Essay Analyzing The Book 'how To Argue About Abortion' By John Noonan. Essay Also Analyzes The Topic Of Pro Choice Vs. Pro Life.

2097 words - 8 pages

The issue of abortion is by far, one of the most controversial topics in American History and everyone seems to have an opinion on the topic. Although there are many sides to the topic, the issue has divided the majority of people to the two extreme views of the topic --Pro-choice Vs. Pro-life. We can see the main arguments of each side just by analyzing the titles given to the two sides. Those who are pro-life believe that they are in fact Pro-Life and that abortion is murder. Those who are pro-choice believe that they are Pro-choice and that outlawing abortion would take the women's freedom to make a choice about her own body. Feelings and emotions about such an issue are very powerful and it has been the case that both sides will go to extremes to defend what they believe in. Such was the case Rosalie and Hector Zevallos, owners of an abortion clinic who were kidnapped and threatened with their lives, if they would not close down their clinic. (Glover, CC, 22)John Noonan is an abbot supporter of the pro-life movement and in his essay, How to Argue About Abortion, he provides many arguments to support his theory that abortion is nothing but the destruction of a living, breathing human being. Noonan attempts to prove his point by first showing counter arguments to many of the traditional pro-choice themes that have been brought up over and over in support of abortion. He then goes on to mention many arguments that he feels can clearly illustrate the logical reasoning of the pro-life movement.One of Noonan's first topics to discuss is that of "hard cases" which the pro-choice movement argues are valid reasons as to why abortion should be available. The main point of this discussion is in the case of Rape. The pro-choice movement argues that a women is not responsible for a child that was conceived when the women was raped and therefore can not be held responsible to carry and take care of the child. Noonan argues that, first of all, the whole Rape issue is cited as a racist ploy to suggest that a baby can not be allowed to live when a black man rapes a white women (Noonan, CC, p12). Noonan suggest that the argument is brought up to play on the racist emotions of many Americans in this country. But to counter the pro-choice's rape argument, Noonan suggests that the mother can not punish the fetus because she was brutalized by another. It is not fair to the fetus that he die, because his mother experiences certain emotions whenever she notices the fetus. The solution to the problem of the mother's emotions as a result of the traumatic experience, is adoption. If the mother can not control the psychological pressures of the child being a constant reminder of the traumatic experience, then the child should be adopted, not die.Pro-Choice supporters also argue that to abort a child that was conceived as a result of rape, is saving him years of misery of having to live knowing that he was not conceived out of love and that her mother may not care for...

Find Another Essay On Essay analyzing the book 'How to Argue About Abortion' by John Noonan. Essay also analyzes the topic of Pro-Choice Vs. Pro-Life.

Pro choice vs pro life Essay

1176 words - 5 pages The debate between pro-choice and pro-life has been going on for quite a while now, and will continue to do so. The pro-choice side fighting for the women’s right to abortion and pro-life fighting for the fetus’ life. In the book How the Pro-Choice Movement Saved America : Freedom, Politics, and the War on Sex Christina , Page talks about abortion and all other topics that go hand in hand with it such as sex and contraception to evaluate their

Pro-Life vs. Pro-Choice Essay

647 words - 3 pages This article is another piece of written truth as to how one’s social upbringing reflects their views and opinions.      The average pro-life activist tends to be a lesser-educated individual who grew up seeing family life as a root to all means. Her parents were of a lower income bracket, barely finished high school, and more that likely her parents provided many siblings. She wed directly out of high school to a

Abortion-- A view from the pro choice and pro life

1765 words - 7 pages dollars (Jarvis Thomson, page 407), but a woman can have her baby's brains sucked out of its head right into the 32nd week of pregnancy with no charges or fines - only guilt.What do pro life and pro choice think about abortion? Most people try not to think about it. They wish to avoid the overwhelming horrible reality. Abortion is an intentional violent act that kills an unborn baby. Without any anesthesia, the baby is dismembered, torn apart, and

Abortion: The Truth About Pro-Choice

1285 words - 5 pages .” (Center for Bio-Ethical Reform) There is plenty of research that shows abortion causes many psychological side effects, and leaves a woman with a lot of strong decisions about the decision that they made. Sadness, grief over the loss of the potential to see life beyond them are some most common feelings. But mostly a woman can feel ashamed and embarrassed over the choice made, or even having to make the choice at all. There are support groups to help

Abortion: Pro-Life Or Pro Choice.

