Ethical Approach To Utalitarianism Essay

1964 words - 8 pages

Companies are faced with difficult decisions they have to make on a daily basis and Pegasus International Inc. is no exception (Freeman, 1991). In attempt to make the right choice, business ethics are implemented; which states the human conduct that is wrong or right in a business context (Shaw, 2011: 8)
A moral or ethical dilemma is when an agent must make a decision between two ethically compromising choices (White Hat Communications, 2014). In this scenario, Oswald faces a moral dilemma because he has to make a choice whether or not to expand the company by operating in China (Hackworth & Shanks, 2007). To operate in China, Oswald needs to pay off the Chinese authorities, and Oswald will have to disclose that the business is not a part of any bribery activities dishonestly (ibid).
A question Oswald will have to ask himself is also a question frequently asked in normative ethics: “What is the ethically right thing to do and how is it justified?” (Encyclopædia Britannica Inc, 2014).
At stake for Oswald and his company are a 100 million-dollar deal and the integrity of the company’s ethically correct reputation (Hackworth & Shanks, 2007). The clashing alternative actions Oswald are confronted with differs in moral rightness and the quality of the result of the action (CIMA, 2010). Oswald is morally obliged not to operate in China but at the same time, he is obligated.
This essay will discuss the ethical approach of utilitarianism that will help Oswald to choose the right action for him so that the company’s ethical reputation will not be ruined and the company will still be successful. There will be a critical evaluation, which assess Oswald’s situation and clearly discuss what appropriate actions needs to be taken by Oswald before making a final decision.
Utilitarianism is a form of consequentialism; meaning that when deciding if an action is right it is entirely based on the consequences that the action will produce, relative to the consequences of other “alternative actions” (Driver, 2012). One of the most persuasive normative approaches in the history of philosophy is utilitarianism (The History of Utilitarianism, 2009). Utilitarianism attempts to identify the morally right decision by finding the one that creates the most “happiness” for all those affected (Shaw, 2011:53).
There are two forms of utilitarianism namely act utilitarianism and rule utilitarianism, the former being applied on a case-by-case basis and the latter by a utility of rules (Shaw, 2011:55). Act utilitarianism is directly applied to each alternate act and the right act is the one, which consequences do more good than harm to those affected, directly or indirectly, by this act (Utilitarian Theories, 2002). In the case of the Million-Dollar Decision, we are applying act utilitarianism. We will measure up the consequences of the decision that Tom Oswald (“Oswald”) has to make of whether he should or should not “bribe” the Chinese officials to do business, then we will...

Find Another Essay On Ethical Approach to Utalitarianism

The Importance of Ethical Decision Making

969 words - 4 pages instance, if the air rescuers are not available or they can not make it within the scheduled time, and optionally the navy officers are also not available, I will be forced to sacrifice one life by running over the man on the road and significantly saving the six lives due to perish on the beach, but only if I will make it on time based on my approximation. This decision will minimally go against the ethical approach of handling calamities, because

Kudler Fine Foods Case Study: Personal Values

1091 words - 4 pages responsibility. Kathy’s approach to ethical issues tends to focus on two main traits, effective communication, and leadership skills. Her effective communication is vital to her role as a leader when communicating to her staff. In fact, the decision to hire managers to run the day-to-day operations at each store enabled Kathy to work on other business ventures and focus on meeting the customer’s needs. When making the decision to hire managers for

Unethical Decision Making

1779 words - 7 pages Understanding the Triggers, Impacts, and Prevention of Unethical Decision-Making Ethics is a topic that is not discussed and understood in detail in the professional or academic settings. Ethical codes such as The American Psychological Association’s (APA) Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct are often used to guide researchers but even this guide is too vague and generic (American Psychological Association, 2012). Because

Ethical Perspective Paper

1106 words - 4 pages /relativism is described as a self interest approach. This theory does not hold any universal rules that can be used to judge the morality of an act. According to this theory, people set there own rules, moral standards to judge the morality of an act. The decisions are based on the self interest and the values.The EAI found that this principle did not exist in my personality. My Score was negative five (-5). In my ethical perspective, my

moral identity of a leader

1015 words - 4 pages obligation a leader has to its followers and all stakeholders thereby reiterating ethical leadership as a central part of top management in today's business environment. Trust between followers and leaders is required if a leadership style such as the transformative leader or any other leadership approach is to be effective. Leadership can be seen to be more about the followers than the leader themselves as it is ultimately the followers not the leaders

