This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Essay On Fate And Human Responsibility In The Aeneid

2822 words - 11 pages

Fate and Human Responsibility in the Aeneid     

 
      If you're going to write an epic about great heroism, don't use the Aeneid as your primary guide. It's not that heroism can't be found in the Aeneid, it's just hard to prove. First off, Virgil writes a story in a fatalistic universe, wherein every action and every event is under Jupiter's divine thumb .  Fatalism "is all-pervading in Virgil . . . in it [the Aeneid] the words fatum and fata occur some 120 times" (Bailey 204). And in the first three books alone "the word 'Fatum' or 'Fata' occurs more than forty times" (Sellar 334).   Venus praises Jupiter as one who: "command[s] and govern[s] the events of gods and men . . ." (1:321-21). Furthermore, Phoebus tells Aeneas that "the king of gods allot the fates, revolving every happening . . ." (3:484-87).  So whenever Aeneas wins a battle, whenever Aeneas needs help, whenever Aeneas catches a cold, Jupiter has control.  And though not all events are fated (e.g. Dido's suicide), most events are under the control of the gods .  Aeneas even admits that he doesn't have a free will (4:491-92), because he is bound for Latium.  If a universe is fated, how can anybody be responsible for his or her actions?  The very idea of fatalism obliterates any notion of heroism because it removes the potential for human responsibility .

         Why should Aeneas be praised for conquering Latium? Why should Aeneas be called a hero?  The interesting paradox within the Aeneid is the idea of human responsibility interwoven with fatalism.  Though Aeneas knows that "fate has promised" his settlement in Latium (1:286-87), he doesn't sit around waiting for Jupiter to zap them all into Latium; he is on a constant quest to settle there.  And though 'fatum' works nicely for Aeneas, the tragedy of 'fatum' is revealed in the deaths of Dido and Turnus, who are mere innocent victims of fate.  Anderson notes: "Everything that Aeneas does seems to have its cruel price; every time he promotes the destined future he also hurts the present condition of someone else" (26). Yet, out of all the characters in the Aeneid, readers will pity Dido the most.  Turnus could fight back against fate, but Dido can't.  In fact, Poschl argues that "the book of Dido can be considered the climax of the whole poem (91). Dido's death is by far the most problematic because through her death, which she didn't deserve , ushers in the future death of everyone in Carthage  .  The idea of a praiseworthy hero, who incites the suicide of an innocent Queen, becomes highly suspect.  We want to cheer along Aeneas through his adventures, but it becomes increasingly hard knowing that he is the cause of Dido's suicide.   Even though Venus and Juno engineered Dido's love affair with Aeneas, our view of Aeneas is damaged because he wasn't forced to have sex with Dido.  Dido was spellbound, but Aeneas wasn't. Aeneas could have been heroic and refrained from fornication, but he didn't.  Aeneas enjoyed his...

Find Another Essay On Essay on Fate and Human Responsibility in the Aeneid

Essay on Fate in Beowulf, Grendel, and Macbeth

2218 words - 9 pages agent that determines destiny. In Beowulf, God plays this role, and fate is generally accepted as God's will. In John Gardner's Grendel, a novel which serves as a commentary on the poem, fate is totally predetermined, and is the will of no being. By contrast, Macbeth's agents of fate are the Witches, who generally go against God's will.   In all three works, fate plays a powerful role, as it did in many prescientific cultures. Fate is a

Promoting Morality in the Aeneid and Metamorphoses

1653 words - 7 pages VI, 245), he cannot help but be "shaken by [Dido's] ill fate" (Book VI, 264). Aeneas, even in his insistence that divine machinations drove him to leave Dido, accepts his preordained role as founder of Rome; though he briefly worries that he is, in Dido's eyes, "someone to flee from" (Book VI, 251), Aeneas does not shy from his duty to Troy. Where Virgil's Aeneid describes the second "founder" of Rome and an superior citizen which those under

The Underworld and Morality in Vergil's Aeneid

1063 words - 4 pages The Underworld and Morality in Vergil's Aeneid Book IV of the Aeneid can stand alone as Vergil's highest literary achievement, but centered in the epic, it provides a base for the entire work. The book describes Aeneas's trip through the underworld, where after passing through the depths of hell, he reaches his father Anchises in the land of Elysium. Elysium is where the "Soul[s] to which Fate owes Another flesh" lie (115). Here Anchises

Destiny in the Aeneid

563 words - 2 pages Destiny in The Aeneid      Fate, in the Ancient Greek and Roman world, was one of the great unchangeable powers that stand above even the gods in the hierarchy of supernatural forces. The Greeks and Romans thought that the Fates were three ancient women who spun the web of destiny together. Each man’s life is a thread, and the fates would draw it out and cut it as they saw fit. The gods themselves had to obey the Fates, for even they had

