This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Essay Contrasting Shakespeare’s Play Macbeth And The 1978 Film Franklin English Essay

1198 words - 5 pages

“Macbeth”
“Murder, murder, murder!” cries Lady Macduff as the murderers come after her. Murder is a recurring theme in William Shakespeare’s play Macbeth and the Macbeth 1978 film directed by Roman Polanski. Although these murders, and many other aspects of the storyline, are similar in both the Macbeth play and the Macbeth movie, each scene is portrayed differently. The most prominent difference between the play and the movie is the second witches’ scene, which contained more material in the movie. A second difference is seen in the showcasing of Macduff’s family’s, and servants’, murders. Finally, the apparitions conjured up in the second witches’ scene are more tangibly present in the Macbeth movie. Although there are many differences between the seventeenth century Macbeth play and the 1978 Macbeth film, the most outstanding differences lie in the second witches’ scene, the scene of Macduff’s family’s murder, and in the portrayal of the apparitions from the second witches’ scene.
The second witches’ scene in the Macbeth film is the chief difference between the play and the film. The scene is longer than the original and also reflects the current news of the era by alluding to the Charles Manson ordeal. In Act IV of the play, all the witches participate in throwing ingredients into the caldron and the all say “double, double, toil and trouble; fire burn and caldron bubble.” But in the movie, only one witch is active in throwing in ingredients, while the other two say “double, double, toil and trouble; fire burn and caldron bubble” simultaneously. The youngest witch is one that does not participate in throwing in ingredients and she is also the only one that seems to have prophesizing abilities in the movie. In both the play and the movie, when Macbeth comes, the witches show him the apparitions. But in the movie, the apparitions are tangible and the scene resembles Charles Manson and his solicitation of female Nation Honor Society members to commit murder. The witches take of Macbeth’s shirt and paint a black cross on his forehead, back, and chest. They then give him a potion to drink, which did not happen in the play, and show him the three apparitions. After that, the witches sat him up and moved candles back and forth in front of his face. Each time the candles got near his face, Macbeth would scream. Before the witches left, they blindfolded Macbeth and when he finally came to, he put on his coat, which looked like a leather jacket, and got ready to leave. Someone then came and Macbeth asked him if he had seen the witches. When he said no, Macbeth grabbed the apparitions and left. Although there are many differences between the play and the movie, the second witches’ scene is definitely the most blatant.
There is also a difference in the portrayal of Macduff’s family’s murder between the play and the movie. In both mediums, Ross and Lady Macduff talk with Macduff’s son in the background, Ross leaves and a messenger enters warning...

Find Another Essay On Essay contrasting Shakespeare’s play Macbeth and the 1978 film - Franklin English - Essay

English Feature article on Shakespears Macbeth with reference to both play and Polanski's adaptation. Title: Windows changed through time

1192 words - 5 pages characteristics that were used to shape his own work would be put into use yet again for a modern day adaptation, That in short took the great writers technique of windowing their own time and creating a work to be treasured by today's audiences.In 1917 Roman Polanski produced a film adaptation of William Shakespeare's great tragedy. Roman Polanski presents his nightmarish vision of Shakespeare's classic play as a lust for power and its bloody

natalie maroof english comparing and contrasting essay - English - english essay

593 words - 3 pages Natalie Maroof English 1180 Professor L. Dupery 27 September 2017 “A Rose for Emily” vs. “The Yellow Wallpaper” Everyone suffers from some type of depression throughout their life but each person handles the situation differently. Some might have control over and the can get over come their depression whereas others does not have any control and has no choice but to follow through until they finally fight to get their freedom. "A Rose for Emily

english comparing and contrasting essay - Macomb/english - essay

593 words - 3 pages Natalie Maroof English 1180 Professor L. Dupery 27 September 2017 “A Rose for Emily” vs. “The Yellow Wallpaper” Everyone suffers from some type of depression throughout their life but each person handles the situation differently. Some might have control over and the can get over come their depression whereas others does not have any control and has no choice but to follow through until they finally fight to get their freedom. "A Rose for Emily

Write an essay comparing and contrasting the two play Top Girls and A Doll's House

1534 words - 6 pages Self -expression is about being able to voice out what you think, feel and mean in any form of activity. However, women that existed in the early centuries often have to follow the constrictive protocols prescribed by their patriarchal societies, thus depriving them many opportunities of self expression. This essay explores the different unique ways in which the female characters in Top Girls and A Doll's House challenge these protocols and how

Macbeth Analysis of the play Essay - year 10 - essay

1292 words - 6 pages Shakespeare’s MacBeth is one of his shortest plays, yet it possesses perhaps the most potent meaning of all. “O valiant cousin, worthy gentleman” is a quote said by Duncan, the former King of Scotland upon hearing of MacBeth’s (the eponymic character of the play) success in the first battle. From this point he becomes blinded by other characters and is trapped in a life that he may not have wanted. The main characters responsible for this are

