This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

English Colonists Vs Native Americans: Property Rights In The New World

1206 words - 5 pages

English colonists that came to settle the New World had one conception of what property was; in their minds, property equaled money. This differed greatly from the Native Americans’ perspective, where property equaled survival. When the English colonists took land that naturally belonged to the Indians under the rights of the charter given to them by the English Crown, they misconstrued many of the conceptions of property that the Natives’ had. Even though the English were similar to the Natives in certain aspects, in most, such as who had the right to the land, how the land should be farmed, what value property actually had, and who pre-owned and could distribute the land, both cultures differed greatly, leading to eventual conflict between the English and Native Americans.
Although the English and Native Americans were both every different in how they viewed the land, there were some similarities between the two cultures. First of all, both agreed to the terms of a monarchy- the idea that a monarch that ruled over the land was more a symbolic figure of a whole people rather than a rich and wealthy land owner. Even though the English called their monarch a King, and the Indians’ a Sachem, the ideas behind the two were virtually the same. Secondly, if hunters were in pursuit of game, both cultures agreed to the fact that they could cross otherwise strict borders in attainment of the game. This shows that even though both were fairly precise in drawing village borders, food superseded otherwise legal boundaries. Lastly, the English and the Native Americans both were little different in their sense of how land could be bought or sold. Now, this does not mean that they thought viewed property the same or that they used it in the same way; no, it just means the both sold it in similar fashion: treaties that outlined what the specific rules for that purchase were. Both had a fixed list of things that the buyer could, could not, to with the land, demonstrating the fact that they mutually believed it to be beneficial to both parties to have a set contract for each individual purchase. So although the Indians and English were very different in the way in which they viewed property, in a few aspects they had similar view points.
Since the Indians did not use their resources to the fullest and ‘improve’ the land, besides planting crops and burning woods, many English colonists believed that they could supersede the Indians’ natural right to the land by using the civil law of owning land; anyone who began to raise crops, keep cattle, or improve the land by enclosing had the right to the land that they were farming on: “People who moved so much and worked so little did not deserve to lay claim to the land they inhibited”(Cronon 55). This was a misconception of the Native American way of life was common among the English settlers. From the English view point, the Indians lived “like paupers in a landscape of natural wealth” (Cronon 54),...

Find Another Essay On English Colonists vs Native Americans: Property Rights in the New World

Native Americans' Civil Rights Struggle Essay

1144 words - 5 pages The Native Americans have come across long journey of difficult times since the occupation of their land by European settlers. There are still two sides of a coin- a world of civilization and a world of underdeveloped society in this one country- USA. The paradox is that the constitution which seems to be a model of democracy to many nations of the world lacks a lot for not acting accordingly. Those organized and unorganized struggles of

The Inevitable War between Native Americans and Colonial English Settlers

787 words - 4 pages the New World to be what they envisioned it to be. In Anderson’s article, conflict between the Native Americans and the English settlers was inevitable due to the Native Americans inability to accept the European’s using animals as livestock. “Moreover, the Indians, for whom most beasts were literally fair game, struggled with the very notion of property in animals. They assumed that one could own only dead animals, which hunters shared with

What made the English settlers who came to the New World (America) make the transition from Englishmen abroad to Americans, and what made them come together in the end for a Revolution?

829 words - 3 pages The English and Parliament did a lot of injustices to the colonial people. England's greediness is what caused the "Englishmen abroad" to make the transition to be Americans. Who could blame them for wanting to break their ties with the Crown and call themselves American. The colonists produced their own things and England was jealous and wanted to kill colonial competition, so they took advantage of the colonists and took their things. The

The Relationship between the Environment and Humans as Shown by the Native Americans and the English Settlers

821 words - 3 pages Americans were natural born warriors, they were not schooled and they suffered from a lack of farming abilities, but their capability to adapt to their surroundings was unmatched and gave them a greater appreciation for the land they lived on. The English settlers were more advanced than the Native Americans in farming techniques, but they struggled to adapt to the climate of North America given the fact they were new to the land. The Native

