Ethics And The Commercialization Of Organ Transplants

1084 words - 4 pages

Commercialization of organ transplants has remained a highly debated issue and has been being considered unethical mostly. Mostly points have been raised by scholars and researchers against it. People have generally opposed the idea of sales of human organs like spare parts. However, it is also essential to check the other side of the same issue. The availability of organs required for transplantation has generally remained low and many deaths have also been caused due to unavailability of organs at the time they are needed. There are two aspects of this debate. The first aspect is that if people have the right to sell their own body parts. The second aspect is will not it give rise to illegal sales of organs since every second we know in various parts of the world people are waiting for organ transplants. Keeping these points in view it gets difficult to reach a conclusion if commercialization of organ transplant can be considered ethical.
Seeing the wide gap that exists between the availability and the need of organs for transplant, it really seems essential to facilitate sales of organs to meet the demand and to save lives. Consented organ donations till now in our society have remained limited and not all people agree to it. Seeing the demand for cadaveric organs for transplantation, it does not appear possible that the current voluntary opt in system will be able to match the demand. The number of potential donors is high. But despite that only 15% of organs from potential donors are being transplanted. There are both psychological and cultural reasons behind it. (Dougherty, 1986) People generally are unable to decide whether they should donate their organs after death or rather their bodies should be buried without any surgery. In such a case there are very few people who would willingly consent when they are alive to donate their organs after death. Then it comes to the next of the kin. However, in times of death especially if death has happened under tragic circumstances, it becomes difficult to ask the next of kin to donate their loved one’s organs voluntarily.
Still, we very well know that the demand for organs for transplant has kept rising and we need to find a way so that there are enough donations to match the demand. There can be two ways in such a scenario. The first is that the people are offered financial incentives for donating their organs after death and the second is that the state be granted this authority. However, both of these have given rise to discussions related to ethical acceptance. Commercialization of organs would also most likely lead to quality related problems as well as provide some people the incentives to shorten lives for money. (Dougherty, 1986) All the ethical debate has mostly surrounded the issue that if commercialization of organs would not lead to illegal obtaining of organs through illegal means for sale to the persons in need. This can definitely not be encouraged.
The other way is to grant...

Find Another Essay On Ethics and the Commercialization of Organ Transplants

The Commercialization of Christmas Essay

715 words - 3 pages The Commercialization of Christmas Over the years, one topic which has sparked an interesting debate among intellectuals, business men and Christians is whether or not Christmas has enrolled into an over commercialized holiday. The period at the climax of the year, December 25th, which we celebrate as Christmas is the time when consumers increase their spending to an outrageous level and business persons become elated

The Commercialization of Christmas Essay

693 words - 3 pages The Commercialization of Christmas In my opinion I think Christmas is fine the way it is, although Christmas is the festival in which Christians celebrate the birth of Jesus. The word `Christmas' means the `Mass of Christ' and refers to the Mass which is celebrated on Christmas Day which the majority of people forget. Many in today's society consider that Christmas has become too commercialised and that the real meaning

The Commercialization of Sex

1315 words - 5 pages George Orwell, author of “1984,” portrays a dystopian nation concentrated on despair to warn his readers of Communist governments. Michael Radford, director and screen writer, film adaptation of the fiction story successfully captures the cinematography Orwell portrayed to the reader throughout the three sections of his novel. The industry influence commercialized minuscule topics like sexual affairs to increase the number of viewers and

The Process of Organ and Blood Donation

2624 words - 10 pages organs and/or blood transplants. (Unknown) Each year, thousands of people die because of the need for an organ transplant or blood donation. (Unknown) Contrary to popular belief, you don’t have to be dead to be a donor! You can be a living donor! To be a living donor you must be over the age of twenty one, complete an education class called “Donor 101”, and have a Body Mass Index also referred to as “BMI” that is less than thirty. You must

Commercialization of Photochromic Dyes and Products

1714 words - 7 pages Commercialization of Photochromic Dyes and Products Background While most people, including this author, hold quite optimistic views of the photochromic industry, very little commercial success has been realized. In Professor Giacomo Ciamician’s famous paper on photochemistry of the future, he predicted that photochromic clothing would be popular. It turns out that he was right. His paper was written in 1912 and photochromic clothing was

