Administrative Failures Surronding The L'aquila Earthquake

3125 words - 13 pages


“Disasters do not just happen – they result from failures of development which increase vulnerability to hazard events” (White, Philip et al, 2004, 3).

On 6 April 2009 the medieval city of L’Aquila, located in the Abruzzo region, central Italy, was shocked by a massive earthquake measuring 6.3 on the Moment Magnitude Scale. 309 people were killed, 25000 people were displaced, 10000 buildings were considerably damaged and USD 16 billion was the overall estimated damage (Prats, 2012).
On 20 September 2011, six members of the Serious Risk Commission and a government administrator, at the time members of the National Commission for the Forecast and Prevention of Major Risks, were taken to court and “accused of providing ‘inaccurate, incomplete and contradictory information’ on the probability and risk of an earthquake and of falsely reassuring the population” (Prats, 2012, 13). In fact on 31 March 2009, just 6 days before the quake, Guido Bertolaso, the former director of the Civil Protection Agency, summoned the National Commission for the Forecast and Prevention of Major Risks in L’Aquila in order to “furnish citizens in the Abruzzo region with all the information available to the scientific community about the seismic activity of recent weeks” (Hall, 2011, 267). The experts at the meeting agreed in declaring the situation under control and advising the population to relax: an earthquake was unlikely to happen, although it could not be totally excluded.
On 22 October 2012 the verdict convicted the seven experts of manslaughter for failing to provide an adequate seismic warning to residents and to play down earthquake risks in the region.
Is this a trial against the failure of science or against the failure of communication of science and risk assessment in disaster risk reduction (DRR)?

Italy is an earthquake-prone country and Abruzzo region is one of the most seismically active areas in Europe. Historically one of the poorest region in Italy, from 1950s the region has achieved a notable level of development. Then in 1990s the nationwide Italian judicial investigation called Mani Pulite (Clean Hands) deeply impacted the region affecting the election and increasing corruption in particular in building sector (Özerdem; Rufini, 2013).
The institutional structure for disaster management in Italy is formally divided into two bodies. The first one is the Dipartimento della Protezione Civile (Civil Protection Department - DPC), which is accountable for the four phases, such as preparedness, relief, reconstruction, and mitigation, in disaster management. The second one is locally constituted as the result of the decentralisation process and it comes from the Decree Bassanini of 1998. The resolution amounts to the distribution of responsibilities and powers among central state as body of coordination and local authorities as decision-maker. The swing of responsibilities discloses an incompetence of the local civil protection and...

Find Another Essay On Administrative Failures Surronding the L'Aquila Earthquake

Interagency Response Essay

1752 words - 7 pages (USG) to deliver on the promises of the programs. A national crisis can provide opportunities for the USG to gain the support and confidence of the American public. The 1964 Alaskan earthquake provided the USG with that opportunity. Six days after the earthquake, President Johnson established the Federal Reconstruction and Development Planning Commission for Alaska (FRDPCA) that successfully coordinated efforts across all agencies to bring the

Kugler Foods Disaster Recovery Plan Essay

8162 words - 33 pages disaster might involve the arrival of severe weather or an earthquake, extended or widespread power failures, a significant fire, or a significant hazardous material release around the local area.Notification for a Phase 2 disaster will be accomplished via group page. Each store manager or supervisors with specific roles in a disaster are responsible for notifying their own staff and employees. Upon notification of a Phase 2, employees will remain on

Hydraulic Fracking Should Not Be Allowed

1541 words - 6 pages seismic waves (Spellman 5). Manipulation of these rock formations can provoke earthquake tremors throughout the surrounding area. Microseismic mapping technology also show evidence when the bounding rock layers of a formation is disturbed leads to failures in the earth’s faults causing earthquake tremors and a small scale (Spellman 174). It has also been shown that these earthquakes contribute to the seismic activity that causes the cement casing

History and Scientific Understanding of Tsunamis

2017 words - 8 pages action is one of the sources that can generate tsunamis, yet, most of it are born when plates forming earth crust starts moving. The lighter continental plates bury the dense oceanic plates resulting in an abrupt shaking of the ground, a phenomenon known as earthquakes. Most of which are violent but despite how big or small an earthquake is, all are able of generating devastating tsunamis as long as it occurs in the marine regions. Due to this


2815 words - 12 pages the most important, interesting, complex, and controversial phenomenon whereby a saturated soil significantly loses strength and stiffness in response to an applied stress, usually earthquake shaking or other sudden change in stress condition, causing it to behave like a liquid. It can cause spectacular damage including slope failure, bridge and building foundation failures, and floatation of buried structures. Nowadays, many researchers around

A Review of Major Bridge Collapses and Why

2325 words - 10 pages added additional supports using metal baring. The Loma Prieta earthquake also caused Cyprus street viaduct carrying interstate 880 to collapse killing 42. These bridges were not designed to withstand earthquake conditions at the severity seen during the collapse. Today, these bridges have been modified to prevent these failures from occurring in future earthquake events. (8, Carl W.) Fire may be the rarest cause of bridge failure with bridges

Fukushima Daiichi: Is It Worth it?