The Villainous Macbeth - Honors English - Essay

1471 words - 6 pages Tragic Hero, his constancy as a villain, culpability for his actions, remorselessness, and the fact Macduff is the true Tragic Hero, show how Macbeth is truly a villain. Macbeth was a villain throughout the whole play; it simply became more noticeable when he committed traitorous acts against the people he once served. Macbeth starts the play an honorable soldier, risking his life for his nation. Killing the insurrectionist Macdonwald for King

English film essay

912 words - 4 pages In the movie "Mary Shelly's Frankenstein" directed by Kenneth Branagh. The director uses many techniques such as characterisation, symbolism and cinematography to portray a negative view about Victor Frankenstein. Branagh uses these techniques to reinforce that Victor is an obsessive, arrogant and secretive scientist. This negative view of victor’s character is important as it reinforces the message in the film that scientific exploration is

Relationship between Macbeth and Lady Macbeth - English - Essay

832 words - 4 pages Discuss the relationship between Macbeth and Lady Macbeth. How does it change and why? To what extent is their relationship the engine that drives the tragedy. The play Macbeth written by William Shakespeare presents a man faced with many hurdles caused by those around him, primarily his wife, Lady Macbeth. Shakespeare presents the play in such as way that the audience sees how progressively their relationship changes dramatically as a

Macbeth and good or bad influences essay - English - Macbeth/influences

442 words - 2 pages Influences can be good or bad, It depends on the person you are getting influenced by. #1 In the article “The tragedy of Macbeth” Lady Macbeth kept pushing him to do evil. Also the three witches influenced him to do evil by letting him know that he will be king. #2 In the article “The invisible influence: How decisions are rarely ever ours” They explain that being influenced isn’t always a bad thing and it can be a much faster and excellent

Macbeth Essay How are the witches, Macbeth and Lady Macbeth held responsible for the tragic events in the play? Macbeth written by William Shakespeare

1366 words - 5 pages tragic events that are caused because of the involvement of the witches, Macbeth and Lady Macbeth. These tragic events led to the demise of Macbeth and Lady Macbeth.The witches are the first to appear in Macbeth and this signifies their importance in the tragic events of the play. Their first appearance straight away categorises the witches as evil as their riddles show that they want to stir up trouble. 'Fair is foul, and foul is fair' (act1

Macbeth essay equivocation and moral - English 121 - Essay

1147 words - 5 pages Macbeth essay: The Dangers of Destiny In the play Macbeth by William Shakespeare it is evident that Macbeth’s demons is lead to his own demise. In Majorie Garbers characterisation she explains that we can see how the Macbeth’s self-doubt changes him, we can see this in the changes in his mannerisms and also his appearance. He changes from a great leader to a broken king who’s own devils leads him to his death Macbeths trust in the witches

Similar Essays

Role Reversal In William Shakespeare’s Play Macbeth

1341 words - 5 pages William Shakespeare’s play Macbeth has a few main themes, one of which is role reversal. Macbeth is portrayed as a strong, fierce, and trustworthy soldier. At this stage in the story he had a conscience, and had a boundary between good and bad. However, Lady Macbeth is depicted as a devious and an extreme organizer, without a good sense of what is right and wrong. She would do anything in order to obtain supreme authority. Gradually they both

Belonging Themes In William Shakespeare’s Play Othello And Gurinder Chadha’s Film Bride And Prejudice

932 words - 4 pages Good Morning Whilst plainly mentioning the word belonging, each and every one of our minds will generate a unique visualisation of what we interpret of belonging. This is because I believe that one’s life experience can enhance and diminish their sense of belonging. William Shakespeare’s play Othello and Gurinder Chadha’s film Bride and Prejudice both deeply explores the notion of belonging through the use of various film techniques, imagery

Macbeth Analysis On What It Means To Be A Man Webster And English Play Analysis

1140 words - 5 pages Wehmeyer 3 Bethany Wehmeyer Armbruster ENGL 1900 6 December 2016 Be a Man: Reclaiming Macbeth’s Manhood Macbeth is one of Shakespeare’s most familiar tragedies, with the protagonists being the murdering duo of Macbeth and Lady Macbeth. Macbeth is the quintessential tragic hero. A tragic hero is one who makes a judgment error and in doing so brings forth their fall. He starts of being a “brave [man]” (1.2.18), who did this heroic act of killing

Shakespeare’s Play Othello And Tim Blake Nelson’s Film O Both Portray Universal Themes And Values That Are Relevant To Their Contexts. Discuss How

1027 words - 5 pages believing by Hugo who represents Iago, that there is a chance that his girlfriend Desi might be cheating on him. The opening voiceover in the first few minutes of the film “I know you’re not supposed to be jealous of anything” foreshadows the events that are due to occur in the film and the concept of jealous will play major role. Many instances of film techniques are used to incorporate the theme of jealousy such as with the use of close-up camera