Ethical Scenarios In The World Of Intelligence

1793 words - 7 pages

Right or wrong, this question can be applied to almost every decision made throughout your day. For most decisions made in a day the answer to this question is usually simple, but from time to time we run into crossroads were which path to take is not clear. This may be a little decision like choosing to give money back when you have been overpaid all the way to large decisions such as whether abortion, when the mother is not at risk, is right or wrong. In the profession of intelligence these ethical decision may present themselves in a number of ways. In the paper we are going to discuss two fictional case studies that were presented in the book Fair Play by James Olson, the former director of Counter Intelligence for the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA). Both scenarios will present plausible ethical dilemmas that may be encountered in modern day espionage.
Scenario1, Trojan Horse: The Chinese foreign intelligence service, the Ministry for State Security (MSS), has as one of its primary operational objectives to steal defense- related technology from the United States. The Cox Report, released in 1999, documented for the first time the extent of such technology theft by MSS and analyzed the implications for U.S. national security. The MSS uses variety of illegal mechanisms and cutouts (clandestine intermediaries) to acquire embargoed U.S. technology. The CIA learns from a sensitive intelligence source that the MSS is using a French aerospace company as a front for illegal acquisitions. The French company purchases the items from a trading company in Long Beach, California, and then secretly transfers them to the Chinese. The same CIA source indicates that the MSS has just tasked its French cutout to acquire on its behalf an extremely sensitive U.S.-manufactured radar tracking system. The heart of the radar tracking system is a U.S. high-performance computer. This system has several different military applications and, as a result, cannot be legally sold to China. It also has a variety of legitimate uses in civilian aviation. The CIA, using sensitive intelligence assets, has the capability of inserting a “doctored” or sabotaged computer into the illegal MSS technology acquisition channel-through Long Beach, to France, and then to China. The sabotaged computer can be programmed so that the radar tracking system will fail at a critical moment of high usage. The false information could cause an accident for the military users, or, if the system is assigned by China to one of its major airports, could result in a civilian aircraft disaster. The CIA has no way of knowing the identity of the ultimate end user of the sabotaged computer. (Olson, 2006, pp. 49-50)
The “Trojan Horse” scenario above is an obvious moral dilemma. The CIA is charged with a national security mission within the United States (US) government. They have the obligation to protect the American...

Find Another Essay On Ethical Scenarios In The World of Intelligence

The Burden of Intelligence Essay

2433 words - 10 pages Everyone on Earth is dealt different hands. Some have been gifted with wealth; others are born into a world of very little. Lucky children have been welcomed into a loving family; others are merely one of several children, of whom only half will reach adulthood. Finally, a few are destined to be brilliant, while the rest are not as clever. When it comes to education and levels of intelligence, however, who really has been gifted? “Intelligence

My Future in The Intelligence Community of the U.S. Navy

1703 words - 7 pages examination, and medical fitness. (2011). On the other hand, the outcomes of the trends and issues in the nation have also made an impact on people. Nowadays, background checks on an individual became an important part of a job selection process. Social and Ethical Implications: There are also social and ethical implications that greatly affected the intelligence community. Due to all the advanced technologies being used to ensure the

The Function of Analysis in the Government Intelligence Department

1167 words - 5 pages can become too focused, it loses sense of greater world. Intelligence is meant to engage with contemporary society and remain the leading source of truthful information. During the 9/11 Commission it stated that if intelligence is to continue to focus solely on one issue it will permit uncertainty and ambiguity (Gibson 2005). Even though intelligence has come full circle in recent years it cannot and will not win wars on its own, it will

The Role of Connecting Unrelated Events in Developing Intelligence

2391 words - 10 pages continue the practice of drawing from other disciplines in their quest to develop artificial intelligence. Early Connections: The Role of Experience Leonardo da Vinci said: "all our knowledge finds its origins in our perceptions" (Willis, p. 47). Just like falling off a bike, experiences form one's perception of how the world functions into a term called folk physics (Bechtel, p. 72). These workings can then be applied to new problems. Tackling

