Essay On Kierkegaard

5106 words - 20 pages

Willed Faith and Belief An essay on Kierkegaard 1. Introduction Can we will to believe what we choose? Are there times when we should at least try to believe in something? If it were easy to manipulate our own beliefs, low self-esteem would vanish, the divorce rate would decline, and over-consumption would disappear with the reminder: "I already have enough stuff." Yet there is something suspect about willed beliefs. Perhaps it is not ethically responsible to change beliefs without regard for the truth of the matter.1 And the epistemological coherence of the notion is questionable. Perhaps belief states are just not the kind of things that are under the influence of our will - analogous to the fact that we cannot decide to perceive blueness when looking at a red apple.This is an issue that has attracted some interest in the course of the history of thought. In this paper I will be looking into the views of a contemporary author who sees the relationship of willing to belief as an issue recurring thoughout the history of philosophy.In his book Religious Belief and the Will2, Louis Pojman identifies Soren Kierkegaard as a direct prescriptive volitionalist, i.e. a thinker who holds that beliefs can and ought to be (at least in some circumstances) directly willed.C. Stephen Evans, in "Does Kierkegaard Think Beliefs Can Be Directly Willed?"3 responds to Pojman's position, arguing that the attribution of direct volitionalism to Kierkegaard is too strong a claim. Evans does admit Kierkegaard as an indirect volitionalist, i.e. as holding that we can bring about belief states indirectly, as consequences of other actions that are themselves directly willed. (An example might be my taking up a winter sport, in order to produce a belief that winter is an enjoyable season.) Additional articles4 have appeared in the literature recently, which respond to Pojman's position in Religious Belief and the Will, as well as views presented in Pojman's book entitled The Logic of Subjectivity5, and a paper Pojman recently contributed to the ongoing discussion, viz. "Kierkegaard on Faith and Freedom."6 Various related issues are dealt with in these discussions, many of which would make interesting topics for another paper.In this paper I will be examining Pojman's analysis of Kierkegaard's views, as articulated in Religious Belief and the Will, and Evans's paper, as it relates specifically to arguments contained in Pojman's book. For support of their varying positions, both authors rely primarily upon references to Philosophical Fragments7 and Concluding Unscientific Postscript to Philosophical Fragments8, by the pseudonymous author Johannes Climacus. These are the Kierkegaardian writings that I will be referring to as well. The question of the relationship between the views of Kierkegaard and the views attributed to the pseudonymous author will not be discussed here. I will refer to the author as Kierkegaard when responding to a discussion that refers to 'Kierkegaard.'...

Find Another Essay On Essay on kierkegaard

Kierkegaard: Ethics And Religion Essay

1022 words - 4 pages Kierkegaard: Ethics and Religion Where is the line drawn? That seems to be the question raised by Kierkegaard's take on the Abraham story. To what extent is one justified in carrying out what he or she perceives to be God's commands? To the extent of killing one's own son? According to Kierkegaard, the distinction between what we deem ethical and what we deem as service to God has blurred, to the degree that "when we see someone doing

Kierkegaard and christianity Essay

1658 words - 7 pages Soren Kierkegaard is said to be one of the "founding fathers" of existentialism. His style of writing, his tone and vocabulary tie him closely to another forerunner of existentialist thought: Fyodor Dostoevsky (although either of them would probably deny this vehemently). However, in the course of his writings, Kierkegaard takes quite a liberal and (dare I say it?) individualistic stand on the side of Christianity. In the passages I have read of

Soren kierkegaard vs Friedrich Nietzsche

1043 words - 5 pages Friedrich Nietzsche. Søren Kierkegaard is a very enthusiastic philosopher who believed that the way to live is to have a religious authenticity and avoid the crowd life. Friedrich Nietzsche is a very controversial philosopher who believes that everyone is entitled to their own point of view on life and that there is no absolute truth. Both thinkers express ideas that are different from the norms of their societies and have therefore provoked

Soren Kierkegaard: Stages on Life's Way

605 words - 2 pages dominating father and against God."(Denise 172). Kierkegaard's father, Michael, who was a very religious man, led a extremely somber life and often suffered from depression, as he feared for the salvation of his soul. He taught Soren about Christianity, but mainly focused on the crucifixion of Christ. Kierkegaard once said concerning his father's teachings, "Even as a small child I was told, as solemnly as possible: that everyone spat at Christ

The Sickness Unto Death According to Kierkegaard

1261 words - 5 pages inward and focus on existential being. Once one turns their focus inward they can they find the real truth of their existence, and that existence is the action relational happening of relating of oneself to oneself, and to God. 2. The knight of infinite resignation to Kierkegaard is one who has realized the loss of all meaning in life. They have accepted the world as something that is beyond their objective understanding and have infinitely

