Ethical Quandaries Essay

843 words - 3 pages

During the process of planning for catastrophic events there are many ethical quandaries that must be addressed by the planners but the common denominator in most of them is how to be fair and respectful to all while also providing the best protection for the most people. And just what exactly is fair and what about the situations that present conflicts between fair and safe?
There are several different typologies concerning how to be fair, respectful, and provide the best for the most. During the planning stage of preparing for response to a catastrophic event they may all come into play. The planners may not know or be able to articulate the underlying philosophies by name such as Teleological Ethics or Utilitarianism (right or wrongness based on positive or negative outcomes) or Deontological ethics (Duty-based) but they will be guided by their personal beliefs, morals and standards of what is right and wrong. In other words, they will be operating under what is considered to be applied ethics. Which can be defined as, “Ethics refers to standards of conduct, standards that indicate how one should behave based on moral duties and virtues, which themselves are derived from principles of right and wrong.” (Adams, 2011).
As the planning process is undertaken many questions will need to be answered specifically regarding how to response and they will have direct impacts on the people who have been affected by the catastrophe. Judgment calls made during times of duress and the chaotic circumstances encountered during a response cannot all be covered by careful ethical planning, of course. There will be times when a responder or official will have to rely on their personal ethics during the crisis but at least by having discussions and reaching agreements during the planning phase many of the really tough choices may be covered. The planning phase will lay a guiding foundation for specific response scenarios and hopefully relieve some of the more stressful decision making in the field and provide the responders the ability to just get the job done.
Deciding what is fair while deciding how to protect is probably the toughest question to answer when planning a catastrophic response. The question of value and worth are inevitable when discussing fair and those qualities are usually judgment based. And judgments are usually based on perspective or position. For example, the town has received notice that a dam up river has been breached and within 4 hours the town could be inundated and completed flooded. Priorities...

Find Another Essay On Ethical Quandaries

Comparing The Watsons Go to Birmingham-1963 and My Brother Sam Is Dead

726 words - 3 pages Comparing The Watsons Go to Birmingham-1963 and My Brother Sam Is Dead In the novels The Watsons Go to Birmingham-1963 by Christopher Paul Curtis and My Brother Sam Is Dead by James Lincoln Collier and Christopher Collier, two young boys are faced with the challenge of learning the moral and ethical codes that will shape their futures. Kenny Watson and Tim Meeker live in very different times, but they face events that complicate their

Why do Students Plagiarize? Essay

650 words - 3 pages simply too tempting to pass up.Every day, millions of students face similar ethical quandaries--and unfortunately, research indicates that most choose to plagiarize. In a nationwide poll, 80 percent of America's best students admitted to having cheated at least once; More than half said they did not believe cheating was a big deal--and 95 percent of the cheaters said, simply put, they have never been caught. In addition, a U.S. News poll found 90

Analysis of the Bioethical Issues in Gattaca

1039 words - 4 pages exemplify the ethical quandaries raised by these procedures. Worried critics point to the extreme application of eugenic ideas in Nazi Germany. Others are simply opposed to any “tampering” with nature by the inadequate hands of humankind. In the movie’s time period of “the not too distant future,” genetic engineering technology is far progressed from today’s capabilities. The predicted abilities to eliminate genetic propensity for disease and

Obedience to Authority

1132 words - 5 pages Reserved. 2007. Print 6(10) Cotkin, George. Morality’s Muddy Waters: Ethical Quandaries in Modern America. Dougherty, William Frederic. Testimony of SP 4 William F. Doherty, RA 11 620 737, Co B, 2d Bn, 41st Inf, Fort Hood, Texas, taken at Office of Inspector General, I11 Corps, Fort Hood, Texas, at to 1422 hours on 5 May 1969, by Colonel Wilson, I G Milgram, Stanley. “The Perils of Obedience

Moral Dilemmas Faced by Jewish Leaders

2408 words - 10 pages rampant in the midst of ghettos. Thievery, smuggling, bartering, illegal businesses; anything was possible within a ghetto. The Judenrat arose among these ethical quandaries and added to the madness. The discussion of the creation of Judenrat dates back to 1933; the Judenrats were Jewish led councils of elders and used by the Nazis to carry anti-semantic acts against the Jews (Grobman). In the beginning the Judenrat was created to induce a fear that

