This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Essay On Behalf Of The Smart

651 words - 3 pages

Anselm’s classical ontological argument is criticized precisely for its attempt to define God into existence. The argument is deductive and its form known as reduction ad absurdum. “That is, it begins with a supposition S (suppose that the greatest conceivable being exist in the mind alone) that is contradictory to what one desires to prove” (Pojman 41). In other words, the argument attempts to show a contradiction or absurdity in the opposite view in order to claim his own view is correct.
There is nothing inherently wrong with this method. However, it does become a problem when a deductive argument is attempting to bring something into existence. We simply cannot do that, for it goes against the common sense laws of logic. Gaunilo offered us an example famously known as the “Isle of the Blessed” (Peterson 173). In this example, he attempts to use the same deductive form Anselm uses to bring an island into existence. “Because it is better ...view middle of the document...

This point clearly showed a big flaw in the ontological argument.
In short, Anselm’s basic ontological deductive argument attempts to use it valid form in order to bring a concept, namely God, into existence. Critics will always refute this with an analogy, replacing the concept of God with anything non-existent. This criticism gives the same plausibility to a unicorn, Leviathan, fairies, with God. Of course, the reader would acknowledge an absurdity here. Nevertheless, Alvin Plantinga objects Kant’s criticism by making a modal version of the argument. This argument attempts to prove that “God’s existence cannot be merely contingent but must be necessary-that is, maximal greatness must be exemplified in every possible world” (Pojman 47).
Before Immanuel Kant and Alvin Plantinga offered their criticisms and support of the ontological argument, Anselm responded to the first objection, that is, Gaunilo’s island analogy. “Anselm’s reply is that the analogy fails, for unlike the greatest possible being, the greatest possible island can be conceived as not existing” (Pojman 42). Anselm attempts to show that God is a necessity, whereas an island is not. However, this has not disposed Gaunilo’s objection. Immanuel Kant, as stated above, through Gaunilo’s concept of the perfect island, was able to derive a flaw in the argument.
Kant said, “‘Being’ is obviously not a real predicate; that is, it is not a concept of something which could be added to the concept of a thing. It is merely the positing of a thing, or of certain determinations, as existing in themselves” (Pojman 42). This is the precise point, existence does not necessarily mean “greater.” Pojman showed us a clear example of this point. “When you say that a check for $100 is equivalent to one hundred single dollars, you are describing the properties of the check; when you predicate the idea with the concept of existence, you haven’t added a new property to the idea of $100” (Pojman 43).
This is the biggest dagger to the ontological argument. Existence alone, according to Kant, is equivalent to nothing, for without other qualities in that existence, there is nothing. Anselm’s reply to Gaunilo was not strong enough to hold against Kant’s criticism.

Find Another Essay On Essay on behalf of the Smart

The Architecture of the smart antenna

661 words - 3 pages ALOHA can be improved by adaptive smart antenna which has the ability to receive prolific number of packets simultaneously. In Adaptive array throughput of the slotted non persistent CSMA is being analysed, whereas the performance of the FH-CDMA has been realized in rayleigh fading channel. There are several experiments going on to improve the network performance which involve GSM with smart antenna by the Ericsson corporation In that there is

The Definition and Functions of Smart Gird

996 words - 4 pages A smart grid (SG) is an intelligent electricity network that integrates the actions of all users that are connected to it and make use of advanced information, control, and communication technologies in order to efficiently deliver sustainable, economic and secure electricity supplies [1]. The high-speed, bi-directional, real-time, and integrated communications system is the foundation of SG [2]. In addition to counting and pricing in smart

The ANSWER LIES in the IMPLEMENTATION of SMART-RBM

1256 words - 6 pages even the findings of violations in the region remains high. 'The Effectiveness also include setting management the team on the field so there won’t be overlap patrol locations by different teams. We do not need to master GIS to operate the SMART, because the GPS data can be downloaded instantly and SMART will automatically processing spatial information, 'explained Kholis who is the Trainer Coordinator of the SMART-RBM. SMART'S modules itself have

The Use of Smart Technology in the Hotel Industry

3144 words - 13 pages challenging as a result of the current final crisis and diverse customers’ needs. This paper examined the smart technology that is being employed in hotel industry and its effect on the performance of the hotels – that is reduction of cost and competing well in the market and ensuring that customer satisfaction remains a paramount consideration. The research in this paper used questionnaire to examine the current implementation of the smart

