Management Should Have The Right To Allow A Union In The Workplace Or Not

1906 words - 8 pages

History shows that there has been conflict of power within the workforce between union and management. This essay will discuss if management should have the right to determine whether a union should operate within their workplace. It is necessary first to discuss the roles of unions and management in the workplace and discuss both points of view on the power distribution between unions and management in the workplace.
The rise of industrial age led to the rise of industrial factory systems. As the industries grew larger as well as the workplace, it required more employees. As the employees grew in the workplace, their relationship with the employer became less personal hence individuals lost power. (History of Labor Unions Summary & Analysis, 2014) emphasizes that there was little to nothing an individual could do to pressure a large industrial business to increase his/ hers wages or shorten his/hers hours or provide a better working environment. The increasing migrants in Australia during the 1960’s continually replenished the supply of unskilled workers making it difficult for any employee to attain any leverage in negotiations with their employers. This led to employee’s embracement of collective action which then led to the rise of unions. According to (Burchielli, R 2006) Unions are seen as the power house of employees in the workplace, their role was to give employee a collective bargaining with their employers for better working environment, better wages and benefits such as paid leave. However union membership have decreased over the last couple of decades, according to (Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS), 2013) in 1986 46 % of employees were members of trade unions by 2007 the figures have dropped to only 19%. There are many factors that have contributed to the reduction of unions such as the change of the industrial environment in 1980s and membership fees increase and the change from majority of employees being casual rather than permanent or part time.
Many unions have lost the employees trust over the past few years, (John W. Budd 2004, p. 103) this article states “Unions are portrayed as powerful organizations, often corrupt, that at best benefit their members at the expense of non-members and the society at large, and at worst really only serve the interests of union bosses”. The reduction of union members can show us that employees are preferring individual bargain rather than collective bargain. The implementation of an award in Australia by the Australian Industrial Relation Commission (AIRC) (Peetz 2006, pg.8) has encouraged more employees, especially casual employees to embrace individual bargaining hence reducing the need of unions in workplace.

There has not been a definite definition of management’s role in a workplace over the year but I think jones & George said it best when they described it as, “the planning, organising, leading and controlling of human and other resources to achieve organisational goals...

Find Another Essay On Management Should Have the Right to Allow a Union in the Workplace or Not

Should Canadian government have the right to withhold or suspend the rights of Canadian citizens in times of crisis?

901 words - 4 pages Should Canadian government have the right to withhold or suspend the rights of Canadian citizens in times of crisis?Looking back at the past that Canada strived through, there were many problems that she faced to be an independent and democratic country it is today. Times of major wars troubled internal-external affairs, sovereignty issues and national security regarding international organizations were all a part of a big crisis that put

The Courts Should Not Have the Right to Make Legislation that the Majority of People Do Not Approve Of

680 words - 3 pages should favor the majority. That way we can be sure that a number of people are being protected, while the minorities are also being protected in other ways. The law should reflect the will of the majority and lawmakers should not have the right to make legislation that the majority of people do not approve of.

Should convicted felons have the right to vote?

1343 words - 6 pages the Bible tells how Jesus was saying to his followers that we should love everyone, even our enemies and persecutors. I honestly believe that the law should treat everyone fairly but only if the ex-convicts have learned their lesson. In the 2008 election, roughly 5.3 million Americans could not vote due to a felony conviction and disenfranchisement. Like I have said before, 38 states in the United States of America allow the right to vote to be

Should adults have the right to die as they choose?

1744 words - 7 pages protect you from living the rest of your life in an undesirable state? In essence, our life and physical body belong to ourselves therefore we should have complete control of what we choose to do with it. If humans have the right-to-life should they not also have the right-to-death? I believe that it should be the right of every adult who suffers from a chronic, debilitating condition, terminal illness, or mental distress to have the right to die as

Dating in the workplace: Do employers have the right to regulate the social activities of their employees?

1297 words - 5 pages company may take appropriate action, up to and including termination. Listed below are a few of the requirements that employees must agree to before engaging in workplace dating.1. Our relationship is entirely voluntary.2. Our relationship will not have a negative impact on our work.3. We will not engage in any public displays of affection or other behavior that creates a hostile work environment for others, or that makes others uncomfortable.4

Russia and Countries that Allow Discrimination to Freely Occur Should not be Given the Privilege to Host The Olympics.

