Increase Of The Tax On Cigarettes

1039 words - 4 pages

The central issue in the article is whether or not the government should be allowed to increase the tax on cigarettes. Contemporary liberal society is governed on the basis that autonomy, human rights, and liberties will be respected, but also that the government will care for its citizens. Upon careful analysis of addiction to nicotine, the effects this addiction will have on the population, and the obligations of the government, one will find that the government does not have the right to increase taxes on cigarettes.

The government has the right to interfere in tobacco sales as long as the autonomy of the individual is impaired. In this case the government is allowed to interfere, because government is itself established in order to protect the interests of its citizens and be paternalistic. When something impairs the autonomy of individuals and they are no longer able to make rational decisions, the government (and citizens) are required to interfere in the interests of the impaired individuals’ own wellbeing. There is almost no debate that individuals can become addicted to smoking, and addiction impairs autonomy in that the addicted individual cannot be considered rational when they persist in smoking despite evidence that it harms them, those around them, and their environment, all the while taking up chunks of the household income. The detriments brought about by smoking cannot be negated, in my opinion, by marginal benefits such as stress relief, and so a fully rational individual has no reason to smoke. An individual addicted to smoking thus cannot be considered rational because the addiction overrides rationality, and in that capacity the government has right to intervene. Some might argue that it is possible for an individual to overcome addiction solely on willpower, or that some are purely social smokers and it is thus an autonomous choice; however one cannot expect all (or any) individuals in society to have the capacity to break free of an addiction to smoking. This brings into question whether one can quantify willpower or addiction, and I take the stance that they cannot, because willpower and addiction are subject to factors such as filial, social, psychological, and emotional pressure which fluctuate each day, and therefore it is better to dissuade all smokers to reduce the number that become addicted. It is thus not realistic to expect anyone to have capacity to quit – smoking has been analogised with slavery accurately, in that it disallows autonomy , . Clearly there is an imperative for the government to intervene, as the autonomy of smokers is impaired.

The nature of the tax disallows less prosperous individuals who really/autonomously desire to smoke to continue to do so. The idea behind this legislation is that those who cannot support the habit and themselves at the same time are forced to go ‘cold turkey,’ but some who are stubbornly addicted to smoking can be expected to pursue it at the expense of other,...

Find Another Essay On Increase of the Tax on Cigarettes

The Harmful Effects of Cigarettes Essay

1261 words - 6 pages , lead people to be exposed of second-hand smoke, and causes people to abuse their usage of these drugs which leads to health issues; thus, we need to ban the use of cigarettes in our country to stop the death rate and the problem of addiction. Two of the major factors that mostly influences one to smoke are friends and going to parties or clubs. Telling one to quit without an understanding of the health issues involved in smoking, is not quite a

The Negative Effects of Cigarettes and E-cigarettes

2809 words - 11 pages years. Cigarette tax is manly why the U.S. will not deplete cigarettes but will only care to put a label of advice saying it’s not a good idea. Without the tax money available to the government, the government would be no more. According to tobacco free kids every state that has significantly increased its cigarette tax has enjoyed substantial increases in revenue. The federal government is increasing the tax on cigarettes to little over $1.51

Analysis of the Electronic Cigarettes Market

2291 words - 9 pages -cigarettes market and their supply conditions. After supply conditions, we should think about how to increase the demand which can help companies realise how to operate in the market. It will be talked about below. Forces driving demand of E-cigarette Understanding about demand will help companies understand how to operate and adjust themselves on the basis of demand. This report will discuss that by price and substitute. The characteristics of E

The Increase of Transgender people

1529 words - 7 pages relate to transgender students are, and how they help these students find themselves. (Sokoll 1). This means that more students are having the opportunity to be be exposed to the concept of transgenderism. With more young adult transgender novels on the bookshelves, students who are questioning their gender identity or are even dealing with it can know that they are not alone. There has been a significant increase in religions that support

The Increase of Teenage Pregnancy

1327 words - 5 pages The Increase of Teenage Pregnancy Teenage parenthood is by no means a new social phenomenon. Historically, women have tended to begin childbearing during their teens and early twenties. During the past two decades the U. S. teenage birthrate has actually declined (Polit and others, 1982). In the late 1950s, 90 out of 1000 women under 20 gave birth as compared with 52 out of 1000 in 1978. Several factors contribute to the current attention