Consuming Kids: The Commercialization of Childhood

1725 words - 7 pages , Consuming Kids , written by Adriana Barbaro and directed by Jeremy Earp, highlights children as this powerful demographic, with billions of dollars in buying power, but the lack of understanding of marketers’ aggressive strategies. Children are easily influenced and taken advantage of, which is why commercialization of children needs to stop. Commercialization to children leads to problems that parents do not even know are happening such as social

The Commercialization of Drugs in Malasya

2372 words - 9 pages Drugs Act, 1952). Drug misuse is considered a demoralizing factor in nation-building thus anti-drug law is regulated with an aim to create a society free of drugs, in terms of both supply and demand, thus enabling a morally-conscious and functioning nation. Nevertheless, the numbers of drug addicts and drug traffickers are still worrying. There is a total of 10,500 drug traffickers detained between 2006-2011, and there is a reported total of 7,864

How to Approach the Escalating Utilization and Commercialization of Nanoscale Materials

1204 words - 5 pages field. These concerns are important in determining how to approach the escalating utilization and commercialization of nanoscale materials, and are the reason why regulations for materials specifically on the nanoscale are needed to keep people and the environment safe. The debate of whether or not nanomaterials can be considered a new substance is one that is not clear with the current standards. The chemistry of a nanoparticle is similar or

The Pros and Cons of Xenotransplantation: Organ Donations

1367 words - 5 pages Xenotransplantation The topic I would like to talk about today is called xenotransplantation. If you haven’t ever heard about xenotransplantation that’s okay, a lot of people haven’t. As you know many of the people who need organ donations need them because of new and old health issues. The worldwide demand for organs far surpasses the supply. A study done by the United Network for Organ Sharing in 2004 found that over one hundred thousand

The Importance of Organ Donation

1721 words - 7 pages The Importance of Organ Donation      Each day approximately 6,300 people die and what makes this haunting is that presently there are 83,513 people waiting for organs to be donated, yet each day 17 people die because they do not receive a transplant ( These statistics show that people who are waiting for organ transplants have a good chance at being saved and get what they need. The sad truth is

The Importance of Promoting Organ Donations

1211 words - 5 pages therefore, finding a donor becomes difficult because in order to receive a transplant the recipient must be compatible with his or her donor in several ways. In order to have a successful transplant the donor must have the same blood type, tissue type, the right size of organ, and be close in age with the recipient (Finn, 1992). Compatibility is very important when it comes to organ transplants because, if the donor and the recipient are not well

Similar Essays

Commercialization Of Organ Transplant Essay

1132 words - 5 pages any needy person. Lately donation of organs specially to help needy people has increased. Often these donations happen at the time of death. Analysis of commercialization of organ transplant shows that lots of people are involved in the process of buying and selling human organs. So the important question is that how effective is commercialization of transplants? Some people are in the favor of commercialization of transplants and some people

A Comparison Of Medical Transplants And Organ Donation In Canada And China

1410 words - 6 pages , Canada transplanted heart valves first time in the world. In 1963, Canadian doctors performed first successful kidney transplant. This transplant was in between two identical twins. In 1980s Canadian doctors performed many successful organ transplant operation such as lung and combined liver bowel transplants. During the last few decades, lots of successful organ transplant operations have been performed in Canada. Conclusion Medical

The Equtiy And Efficientcy Of Kidney Transplants

2606 words - 11 pages after transplant. With organs being limited and with so many factors that cause a negative outcomes with kidney transplants; should there be limits to whom transplants should be given to or should every patient have a chance without regarding of age or outcome? The Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network allocates organs and takes longevity into appreciation, but the Age Discrimination Act states that no one should be denied the chance of

The Commercialization Of Education Essay

858 words - 3 pages Commercialization is the process of involving an activity in commerce. Commercialization is the process that is involved in making a product commercially successful. The process involves the production, dissemination, sales, marketing and support necessary to commercialize the product or activity. Commercialization apples to various sectors and these include the education, agriculture and the sport industries. Commercialization of education