2133 words - 9 pages government is not taking action to intervene but instead supporting it. After studying these controversial issues we decided to title our persuasive communication, ‘Russia and countries that allow discrimination to freely occur should not be given the privilege to host The Olympics.’ We studied the origins of The Olympics, what it represents and its interrelation with events that overcame discrimination in the past. Our main stand point was that The

Should mothers to be have a right to abortion?

1013 words - 4 pages are poor. The majority of people today may gear their views against abortion, because they feel as though it is morally wrong. Yet, the question still remains, 'Should mothers to be have a right to abortion?' My answer is, yes mothers should have that right.A woman may refuse to have an abortion because she believes that it is against God's Law or words, as stated in Exodus 20 verse 13 "Thou shall not kill". And by that means, some would say that

A persuasive essay leaning towards the fact abortion should be a decision women have the right to make.

594 words - 2 pages Think for a second that you are against abortion. Now put yourself in the shoes of a father or relative of a woman who was raped or a young teenager who was impregnated by her boyfriend. Would you still be against it then? It is easy to be against something that has never affected your life. You can say abortion is murder and it is wrong, but it is a choice women have the right to make. Whether or not to have an abortion is a decision women have

Do you agree that abortion should be legal under circumstances or mothers should have the right to abortion as they wish?

1248 words - 5 pages Do you agree that abortion should be legal under circumstances or mothers should have the right to abortion as they wish?Why should abortion be legalised? A number of Controversial arguments about problems of abortion have been discussed seriously in many countries over hundreds of years. For example, Ireland and Texas have just passed the law and restrictions respectively relating to abortion after lengthy heated discussion. It is a very

The United Kingdom Should NOT Leave the European Union

1260 words - 5 pages the EU, people for example have a guaranteed 48 hour working week, guaranteed rights and people are paid four week holidays as well as being protected by anti-discrimination laws. All of these rights and laws could be diminish by the British Government. Therefore staying in the EU allows the citizens of the UK to feel safe and not worry over the future. In conclusion Great Britain should not leave the European Union, if it did, it will

Should Celebrities Have Their Right to Privacy?

2330 words - 9 pages became the first court to recognize that a common law right of privacy exists in the state. That has used an unauthorized photograph of the plaintiff Paolo Pavesich and attributed statements to him that he did not make. In 1920 The American Civil Liberties Union is dedicated to protecting First Amendment rights and rights to equal protection under the law, due process, and privacy. The European Convention on Human Rights states that all people have

Similar Essays

A Discussion On Trade Unions And Whether Management Should Have The Right To Determine Whether They Should Operate Within Their Workplace.

2104 words - 9 pages employer to fire a worker for being a member of a union, and they are unable to prevent workers from joining a union (Trade Unions 2012). In the same respect, management cannot force employees to join unions or treat their staff unfairly for belonging to a union (Fair Work Ombudsman 2013). This essay will focus on the importance of unions in the workplace and will discuss why management should not have the right to determine whether a union should

A Letter To King George Iii Of England Expressing Whether Or Not He Should Allow The Colonists To Declare Their Independence From England.

744 words - 3 pages gullible. The Tea Act only allowed us to buy tea from the British East India Company. We should have the right to make our own decisions. The Navigation Acts have forced us to only trade with Britain, who in return sold us the same item, but for more money. The Proclamation of 1763 forced us to not move west of the Appalachian Mountains for which we fought and gave our lives for. Since you could not protect us from the Native Americans because of your

Should Women Have The Right To Abortion?

1262 words - 5 pages Federation). Additionally abortion does not involve any babies; it is the termination of a pregnancy by removing the embryo or the fetus from the woman’s womb. If a pregnancy results from rape or incest, the survivor should have the option to go through an abortion if they do not want to give birth to the child of their aggressor. In 2012 RAINN estimated about 17,342 pregnancies as a result of rape (Rape, Abuse and Incest Network). While not all victims

Euthanasia: A Controversial Issue Paper Dealing With Whether Or Not People Have The Right To Choose To Die. This Paper Is In Support Of Euthanasia/Assisted Suicide.

1257 words - 5 pages , terminally ill patients have the right to choose.The Hippocratic Oath is an oath in which a doctor promises not to givea lethal drug to a patient, or to suggest that a patient take any lethaldrug. In the past, state legislatures have advocated the medicalprofessions monopoly by not allowing unauthorized medical procedures and bygiving physicians control over powerful drugs. In return laws have requireddoctors to abide by the Hippocratic Oath which