The Regulations of Tax Laws

2033 words - 8 pages extended or not. The purpose of this paper is to present an argument against extending section 164 (b) (5). Whose entitle to explore that option? Proponents of extending section 164 (b) (5) contends that this is a benefit for taxpayers because they have an option to take what benefit them the most: state and local general sales tax deduction or take their state and local income tax deduction. We on the other hand

The Level of Understanding of Students in De La Salle Lipa On Tuition Fee Increase

1900 words - 8 pages Proper education is one of the main factors for a progressing nation. With the increasing cost of living, education cost also increases. This research, “The Level of Understanding of Students in De La Salle Lipa on Tuition Fee Increase” is conducted to determine students understanding on the possible cause of tuition fee increase in our school and tuition fee allocation. It is also an objective to indirectly help the students to be aware of the

The Impact of the Internet and E-commerce on Tax Regimes in the Commonweath Caribbean

5786 words - 23 pages The Impact of the Internet and E-commerce on Tax Regimes in the Commonweath Caribbean Introduction Most, if not all, of the member states of the Commonwealth Caribbean derive their right to tax from their Constitutions.[1] Section 48(1) of the Jamaican Constitution, for example, provides that '…Parliament may make laws for the peace, order and good government of Jamaica.' The Courts have continuously interpreted

Is there a need to increase the number of women on company boards in Australia?

2984 words - 12 pages also consider the organization's impact on the world. The well-known Catalyst and Harvard Business School study found that companies with three or more women directors made CSR donations at a rate of 28 times higher than companies with no women directors. This means each additional woman director represented an increase annual philanthropic giving by $2.3 million. It was speculated that by accentuating gender issues in the workplace, gender

Making the Production and Selling of Cigarettes Illegal

1400 words - 6 pages and selling of cigarettes illegal is although tobacco related deaths would drastically reduce each year, crime rate and taxation loss would substantially increase. In theory millions of Americans would finally quit, and millions would never start. Many Americans on the other hand would continue to smoke and Big Tobacco would be replaced by a more dangerous and violent black market. Murder would increase as criminal organizations would compete for

The Increase of Health Care Costs

1069 words - 5 pages . If I had to place a family member in any time of care facility it would be a nursing home. It gives that little extra reassurance that if something where to happen to your loved one that will be in good hands. They will be able to treat any type of accident on the spot without having to wait for EMS to arrive which could increase the chance for survival. Nursing homes also offer a variety of rooms. They offer private, semi-private, and group

Similar Essays

Does The Tax On Cigarettes Really Reduce The Demand For Cigarettes?

1845 words - 8 pages , distribution, and health care. Does the tax on cigarettes really reduce the demand for cigarettes? Well if you were to ask a cigarette company they would say that the higher taxes on cigarettes don’t work, but that’s not completely true. The taxes aren’t the only factor to the reduction of cigarette consumption though it is a big part of the reason why,“….comparing the trends in cigarette prices and overall U.S. cigarette consumption from 1970 to

The Banning Of Cigarettes Essay

2699 words - 11 pages have to pay for the selfishness of those people who do smoke. If those people who do smoke decided to quit because of the ban on cigarettes it would not only put extra money in their pocket, but it would benefit society by decreasing their taxes. This would make for a better society because of the increase in money income with those who work. Another perk to banning cigarettes is reducing the health hazards. Health risks on

Plagiarism On The Increase Essay

1279 words - 5 pages Plagiarism seems to be an increasing problem in today's society, especially on college and university campuses, with the immense resources presently available to people. Previously, individuals were restricted to finding information in resources such as books, magazines, journals, encyclopedias and newspapers, but with the technology and the growth and popularity of the Internet, plagiarism has truly become an issue. There seems to be a

The Joy Of Smoking Cigarettes Essay

758 words - 3 pages cigarettes you will eat less food. Smoking can also be used as a pretty accurate gauge of time. A cigarette takes about five minutes to smoke, so if you are waiting to meet somebody, you can smoke a cigarette and know just about how long it will be until they are there. While going on long drives, a cigarette is crucial to making the trip more enjoyable. You can break a six hour drive down into six cigarettes, and this seems to make the time go by