This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Ethical Considerations Of College Recruiting Essay

2106 words - 8 pages

The United States has an obsession with sports. From little leagues to major leagues, winning is above all and being competitive is important for both coaches and administrators overall success. That is why college recruiting has so many ethical issues today. When universities are able to offer money and other incentives to student-athletes in order to persuade them to enroll with their institution it gives them an advantage some others are not able to offer. Gifting money, cars, clothing, houses, and sometimes even sex take place in order to sway an athlete to one’s school. This issue may not be a problem for all sport managers because there are a few schools that have the money to spend and have no problem offering it to athletes, but most other smaller schools are left in the dust with lower end recruits. Illegal and unethical recruitment affects sport managers and coaches because of the lack of success some may have getting higher end recruits to attend their institution. There is also risk involved for sport managers and coaches through the chance of getting caught doing said illicit acts. The purpose of this paper is to highlight the history of illegal and unethical recruiting as well as my proposed solution to try and limit illegal recruiting.
In the early years of collegiate athletics the only sport that enforced a governing body for rules and eligibility was rowing. Years later along with a handful other sports, football had created its own governing body in 1876 named the IFA. The purpose of the Intercollegiate Football Association was to create eligibility and game guidelines for institutions partaking in football. On account of regulation and eligibility not being enforced well, there was a lot of illegal recruitment along with players not having to attend class to play for the school. The IAAUS (now known as the NCAA) was created in the early 1900’s in order to “protect young people from the dangerous and exploitive athletic practices of the time” (History, 2013, para. 1). The IAAUS was created during the time of a lot of injury and death in the sport, so a change was needed to make the game safer to play. Two decades later, a 1929 Carnegie report had opened the eyes of people in the college sporting world. The report had shown that many of the universities who had participated in the survey had been partaking in unethical practices with athletes such as recruiting abuses, academic dishonesty, and illicit slush funds. The Carnegie report would ultimately put pressure on the NCAA to be more involved in making and regulating guidelines for athletes at the scholarly level. Some of the new rules put forth were things such as setting the principals of amateurism, ensure that all teams were recruiting legally, and to set a standard and monitor academic records for athletes. The Carnegie report had been a catalyst for change in the standards of collegiate sports and had made the first look into the unethical ways of recruiting. Soon after,...

Find Another Essay On Ethical Considerations of College Recruiting

College Recruiting Essay

1661 words - 7 pages College Recruiting MBA 504 Human Resource Management National-Louis University Julie Pflomm Professor: Ken Bellinder January 22, 2001 Introduction ?Recruiting is the process of identifying and attracting a pool of candidates, from which some will later be selected to receive employment offers? (Milkovich & Bougreau, p. 181). This statement reflects on the efforts to recruit and select high-quality employees, in order for an organization to

Improving College Recruitment Essay

2097 words - 8 pages students. Networking is a skill that needs to be learned. Recruiters can practice the skill of networking and receive refinements in etiquette in networking. Legal Considerations The importance of abiding by legal regulations and laws cannot be underscored. Discussing cases and their legal or ethical implications is an effective method to train in how to approach various situations in the recruiting process. Additionally, focusing on this area

Tanglewood Case Study: Recruitment Guide

2352 words - 10 pages Manager Budget: Open Job Targets Based on the positions avaliable, the targets for this recruiting campaign are candidates who are enrolled or recently out of high school as well as currently enrolled college students. The reason for targeting high school students is due to the fact that there is a large hiring pool for this targeted area especially for summer jobs. Targeting current college students is due to the fact that graduates are less

Development of a code of ethics: IT challenges

1721 words - 7 pages and the resultant emerging ethical considerations, students need guidance in making ethical decisions, which are now unique to today’s technology driven world. (Brooks, 2010, p. 11) The Josephson Institute conducts a national survey on the ethics of American high school students every two years. Stealing, lying and cheating have risen exponentially. (Brooks, 2010) Within the IT industry snooping has become excessive; IT professionals are

NCAA Recruiting Ethics

1352 words - 5 pages College recruiting is something that was created for the good of college sports, but is often used for such unethical actions that will make anyone with a soul cringe. In 2004, University of Colorado’s athletic department used alcohol, drugs, and sex to lure recruits during official campus visits (Gerdy). These actions are immoral on a number of levels, and should not be tolerated. If this type of behavior continues to be seen in college

