This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Was Stalin A Success? Essay

2044 words - 8 pages

Was Stalin a Success?

Whether Stalin was a success can only be measured in two ways, his own
terms, in the terms of Russia or in the terms of Communism - meaning
whether what he did with 'Communist' Russia would have been seen as
Communist by Karl Marx. How much of a success was Stalin? - If at all
and from whose point of view was he a success or not.

Stalin being a success in his own terms that is what he would of felt
he achieved and what he believed made him a success. He was very
successful politically as he won the Struggle for power in 1917, this
he would have seen as a success, and he would have seen his life as a
resounding success in his own terms. The First Five Year plan, he
would have deemed a success as it achieved the crash industrialisation
and doubled the productivity of industry, which meant the working
class grew, which meant communism was growing as well. He managed to
collectivise the peasants so controlling the food supply for the
workers - a success (in his terms). The Great Terror 1936-38, he now
had total control over his people, government and army, he had created
a Totalitarian State through the Trotskyite - Zinovievite conspiracy,
which made people produce more and through the fear of being named as
a conspirator. Another success in his eyes was the performance of the
Red army in the WWII, as he believed they won by capturing of Berlin -
with the Russian tanks getting to Berlin first. After the Second World
War Stalin had steadily captured more and more of Eastern Europe
between 1945-1948, he had slowly dropped an iron curtain over Europe
and had also turned China communist. He used each country as a
satellites, this slow but steady capture of Eastern Europe was again
to Stalin a success. These successes from the point of view of Stalin
would have meant that he was a success; because it was due to him that
all of these 'successes' happened. This is only from the opinion of
Stalin, whereas these 'successes' may have been felt differently from
the terms of the Russian people, yet in Stalin's terms he was a
success as nearly everything he attempted worked for him, one way or
another.

Russia may have been a military superpower under Stalin and Communism
it was still a third-world economy, which meant the people suffered
greatly. The Five Year Plans that Stalin saw as a success from his
point of view left the workers disillusioned, because the
concentration of the Five Year Plans was on Capital goods, this left
no room for commercial goods, like clothes and shoes. This meant
during the Five Year Plan shoes usually ran out. The results of this
was that the workers felt alienated from the system and they
subsequently their productivity was low and unproductive. If the Five
Year Plans had included basic consumer goods then the productivity of
the...

Find Another Essay On Was Stalin a Success?

The league of nations was a success

551 words - 2 pages The League of Nations managed to keep a lot of items going and introduced co-operation between countries in the 1920'sIn my opinion the League of Nations was a success I will discuss my reasons in this essay.The aims of the League of Nations were to discourage aggression, to encourage co-operation, disarmament and to improve working conditions for everyone in the world.The League of Nations was set up because after the First World War everyone

To what extent was Stalin anything more than a brutal dictator?

1116 words - 4 pages Yes Stalin was brutal few would deny that. Many might think that was an understatement. Whether he was anything more than brutal asks the question did Stalin cause anything of worth or success that was valuable to Russia or beyond. If you take that further the word 'more' suggests this theoretical value or worth of Stalin would have to be above or excel beyond his brutality. Where the successes of Stalin separate/more than a by-product of his

Was the league of nations a success or a failure?

3786 words - 15 pages should keep the island but they also made it a Demilitarized Zone. This decision was respected by both countries. However, the islanders were given autonomy - a kind of independence, they ruled themselves. The Fins had no control over them. Another area of dispute, that the League had success solving, was Upper Silesia in 1921. The inhabitants, under the treaty got the right to choose whether they wanted to be part of Germany or part of Poland. The

Chris McCandless' Quest for Inner Peace Was a Success

592 words - 3 pages , as his journey comes to end of fading death from the poisonous berry, he learned how take human relationship as a luxury not a necessity. Throughout the weeks of solitude and lack of human contact in the deep forest, he learned to take human relationship from another perspective the learned the quality to forgive as an adult. Last but not least, he was able to find inner peace when he was to forgive his family symbolizing his success of finding the inner peace and transition to adulthood.

What Caused the First Crusade, and was it a Success?

