This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Erroneus Assumptions In The Trial And Death Of Socrates

2336 words - 9 pages

Erroneus Assumptions in The Trial and Death of Socrates

In Plato's Crito, Socrates explains to his old friend Crito his reasons for refusing an offer to help him escape execution. One of the tools Socrates uses to convince Crito of the righteousness of his decision is a hypothetical argument concerning the state and laws of Athens. Central to this argument is the congeniality that Socrates had always found in Athens, reflected by the fact that Socrates chose to remain in Athens for most of his life. Such a choice, the laws insist, implies a tacit agreement between Socrates and the state of Athens, stipulating that Socrates either obey the laws or, when he deems the laws unjust, persuade the city to act in a more suitable fashion. It is this "just agreement" that prohibits Socrates from fleeing Athens to avoid execution. Socrates proves to Crito's satisfaction that to break this agreement would be to do wrong to the city of Athens, and as such it cannot be seriously considered.

As he discusses his situation with Crito, Socrates refutes some of Crito's basic assumptions. Curiously, however, Socrates does not examine his own assumptions; he never once asks if his agreement with Athens is "just." He correctly assumes that Athens' congeniality to him obligates him to follow the tenets of the agreement, but he does not ask if Athens feels similarly obligated. This question is central, for if Athens fails to uphold its part of the agreement the agreement cannot be just and Socrates is freed from any duty to it. I will argue that Socrates' own reasoning, particularly that used in Crito and Euthyphro, will prove that it is not only not wrong to break the agreement, but also that it is wrong to abide by an unjust agreement, such as the one between Socrates and the Athenian state. This essay will show that this agreement is unjust and therefore impious. I will then argue that its impiety makes upholding the agreement unacceptable in the eyes of the gods and that it is the opinion of the gods that must direct Socrates' decision.

Socrates' first step is to establish that one must never do wrong (not even in retaliation for a wrong done against oneself) and that one must fulfill any just agreement into which one enters (49B).[1] Crito offers his consent to this claim, but cannot agree with Socrates' assertion that fleeing Athens in defiance of the law would injure the city. He believes that Socrates would not be doing anything wrong by avoiding execution. Here Socrates makes a hypothetical argument on behalf of the Athenian state, although he makes it clear that their argument is also his own. Athens, Socrates believes, is correct in asserting that an attempt to escape his death sentence would also constitute an attempt to destroy the city by undermining its laws. It is worth noting that harming Athens is explicitly described as "impious" in Socrates' argument. Crito stands by the defense that Socrates has a right to destroy Athens because its...

Find Another Essay On Erroneus Assumptions in The Trial and Death of Socrates

Plato's "trial and death of socrates", Explains socrates view of self-examination (meditation) as the path to knowledge

897 words - 4 pages fact they did not know it. This gave Socrates an important advantage over the other men in Athens. How can someone know the truth and gain mass amounts of knowledge if that person doesn't know and have great knowledge of his or herself.Socrates analyzed everything including his own knowledge and actions. Socrates realized that wisdom can be obtained by self-examination and by speaking the philosophical language. He spoke the philosophical language

The Trial of Socrates Essay

1100 words - 4 pages hypocrisy. It is this hypocrisy that makes the trial and death of Socrates quite ironic. Athens, the city in which Socrates resided, was a free democratic city that was governed by all citizens in a fair democracy as seen in apology. It was said to be an association of free men with no single leader or king. The town prided itself on the freedom of its citizens and, especially, its freedom of speech. Most all citizens prided themselves on these

The Trial Of Socrates

1918 words - 8 pages Socrates. In the preface of his book, Stone speaks of the spectacle of Socrates before his judges. He calls the trial of Socrates, "a black mark for Athens and the freedom it symbolized," he questions, "how the trial of Socrates could have happened in so free a society," and asks even more importantly, "How could Athens have been so untrue to itself." To attempt to answer these questions we first need to explore how Socrates differed politically from

The Trial of Socrates

983 words - 4 pages Socrates was accused of being a sophist because he was "engaging in inquiries into things beneath the earth and in the heavens, of making the weaker argument appear the stronger," and "teaching others these same things." (Apology, Plato, Philosophic Classics page 21) Socrates is also accused of denying the existence of the gods, and corrupting the youth. Socrates goes about trying to prove his innocence. The jury that Socrates was tried by

