This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Essay On The Japan: The Modern Girl As Militant Discussing About The Modern Japanese Women During The Period Of The 1920s<Tab/>

1179 words - 5 pages

In Japan, the images of women have undergone rather remarkable transitional changes. In her article "The Modern Girl as Militant", Miriam Silverberg focuses on the category of Modern Girl ("moga," or modan gaaru), a topic of debate in Japanese society during the 1920s and early 1930s. She argues that the Modern Girl was a media creation designed to portray women as promiscuous and apolitical. It was a way of displacing the militancy expressed in their political activity, her labor in new arenas and their adoption of new fashions.Therefore, when examing the history of Japanese women during that era, the historian should not be trapped in viewing her as just an epitome of moral decadence, but rather should become conscious of her militant nature. This paper begins by focusing on some of Silverberg's strong arguments, which defends her position on the image of Modern Girl as militant . I would then proceed to highlight some ambiguities and questions with regards to her arguments.Silverberg begins her paper by asserting that the Modern Girl was a highly commodified cultural construct crafted by journalist during the decade of cultural and social change. She then proceed to discuss some of the contemporaries such as Kitazawa Shuichi, Nii Itaru, Kishida, Kataoka Teppi etc., who tried to define the characteristics of the Modern Girl. Despite the fact the contemporaries writing about the Modern Girl struggle to find an absolute definition, the essence of who the Modern Girl remains clear to society. The Modern Girl stood for everything modern and non-Japanese. It stood for all the materialism and decadence in Japanese society at that period, and all "modern" ideals and lifestyle that threatened the traditional social order of Japan. It was a conservative construct, a symbol of what women should not be, and a reflection of the negative social phenomena in Japan's modernisation process.However, Silverberg argues against that the true reality of the Modern Girl was in fact militant. She claimed that there was an increased in politicization of Japanese women during the 1920s to 1930s. For example, there was an emergence of militant feminist organizations such as the New Woman's Association (1919) and the Red Wave Society (1921) . Silverberg also highlights that women were active in the labour movement, with the setting up of many unions and professional organizations that dealt with the problems in some of the female-dominated occupations. Women also took part in strikes, such as the Toyo Muslin strike and Florida Dance Hall strike, with some strikes seeing women as active participants and organisers . She also noticed that the threatening emergence of the Modern Girl coincided with a debate on the possible revision of the Meiji Civil Code.According to Silverberg, the media and the government therefore sought to downplay the militancy of Japanese women by defining her image as apolitical and promiscuous. In this way, they are made to be less of a threat and...

Find Another Essay On Essay on the Japan: The Modern Girl as Militant Discussing about the modern Japanese women during the period of the 1920s<Tab/>

Influence of the Samurai on Modern Japanese Society

1763 words - 7 pages Feudal Japan. Along with their dominant military and political standing, the samurai brought with them a unique code or moral belief that became the core of Samurai culture. Because of this, the Samurai and their principles still affect modern day Japanese society with social customs today deriving directly and indirectly from the beliefs of the Samurai. History of the Samurai When discussing the origin of the Samurai, an important time in

Japanese Literature during the Medieval Period

1264 words - 5 pages During the Medieval period (1185–1603) in Japan there was change and innovation in Japanese literature. “Waka composition practices change as Japanese society does” (Huey 652). The medieval world was greatly reflected in Japanese literature because during this time there were numerous civil wars that led to different classes in society. “In fact, many different types of people helped shape the medieval period. Over 400 years, from the late

The Modern Women

1551 words - 6 pages Common misrepresentations of women are said to be that they are weak and inferior to men in which American society continuously place women in these roles within domestic, political, economic, and social settings. The public rarely pays tribute to the feminine heroine because she is unrecognized and unseen in American culture. However, during the 1960s to 1970s, African-American female representation has changed the way we define femininity and

Japanese History Paper on the Peace Constitution - Modern Japanese History Class - Essay

1123 words - 5 pages ] Nevertheless, even though Kaname was an active participant during WWII, he recounts on his horrific memory of “seeing the terror on their faces as he sent them crashing to their deaths” and then calls for his final mission: “using his wartime experiences to warn Japan against ever going to war again.”[footnoteRef:8] As a whole, with his vivid experiential context during WWII, Kaname holds the absolute ‘pacifistic’ view of avoiding war or any military

Witch Hunts of the Early Modern Period as the Result of Religious and Social Upheaval

