This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Enron: Who Was At Fault? Essay

2201 words - 9 pages

Most of the world has heard of Enron, the American, mega-energy company that “cooked” their books (Gupta, Weirich & Turner, 2013) and cost their investors billions of dollars in lost earnings and retirement funds. While much of the controversy surrounding the Enron scandal focused on the losses of investors, unethical practices of executives and questionable accounting tactics, there were many others within close proximity to the turmoil. It begs the question- who was really at fault and what has been done to prevent it from happening again?
The story of Enron begins in 1985, with the merger of two pipeline companies, orchestrated by a man named Kenneth L. Lay (Zellner & Forest, 2001). In its 15 years of existence, Enron expanded its operations to provide products and services in the areas of electricity, natural gas as well as communications. Through its diversification, Enron would become known as a corporate America darling (Tonge, Greer & Lawton, 2003) and Fortune Magazine’s most innovative company for 5 years in a row (Hayes & Ariail, 2013). They reported extraordinary profits in a short amount of time. For example, in 1998 Enron shares were valued at a little over $20, while in mid-2000, those same shares were valued at just over $90 (Hayes & Ariail, 2013), the all-time high during the company’s existence (Tonge, Greer & Lawton, 2003).
Though the numbers looked good, the process behind them was questionable. Unbeknownst to many, Jeff Skilling, a top Enron executive, was able to persuade the SEC and their accounting firm, Arthur Anderson & Company, to approve the use of mark-to-market accounting (M2M). This technique allowed the company to report profits from long term contracts up front, before all earnings had actually been achieved. This allowed the company to report earnings in one year that would normally be booked over the life of a ten to twenty year contract. Based on these inflated numbers, Enron funded management bonuses as a percent of reported net income, subject to decrease if management failed to meet goals for earnings per share (EPS). By establishing this type of bonus plan, the board essentially put out the word that company success was based on growth in earnings and EPS was to be the first priority. Managers and employees were encouraged to concentrate on producing as much accounting profit as possible (Stewart, 2006). This way of thinking became an underlying issue to the failure of Enron. Numbers became the ultimate goal, which led to tunnel vision and lack of ethical standards and reporting among those on the inside.
While the unethical decisions made by key Enron executives aided in the downfall of the company, they are not the only parties at fault in one of the largest corporate fraud scandals in history (Hayes & Ariail, 2013). In the world of business, there are other internal controls in place to help insure that the rules are being adhered to. One of these controls is in the form of a company’s...

Find Another Essay On Enron: Who was at fault?

"Every work of history is at least as revealing of the person who wrote it, and of the period in which it was written, as it is of the events it portrays."

822 words - 3 pages complication of history is identifying what is fact and what is an interpretation derived from those facts. It's common belief that Hitler was responsible for the death of six million Jews, but is there indubitable evidence that an investigation was conducted and proved the death of all six million, or was this derived from a historian who made this judgment based on facts or evidence such as the concentration camps, journal entries and accounts of

The Rise And Fall Of Enron

956 words - 4 pages The Rise and Fall of Enron The objective of every company is to maximize profit, become a big player and remain viable. Enron was no exception the key players at the time were Kenneth Lay CEO, Jeffery Skilling who was hired by Lay in 1990 to head the Enron Finance Corporation and by 1997 Skilling was made President and Chief Operating Officer. Andrew Fastow, CFO who was the chief financial officer of Enron. Enron merged Houston

Enron: Ethical Mess

2136 words - 9 pages Chase & CO. financed 8.5 billion in loans over nine years to keep Enron’s income statements profitable. Another billion dollars was borrowed from other banks. (Wire Reports, 2002) When Enron went bankrupt the banks ended up losing billions of dollars in unpaid loans and stock losses. Enron’s auditors are most at fault in the downfall of the company. It is an auditor’s job to find out what rules and regulations set by the company and state and

Monopoly: Do not pass Go, Do not collect $200. Is more government oversight of corporate finances needed?

