Ethical And Professional Implications Essay

1300 words - 5 pages

Ethical and Professional Implications

The autonomy of a competent patient is an issue not often debated in medical ethics. Refusal of unwanted treatment is a basic right, likened to the common law of battery, available to all people capable of a competent choice. These fundamental rules of medical ethics entered a completely new forum as medical technology developed highly effective life-sustaining care during the 20th century. Several watershed cases elucidated these emerging issues in the 1960’s and 70’s, none more effectively than that of Karen Ann Quinlan. Fundamentally, this case established that a once-competent patient without the possibility of recovery could have their autonomy exercised by a surrogate in regard to the refusal of life-sustaining treatment. This decision had a profound effect on medical ethics, including treatment of incompetent patients in end-of-life situations, creation of advance directives, physician-assisted suicide (PAS) and active euthanasia.

By ruling in the favor of Mr. Quinlan, the New Jersey Supreme Court allowed for patient autonomy to be exercised by an incompetent patient. Though the legal implications of this decision vary from state to state, medical ethics now had to incorporate the possible refusal of a once competent patient unable to give that refusal. This concept is not one that was totally unexpected by the medical community. By developing machinery capable of sustaining life even in the case of severe deficit, it is only natural that medical ethics would need to adapt, growing to accommodate this new realm of consideration. Just as a competent person has the right to decide “how much to struggle, how much to suffer, how much bodily invasion to tolerate, and how much helplessness and indignity to endure,” (Cantor, N. Twenty Five Years After Quinlan) so too should this right include the incompetent patient. The case of Karen Ann Quinlan led to four basic approaches to this ethical problem; advance directives or other clear evidence of the patients wishes while competent, surrogate decision making (power of attorney), and action in the patients best interest. Each solution has deficiencies both in theory and practice, but there can be no debate that their application has changed the landscape of medical ethics.

The advance directive, or living will, is one way of circumventing the ethical dilemma of Quinlan, as it is essentially a set of choices by the competent patient if faced with different hypothetical circumstances. Patients can thus feel comfortable knowing that their competent wishes have been documented and can be easily interpreted in case of catastrophe. However, the authority of advance directives is a topic hotly debated amongst medical ethicists (see Advance Directive Authority). Arguments against directives state that not all factors are considered by the person creating the advance order. Also, in some cases of severe dementia, it is argued that...

Find Another Essay On Ethical and Professional Implications

Social, Ethical, and Legal Issues Faced by an Information Technology Professional

1012 words - 4 pages 1. Introduction This essay will discuss some of the Social, Ethical and Legal issues that an IT (Information Technology) Professional will likely face during their career in the Information Technology Sector. Furthermore, I will talk about how these issues affect professionals and how they could approach these challenges to try finding feasible solutions for them. 1.1 Social Issues When every IT professional starts their journey into the IT

"How would you define business ethics, and why are ethical standards necessary in professional selling"

1467 words - 6 pages , Fraedrich and Ferrell 2005, p. 6).Ethical standards are necessary in professional selling and it contributes to quite a number benefits for both the business and salesperson. Ethics in general, starts from the top line managers. Futrell (2005 p.56) stated that, "Salespeople are valuable resources: they are recruited, carefully trained, and given important responsibility. They represent a large financial investment and must be treated in a

Discuss the ethical, political and practice implications on accountability in nursing as a result of the current economic climate and recent cuts in health care spending.

3588 words - 14 pages healthcare system.This essay aims to analyse and critically apprise evidence from a variety of sources in relation to accountability. All evidence will relate to the current economic climate and proposed cuts in healthcare spending. Professional, ethical and practice implications in relation to advocacy in nursing will be discussed. There are many areas that could be explored within the topic, such as whistle blowing, guidelines or decision

The Odyssey: The Greek Ethical Mind - explores the implications of Greek attitudes, customs, and culture in Homer's the Odyssey

1072 words - 4 pages what horrible social ideals did our great ?ethical? society rise. In the times depicted in The Odyssey, the Ancient Greek mind differs from modern society and conformities in three major areas: warfare, honour, and sex. Dream or Nightmare, heaven or hell, and whether it entrances the reader with bliss or transfixes the reader with horror, the Odyssey keeps its reader intrigued and bound in its spell.Perhaps the most distinguishing characteristic

Ethical Decision Making

1401 words - 6 pages company or personal ground rules will have its own set of implications. In the following paragraphs I will discuss the impacts of ethics on decision-making, discuss the elements of an ethically defensible decision, define what the ground rules are; what they could be and what they should be, discuss the ethical implications of the decision, and explain how the decision may change the ground rules. Ethics is a standard that tells us how we should

