This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Erwin Panofsky's Gothic Architecture And Scholasticism

1015 words - 4 pages

Erwin Panofsky's Gothic Architecture and Scholasticism presents a compelling connection between the architectural styles of Gothic Cathedrals and the order and form of the Scholastic school of thought. Focusing on the "100 mile zone around Paris" during the years between 1130-40 and 1270 where and when Scholasticism was the dominate theory of education and Gothic architecture began to take a stronghold over the ageing Romanesque style. In Panofsky's own words "A connection between Gothic art and Scholasticism which is more concrete than a mere "parallelism"…the connection which I have in mind is a genuine cause-and-effect relation." But is there a more meaningful conviction that Panofsky is trying to present by explaining this "cause and effect"? Before diving deeper into Panofsky's theory, the terms Scholasticism and Gothic Architecture need to be defined.Scholasticism is a method of learning taught by the academics of medieval universities from the 11th until the 15th century, originating in Paris. This method of learning was based on dialectical reasoning, with the purpose of answering a question or settling a disagreement through the use of the Scholastic method. The Scholastic method would compare two or more writings of a related source. The sources would be read aloud to a class of pupils or academics to point of the contradictions between the texts. Then through a series of dialectics focusing on philological and or logical (commonly Aristotelian logic after the Second Crusade circa 1149) analysis the two sides of the contradiction would be interoperated to essentially agree with each other.Gothic Architecture is a style of architecture originating near Paris with the construction of the abbey church of Saint-Denis. The gothic style flourished during the High and Late Medieval periods. Classic features found in gothic architecture include thin columns and surrounding walls supported by flying buttresses, stained-glass, ribbed vaults, and detailed sculptural elements. Gothic vaulting allowed for the pointed doorways, large windows and high ceilings creating a high heavenly environment worthy of being described as the house of God.The connection between Gothic architecture and Scholasticism begins with the town professionals of each field. The two most well read professionals in the medieval "town" would have been the scholar and the architect. The scholar commonly a cleric devoted his life to writing and teaching. As well as being properly schooled in the Scholastic method. While the architect who frequently rose from an ordinary laborer to the overseer of an entire structure through hard work and diligence would become a well traveled, often well read man. "The architect himself had come to be looked upon as a kind of Scholastic"The Scholastics were the first medieval educators to divide books in to chapters leading the reader "step by step, from one proposition to the other and is always kept in formed as to the progress of his...

Find Another Essay On Erwin Panofsky's Gothic Architecture and Scholasticism

The Contrast between Gothic Architecture and Romanesque Architecture

1920 words - 8 pages The Romanesque and Gothic architecture period both occurred during the Middle Ages with the Gothic period taking place during the later half. Gothic and Romanesque architecture were related in many ways, but they also contrasted in style too. Over time, masons began to test the waters and push the limits. They thought of new ways to add lighting and ways to allow more height to the building without it being to heavy and weak. Many of the reasons

Comparison of Romanesque and Gothic Architecture - Art History - Essay

511 words - 3 pages COMPARISON OF ROMANESQUE AND GOTHIC ARCHITECTURE The Romanesque Basilica of St. Sernin, church in Toulouse, France was constructed between 1080 and 1120 and the Gothic, Chartres Cathedral located in Chartres, France was built from 1194 to 1120, and was completed 1220. Both structures have magnificent presence due to their large size and have the basic cruciform floor plan. The period of Romanesque architecture, concentrated on large building

Comparision of Gothic Cathedral Architecture of England and Europe

1251 words - 5 pages Gothic architecture refers to the styles of buildings from late 1100 to 1500. This period of architecture produced many tall and inspirational structures such as those in the cathedrals that rose up throughout Europe during that time. The structural improvements and innovative methods for increasing strength and beauty in cathedrals during the Gothic period enabled them to be built taller lighter and more airy giving them an air of the

A Critical Comparison of Gothic Architecture in Italy, France and Germany

1400 words - 6 pages thrust and counterthrust. Gothic architecture is an artistic, strategic system of engineering, schemes for building were followed for elevations, termed quadratum (four sided) and triangulorum (three sided). 2 This system allowed them to raise their ideal structures according to symbolic measure and numbers reflecting the geometry of the New Jerusalem and its prototype, the Temple of Solomon. (Figure 1.1) France is typically referred to as

Which Art Historical Method I Would Use

1373 words - 6 pages As an aspiring art historian who has been exposed to a variety of diverse methods for analyzing art, there are two techniques in particular that stand prominent amidst the others: the ideas of Erwin Panofsky and Adrian Piper. It is not invalid to say that both art historians share a similar view of interpreting works of art, however, they also manage to complement one another perfectly. An integration of both Piper and Panofsky's points of view