981 words - 4 pages . Auditors, internal/external controls, government regulators, accountants, etc., all failed to recognize the deception.Because the government was somewhat at fault for this, it is hard to make a decision as a whole, if the government should be the one to regulate or oversee corporate finances. Obviously, by what was seen with Enron alone, no matter how many committees, boards, groups, or agencies are involved, there is always a way to get around the


716 words - 3 pages The Fall of Enron The History Enron began as a pipeline company in Houston in 1985. It profited by promising to deliver so many cubic feet to a particular utility or business on a particular day at a market price. That change with the deregulation of electrical power markets, a change due in part to lobbying from senior Enron officials. Under the direction of former Chairman Kenneth L. Lay, Enron expanded into an energy broker, trading

The Fall of Enron

1041 words - 5 pages strategy was made famous by Jeffery Skilling who was hired as the new CEO by Lay. This strategy did not take into account whether or not Enron would make any profits from the contracts. With this scandal, Enron was able to have the appearance of a profitable company even though it was not. Skilling was also responsible for creating a highly unethical corporate culture at Enron. Every year, there would be a committee that would grade each employee

Fundamentals of Business for Managers

1237 words - 5 pages at risk. It isn't only true believers who lost money on Enron, supposedly conservative investors sank millions into Enron stocks and funds. And they continue to sink money -- including, possibly, parts of your retirement -- into other existing Enron companies. Enron was never alone in its ways. The CEO of Global Crossing Unlimited, the largest telecommunications company ever to go belly up, is walking away with over $700 million from his

The Beginning of the End of Enron

2097 words - 8 pages August 2001. Lay’s involvement is not clear; two theories have emerged according to LA Times – “He was an isolated statesman, unaware of financial trickery perpetrated by underlings, or he was a hands-on manager who knew what was going on” (LA Times, August 21, 2002). Sherron Watkins, Vice President of corporate development at Enron, is considered the whistle-blower of Enron. She helped uncover the scandal; Watkins wrote a note to Lay informing

The ENRON scandal: The downfall of the ENRON corporation

1270 words - 5 pages a lot about the cultural change that was taking place within the company.Another factor that took its toll on and ultimately resulted in the demise of Enron was greed. The pressure at Enron was constantly high, not only to keep your job but to make the major deals. Those who did make those deals were paid up to 3 percent of the value of the entire deal immediately, not when the project actually began making money. Because of policies like this

Accounting: Enron Scandal

790 words - 4 pages at the Arthur Anderson Company for over 20 years and started working at Enron since 1997. He was born in 1960 and He graduated from high school with honors after losing his father at the age of 18. After graduating high school he joined Arthur Andersen LLP out of Texas A&M University. Soon after getting the job to be an accountant David Duncan be came one of the youngest business partners in the world. He was making over one million dollars a year

Management and Ethics

1439 words - 6 pages companies values from "respect, integrity, communication and excellence" to "smart, bold, and aggressive". This explained a lot about the cultural change that was taking place within the company. (Loadstone, 2004)Another factor that took its toll on and ultimately resulted in the demise of Enron was greed. The pressure at Enron was constantly high, not only to keep your job but to make the major deals. Those who did make those deals were paid up to 3

Similar Essays

Who Is At Fault? Essay

983 words - 4 pages “A glooming peace this morning with it brings. The sun, for sorrow, will not show his head. Go hence, to have more talk of these sad things. Some shall be pardon’d and some punished, for never was a story of more woe than this of Juliet and her Romeo” (Act V Scene III of William Shakespeare’s play, Romeo and Juliet). That is what the Prince decrees at the end of the play, he is speaking of the love Romeo and Juliet had for one another. The

'the Pearl Harbor Conspiracy' Who Was At Fault? Was It A Suprise Or Was It Known In Advance?

2604 words - 10 pages ' targets as soon as they knew them, because he received the bomb plot the same time they did. He had their specific targets, ship by ship, in his hands at the White House. Chief of War Plans and Naval Operations repeatedly kept it and all other warnings from being passed to Hawaii. Why would FDR not pass the message?U.S. intelligence officials knew of a Hawaii- based Japanese spy who was transmitting maps of bombing targets to Japan. Why was nothing

Dilemma In The Workplace The Enron Corporation. Includes Background On The Company, Key Problems And Issues, Who Was Affected, And Evaluations And Solutions. 3,010 Words. Greatly Detailed

2933 words - 12 pages big fluctuation in their earnings growth, nobody wanted to question the company and took them at face value. On October 16, 2001, Enron reported that they were taking a major loss on their third quarter earnings. As a result, everyone was questioning their financial stability. The third quarter losses were connected to the ending of the relationship with a pair of investment partnerships that were created by Chief Financial Officer (CFO) Andy

Life After Rape, This Story Is About A Young Girl Who Was Raped At A Baseball Game

1980 words - 8 pages to be okay. She thought it was not his fault, that she led him to do this to her. She walked to the court doors, feeling befuddled on what is to come next. She wished to turn away, but knew she couldn't. The judge sentenced him to 10 years. Everyone gasped. "There's no future for him now," his mother squabbled down the hall. "You lied, he didn't touch you, you know he didn't, he would never do that evil thing to you, you are just a bad bad