Ethical Dilemma For Mental Health Professionals

827 words - 3 pages

In a national survey exploring the significant ethical challenges and dilemmas faced by helping professionals, respondents ranked “blurred, dual or conflictual relationships” among the most difficult to navigate in their day to day practice (Barnett, Et Al., p. 401). Dual relationships, also commonly referred to as multiple or nonprofessional relationships, are defined in the American Psychological Association’s ethics code as “ones in which a practitioner is in a professional role with a person in addition to another role with the same individual, or with another person who is close to that individual” (Corey, Corey & Callahan, p. 268). While any relationship occurring simultaneous to the therapeutic one has the potential to be harmful, the only relationships extensively studied in this regard have been those of a sexual nature. Most agree that such sexual relationships are unethical, resulting in boundary violations that are both harmful and exploitative to the client. Both ethical and legal ramifications exist to address this issue including revocation of one’s license to practice and both criminal and civil sanctions.
However, continued debate regarding the benefit of nonsexual multiple relationships to the therapeutic process is ongoing. Historically, there was an outright ban on engaging in such relationships. Opponents argued that due to the inevitable power imbalance existing in the therapeutic process, exploitation and harm to the client would undoubtedly be the result. Professional boundaries were enforced to prevent compromise to the level of care received and crossing such boundaries was unanimously discouraged (Nickel, p.17).
However, in more recent years, there has been a shift in the ethical codes governing the mental health profession. The APA ethics code now states, ”multiple relationships that would not reasonably be expected to cause impairment or risk exploitation or harm are not unethical” (Barnett, Et Al, p. 403). Today, it is acknowledged that not all boundary crossings can be avoided or are even unethical and, in fact, some may even be beneficial to the therapeutic process. Today, the ban on multiple relationships has been downgraded to a cautioning against. However, the difficulty exists in determining which relationships are acceptable and which are not (Nickel, p. 403).
Because of the varied consensus regarding multiple relationships, there is no real direction available to instruct the professional in how to proceed if the opportunity presents itself (Nickel, p. 21). However, it...

Find Another Essay On Ethical Dilemma for Mental Health Professionals

Client and Counselor Safety for Mental Health Counselors

1012 words - 5 pages confidentiality and privacy when conducting one-on-one, group, or any type of counseling services. Like any medical patient, mental health clinicians need to treat their clients with dignity and respect. It is extremely important for the mental health counselor working with his or her assigned caseload to promote their clients’ right by providing a safe and private place to conduct counseling services. This is also where the counselor can begin a

A Vision for Change: The Recovery Model and Irish Mental Health Services

3506 words - 14 pages literature in this field that in order for recovery to develop, the voice of the service user will need to be at the centre of their own care. They will be the ‘expert’ of their own experiences - deciding on the form of the care and support they receive, whether it is psychological, medical, social or educational. The mental health professionals’ role will shift from the traditional one of being the ‘expert’, to one working alongside the service user

What is the Experience of Burnout Syndrome for Mental Health Nurses?

2073 words - 9 pages This research proposal is a literature review designed to answer the question “what is the experience of burnout syndrome for mental health nurses?” In order to answer this question, background information will be gathered by the way of the literature review and the essential points will be discussed under the appropriate headings. Under the heading the concept of burnout there is a discussion on workplace pressure and workplace stress which

Explaining the effectiveness of current treatments for mental health conditions using existing models and hypotheses

1359 words - 6 pages All treatments for mental health conditions are based on hypotheses that seek to explain their aetiology. These tend to be reductionist models approaching the problem from one dimension of the biopsychosocial paradigm. Unsurprisingly this approach is far from effective. Four models and therapies will be described and evidence that offers support or otherwise will be discussed. It will then be concluded that to improve therapy success rates a

The Mental Health History and Treatment Plan for an Agressive Child

1167 words - 5 pages IDENTIFICATION: Benjamin is a 9-year-old grade 4 student who currently lives at home with his parents and 2 younger siblings, Miya age 2-1/2 and Hanna age 7. He is currently being home schooled. He was recently admitted to the Child and Adolescent Inpatient Mental Health Unit at North York General Hospital on December 13th and discharged on December 17th. Please see Dr. Solomon’s comprehensive discharge summary, job ID 4337036 for a complete

Critically examine a health promotion activity that had been observed in a practice setting, which was intended for a patient that required mental health promotion

2396 words - 10 pages Health promotion is defined by Simnett (1995) to be "an umbrella term for a very wide range of activities which enhance good health and well-being and prevent ill-health, this include health education and health information, and preventative medical measures".In attempting to establish critical thoughts regarding defining mental health promotion it is first necessary to establish a shared understanding of what it is to be mentally healthy and to

How do you account for the prejudiced attitudes found in some localities towards people with mental health problems and how might such prejudice be countered (opposed/retaliated against)?