The Triple Bottom Line: the People, the Planet, and the Profits

988 words - 4 pages People: Ethical Leadership Considerations and Recommendations One of the most overlooked components of the 3BL is the portion concerned with ethical decision-making and leadership within an organization. The ethics of a company are a direct reflection of the values and morals that are embodied in a company; a company cannot claim to be an employee-friendly organizations while its policies and procedures are designed to unfairly exploit the

Recruiting Performance Improvement

1942 words - 8 pages approval. All references to recruiting moving forward will be directly related to the recruitment of experienced professionals, not college graduates. Why the recruiting department?Recruiting Performance Improvement ProjectCurrently the process within the recruiting department is linear, as they seem to apply one line of thought throughout their efforts (Ackoff, 2006). The department is aligned with the functional areas within GMI, matching a

Recruiting Violations in College Sports

2290 words - 9 pages money to play sports a certain college. However, colleges do not have to just pick from what students they have in their school. They can recruit. Recruiting is trying to get an athlete to come play at a college, by endorsing that college as the right place for an athlete to play. It seems fair, the player ultimately gets to choose where he/she wants to play. However, the problem with this is that coaches and recruiters push the limits of fair

Early recruiting

798 words - 4 pages for young athletes. One reason early recruiting is a bad idea because it places too much pressure on these young athletes. At the ages of 13-15 is it right to make a choice of where you want to go to college? When you don't even know what you want to do for the future. Most people would say No to this. But it is still happening and continually getting worse. How can 13-15 year olds, know what they want to do. Yes play sports but to make it a

Systems Thinking

1854 words - 7 pages experience after graduating from college. This linear thinking leads to misconceptions on the actual recruiting and hiring time, which then causes frustration within the members of the functional areasAdditionally, the functional areas do not understand the impact of the "Rob Peter to pay Paul" mentality. The shuffling of internal people creates holes within teams across multiple plants or locations. Sometimes, only providing a quick fix to the

Analysis of a Research Project on Dementia Patients Being Cared for by Adult Daughters

802 words - 4 pages recruiting and sampling process included posting flyers out in the community and contacting health professionals in contact with women with dementia and/or their families. After recruiting a sample group, participants were selected based on the criteria including consent from both parties, the ability to speak English, at least 2 hours of care per week provided by the daughter, a score of 17 or higher on the Standardizes Mini-Mental Status Examination

Similar Essays

Ethical Considerations And A Code Of Conduct

1761 words - 8 pages As with every job, there has to be a set of rules or a code that employees need to follow. Journalism is no different. People all around the world; put their trust in journalist to bring them the news, in the most honest, non-biased, and enjoyable way. Given the importance of the job, it is easy to see why there must be a code of conduct and ethical considerations for the job. As news director at Cub Broadcasting, implementation; of code of

The Ethical Considerations Of Stem Cell Research

2063 words - 9 pages discovered that embryonic stem cells that were isolated with other types of cells would transform into that type. This led to the assumption that stem cells could be used to advance medicine because they could possibly treat injuries and diseases (AAAS, 2012). The conflict surrounding stem cell research is, with ethical consideration, whether it is a good or bad. The majority of Americans are advocates due to the possibilities of medical advancement

The Sociological Effects And Moral And Ethical Considerations Of Genetically Modified Foods

2326 words - 9 pages Genetically modified foods are an emerging technology in the biomedical field due to the result of organisms being produced from methods of genetic engineering and the technical, social, cultural, moral, and ethical issues presented by them. Problem is, nearly a billion people go hungry because they cannot grow or buy enough food. There is an estimated 2 billion people that suffer from lack of iron which causes tiredness to premature death

Concept Paper

2309 words - 10 pages such as college and veteran recruiting, content marketing on the website, and optimizing the site for mobile. Job seekers or passive applicants are surfing for jobs wherever they can – on their lunch break, at the bus stop, or at the coffee shop. Pepsi took making their job portal mobile seriously when a survey in 2012? came out that 82% of those looking for jobs did it on their smart phone. However, the survey also revealed HR professionals said