Ethical Dilemmas During A Pandemic Essay

1922 words - 8 pages

Florence Nightingale once said, “apprehension, uncertainty, waiting, expectation, fear of surprise, do a patient more harm than any exertion.” Nurses face ethical dilemmas daily while caring for patients and patients’ families, and while working in a multidisciplinary environment. Many ethical dilemmas faced by a nurse are often difficult to resolve, which often times, leads nurses to withhold care due to the conflicting values of self, of patients’ values, and employers values and expectations of its employees. It is of the essence that nurses recognize this dilemma and resolve it without delay to preclude compromise of patient’s care and wellbeing. But this is not always an easy fix as in the case study of nurse PT and her ethical dilemma during the H1N1 pandemic in Ontario (CNA, August 2008)
Ontarians had one thing on their minds back in April 2009....the influenza A virus subtype H1N1, or swine flu. On June 11, 2009, the World Health Organization (WHO) affirmed a global pandemic, with over 8000 confirmed cases in Ontario alone, and 95 confirmed deaths by November 26, 2009 (Wikipedia, 2011). A pandemic is an astonishing event that sometimes compels nurses to go above and beyond their duty to provide care to their ailing patients. With their duty to provide care, many nurses were faced with grappling ethical dilemmas, as in the case of nurse PT who was ambivalent between her need to work for financial means, her accountability to her patient and employer, and her uncertainties that she may become infected and will than transmit the disease to her children.
Nurse PT cared for many patients infected with the H1N1 virus, but most memorable was a four year old girl name CR. CR was brought to the ER by her parents in July 2009. CR was very sick and had a fever of 41.3C, vomiting, diarrhea, sore throat, headache, low blood pressure, pallor skin tone, and shortness of breath. CR was admitted and intervention was applied quickly, such as administering the antiviral medication called Tamiflu and had a complete blood count (CBC) done. When the blood test came back, it confirmed CR was infected with the H1N1 virus. CR continued her medication therapy and was isolated in her own room.
During the care of CR, nurse PT noticed CR’s mother also looking very sickly. She was coughing and had difficulty breathing. Nurse PT asked CR’s mother if is she is feeling ok? CR’s mother expressed to nurse PT that she has a cough, has muscle aches, and is having difficult time breathing. The mother also told nurse PT she has an autoimmune disease called Lupus, in which her body’s immune system attacks her body tissues. After assessing her vitals, nurse PT confirmed the mother indeed was sick and had the same symptoms as her daughter. The mother was admitted, was placed in isolation, had a CBC test done, which later confirmed the diagnosis of H1N1, and was given antiviral therapy. Within 24 hours, both mother and daughter’s health deteriorated drastically. The mother...

Find Another Essay On Ethical Dilemmas During a Pandemic

Ethics and Preparedness Planning for an Influenza Pandemic

1917 words - 8 pages , 2006, for instance). The diversity of concerned inquiry and discussion around ethic’s place in pandemic flu preparedness efforts is represented by discourses and recommendations from the around the world. There is also still a lot of ground to be covered before universally accepted and sanctioned principles are adopted regarding ethical treatment of everyone during an influenza pandemic. Some of the issues still being debated have been

Vaccination vs. Autism Essay

1296 words - 6 pages As Albietz was notifying how most vaccination cases do not lead to Autism, Calfee adds on to what Albietz have to say. In his ethical impact “Concerns About a Link Between Vaccines and Autism Are Unfounded” (2012), a resident scholar at the American Enterprise Institute until his death in2011, Calfee, John E. stresses externalism and historicism causes society to be strict from obligations, stress, and awareness by addressing vaccines, autisms

Flu Pandemic

1044 words - 5 pages or a virus with a hemagglutinin or a hemagglutinin and neuraminidase combination that has emerged from an animal population,” as seen with H5N1 virus. This change leaves people defenseless against this new virus. (CDC, 2013) Currently there is no vaccine to combat all strains therefore “Planning and preparedness for implementing mitigation strategies during a pandemic requires participation by all levels of government and all segments of

The Flu is an Imminent Pandemic

1207 words - 5 pages stockpiling and dependence on a single drug during a pandemic need to be addressed, underscoring our lack of preparation (Wilschut 146). Today, the world is still woefully ill-equipped to deal with an influenza pandemic. According to the WHO, “It is our priority to strengthen virological and disease surveillance, increase our knowledge on the health and economic burden of influenza, increase vaccine usage, and accelerate international pandemic

The 1918 Spanish Influenza Pandemic

1946 words - 8 pages in Hong Kong, China. Pandemic strains in 1957 and 1968 had HA genes close to avian flu strains, H8 and H9. (Reid 1999) There is no known way to prevent the disease. Some humans may have a natural immunity to the disease, while others may have a recently acquired immunity as a result of the H1N1 (Swine Flu) pandemic. During the 1918 pandemic scientists throughout the world searched for a vaccine and were unable to find one. A wide range of