Ethical Decision Making Essay

1242 words - 5 pages because I felt guilty about what was happening. I wanted to get rid of my guilt and that why I told Amber. Kant would say that because I taught about my feelings more then Amber or Eddie. Carol Gilligan is the last philosopher who has two ways into making an ethical decision. The first one is the Justice approach. The justice approach is when you break down the situation into doing something or not going something. Using the justice approach to my

Defining “Right”: Using Ethical Framework to Define the Term “Right”

1204 words - 5 pages questions that help use analyze the find the “right” thing to do. With anything, there is no steadfast rule on what is the correct framework to use. It is a mix between different thought process mixed with your personal values that help create a personal sense of “right” and “just”. Ethical Relativism Ethics cannot be discussed without first addressing ethical relativism and pointing out the potential traps of this flawed thinking. Ethical

Individual Ethical Perspective

1921 words - 8 pages interact with peers and higher leadership in a more effective manner when it comes to ethical considerations and stands. Even though this survey gave me great insight into my own core beliefs, it also gave me an understanding of how other people may approach circumstances. This will be very beneficial when it comes to influencing any organization or social group's policies so that everyone is served in the best possible way. This paper will

Ethical Issues in the Study of Domestic Violence

1237 words - 5 pages from potential ethical problems. The research carried out by Hoyle involved in her using the method of ‘cold calling’. This is a method used by many researchers whereby they approach the participants unannounced ready to research them, in Hoyle’s case, she turned up at the victim’s doorstep uninvited. This method of research does indeed does create many ethical problems. One of the ethical dilemmas of cold calling is that, even though it improves

The Importance of Critical Thinking and Ethical Decision Making on Social Work

1172 words - 5 pages Shanks, Margaret R. McLean, David DeCosse, Claire André, and Kirk O. Hanson. (2009) at the Markkula Center for Applied Ethics at Santa Clara University. The first step is to recognize the ethical issue. The second step involves getting the facts about your social issue. Next, it requires the social worker to evaluate alternative actions by asking ethics approach questions. Fourth, it sets for the social worker to make a decision and test it

Dynamics of Ethics

1428 words - 6 pages Running head: SHORT TITLE OF PAPER (<= 50 CHARACTERS) Dynamics of Ethics Monique Cone BSHS332 December 6, 2010 Audra Stinson Dynamics of Ethics Organization influences the ethical behavior of employees. Employees care and always question about the ethical conduct of employers and tend to believe the action rather than the word of the employer. Managers can discipline an employee by verbal warnings or

Similar Essays

Outsourcing: A Utilitarian Approach To An Ethical Issue

1529 words - 6 pages An ethical business problem arises in case of outsourcing. The decision making framework can be used to explore the dilemma and to develop a course of action in order to resolve this problem by using the utilitarian approach and ensuring that the maximum number people are helped or favored by the decision. Utilitarianism has had great popularity in American and Western culture mainly because it focuses on the welfare of the masses than the

Ethics Essay

1076 words - 4 pages 1. Ethical relativism is an approach to ethics connected to ethical insight that a legitimate set of ethical guidelines is related to an actual society or group.2. Ethical subjectivism is that good and evil are related to the feelings or attitudes of specific individuals. Yes, because ethical theory must be able to show that some ethical guidelines are better, and that ethical subjectivism can identify some moral guidelines. Moral

The Descriptive Approach. Essay

577 words - 2 pages The descriptive approach is also called the psychological approach. According to this chapter the psychological approach "relies on psychological research and describes how people actually make ethical decisions" (pg.88). It also focuses on "cognitive barriers that can keep people from making good ethical decisions" (pg.110). In fact, this chapter mentions steps that we can follow to help us make better decisions and overcome obstacles that

Developing An Ethical Framework And Applying It To An Ethical Dilemma

2319 words - 9 pages approaches, such as Utilitarianism and the Justice Approach. I used a book by David Robinson and Chris Garrett titled Introducing Ethics: A Graphic Guide, to further inform myself of how philosophical arguments can be of assistance in my ethical framework and where they can lack effectiveness. The Utilitarianism approach may work when an ethical dilemma is presented within a group project; however this argument places emphasis only on human