Five Ethical Principles for Research With Human Participants

1307 words - 5 pages to develop a systematic approach to reviewing all relevant sources of ethical responsibility, including one's own moral principles and personal values; cultural factors; professional ethics codes, such as the APA code; agency or employer policies; federal and state rules and regulations; and even case law or legal precedent. A process-oriented approach to ethical decision making may involve some variation of the following: (1) writing a

Technology and The Workplace

1776 words - 7 pages , N., Maccaull, W., Miller, K., & Macdonald, M. (2012). Information technology and hospice palliative care: social, cultural, ethical and technical implications in a rural setting. Informatics For Health & Social Care, 37(1), 37-50. doi:10.3109/17538157.2011.613553 Kostyk, T., & Herkert, J. (2012). Computing Ethics Societal Implications of the Emerging Smart Grid. Communications Of The ACM, 55(11), 34-36. doi:10.1145/2366316.2366328 Vance, A., Lowry, P., & Eggett, D. (2013). Using Accountability to Reduce Access Policy Violations in Information Systems. Journal Of Management Information Systems, 29(4), 263-290. doi:10.2753/MIS0742-1222290410


931 words - 4 pages and self-interest. Lack of awareness of ethical nature of their action can lead to self-interested behavior. Frequently, the consequences of decisions do have ethical implications, which may not be immediately obvious. Under such conditions, managerial choices may be driven by considerations other than ethics. Once ethical values have been raised to the level of awareness, they will be a significant force in an individual's decision making


1163 words - 5 pages Key Term and why you are interested in it Ethics is defined as “the discipline dealing with what is good and bad and with moral duty and obligation”. “Business ethics is defined as “the study of ethical dilemmas, values, and decision making in the world of business”, which is not considered as a “separate disciple from ethics, and international business ethics, “examines many practical issues that result from international context of business

Ethics Codes Analysis Paper

1556 words - 6 pages differ in approach and function. This paper will evaluate, compare and contrast the similarities and dissimilarities of the codes in the areas of informed consent, competence of the counselor, and the counselor's relationship to society.Ethics Codes Analysis PaperOne of the intentions of the both the 2005 American Counseling Association Code of Ethics (ACA) and the 2004 American Association of Christian Counselors (AACC) is to serve as an ethical

The Ethics of Assessments in the Classroom

1886 words - 8 pages recording of specific incidences, if and how these where mitigated, and the action undertaken in solving the incidence could then be researched to find specific causes of dilemma. The research data supports the need for research, discussion, and professional development around ethical conflict. Schmeiser (1995), complements this understanding when discussing the student evaluation standards (The Joint Committee on Standards for Educational

Similar Essays

The Social And Ethical Implications Of Assisted Reproductive Technologies

2451 words - 10 pages The Social and Ethical Implications of Assisted Reproductive Technologies Test tube babies have long been stigmatized by society as the unnatural results of scientific dabbling. The words `test tube baby' have been used by school children as an insult, and many adults have seen an artificial means of giving birth as something perhaps only necessary for a lesbian woman, or a luxury item only available to the elite few. The reality is that

Ethical, Professional And Legal Issues Influencing Theatre Practitioners

3896 words - 16 pages Essay title - Critically analyze ethical, professional and legal issues influencing theatre practitionersIntroductionNow-a-days nursing has developed its all functional activities in accordance with technological, political or socio-economical rapid change. Perioperative practitioners are the part of this all nursing activities. Most importantly, in the operating theatre the role of the perioperative nurses vary for several reasons. For example

Ethical Implications On Society: An Analysis Of Wilkinson's "Inequality And Health"

2645 words - 11 pages Wilkinson has researched, his psychosocial analysis might fall through, as this data does not represent all States, and could not be the case in certain third world countries.Despite criticism, it seems that there is overwhelming evidence in support of the correlation between income and health. This causes a number of ethical, legal and political implications to arise with respect to autonomy and the State.Political ImplicationsThe State has

The Ethical Implications Of The Human Genome Project And Its Parallel Efforts

3349 words - 13 pages time when cooperation is of outmost importance. The availability of prenatal testing, and other genetic screening procedures that are already possible raise important and often controversial issues about the implications of the Human Genome Project and its parallel efforts. Genetics has been compared to the Eugenics movement of the 1920's, which eventually led to Hitler's genocide and concentration camps. Most would agree that this is a far off