Clash Of The Titans: Kierkegaard Vs. Nietzsche On Theories Of Knowledge

3019 words - 12 pages Søren Kierkegaard and Friedrich Nietzsche are considered by most to be the grandfathers of existentialist thought. While they had many ideas in common, such as the errors of all previous philosophers, they differed on thoughts concerning knowledge. Kierkegaard believed that knowledge could only be communicated to the audience indirectly, and through that the individual must make his own choice as to which possibility he will accept and

Comparative: Smith and Marx's to Kierkegaard and Dostoevsky's view of god and religion

633 words - 3 pages , along with society's, and obtain salvation through an absolute devotion to faith. However, the works of Smith, Marx, Kierkegaard, and Dostoevsky prove that argument to be ridiculous. There is no "in between" stance; only one or the other.Though Smith and Marx differ greatly in their socioeconomic theories, they are similar in the fact that they are both concerned with our economic society. The two revolutionaries recognize the impact society has on

Kierkegaard and Abraham: A Literary Tool and Belief in the Ideal Christian-Existentialist

1690 words - 7 pages Abraham, the father of the Christian, Jewish, and Islamic religions is held up by Kierkegaard as the perfect model for faith in Fear and Trembling. The specific example most strongly used in Kierkegaard’s writing is the unhesitant actions of Abraham to heed God’s call and sacrifice his only son and promised heir to his kingdom, Isaac. Abraham faithfully follows God’s command without remorse, doubt, sadness, or anger. It is only moments before

Kierkegaard's understanding of faith as a paradox, whereby the particular is higher than the universal, and therefore demands a teleological suspension of the ethical

1940 words - 8 pages In his book Fear and Trembling, Søren Kierkegaard deals with the concept of faith and the idea of sacrifice, focusing particularly on the story of Abraham and Isaac, as presented in the Bible. Abraham here is depicted obeying God and abandoning social norms - the process through which he earns honor and glory as the father of faith. This is what Kierkegaard calls "the teleological suspension of the ethical", and concludes that faith is

Relationships in a World without God

2247 words - 9 pages scientific method was that of phenomenological reduction. Although Søren Kierkegaard accepted the paradox of being defining itself, as a scientist, Heidegger could not accept this paradox. According to Heidegger, a concept must be defined without using itself as reference. The difficulty of definition was confronted by defining Being as a collection of concepts. In his essay “The Fundamental Question of Metaphysics” the central question he asks is “Why

Kiekegaard and human dignity

1751 words - 8 pages In order to understand the role that Socrates played in Kierkegaard’s thought as well as the relevance of this connection to the world today it is useful to understand the immediate background of Kierkegaard’s critique. Specifically, this essay examines the problem that both Romanticists and Kierkegaard grappled with and the novelty of Kierkegaard’s Socratic approach in tackling problems with the Romanticist analysis. Rousseau is discussed as a

Similar Essays

Kierkegaard And Postmodernism Essay

5151 words - 21 pages ": A Middle Knowledge Perspective on Perseverance and Apostolic Warnings [pp. 65-74] The Causal Theory of Reference and Religious Language [pp. 75-86] A Problem for the Eternity Solution [pp. 87-95] Kierkegaard on the Limits of Christian Epistemology [pp. 97-112] Critical Review Essay Review: Kierkegaard and Postmodernism [pp. 113-122] Book Reviews Review: untitled [pp. 123-125] Review: untitled [pp. 125-127] Review: untitled [pp. 127-128] Back Matter

Kierkegaard And Wittgenstein Essay

2647 words - 11 pages Kierkegaard and Wittgenstein The connections between Ludwig Wittgenstein and Soren Kierkegaard as philosophers are not at all immediately obvious. On the surface, Wittgenstein deals with matters concerning the incorrect use of philosophical language and Kierkegaard focuses almost exclusively on answering the question 'how to become a Christian'. But this account belies deeper structural similarities between these men's important works

Kierkegaard Essay

710 words - 3 pages Kierkegaard Kierkegaard felt that subjective reflection was more crucial to the individual life than objective reflection because it focused on passion and human existence instead of logic and impersonal truth. The objective world is the world of facts and truth independent of the perceptions of humans. Objective reflection focuses on what actually is, in the objective world. Objective reflection centers on the things and ideas in the

Soren Kierkegaard Essay

599 words - 2 pages I believe Soren Kierkegaard was a great Philosopher but insane. I will show what makes him a great Philosopher and why I like him the best.Soren Kierkegaard was born in 1813 in Copenhagen. Kierkegaard was considered insane by most standards. In most of the history books, a lot of philosophers were insane from syphilis. Kierkegaard was mostly influenced by his father. As a child he was mentally abused by his father. This helped him develop his