This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Ethics Case Study

1458 words - 6 pages

There are two main ethical issues that have been identified within this scenario. The first is that the acceptance of McJack’s sponsorship conflict with the schools recent efforts and policies to encourage healthy eating habits and lifestyles. Furthermore, if the school accepts the sponsorship offered in conjunction with the stipulated conditions it would ultimately be endorsing discrimination against Molly based on her appearance.

The focus ethical frameworks that have been use to provide my final recommendations for this scenario are Consequentialism, Non-Consequentialism, Virtue Ethics and Care Ethics.
Consequentialism is an action-based decision making framework which determines whether an act is right or wrong based on the consequences that occur from them. Decisions are considered to be effective when the negative consequences are eliminated or minimised (Baron, Pettit & Slote, 1997; Burgh, 2006). Egoism, Altruism and Utilitarianism are some of the subcategories of Consequentialism.
Egoism states that people should consider their own interests first and foremost (Baron, et al.,1997). Looking from an Egoistic perspective I ought to have cancelled any further association with the fast food chain. I would benefit most from this because I would not have the Principal’s disapproval by endorsing a sponsor which contradicts the school’s healthy living ideals and I would not have to explain why Molly was deemed unsuitable by McJack’s for promotional shots to her and her parents. Alternately, the Altruism perspective does not take into account personal needs and seeks to maximize good consequences for everyone else. Looking through the Altruistic lens I also ought to refuse the sponsorship deal as I would be considering the health and well being of all my students and their families by refusing to sending out mixed messages about fast food. I would, however, be trying to obtain a more suitable sponsorship to ensure my students had the best resources possible. Utilitarian perspective can be described as “the greatest good for the greatest number of people (Burgh, 2006). What I ought to do from a Utilitarian perspective is very similar to the Altruistic perspective however this time I will also be incorporating my happiness into the equation.
The possibilities of adopting the Consequentialism perspective may include that Molly would not be discriminated against and the students would still benefit from alternative fundraising and sponsorship efforts. The schools would stay true to its healthy living policies and my professionalism with the principal will be upheld.
Non–Consequentialism is also an action-based perspective although it focuses on the rule at hand rather than the consequence. Immanuel Kant contended that this perspective refers to acts as simply being right or wrong- irrespective of consequences (Lafave, 2006). The four sub-categories associated with Non-Consequentialism include: Natural Rights, Social Contract, Deontology...

Find Another Essay On Ethics Case Study

Ethics In Workplace Case Study

2630 words - 11 pages and newspaper interviews, which allowed the company to remain a trusted corporation in the public's eyes. This helped keep the door open for the corporation to heal once this incident had been corrected.Ethical Issues InvolvedThere are two main ethical issues involved with the Johnson and Johnson case study. The first ethical issue was responsibility. Johnson and Johnson accepted responsibility for the Tylenol poisonings and took the blame for

A Case Study Depicting the Importance of Ethics in Medicine

4553 words - 18 pages inform the modern code of ethics (Preston, 2009). Furthermore, these principles may not be enough in undertaking moral reasoning. Therefore professionals may have to employ some of the ethical theories which include theory of justice, teleology and deontology in deciding the best possible action for Marge in the case study. Marge has been diagnosed with bipolar affective disorder, and the multidisciplinary team (MDT) were faced with the dilemma

Ethics and the Environment Case Study: Fueling the World

2191 words - 9 pages "Humanity's way of life is on a collusion course with geology, with the stark fact that the earth holds a finite supply of oil" (Appenzeller, 2004, p. 88). The United States is one of the largest consumers of fossil fuels. This paper presents Learning Team A's fossil fuel case study analysis. The selected case study is, Fueling the World: What are the Alternatives? (Newton, Dillingham, and Choly, 2006, p. 157).This case summary details the

Ethics and the Environment Case Study: Fueling the World

2393 words - 10 pages Ethics and the Environment Case Study: Fueling the WorldWe are a global society of energy junkies. Our utility grid runs at maximum capacity resulting in rolling blackouts, our consumption of fossil fuels creates greenhouse gases that result in global warming. Even with this knowledge our demand for energy continues to increase. Where are we going to get our "energy fix" when the world's oil fields dry out, and our government's energy

Nursing Ethics Case Study

1148 words - 5 pages ). Ethical Dilemmas in Nursing. Journal of Medical Ethics. Retrieved on 12th July 2010 from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1375348/pdf/jmedeth00258-0013.pdf Fry T. Sara Veatch and M. Robert (2006 ). Case Studies in Nursing Ethics Jones and Barlett Learning Timby, Kuhn Barbra (2008). Fundamental Nursing Skills and Concepts. Lippincott Williams and Wilkins