1559 words - 6 pages of witch-hunting and helped it to spread from place to place. The Early Modern Period was fraught with events that caused social upheaval within communities. As I have said, the Reformation and Counter Reformation caused not only religious upheaval but considerable social upheaval as well. The movements caused the change of people’s beliefs on religion, which therefore changed their whole outlook on life because

This book report on "The modern Temper: The American Culture and Society in the 1920s" by Lynn Dumenil summarizes the content of the book and praises Dumenil on her unique insight of this period

1126 words - 5 pages In Lynn Dumenil's account of the era commonly referred to as the "roaring twenties" in The Modern Temper: American Culture and Society in the 1920s there is an intentional emphasis placed on the effort to dispel the popular notion that the new, revolutionary transformations in culture and society that took place at this time in history were direct results of the First World War. In the stead of this less insightful means of analyzing the 1920's

The Rise of Modern Chinese Women

1100 words - 5 pages by those feudal way of thinking anymore. This essay will argue that the gender role has been changed and tends to sexual equality and women have higher social status than before. In the family aspect, female in the typical Chinese-lineage dominated society owned little freedom as well as the right of coming to grips of properties. All of the above happened, according to prof. Ma, owing to women were defined as not trust-worthy and considered as

Assess the Impact of WW1 on British women during the period 1914 - 1921'

1352 words - 5 pages never forgotten.The Great War had immense influence on the lives of all British women. The unprecedented scale of the war resulted in the demand for female labour on an enormous level. Socially, women began to feel liberated with their newly attained freedoms. The success of the allies on the fighting front became increasingly dependent on the efforts of British women. The Great War's impact was seen most crucially during the post-war period when their efforts were highly valued by the British people and resulted in the beginning of the recognition of the that sought to bring about justice and equality for all women.

How has Britain experienced the transition from the early modern to the modern period?

2782 words - 11 pages This essay addresses the question of how Britain has experienced the transition from the early modern to the modern period. It argues that Britain has developed dramatically during this period of time: it became a very powerful nation and indeed assumed the mantle of global superpower. To support this argument and to understand its development, the essay analyses economic, social, political and cultural developments in Britain. Specific

The Exploitation of Asian Women in the Japanese Comfort Women System During World War II

2550 words - 11 pages found itself covered with incriminating evidence (Hicks). It is suggested that "the massacre of Korean comfort women" represented fear the country had about being exposed as barbarians. Stetz and Oh write that "Non- Japanese women were seen a expendable supplies too cumbersome to be take along at the end of the war" (83). The mass murdering of Korean comfort women only further proves that the comfort system in Japan during World War II, was

The Implications of the Presentation of Women During the Romantic Period

1165 words - 5 pages people over Europe thought freedom and equality was very important,” according to During the Romantic Period, women did not have any voice on political issues. They were mainly household wives, and had no equality rights. But, what is the real role of the women? Women were treated as property and their only jobs were to stay at home and take care of household chores and their children. Many writers like Austen and Byron had different

Similar Essays

Women During The 1920s Essay

684 words - 3 pages An explaination of what women were like and how they were treated during the 1920sWomen During the 1920sCanadian women benefited from the courageous acts of several leaders who challenged the legal restrictions that limited woman's rights in this country. Many women such as the women in the Famous Five, like Emily Murphy, and Agnes Macphail were all in the "persons case" to make women's rights become equalized.Emily Murphy, Nellie McClung

The Modern Period Essay

1127 words - 5 pages It is common that the affluent writers of the modern period would naturally write about the events and circumstances of their time. It seems easier to write about people who mirror their society. Additionally, in doing so, it makes the content more relatable to their literary lay readers. No one really understands what they have not personally experienced. Therefore, it seems astute to have a storyline based on broad pragmatic circumstances

The Early Modern English Period Essay

1675 words - 7 pages Early Modern English and Modern English. Therefore, it is not that difficult to understand the Early ME. Now, when examining another work “Novum Organum” by Francis Bacon which is translated by Jonathan Bennett as “The New Organon”, you can also see that there is not much change in terms of expression. Man, as the minister and interpreter of nature, does and understands as much as his observations on the order of nature, either with regard to

Contemporary Revision Of The Progressive Modern Korean “New Women” In The 1920s: Blue Swallow

1549 words - 7 pages decision to choose career and dream over love portrayal in the film Blue Swallow contains a contemporary revision of the “new women” in the 1920s of the Japanese colonial period, which justifies the shift in the social status of Korean women. In the beginning of the film where Park as a young child is watching the Japanese soldiers during their march, the Japanese flag is shown in color while everything else is shown in black and white. This