1788 words - 7 pages The world needs to be powered. And the ever- present question in today’s world is how to get the power we need. There have been many solutions to this need for power. One of the most revolutionary was nuclear energy. Nuclear energy is created when In 2011, a tragedy struck. On March 11, 2011, an earthquake struck. Measuring at an 8.9 on the Richter scale, it was the largest earthquake in history. This earthquake was off the eastern shore of

Exploring the Leadership of Roman Emperor Claudius

2498 words - 10 pages we see in his administration of provinces, ‘a convitionthat humanity must be placed before legalism.’ Due to his simple mindedness Claudius changed many simple things within rome, for example, ‘Claudius not only revived obsolescent traditions, but invented new ones,’ such as calling a public holiday if an earthquake happened in rome. Now we have looked at a few of the ways in which Claudius was effective in ruling his population, we will now

United States’ Government Response to Hurricane Katrina: Where Does the Blame Belong?

1980 words - 8 pages their urban development decision-making. Failures included by Burby of the national agencies include design limits that can lead to levees being overtopped by flood and hurricane events that are larger than they were designed for. Also, design flaws and construction and maintenance shortcomings can lead to protective works being breached when they cannot stand up to the forces exerted by large flood and hurricane events. There are many reasons

Nuclear Energy: A Disaster Waiting to Happen?

2572 words - 11 pages Stop for a moment and visualize living in a region that has a nuclear power plant. The efficient and clean energy is perfect for this ever growing world. It is the picture-perfect form of energy until something goes terribly wrong. An earthquake rocks the town in which this nuclear power plant is located. The structures covering the nuclear core crack and the core melt’s down causing massive amounts of radiation to escape into the environment

Del Piero

5433 words - 22 pages Research".In 2008, he has participated in a golf tournament organized by the foundation of Gianluca Vialli and Massimo Mauro for Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis research. In 2009, he played a friendly match at Stadio Olimpico with his team "Ale 10+"; the collection was donated to solidarity projects.In 2010, he auctioned off his Juventus's shirt number 10 for the foundation "Un Campo per L'Aquila". On 1 April 2011, he launched the project

Similar Essays

Earthquakes The Destructive Natural Phenomena Essay

854 words - 3 pages Earthquakes the Destructive Natural Phenomena An earthquake, one of the most destructive natural phenomena, consists of rapid vibrations of rock near the surface of the earth. It is the most terrifying of all natural phenomena and has brought fear since ancient times because of its sudden unpredictable occurrence and enormous capacity of destruction. A single shock usually last no more than a few seconds, although several quakes may last for

Japanese Earthquake Aftermath Essay

2146 words - 9 pages and Japan faces the difficulty of providing medical treatment to them before their health deteriorates. Prime Minister Naoto Kan, believes that all six reactors at Fukushima will be decommissioned (Xiang). The lack of energy will be a major bottleneck limiting the recovery time of the Japanese economy. When the earthquake hit, explosions at Daiichi nuclear power plant located in Fukushima caused cooling system failures. These cooling systems

Haiti: Earthquake, Aftermath And Condition Essay

2642 words - 11 pages RESULTS Statistics: • 222,570 people died and 300,572 were injured • 1.5 million children under 18 were directly or indirectly affected by the quake • The total value of damage and losses caused by earthquake is estimated at US$7.8 billion — US$4.3 billion represents physical damage and US$3.5 billion are economic losses — some 120 percent of the 2009 gross domestic product (GDP) of Haiti • 60 percent of government, administrative and economic

The Video Gaming Culture In Japan

2309 words - 9 pages where the earthquakes and volcanoes generally occur in the basin of the Pacific Ocean. (“Facts about Japan”) About 90 percent of the world’s earthquakes occur along the Ring of Fire. (“Facts about Japan”) Over a thousand earthquakes occur each year in Japan. (“Facts about Japan”) In March of 2011, Japan suffered one of the largest most powerful earthquakes to hit Honshu, Japan. (“Facts about Japan”) The earthquake registered 8.9 and was the fifth