Colonists Living Among Natives in the New World

2970 words - 12 pages Colonists Living Among Natives in the New World When the Europeans invaded the New World in 1492 they brought along their culture and way of life. The Europeans were not prepared to encounter a previously developed culture, which was home to the Indians. The negative stereotype of the Indians as viscous savages and barbarians was immediately formed by the Europeans beginning as early as Christopher Columbus' discovery of the New World

The Colonists of the New World

1258 words - 5 pages In the 1600s the land of Massachusetts Bay and Virginia were the first two regions to be colonized in the New World. Both colonies, New England and Chesapeake, had each of their own separate failures and of course, their successes. Virginia’s colony focused immensely on labor and profit which took the attention away from forming community infrastructure and stability which is what allowed Massachusetts Bay to start their settlement on the right

Property Rights in the West

2184 words - 9 pages today’s time, we can see that the lack of property rights in nature such as fishing in the oceans has caused a larger and greater problem for the world in general as follows from the tragedy of common’s theory. The natural consequence of property rights, and we do not need government intervention to allow this to happen if the people in the system are thinking of the correct sense. In that way, Anderson and Hill believed the Native Americans for the

Europeans vs. Native Americans

1018 words - 4 pages It is commonly accepted today that perceptions form the views of reality. Our perceptions shape our world view. "It is the gift that enables you to become acquainted with the world around you." What happens when people who perceive things differently meet? Their realities collide and conflict often results unless the gap which exists between their worlds is bridged. This has never been truer than in the case of the Native Americans. In this

The Disappearance of Native Americans in California

1642 words - 7 pages throughout the United States joined in a struggle for Indian rights and in 1987 the U.S. Supreme Court granted the right to Native Americans to build casinos on reservation. This new business system dramatically changed the economic living situation of many California's native people. “By 2005, there were 55 Native American casinos in California bringing in a total annual income of more than $3.5 billion” (Paddison

Native Americans in the Modern US

583 words - 3 pages Native Americas Pursing STEM Majors The Article I have selected to present on the topic of Native Americans in the modern US discusses the potential for success among Native Americans in the fields of science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM). Research shows there is a great need for technology students in the US (http://www.ed.gov/stem). Native Americans have the potential for success in the fields of science and technology

Native Americans In The United States

1121 words - 4 pages States? Why do they receive this special treatment? A common misconception is that the unique status of Native Americans in the United States is based on race. On the contrary, the special treatment of Indian people and tribes has nothing to do with racial discrimination or classification, but it is their status as separate political groups that requires special treatment. In fact, "the Commerce Clause of the Constitution explicitly authorizes

Similar Essays

Native Americans Vs. European Colonists Essay

2164 words - 9 pages The European colonists and the Native Americans of North America had very different views on nearly everything they encountered in their lives. Living in vastly different cultures lead both groups to have two extremely different outlooks on four main topics; religious beliefs, the environment, social relations, and slavery, differences which the colonists used to their advantage when conquering the peoples of the New World. The

Europeans And Native Americans In The New World

1081 words - 4 pages Europeans and Native Americans in the New World Disease and Medicine along with war and religion were three ways American history has changed. When the colonists came over from Europe they unknowingly changed the world forever in ways they couldn't have imagined. These effects were present to both Native Americans and Europeans. Some of these changes made life easier for both Native Americans and Europeans but some made relations worse too

John Steinbeck's Discussion Of The Interaction Between Native Americans And Colonists In "The Pearl"

2123 words - 8 pages " to other races.Steinbeck reinforces the idea that the colonists were living better than the Native Americans in the following quote:"The procession left the brush houses and entered the stone and plaster city where the streets were a little wider and there was a narrow pavement beside the buildings." (Steinbeck, pg. 47)Steinbeck shows that the Native Americans saw the colonists' living conditions as better than theirs, and that the streets were

Cruel And Inhuman Treatment Of Native Americans By The Colonists

1745 words - 7 pages The process of assimilation, as it regards to the Native Americans, into European American society took a dreaded and long nearly 300 years. Initially, when the European’s came to the hopeful and promising land of the “New World”, they had no desire or reason anything but minimal contact with the Indians. However, starting in the 1700s the European colonists population skyrocketed. The need for more resources became evident and the colonists