951 words - 4 pages involved, making things real with the situation hopefully being made a lot clearer to everyone involved. This sometimes takes a lot of confusion and worry away, allaying many fears and unanswered questions.Staff and mental health users should be advised that some people may upset them, being predujiced and discriminating. It could be painful for the users and support should be on hand if things get a little heated; compromise might sometimes have to

Discuss one change you would like to see in mental health services or practice. Describe what would need to happen for the change to be achieved a

1935 words - 8 pages strategies they use and responses towards others. Stephens (2008) agrees that from evidence to practice choices made in health promotion reflect the values of the practitioner. However all practitioners do have to use beneficence to ensure care is beneficial for the service user and non-maleficence to avoid causing harm (The Open University, 2008c, pp.14-25). Strategies that promote mental health and can reduce levels of depression either focus on

Psychiatric Advance Directives versus Recipient Rights

1146 words - 5 pages Introduction and Scenario Description When a patient enters the hospital, he or she expects the health care professionals to treat him or her with respect and fairness. The hospitals, clinics, and other healthcare settings should deserve and be reputed with a strong set of ethical principles and respect in the face of the law. To John, a 35 year old schizophrenic who is experiencing a crisis situation, his mental health depends greatly on his

Hypothetical Treatment of Ethical Dilemma

1969 words - 8 pages with clients for several years and currently serves as a counselor for an agency in Virginia. Her agency’s director requested that Callie provide him a weekly list of the individuals she counsels along with a comprehensive list of other professionals she consults regarding her clients. The director told Callie he needs this information to provide to the Community Service Board (CSB). This is the primary ethical dilemma in the hypothetical vignette

The Feminist Model to Solving Ethical Dilemmas

963 words - 4 pages for the maximum amount of people (Reamer, 1990). Thus when the two theories are combined the course of action chosen is one that is in the greatest good for the greatest amount of people however with the least amount of sacrifice to individuals rights. In the current ethical dilemma of client self-determination vs. mental health, the feminist model is the embodiment of these two ethical theories subsequently providing the most effective course of

Similar Essays

Ethical Dilemma For Location Approvals Essay

689 words - 3 pages Ethical Issues: Raul has difficulties obtaining the location approvals within the required time frame due to unforeseen circumstances. Raul’s boss, Ian, is responsible for making sure Raul gets the contracts approved in time, no matter what the cost is. Ian is displeased with how long the zoning approvals are taking to acquire. Pedro needs a 6000-peso bribe to complete the job and get the zoning permits on time. Raul is reluctant to pay the

Lack Of Mental Health Services For Children

1915 words - 8 pages the services available to children, then answer is not. There is a lack of mental health services available for children in the United States. I have a personal and professional interest in this topic. Personally, I have experienced the difficulty that parents face when trying to find mental health services for their children. When my son needed to be admitted to the hospital for mental health treatment, we couldn’t find one that had open beds

Mental Health Policies For Children Living In Poverty

2344 words - 10 pages , including mental health, special education, child welfare, juvenile justice, substance abuse, and health” (p.5). More so, this issue was raised, and access to services became an area of concern, both as an important problem facing children, adolescents, and families, and as important areas for professionals (Odar, et al. 2010). Therefore, this pushes an opportunity to put into place a comprehensive system of policies and practices that can

Mental Illness And Health Care For The Mentally Ill

1259 words - 5 pages organizations that follow the Mental Health Parity Act of 1996, allowing for medical health coverage for mental and physical illness (Mental, 2008). There are three governmental sources that help fund mental health care. As previously mention, governmental funding through private medical plans provides tow sources: health insurance companies and health maintenance organizations. However, agencies led by the World Health Organization (who