1346 words - 5 pages repentance and joy; and then again they would start up and break loose into some frightful acts of cruelty and plunder against the conquered enemy, sparing neither old man, nor woman, nor child" (The First Crusade). In the end they did succeed in capturing Jerusalem but there were only a few left of the crusader's army because many had died in battle and of starvation and diseases.To sum up, the First Crusade was a success, but it was the only

Where the Roman Authorities Justified in Claiming that the Campaign of 43ad was a Brilliant success

1344 words - 5 pages Magnus and silanius. To credit his supposed victory Claudius got the submission of the British kings. The submission he received was from the British chieftains but he changed it to kings because a king sounds like more of a worthy opponent. Claudius was hailed as a victorious general or imperator by his troops in Britain.When the senate learnt of his success the senate credited Claudius with many accomplishments. As an ancient Roman equivalent to

"As long as Stalin was running the Soviet Union a Cold war was unavoidable." (J.L Gaddis, We Now Know). Discuss this interpretation of the origins and character of the Cold War

2078 words - 8 pages Comrade Iosef Stalin is that so much propaganda and fear existed on both sides of the bi-polar power struggle. The USA plugged its population with the belief that Soviet Russia had plans to remove their freedoms and to reduce them to a lower than low populace, with no power over their own lives. The Soviets believed that the capitalist west was exploiting its populace; the only way for all peoples to be equal and free was to release these people from

A Nation that was Rocked: How The Ed Sullivan Show Contributed to the Success of Elvis Presley

1910 words - 8 pages popularity was able to take a small town artist and make he or she into an enormous success, specifically, Elvis Presley who was, “something new under the Sun” (Altschuler 30). Teenagers, however, viewed the television as an escape and a look into the unknown and intriguing world of African American culture. Through the extreme recognition of The Ed Sullivan Show, the power of mass media and the fascination with African American culture, Elvis

Animal Farm, a novella by George Orwell, was written during Russia's height of Communist power and is an allegory whose deeper meaning concerns the Russian Revolution and rule under Josef Stalin

661 words - 3 pages Animal FarmAnimal Farm is a novella by George Orwell that was written during Russia's height of Communist power. The story is an allegory whose deeper meaning concerns the Russian Revolution and rule under Josef Stalin. Animal Farm is about a farm where the animals are abused by their master, Mr. Jones. One night, a wise and elderly boar, Old Major, tells the animals of a dream he had where all animals work together, without human interaction

This essay was written for a semester exam to exemplify how valuable a tool an education is to aid success in today's world. Untitled

964 words - 4 pages caveman, what he had to offer - no pretty sight, it turned out, for my friends" (Homer, 700 B.C., pg. 162). Although Odysseus evaded death, members of the crew did not fair such a fate. For an almost perfect example displaying the value of success an education holds, look no further than the story of Susan B. Anthony. Susan grew-up well-to-do house and was properly educated, quite rare for the time especially for women. She enthralled herself with

Was Reconstruction a Success or a Failure

1609 words - 7 pages , he declared, "I will indeed be your Moses, and lead you through the Red Sea of war and bondage to a fairer future of liberty and peace." However, Johnson did little to help the advancement of coloured people. In Document 12, he reasoned, "It will not do to let the negroes have universal suffrage now. It would breed a war of races." Also, in Document 1, Johnson argued that he was not going to allow the government to aid them anymore

Similar Essays

Was Stalin A Neccessary Evil? Assess

1979 words - 8 pages Joseph Stalin is undoubtedly one of the most notorious characters in history. He has been called: The greatest criminal in history and a 20th century Ivan the Terrible. He ruled as a supreme dictator and was responsible for the deaths of millions during collectivization, through slave labour camps and through grave mistakes during WW2. He isolated the Soviet Union from most of the world, keeping his people inside and keeping foreigners out. He

The New Deal Was Not A Success

1056 words - 4 pages crops and more unemployment, and hurt many more people than it helped. The NRA did not provide enough to really help the working people of America. The New Deal did not do enough to help the people out of unemployment and poverty. Overall, while the New Deal was in action, it did not provide sufficient relief to the country, and was therefore not a success.         One of the New Deal Acts that caused a lot of problems was the

Was Henry Vii's Foreign Policy A Success

1334 words - 5 pages HENRY'S FOREIGN POLICY- SUCCESS OR FAILUREIt is possible to argue that Henry's foreign policy was a success. Under his reign England faced no foreign invasions and, largely, he was able to protect and preserve the Tudor dynasty. However, any achievements he made in terms of military victories abroad were little and insignificant - the tiny villages of Tournai and Therouanne being the only territory captured- and overall cost much more than they

Was Henry Vii Foreign Policy A Success

1334 words - 5 pages HENRY'S FOREIGN POLICY- SUCCESS OR FAILUREIt is possible to argue that Henry's foreign policy was a success. Under his reign England faced no foreign invasions and, largely, he was able to protect and preserve the Tudor dynasty. However, any achievements he made in terms of military victories abroad were little and insignificant - the tiny villages of Tournai and Therouanne being the only territory captured- and overall cost much more than they