Cultural Intelligence in the Workspace

1800 words - 8 pages ) states that cultural intelligence and Emotional intelligence works hand in hand. The New Oxford American Dictionary (2010) defines emotional intelligence (EQ) as the capacity to be aware of, control, and express one's emotions, and to handle interpersonal relationships judiciously and empathetically. EQ coupled with an individual’s high CQ can allow the individual to be aware of the needs and emotions of people that they come in contact with. They are

Artificial Intelligence in the Arts

2224 words - 9 pages Throughout the semester, we have intensively studied how computer science relates to the world around us, through video games, database systems, and artificial intelligence. But what we have not discussed is how all of these subjects in computer science, like pep8, pseudo code, gates and circuits, relate to our artistic world; dance, music, and live theatre. Listening to a piece of music, or as an audience member watching a dance or theatre

Current Ethical Issue in Business-World Bank

2158 words - 9 pages . The sad reality is, while the deliberation is mainly focused on the ethical issue of Wolfowitz's girlfriend, the game of chess being played between the World Bank and politics raises ethical issues of its own. Wolfowitz's mistake is quickly becoming a small pond in the bigger game towards the reform and restructure that many feel the World Bank desperately needs.Ethical ChangeAnyone receiving a raise or promotion typically follows a standard

The True Meaning of Intelligence

951 words - 4 pages by exceptional achievements” (APA Dictionary of Psychology: Genius), therefore genius is unable to be used as a proper tool in defining intelligence. As a result of genius being a word of those who possess great intelligence and accomplish notable intellectual achievements, people often confuse the definition of genius with the definition of intelligence. Although genius is a high level of intelligence, genius is not a definition of

The Politicization of Intelligence History

3234 words - 13 pages claims that the analysis and reporting of intelligence have been influenced by political considerations. The process and pressures by which political influence effected the Iraq Weapons of Mass Destruction (WMD) estimates, the Soviet Union military capabilities and the Vietnam military predictions will be discussed, in order to emphasis the safeguards needed to successfully manage the relationship between intelligence providers and consumers

The Controversy of Artificial Intelligence

1495 words - 6 pages Throughout its history, artificial intelligence has always been a topic with much controversy. Should human intelligence be mimicked? If so, are there ethical bounds on what computers should be programmed to do? These are a couple of question that surround the artificial intelligence controversy. This paper will discuss the pros and cons of artificial intelligence so that you will be able to make an educated decision on the issue.What is

The Rise of Artificial Intelligence

2952 words - 12 pages after World War Two, when a number of people independently started to work on intelligent machines. Alan Turing, an English mathematician, invented the "Turing Test" at this time, a test that discussed conditions for considering whether a machine was intelligent; this test is still used by scientists today (M. Bowles, 2010). There have been many milestones in the quest to manufacture intelligence, such as the Deep Blue chess program defeating the

Similar Essays

The Role Of Emotional Intelligence In Negotiation

2297 words - 9 pages be positive. When the parties must reach an agreement or a compromise, one of the best communication strategies is negotiation. The purpose of this research is to determine how emotional intelligence affects negotiation. Mayer and Salovey, in their early research on emotional intelligence in 1993, identified it as “a type of social intelligence that involves the ability to monitor one’s own and others’ emotions, to discriminate among them

The Challenges Of Intelligence Essay

588 words - 2 pages Intelligence! Every day we hear statements like "You are not intelligent enough" or "Intelligent people do not do such things". But what actually is intelligence? Haven't we lost the meaning of this word on the road of every day usage? These and many more questions could be answered very simply by saying that intelligence is knowledge. However, as we know nothing in our world is simple. So it is normal to assume that intelligence is also a

The Theory Of Intelligence Essay

777 words - 3 pages , known as g. The proponents of the other school of thought include Gardner, Sternberg, and Thurstone. These psychologists think that there is more than one general type of intelligence, or in other words, that there are multiple types of intelligences. The most convincing evidence for a single general intelligence model is the fact that there is proof of a single general factor that governs the level of intelligence of an individual. This is also

The Concept Of Intelligence Essay

3430 words - 14 pages from the function of the adverb ‘intelligently,’ the concept of intelligence does not have essential reference to specific verbs but rather to the manner or style of proceeding of nearly any verb that is descriptive of the proceedings of an agent. Intelligence- words are expressive of a manner of doing things that may be narrated in one of two ways. The first takes the form of a series of contrasts which, when put together as a list of disjuncts