A Hoax in Court: The Trial of Socrates

1726 words - 7 pages Meletus can be easily thrown out with the favor going towards Socrates. Such a hearing that does not have strong evidence should be thought through and comprised of a prolonged discussion by the members of the jury, especially when they contemplate on a death sentence. “If it were the law with us, as it is elsewhere, that a trial for life should not last one but many days, you would be convinced, but now it is not easy to dispel great slanders in a

The Death Of Socrates

556 words - 2 pages The Death of Socrates By viewing the painting The Death of Socrates by Jacques-Louis David, Socrates' loyalty to the Athenian government was far more important to him than his own death or friendship. He was more interested in teaching his students about his belief in reason and the law of justice before he died. Still, the students and friends were arguing with him and trying to convince him to renounce his teachings. Socrates was

The Death Of Socrates

515 words - 2 pages The Death of Socrates By viewing the painting The Death of Socrates by Jacques-Louis David, Socrates? loyalty to the Athenian government was far more important to him than his own death or friendship. He was more interested in teaching his students about his belief in reason and the law of justice before he died. Still, the students and friends were arguing with him and trying to convince him to renounce his teachings. Socrates was strong in

'The Death of Socrates'

702 words - 3 pages marvelous work, however, was not completely captured in David's this painting, instead David looking through "Roman lenses" chose to focus more on the famous philosopher's immortality.In the painting The Death of Socrates, the painter Jacques Louis David, takes a scene from Plato's Phaedo and paints it from a Roman perspective. For example the setting of the scene takes place in a chamber that has Roman arches on the windows and an arch in the hallway

The Death and Trial of Emmett Till

807 words - 4 pages defines segregation as “to separate or set apart from others or from the main body or group…”. During the time in which Emmett Till lived, segregation was a common concept, and the exorbitant amount of discrimination was exhibited with Emmett Till’s death. Emmett was murdered by two white men, at the age of fourteen, for saying “Bye baby” to one of the men’s wife. A trial was held in the middle of September, 1955. This trial

Just some notes on Socrates and the Trial of the Generals

3406 words - 14 pages knowing it would turn out this way, and, thus, his decision not to yield to the mob mentality was undertaken with the expectation that he would suffer the same fate as the generals.In the course of Western Civilization, there have been two trials ending in a sentence of death imposed upon two individuals later deemed grossly unfair and unjust by the verdict of history. One trial was that of Jesus Christ, the other that of Socrates.Of course, it can

Socrates’ Trial Defense in Terms of His Values

1472 words - 6 pages before everyone present at his trial using simple reason. Those parts of the defense would have had additional strength because even some people who initially thought that Socrates was an atheist or just that he believed in other gods would have become doubtful after witnessing him prove that his accusers had lied. In terms of his values, the weaknesses in Socrates’ defense that led to the guilty vote and his death sentence were

Similar Essays

Morality And Laws In The Trial And Death Of Socrates

1231 words - 5 pages Morality and Laws in The Trial and Death of Socrates Upon reading Plato, The Trial and Death of Socrates, Socrates strongly held views on the relationship between morality and laws become apparent to the reader. Equally, Socrates makes clear why laws should be followed and why disobedience to the law is rarely justified. Finally, he makes clear his views regarding civil disobedience. Socrates’ view on morality is that anyone can do wrong

The Trial And Death Of Socrates

1656 words - 7 pages The portrayal of Socrates, through the book “the trial and death of Socrates” is one that has created a fairly controversial character in Western history. In many ways, Socrates changed the idea of common philosophy in ancient Greece; he transformed their view on philosophy from a study of why the way things are, into a consideration man. Specifically, he analyzed the virtue and health of the human soul. Along side commending Socrates for his

The Trial And Death Of Socrates

1017 words - 4 pages Socratic Method had come about. With Socrates’ pedagogy, a series of questions can be asked not only to draw individual answers, but also to persuade deep-seated insights into the real issues at hand. His result remains a frequently used tool in a broad series of discussions. The trial of Socrates was based on two disreputable and indistinct charges that were found to be disliked by the Greek culture; corrupting the youth and impiety. To be more

The Trial And Death Of Socrates

702 words - 3 pages The Trial and untimely death of Socrates, in my opinion, was a small group of people throwing a fit when it was pointed they weren’t as smart as they thought. The reasoning used by Socrates is the greatest example of the facts, not the manipulation of, proving your innocence. Socrates makes several points as to the trial being a complete waste of time and that even if he was brought to court he would be innocent. I agree death was the wrong