Cathedrals of the 12th Century

1108 words - 4 pages in its conquestof space and its creation of a prodigious, visionary scale in the cathedrals of the twelfth century.11BibliographyBranner, Robert. The Great Ages of World Architecture: Gothic Architecture. New York:George Braziller, 1967.Gimpel, Jean. The Cathedral Builders. New York: Grove Press, 1983.Mitchell, Ann. Great Buildings of the World: Cathedrals of Europe. Feltham: The HamlynPublishing Group, 1968.Panofsky, E. Gothic Architecture and Scholasticism. Latrobe: Faber and Faber Limited, 1951.Simson, Otto von. The Gothic Cathedral. New York: Bollingen Foundation, 1956.Worringer, Wilhelm. Form In Gothic. New York: Alec Tiranti Limited, 1957.

Gothic Architecture Key Contribution from the Middle Ages

1960 words - 8 pages Gothic ArchitectureThe technical revolution in architecture known as "Gothic" began at the end of the 12th century and lasted just over two hundred years. The advances made in architecture paralleled those in intellectual life. Gothic architecture was generally tall and inspiring and was a significant structural improvement upon the Romanesque buildings that preceded it.Even though the Gothic era roughly lasted two hundred years (12th-14th

Gothic Architecture

2253 words - 9 pages when mostly Gothic dominated the realm of expression. Gothic was everywhere; it was in painting, in sculpture, and primarily in architecture. Gothic architecture can understood thoroughly through the study in the form of cathedrals of that time. The cathedral stands as the most comprehensive of the various trends that was brought along with the gothic architecture. If there was a cataclysmic event during that time where every thing was destroyed

The Gothic Period

1429 words - 6 pages The Gothic Period in the twelfth century influenced the creation of Gothic Revival Architecture in the nineteenth century. Gothic architecture began in France in 1140. Some of the first buildings made using this style are the Basilica of Saint Denis and the Cathedral of Sens. (Gothic Architecture By Paul Frank) This style of architecture started losing popularity in the early sixteenth century, but did not die out completely during this time

The Seven Different Styles of Gothic Architecture

602 words - 3 pages not led to any clear results. Its distinguishing features seem to consist of two particulars, the effect of the terminating parts in a point and the perpendicular line. Gothic architecture solved some unpleasant problems, created pleasant, airy and light buildings. Fundamentally, it transformed cathedrals, churches, castles and the generally the whole Europe. Some of these buildings such as cathedrals and churches were rendered into places of

Gothic Architecture

1174 words - 5 pages Gothic Architecture Have you ever noticed the style in the buildings of your city? Well the style comes from an antique type of architecture called gothic architecture. The buildings now days have many developed characteristics from this style. Gothic architecture brought to the world many new features; the most important was the ogival arch, it helped the structure of the buildings and their inside designs. Gothic architecture started when

Similar Essays

Modern And Gothic Architecture Essay

798 words - 3 pages . Following out of the experiments in Art Nouveau and its related movements around the world, modernism in architecture and design grew out of stylistic threads originating throughout the world.” “The Crystal Palace, 1851, was one of the first buildings to have vast amounts of glass supported by structural metal, foreshadowing trends in Modernist architecture." Gothic architecture has emerged in the first half of the 12th century. Gothic architecture

Classical And Gothic Architecture Essay

820 words - 3 pages Classical and Gothic ArchitectureThe cultures of the ancient Greeks and medieval Europeans were significantly influenced by religion. Greek Classicism brought about some of the most beautiful artwork and architecture that still exists today. The style strives to exemplify a culture of harmony, order, reason, intellect, objectivity, and formal discipline (Sporre, 2010). Classicism is best exemplified in the ancient temples that are found

Romanesque And Gothic Architecture Essay

1130 words - 5 pages Romanesque and Gothic Architecture The 11th to 15th centuries saw a great surge of the Christian Church within Europe which was emphasized by the persuasiveness of the Crusades. The growing population of the Church increased the demand for the increased presence in architectural monuments and during the Romanesque and Gothic periods, a great cathedral construction boom occurred across Europe. The Romanesque and Gothic architectural styles

"Arnolfini Portrait: Business Or Pleasure?" A Comparison Between Rona Goffen And Erwin Panofsky's Translation Of The Arnolfini Wedding Poitrait

702 words - 3 pages In Erwin Panofsky's article he proposes the idea that the Arnolfini Portrait is a wedding portrait that acts as a "pictorial marriage certificate." He uses comparison to other similar works of his time and matrimonial literature and documents to confirm his theory. The Marriage of David and Michal, comes from a French Psalter and is a representation of a marriage ceremony. In both works of art, The Marriage of David and Michal and the Arnolfini