Adventures in The Aeneid

1268 words - 5 pages taken on a divine mission to see the depths and horrors of Hell. While in Hell, Dante stumbles upon and is intrigued by two lovers, Paolo and Francesca, who were tragically killed by Francesca’s husband, Gianciotti. 	In The Aeneid, Aeneas is on a journey to lead his people, the Trojans to a new homeland. Aeneas was chosen by fate to lead the Trojans to establish a new homeland in Italy and Rome. This fate also represents the national

Tempting Fate: Essay on "The Monkeys Paw"

632 words - 3 pages -Ildar- Tempting Fate The “Monkey’s Paw” reveals an intriguing story of destiny and death. The Theme challenges the classical ideas of destiny and fate. From the beginning of the story Mr. White denies the seriousness of the paw. When he says, “Well, why don’t you have three sir”, he is in a way mocking Morris and the criticalness of the paw. The effects of disturbing fate do not even occur to him at this point and his intrigue and human greed

Reflection on Love: The Aeneid and the the Tabula Cebelis

1626 words - 7 pages True love in a story must be acted on by two different people. It cannot be made to happen by an outside force or it will be doomed to fail. In this essay we will look at two different texts. The first being The Aeneid and the second book being the Tabula Cebelis. We’ll look at different instances of love that are highlighted between both texts and discuss rather it is an instance of true love or a deceitful love. Deceitful love being one that

Female’s Impact on Politics in The Aeneid by Virgil

1382 words - 6 pages In the opening books of the Aeneid, Virgil presents many different characters that play important roles and have influences on Aeneas’s journey. This includes not only mortal men and women, but also Gods and Goddesses. Throughout the plot, Virgil constantly addresses political issues through the actions of the characters. Of these characters, the female figures are often portrayed in a negative way. For example, they tend to act emotionally and

Discuss The Theme Of The Origin In The Aeneid And

599 words - 2 pages ancient Greeks and Romans could do to please the gods. Gods being the ?faith-holder? for human beings in these epics greatly influence way characters act and the way characters are treated. One instance of the role of hospitality in The Odyssey came in book six when Nausicaa found Odysseus on the shores. Even though Odysseus appeared intimidating and horrible, Nausicaa felt obligated to help. Her status as a princess is unknown to Odysseus from

Freedom Defined in The lilad and The Aeneid

2651 words - 11 pages , but they too are controlled by fate. The gods end up generally complying with fate to ensure chaos does not ensue, but Homer raises interesting questions through his subtle doubts regarding what it means for a human to be free within the will of the gods and for the gods to be free within the will of fate. Virgil expounds upon the questions that Homer raises regarding freedom years later when he writes The Aeneid. The Aeneid defines the

Destiny,Love,and Suffering in the "Aeneid" by Virgil

646 words - 3 pages Destiny, Love and Suffering In The AeneidIn The Aeneid, Aeneas is on a journey to lead his people, the Trojans to a new homeland. Aeneas is a very important character because of his divine parentage. After all, his mother is the goddess Venus and his father's brother is the King of Troy. Aeneas will find his destiny manipulated by the Gods at every turn, costing him much. His own mother is one of the Gods working to make himfulfill his destiny

Similar Essays

Essay On Fate And Chance In The Mayor Of Casterbridge

1621 words - 6 pages Fate and Chance in The Mayor of Casterbridge            Thomas Hardy's disillusionment over religion was a major theme in both his novels and his poetry. In his mind there was a conflict over whether fate or chance ruled us. He explores this dilemma in the poems "I Look Into My Glass" and "Going and Staying." Each poem takes a different stance on the matter. It is up to the novel The Mayor of Casterbridge to illuminate which position he

Essay On Luck And Fate In The Rocking Horse Winner

834 words - 3 pages Luck and Fate in The Rocking Horse Winner   The Rocking Horse Winner, by D.H. Lawrence, is an informative story about luck and one's own fortune.  In this story, Lawrence attempts to illustrate how one can guide one's own fate, instead of allowing things to happen by chance.  He believes that the only person that affects what happens to someone, is really that person himself.  "Everything is what you make of it," is

The Role Of The Gods And Fate In Virgil's The Aeneid

1505 words - 6 pages The Role of the Gods and Fate in Virgil's The Aeneid Are the deeds of mortal characters in the Aeneid controlled by the gods or by fate? Aeneas must fulfill the will of the gods, while enduring the wrath of other gods, all the while being a worthy predecessor of Augustus and founder of the Roman people. Of course, the Trojan is successful because he gives himself up to these other obligations, while those who resist the will of the gods

Does Aeneas Control His Own Fate In The Aeneid?

1082 words - 4 pages While reading The Aeneid, a reader may wonder whether Aeneas has control of his own fate or not. The very large number of interactions of the gods and goddesses may sway the reader’s opinion one direction. Jupiter, Juno, and Venus are always interacting with Aeneas’s life. They were notorious for decisions that affected Aeneas’s life like: first arriving in Carthage, leaving Dido, burning down the Trojans ships, and much more. Throughout