Advanced Technology Leading to the Development of Smart Weapons

1846 words - 8 pages “smart weapons” if companies and manufacturers agree to produce personalized guns in the United States. A variety of different arguments have been put forward about this issue. This essay will consider the arguments against developing safer, personalized guns. It will then point to the explanations of how the improvements can help reduce gun violence while also avoiding the political debate of gun control. As a result of the Sandy Hook

An essay on Theater of the absurd

514 words - 2 pages An essay on Theater of the absurdThe issues involving Theater of the absurd has been a popular topic amongst scholars for many years. I find my self constantly drawn back to the subject of Theater of the absurd. While it is becoming a hot topic for debate, Theater of the absurd is not given the credit if deserves for inspiring many of the worlds famous painters. Since it was first compared to antidisestablishmentarianism much has been said

Analytical Essay on the Score of Psycho

1427 words - 6 pages Analytical Essay on the Score of Psycho The man behind the low woodwinds that opens Citizen Kane and the 'high pitched violins' of Psycho (1960). Bernard Herrmann was one of the most original and distinctive composers ever to work in film. He started early, winning a composition prize at 13 and founding his own orchestra at 20. After writing scores for Orson Welles' radio shows in the 1930s (including the notorious 1938

Historical essay on the bombing of Dresden

788 words - 3 pages On February 13-14, 1945 the British Royal Air Force gave the final clearance to commence what would later become known as one of the greatest atrocities that has ever been committed against a civilian population. That night the RAF launched 796 bombers and 9 Mosquitoes, which carried 1,478 tons of explosives in addition to 1,182 tons of incendiary bombs (Dear 311) which turned the city of Dresden, Germany into a virtual inferno. This

Persuasive essay on the merits of DDT

531 words - 2 pages in some species of bird. The ban in the U.S. was the first of many. Soon, many of the more wealthy nations of the world, the nations capable of DDT production, placed bans on the chemical for fear of the threat to the environment that it could cause. Lifting the ban on DDT could save millions of lives across the world.If the ban on DDT were to be lifted, not only would millions of lives be saved from malaria, but from cancer as well. If DDT were

An essay on the causes of WWI

1806 words - 7 pages " in which at least 20 million deaths occurred. Let me set the scene for you and let us embark on a journey that will reach into the realm of horrific torture, an accidental assassination and the source of number of deaths equal to almost a third of the population currently living in the UK. But before I show you these plans of evil. A new country is formed in 1871; it is a day to remember, as this country will be the fundamental reason for

Essay on the Origins of Greek Drama

607 words - 2 pages that flourished in ancient Greece between c. 600 and c. 200 BC. By the 5th century BC, theater had become formalized and was a major part of Athenian culture and civic pride. Athenian tragedy, comedy, and satyr plays were some of the earliest theatrical forms to emerge in the world. Greek theater and plays have had a lasting impact on Western drama and culture. ²There are three types of plays; tragedy, comedy, and satyr. Tragedy can be

Similar Essays

Community Living Ontario: Speaking On Behalf Of The Intellectually Disabled

573 words - 2 pages Community Living Ontario is an organization that speaks on behalf of the intellectually disabled. They have established one hundred and seventeen local Community Living associations across Ontario and have over twelve thousand members across the province. Community Living encourages people to accept and include the intellectually disabled within the community. This essay will discuss how Community Living Ontario promotes individuals to be

Should Christians Ever Use Violence On Behalf Of Religion?

829 words - 4 pages In different circumstances using violence on behalf of religion has aided a reformation, or the spreading of the gospel. Other times, millions of people have died due to resistance. Some situations call for violence and others do not. However, there is a failsafe way of determining whether violence should be used on behalf of religion, or not. The English Reformation and the Thirty Years War, along with the incident on St. Bartholomew’s

Online Marketing: The Smart Way Of Advertising On The Internet

2336 words - 10 pages “The Marketing Accountability Imperative: Driving Superior Returns on Marketing Investments” written by Michael Dunn and Chris Halsall is about how the world today has become so advanced with all kinds of new innovative technology. Including the emerging middle class of other countries brings even more technology and a more competitive world. Because of this emerging middle class it increases the demand of your product to an uncontrollable

Negative Impact Of God On The Minds Of David Hume, Christopher Smart, And William Cowper

1679 words - 7 pages Negative Impact of God on the Minds of David Hume, Christopher Smart, and William Cowper David Hume was one of the most influential writers and philosophers of his time. Hume was the second son of Joseph Hume, laird of Ninewells, a small estate in Berwickshire. He was born and raised in Edinburgh, and studied law at Edinburgh University. He left the University without taking a degree with him, however. He spent the next three years