Engineering Ethics

3500 words - 14 pages actually encountered them. (Waters, 1998: 3-19)Yet, probing examination of the ethics of professions has frequently come about when educators in professional programmes and specialists in ethics have collaborated to address newly recognized ethical quandaries. The engineering profession is not alone in having welcomed or invited ethics specialists from philosophy and other disciplines to consult or take part in ethics initiatives in education and

Surrogate Mothers Must Not be Allowed to Profit

1588 words - 6 pages susceptible to exploitation by people - or an entire industry - purporting to have a solution for their problem. It is therefore important to question the ethics associated with reproductive technologies that try to provide "solutions" for infertile couples. While all of the treatments for infertility lead to ethical dilemmas, I will focus on the dilemma of surrogate pregnancy. Although surrogacy offers a possible solution to desperate infertile

The Giver, by Lois Lowry

1495 words - 6 pages “The Giver” a novel by Lois Lowry (1993), is an, engaging science fiction tale that provides the reader with examples of thought provoking ethical and moral quandaries. It is a novel geared to the young teenage reader but also kept me riveted. Assigning this novel as a class assignment would provide many opportunities for teachers and students to discuss values and morals. The Plot The main protagonist is a young boy named Jonas, living in a

Abraham Lincoln, the Only Honest Politician?

1358 words - 5 pages they make a working machine, as utilized by Lincoln. Though he had strong ethical beliefs about slavery, the constitution, immigration, and politics in general, he was willing to compromise in order to put resolution into action. Of course, Lincoln was shrewd enough to compromise on a superficial level; for example, he would play the political game in choosing his vice president and presidential cabinet, but he kept his colleagues weak enough to

Health Care Inequities for Aboriginal Women

1815 words - 7 pages health care professionals tend to “medicalise” these social quandaries (Browne & Smye, 2000). “Internal Colonialism” refers to ‘fourth world’ conditions in which a minority indigenous population is encapsulated within a nation state wherein powers and privileges are held by a colonising majority that consciously and unconsciously subordinate the original inhabitants of the land” ( O’Neil, 1986, 1989 as cited in Browne & Smye, 2002). Throughout the

Unintended Consequences - Israel from Palestine

1764 words - 7 pages ] Israel” (296). Not only had the rivalry between the capitalist and communist strongholds sparked such political movement, but the partition and statehood were by no means inspired by the Holocaust or its ethical quandaries. Israel became possible once Great Britain was simply too tired to continue ruling their Mandate and the United States and Soviet Union became sponsors from the world’s next superpowers (Immell 104). In fact, it’s doubtful

Similar Essays

The Ideas Of Virtue Ethics Essay

1631 words - 7 pages The Ideas of Virtue Ethics In an attempt to revive the ideas of virtue ethics, many philosophers have expressed their criticisms of so-called "modern ethical theories." Some examples are as follows. Pincoffs presents his idea that modern ethical theory (MET) reduces ethics to resolution of quandaries. Williams explains his idea that MET focuses on only a particular, peculiar variety of ethical thought called "morality." Stocker claims that

Controversial Activity About Short Selling Been Ethical

2074 words - 8 pages firms (Tan & Tan, 2013). These licenses should only be issued to NRFs with exceptional code of ethics and continued education on the ethical quandaries that their employees regularly encounter. This is also to align to the view that Caccese (1997) has about education improving ethical standards.  Bibliography Alexander, K. (2013). Market Structures and Market Abuse. In G. Caprio, Handbook of Safeguarding Global Financial Stability (pp

Can Morality Exist In Healthcare Management?

3749 words - 15 pages -benefit analysis to determine what course of action to take, it is virtually impossible to utilize this process in a situation where you cannot ethically place a dollar amount on people's feelings and emotions.Despite previous thought, Hospital Administrators are on the forefront of a multitude of ethical quandaries. While medical management faces all of the above issues, and many more, one of the largest ethical issues that Hospital Administrators

Human Cloning Isn't As Scary As It Sounds

1218 words - 5 pages they might accomplish, and what sortof ethical quandaries they might engender. Consider the hypotheticalexample of the couple who wants to replace a child who has died. Thecouple doesn't seek to have another child the ordinary way because they feelthat cloning would enable them to reproduce, as it were, the lost child. Butthe unavoidable truth is that they would be producing an entirely differentperson, a delayed identical twin of that child