1019 words - 4 pages an infant, child or adult. In cases where the baby s life is threatened due to unwanted or unplanned pregnancies, alternative solutions to abortion such as adoption and family parenting should be considered. The protection of all innocent human beings should be honoured as a courageous life choice to be supported by our society. Pro-lifers sees life from the starts with conception view , therefore when abortion occurs in a case of rape and incest

A persuasive essay about abortion favoring Pro Choice

971 words - 4 pages with there lives before the whole wrenched scene. After all of these scenarios are considered fairly by an open-minded person, abortion is the better of them.Many of those who are pro life argue that any of these situations are preferable to abortion. They ultimate goal, they think, is to have the child be alive. They claim that it is unfair and unjust for anyone to take that choice of life away from the fetus. Essentially, what they really want is to take the choice away from the mother and give it to the unborn child, giving them this wonderful prospect to be brought into a loveless, forlorn, and cold society.

The point of views of abortion both pro-life and pro-choice.

1610 words - 6 pages feel that they live their own life. Pro-choice people believe that the constitution gives them the right to be able to make their own decisions about abortion. The First amendment of the United States Constitution states:"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech; or of right of the press; of right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to

Abortion. I had to write a paper on the controversial subject of pro-life or pro-choice.

575 words - 2 pages Abortion in the United States is one of the most controversial subjects. The two main arguments are Pro Life and Pro Choice. I have been raised Catholic my whole life and my religion tells me to be Pro Life. As I have grown and become my own person I now believe in Pro Choice. One of the reasons I have come to this conclusion is because of the circumstances these pregnant mothers have been put in. A lot of people believe that if a teenager girl

Abortion: Pro-Choice is the Wrong Choice

828 words - 3 pages Ronald Regan (1983) said “Abortion is advocated only by persons who have themselves been born” (pg. N/A). He was saying that a person who had a chance to live is ending the life of another person, who wasn’t allowed an opportunity to say whether or not he/she wanted to live. So abortion should not be considered as the only way to get out of a pregnancy because the woman could get breast cancer after the abortion process is over, the person may

Abortion- should abortion be acceptable? Discussion of both sides of the issue: pro-life or pro-choice?

878 words - 4 pages one has the right to interfere. Pro-choice activists feel life does not begin at conception, but at birth. They believe that the baby inside is the mother's property. Many have also argued over whether abortions should be legal or not. I agree that abortion IS the Woman's decision, but I think more women should think it through more thoroughly and keep their babies, rather than aborting them.Worldwide, about 26 million women obtain legal

Pro-Life or Pro-Choice: Abortion Analyzed Through the Sociological Lens

3055 words - 12 pages regarding abortion in Canada. By analyzing the laws and legislation that has been put in place by Canadian government, it is easy to see how people can assume different positions on this topic. Throughout the first section, it also discusses women’s rights regarding birth and their bodies. Secondly, this research essay takes a look at the stigma surrounding abortion and how that has evolved over the years. By examining the way in which people view

Similar Essays

Pro Choice Doesn't Have To Mean Pro Death An Essay About Abortion From The Pro Choice Perspective By Kate Buckingham

1554 words - 6 pages safe, legal abortions, right?Adoption is the other obvious alternative to abortion, but in some cases (such as where the woman would be physically or mentally in danger), choice should just be a factor. Now, what if abortions were considered to be done through a case-by-case legal system? That option is also unsteady, because there is simply not enough time or money to conduct a case-by-case consideration. If a pregnant woman is on the verge of

Abortion: Pro Life Vs. Pro Choice Essay

1278 words - 5 pages of the pro-life cause,meaning in short I was against abortion in every aspect, there were noexceptions when it came to abortion, it was simply murder, and I wouldnot stand for it. After a few years of being pro-life I started toquestion why I believed so much in a cause that took choice away fromwomen. After all we do live in America, land of the free, which shouldentitle us (women) the right to choose whether or not we want to carrya baby to

Abortion: Pro Life Vs. Pro Choice Essay

783 words - 3 pages specific topic, the pro-life population gives examples of how people such as Oprah and Ray Charles were brought into this world accidentally and have been through many things and are now inspirations to many people. However, I do not agree that they can make a basis on just these two people. Yes, they are two powerful and inspirational people, but they forgot to mention the thousands of other 'unwanted' children who are brought into a challenging

This Is A Discursive Essay On Abortion, Describing The Views Of Both Pro Choice And Pro Life Groups.

799 words - 3 pages rate than it is now.Many people also say that since the foetus is incapable of self-conscious thought it is not yet a person, and so the rights given to people do not apply to it.Another pro-choice argument is that legalizing abortions has eliminated many illegal abortions performed by unskilled practitioners under unsanitary conditions. These abortions often caused death and permanent reproductive injuries. Abortion on demand also prevents unwanted births, possibly lowering infant and child abuse and neglect rates.