
highly offensive to a reasonable person." Drug testing would be considered to be highly
intrusive and offensive and it violates a person's reasonable expectation of privacy.
In regards to Drug Testing the Tort that we are most interested in is 652B. In this Tort it
says that privacy is invaded by "Unreasonable intrusion upon the seclusion of another." "Drug
Testing reveals all kinds of personal information that has nothing to do with drugs," say's
Murray Mollard, executive director of the B.C. Civil Liberties association. For example a
Urinalysis screening can disclose a person's medical condition or pregnancy. Most employee's
would also agree that what they do off of work grounds is...

Find Another Essay On Employee Drug Testing (violation of constitutional rights.)

Random Drug Testing vs Employees' Privacy Rights

1741 words - 7 pages , suspicion less drug testing of all current employees who were offered promotions was not reasonable under the Fourth Amendment. In this instance, the courts have protected the rights of the employee to not be tested again after they have been hired, just because they are being looked at for promotion. If the employee is acting normally and making good decisions on their current job, there is no reason to test them just because they are being promoted

Drug and Alcohol Testing: Do employers have the right to submit employees to drug and alcohol testing? Do these tests enfringe on the rights of employees?

1137 words - 5 pages may have a case against an employer for an invasion of the employee's privacy in extreme cases.Individuals using the utilitarian form of ethics would likely feel that arbitrarily testing employees was a direct violation of an employees right to privacy. Unless an employee is showing signs of drug and alcohol abuse, employers do not have the right to violate an employee's privacy. On the other hand, individuals that subscribe to the deontological

violation of human rights

1142 words - 5 pages Violations | Beyond Intractability. N.p., n.d. Web. July2003. 22 Nov. 2013. Retrieved from : . Parikh, sanjay. "Phone tapping: Violation of constitutional, human rights." The Economic Times. Web. Apr 26 , 2010. 22 Nov. 2013. Retrived from : . The advocates of

Iraq Violation of Human Rights

1899 words - 8 pages when they express it freely. The same day, “Demonstrators in an ethnically disputed northern city and a minibus carrying Shiite pilgrims to the holy city of Karbala were among the latest targets of Iraqi militants in a string of bombings that killed 20 people,”(Fox). This exceeds the human rights violation radar that has been ringing since the beginning. Not only should the gathering of these people be okay, but they should also not have to be

Constitutionality of Drug testing

1104 words - 4 pages The drug testing policy is a broken system that should be eliminated, it is siphoning off funds, is fundamentally ineffective and a blatant violation of constitutional rights Chris Hardy English III CP T.Wecht September 18, 2009 Constitutionality of Drug testing Free Speech. Fair trials. Due process. Protection from unreasonable search and seizure. The common factor? All the latter are God-given rights, rights that Americans

Violation of Human Rights: Homosexuality and Military

2741 words - 11 pages . Constitutional court found the conflict between the DADT policy and fundamental Human Rights which the US officially recognized. After electing Barrack Obama as a president in 2008, the US was waiting for the repeal of the DADT. He promised to lift the ban in his presidential campaign before. Hovewer, it was not accomplished by his administration until 2011 due to some difficulties. On July 22 2011, the repeal was officially signed by US officials

A Violation of Rights-School Uniforms

927 words - 4 pages of intentions, but it has lead to many problems. It is not the school's responsibility to teach neither morals, principles, nor the entirety of social interaction. This is a responsibility of the home and parents. Proper behavior should be taught at home and re-enforced in school. If the rules are violated, proper punishment should follow. A violation at home should result in a "home based" punishment. A violation at school should result

Violation of Human Rights in Nigeria

1839 words - 7 pages several parts of Asia, a very rarely discussed violation of human rights, even politicians have avoided taking sides on the subject. This practice is believed to be a crippling act, causing many women that undergo the tradition to suffer physical and social discomfort. Reducing their self worth, and sociability is crime enough, but it has been said that it causes a physical discomfort in day to day acts even, buts also in the act of sexual intercourse

Haitian Government and Violation of Human Rights

1621 words - 6 pages the government wanted you dead you would die they had hitmans and everything they are unstoppable to the Haiti citzens. According to The Front Line in Haiti speaking out to the government and defending human rights is asking for death. So that is another human rights violation right there freedom of speech. To no be harmed by the government you had to be on perfect behavior. According to Human rights violations on the increase a Haitian government

Violation of Human Rights in "The Crucible"

689 words - 3 pages , and maybe the clearest, example to prove the point of violated human rights. This article says 'all are equal before the law and entitled without any discrimination to equal protection before the law. All are entitled to protection against any discrimination in violation this Declaration and against any incitement to such discrimination'. In the witch trials of Salem, it was perfectly clear that the twenty people that lost their lives were not

The Violation of Human Rights in Cuba

3442 words - 14 pages The Violation of Human Rights in Cuba One of the largest Human Rights violations occurring in the world today is on the small island of Cuba. The government there is repressing the civil and political rights of all it citizens mainly the right to free speech and free press. Article 53 of the Cuban Constitution provides: “Freedom of speech and press are recognized for citizens consistent with the purposes of socialist society. The

Similar Essays

Employee Drug Testing (A Violation Of Constitutional Rights)

2313 words - 9 pages % Business & Professional Services 36.0% 18.4% Other Services 60.3% 34.7% Wholesale & Retail 63.0% 36.8% Manufacturing 78.5% 42.2% http://www.drugwarfacts.org/cms/Drug_Testing_Employee#sthash.ILKWAqVy.dpuf 2 Legal Authority: Three standards will be used in showing that Employee Drug Testing violates an employee's constitutional rights. 1. The Restatement of the Law, Second, Torts 652B Samuel Warren and Louis Brandeis formulated the common

Drug Testing Is Not A Violation Of Individual Rights

2882 words - 12 pages Every day companies lose millions of dollars due to employee drug use. Athletes break world records with gargantuan strength, but not on a fair scale. Drugs ruin the lives of users and cause injury to those who must work with users. Detection by officials is necessary to curb this problem. When does the safety for others violate the rights of drug users? Drug testing, whether in the workplace or on the athletic field, is not a violation of

Censorship In Music Is A Violation Of Constitutional Rights

942 words - 4 pages on and off the air, and in 1934 the Federal Communications Center (FCC) was created to monitor and filter all music that is released to the public. This censorship is in violation of constitutional rights according to the first amendment, this specific topic of controversy has not taken full affect, yet. However, in Syria many musicians are being scouted, fined, and even jailed for simply trying to express themselves. In addition, the progression

Drug Testing Is A Violation Of The Fourth Amendment

3079 words - 12 pages drug-free workplaces. Most of the employers set up voluntary testing programs and many employees began to sue, claiming that individual testing is a violation of privacy rights (Horgan, 21). The argument is that the employees are being deprived of their Fourth Amendment protection (22). Many believe that government testing programs should be unconstitutional unless the authorities have either reasonable suspicion or probable cause that the