Business Ethics Case Study

1341 words - 5 pages certified with a signature required. I would also keep a detailed journal at home, of which employee was involved and what was said. With the latest spy technology, I would have eyeglasses with a tiny camera attached to the frame. By doing this, no participant in this fraud case can imply the “he said, she said” syndrome. Having them on video knowingly committing fraud that could result in causalities will be difficult to explain in Federal Court

Nike Ethics case study

1870 words - 7 pages codes of conduct to discipline management. So workers must turn to the courts for help which is a long fought battle that no one wants to attempt. In one case that made it to, a Vietnamese court recently found a Korean supervisor guilty of beating workers and extradition may be sought for the accused sexual molester who fled. In Indonesia 24 discharged Nike workers are challenging the legality of their dismissal before the country's Supreme Court

Ethics Case Study - Accepting Meals and Contributions in the Healthcare Industry

1188 words - 5 pages Ethics Case Study I:Accepting Meals and Gifts at Sales Meetings1. Ethics Question: Given John Henry's uncertainty of the ethical acceptance of receiving meals and gifts, is it ethically justifiable for him to evaluate the nature of these gifts, their effects on the organization (past and present), and to report his findings to upper management?2. Ethical Decision Makers:At the onset, it would appear that there are two ethical decision makers

Space Shuttle Ethics Case Study

1098 words - 4 pages -ethics Engineering Ethics. (n.d.). Texas A&M University. Retrieved January 17, 2014, from http://ethics.tamu.edu/Portals/3/Case%20Studies/Shuttle.pdf Neuner, K., & Rider, J. (n.d.). The Challenger Disaster. Northern Kentucky University. Retrieved January 17, 2014, from http://studenthome.nku.edu/~riderj/challenger%20report.pdf The Space Shuttle Challenger Disaster. (n.d.). Seton Hall University. Retrieved January 18, 2014, from http://pirate.shu.edu/~mckenndo/pdfs/The%20Space%20Shuttle%20Challenger%20Disaster.pdf

Tobacco Ads in India: Ethics Case Study

1190 words - 5 pages Tobacco is used around the world, and its negative health effects are also public knowledge. Since everyone knows that tobacco can seriously harm people who use it, many countries face the ethical dilemma of allowing this harmful substance to be sold, regulated, and smoked. The case study “Ban on Tobacco Ads by the Government of India” addresses some of the effects of an advertising ban on tobacco in India, as well as the conflict of interest

China-Ethics and The Environment Case Study

1506 words - 6 pages Are We Problem PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 1 China-Ethics and The Environment Case StudyAbstractAre We The Problem?"First of all, it is obvious when we examine the world's population problem that there are just too many Chinese" (Text, Year, p. 141). "At its founding in 1949 the People's Repulic of China had a population of 540 million" (IIASA, 2008, p.1). "Only three decades later its population was more than 800 million (IIASA, p. 1). "The U.S

Similar Essays

Ethics Case Study

1178 words - 5 pages What are Ethics? Ethics are standards of behavior, developed as a result of ones concept of right and wrong (Judson & Harrison, 2010). Code of ethics is a list of principles that is intended to influence the actions of healthcare professionals within an organization. Ethical principles help guide the decision-making process among healthcare workers in complicated situations. This paper will review the assigned case study and provide the

Ethics Case Study

1018 words - 5 pages This issues study is aimed to explain the importance of ethical business practices which also include social responsibilities and will be compared to an example of an unethical business practice. It will explore the different unethical issues in business, the benefits of running an ethical business and this will be done with reference to a certain case study. Ethics are moral guidelines which govern good behavior. For a business to behave

Counseling Ethics Case Study

896 words - 4 pages In the case study of Gwen, there is one major problem presented. That problem is whether it is ethical for a supervisor to counsel his supervisee. I think that Gwen is going through the grieving process after learning about her mother’s condition and is in a vulnerable spot. She feels like she cannot continue her work with hospice patients because of personal feelings. Ken thinks that Gwen is a great therapist and does not want to see her give

Ethics And Negotiation Case Study

2376 words - 10 pages Case Study: BP Texas RefineryIntroductionAccording to Lewicki, Saunders & Minton (2003), adopting an unethical approach to negotiation in business can have serious consequences. A recent explosion at the British Petroleum (BP) Texas refinery on 24 March, 2005 reiterated this and demonstrated the effect of an unethical approach to negotiation with the death of 15 contract workers.Ethical behaviour refers to the standards of conduct such as