The Ethical Teacher

1972 words - 8 pages administrators, the school board, the state or the federal government. While these dilemmas can materialize through grading policies or behavioral consequences, Campbell (2003) declares that educators “experience a range of ethical tensions and dilemmas as a result of administrative decisions and actions as well as school policies and overall practices,” wherein they must accept administrative orders that are unethical (p. 68). Moreover, because success

Cultural Values And Personal Ethics in Business

1455 words - 6 pages addition, the foundation of ethical dilemmas can often be traced to conflicting values. This paper will also briefly discuss how ethical dilemmas can be mitigated. A practical approach for understanding how ethical dilemmas occur, how dilemmas can be prevented, and how to make ethical decisions can best be done by studying how these values, particularly personal values, affect behavior and influence the decision-making. Personal and Cultural Values

Right to Decide

1193 words - 5 pages Everyday humans face ethical dilemmas; with each of these situations we must make moral choices. It is often difficult to confront ethical dilemmas and moral choices as they tend to unearth the rawest of our human emotions. This paper will discuss the ethical dilemmas brought on by the case of Jonathon, a 22-year-old male quadriplegic, diagnosed as a diabetic during childhood ("Quality of life case study - Session #1," n.d., para. 1). This case

The Potential for Avian Influenza to Cause Another Worldwide Pandemic

1690 words - 7 pages , especially in Hong Kong during both the pandemic of 1997 and the pandemic of 2003. It was the first strain to jump directly from birds to humans without an intermediate vector. It has a very high mutation rate, which implies that it rearranges its genes rapidly to create new hybrid viruses, increasing its? transmission efficiency. It is lethal, with a 100% mortality rate in the birds it affects and a 50% mortality rate for humans who are infected

Science of a Pandemic

3523 words - 15 pages way across a room. Some microbes can live outside for as long as 48 hours or more. They can hang out on whatever surface they hit. During that time, the bad bugs can infect anyone they contact. They can easily invade our bodies through our nose, eyes, mouth, and even our ears!2 Most of us have a healthy immune system. It works to protect us against flu viruses and other germs. But virologists, the scientists who study viruses, and

Primary Health Care

2165 words - 9 pages different in each situation (GlobalSecurity.org, 2011a), but community education about each individual's responsibilities during a pandemic will certainly help keep its reproduction rates at a minimum. Item #2. The director of nursing at the aged care facility will be responsible for updating the swine flu vaccination, antiviral drugs, and antibiotics supply. The order will be placed for the entire community, but the aged care facility needs

Similar Essays

Ethical Dilemmas : Examples During The Holocaust

1040 words - 5 pages themselves or another persons well being. Regardless of ones age during the Holocaust, so many were faced with unbelievable ethical dilemmas. Crisis situations and heavy consciences Times before the Holocaust wasn’t easy for the German people; World War I had left Germany in an economic depression. People at the time had been searching at all angles for a scapegoat. Adolf Hitler gave them one: The Jewish people. Gradually Hitler and his unforgettable

Vices And Virtues: Ethical Dilemmas Of A Fading Man

2387 words - 10 pages over 6 days with almost no food or water from Mariveles in the south of the Bataan Peninsula San Fernando in the north (History). Those who attempted to reach water or were too weak to keep up with the group were savagely murdered (History). Stewart arrived at Camp O’Donnell, a Japanese prison camp. In Sidney Stewart’s Give Us This Day, Stewart shared the ethical dilemmas that challenged him during his 3 years of captivity by the Japanese in

Solving Ethical Dilemmas: How Ford’s Leadership Achieve A Five Peat

1684 words - 7 pages Company: An interview with Bill Ford. McKinsey & Company. Retrieved June 15, 2014, from http://www.mckinsey.com/insights/sustainability/building_a_sustainable_ford_motor_company_an_interview_with_bill_ford Ciulla, J. B. (2011). Is business ethics getting better? A historical perspective. Business Ethics Quarterly, 21(2), 335-343. doi:10.5840/beq201121219 Cranston, N., Ehrich, L. C., & Kimber, M. (2006). Ethical dilemmas: The bread and butter of

What’s Written Versus Reality: Ethical Dilemmas In A Hi Tech Public Relations Firm

1451 words - 6 pages propaganda. Public Relations, Inc. (PRI) a disguised U.S medium-to-large PR consulting firm is a perfect example of an organization faced with ethical dilemmas (Weiss, 2006). Clearly, there are many ethical dilemmas facing PRI employees and although it seems easy for the reader to say she would do the right thing in all these situations, it would be hard. However, if the reader was actually in such a position and feeling pressured to act, she