Ethics Reflection Jacinta Simon And Bob Corporate Law Assignment

1691 words - 7 pages

The fact scenario expounds an unenviable situation in which Jacinta, through no material transgression of her own, having been inadvertently informed of the unethical dealings and fraudulent conduct of Purple Coffee Supplies Ltd, is compelled to make an intractable decision, on which the fate of the entire company may ride. As the CEO of one of Australia’s leading superannuation funds, Bob’s meeting with Purple’s Board members and senior management is critical. Jacinta’s decision as to whether she will disclose Purple’s unethical behaviour will undoubtedly dictate the future of its commercial relationship with Bloggs Superannuation, market reputation and prospective profitability.
As General Counsel and Company Secretary, Jacinta acts as both Purple’s Chief Administrative Officer[footnoteRef:1] and In-house Counsel. Her principal responsibilities are largely imbricated[footnoteRef:2] and lie in ensuring Purple’s compliance with corporate legislation and the continued development of concordant relations with approved market operators (AMOs), such as the ASX and regulatory authorities, like ASIC. These regulators and market operators look to promote investor confidence (in maintaining market integrity) by imposing various transparency and disclosure obligations.[footnoteRef:3] Having been unwittingly copied in on an inculpating email from Simon to senior management, Jacinta now possesses substantive knowledge of Purple’s unethical import practices. Jacinta has three possible courses of action which need to be considered in light of their ethical, commercial and practical ramifications. In order to come to a judicious conclusion, the opposing views of Simon and Bob, as key stakeholders, will also be taken into account. [1: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 9.] [2: Sarah Duggin, ‘The Pivotal Role of the General Counsel in Promoting Corporate Integrity and Professional Responsibility’ (2007) 51 Saint Louis University Law Journal 989, 1001; Jason Harris, Company Law: Theories, Principles and Applications (LexisNexis Butterworths, 2nd ed, 2015) 398-402.] [3: Harris, above n 2, 716-31; Keith Kendal and Gordon Walker, ‘Insider Trading in Australia’ in Stephen Bainbridge (ed), Research Handbook on Insider Trading (Edward Elgar, 2013) 365, 368.]

1. Jacinta remains silent.
Jacinta’s knowledge of the transactions opens her up to possible accessorial[footnoteRef:4] and even direct[footnoteRef:5] liability for the dealings of her firm. Such dealings result in an artificial inflation of profit margins and unethically contravenes statutory disclosure requirements, whilst corrupting, otherwise legitimate valuations of their holdings, beguiling both existent and prospective investors. If Jacinta were to stay silent, should ASIC discover Purple’s unscrupulous dealings, all parties involved, including Jacinta, will be jointly and severally liable. As with most ethical and commercial dilemmas, Jacinta’s decision is not without substantial pressures from...

Find Another Essay On Ethics Reflection - Jacinta Simon and Bob - Corporate Law - Assignment

Ethics and Corporate Social Responsibility Essay

1603 words - 6 pages Introduction/SummaryOften times, many business decisions are not always black and white and there are ethical dilemmas that leaders sometimes face. "Leadership must know how the myriad human behaviors and interactions fit together like puzzle pieces to create a whole picture" (Kehoe, pg. 201). Ethics is the study of honest behaviors and decisions, examining what should be done in relation with Corporate Social responsibility (CSR). Corporate

Law And Ethics Essay

985 words - 4 pages [The role of an engineer] Introduction… In this project, I would like to explain our society and community wants that an engineer should follow the rule and Law in strict way. There are two key points as like, negligence and respect. Two example cases show how the disaster and nasty accident happen without any control in the negligent and respectful ways. For more detail story, there are two articles describing the role of engineers. The one

Ethics and Communication Reflection Paper

1554 words - 6 pages education which was not completely addressed. Therefore in this paper I will be discussing the impact a nurse may have had on the case study, areas of shortage where I felt a nurse would have addressed the issue better, ethical positions that were dominantly discussed in the discussion and ways in which this case study contributed to the role of a nurse in areas of advocacy.   Ethics Communication Reflection Paper Nurse as an Advocate The Case

Corporate tax avoidance and Benford's Law

3255 words - 14 pages that a reduction in the operating loss in the regression sample period is an indication that the firm has used some of the deductions during the regression sample period to avoid corporate taxes. They expect a positive coefficient and also confirm this expectation in their results. Dyreng et al. (2008) and Chen et al. (2010) find that the change in tax loss carry forward has a positive effect on the cash effective tax rate. Thus, I expect a

Business Ethics and Corporate Social Responsibility

581 words - 2 pages .htmlDynacare Laboratories. Retrieved August 8, 2008 from Environmental Management Initiative and Business for Social Responsibility.(2006). GEMI-BSR Survey: Sustainable Business & Strategy: Views From theInside, ExecutiveMedical Diagnostic Laboratories, LL> Retrieved February 29, 2008 from, D. (2008) 100 Best corporate citizens 2008. Retrieved August 8, 2008 from, J. W. (2006). Business ethics: A stakeholder and issues management approach(4th ed.). Canada: Thomson South-Western.

Business Ethics And Contemporary Corporate Thought

1692 words - 7 pages , many accused of obstruction of justice and criminalwrongdoings; this all as the company is desperately trying to avoid bankruptcy. Thiscase has promoted widespread calls for more government intervention in business ethicsand a call for more corporate reform laws.Furthermore, the Internet services company Genuity, is also toying withbankruptcy, as Verizon Inc., citing "[poor] market condition and strategic needs," (Art. 7)backed out of a deal to

Business Ethics and Value Systems- Ethics in Corporate America

2625 words - 11 pages Ethics in Corporate AmericaBusiness Ethics and Value SystemsWinter 2002What turns a "fired up" professional into a "burned out" employee? If you ask a young engineer what is the role of engineering, you'll get an answer like "improving people's lives by solving real world problems." If you ask that same engineer the same question after they've been on the job for about fifteen years, you'll get a more mature perspective: "improving the company's

Law and Ethics in Judicial Systems

1429 words - 6 pages Q The Separation of Law and Ethics The separation between law and ethics has become a central pillar of most legal systems. This essay will review three articles that discuss insights relevant to this topic and acknowledge strengths and weaknesses that contribute to my understanding of this issue. First, Sheppard discusses the role of ethics, law and justice in society and how the state’s role becomes important when enshrining these laws

Ethics and Corporate Social Responsibility: The Regulatory and Legal Framework

1158 words - 5 pages creation subject only to minimalist public policy and perhaps customary business ethics (Windsor, 2006).It is universally agreed there is no single definition of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR), but a great many companies and organizations worldwide promote its ever increasing use (McWilliams, Siegel, and Wright, 2006). According to some scholar, CSR are situations where the firm goes beyond compliance and engages in 'actions that appear to

Legal Issues, Ethics and Corporate Social Responsibility on Business Planning

931 words - 4 pages failures in many aspects of the daily operation of a business and the overall business plan of a corporation. The ongoing evaluation and analysis of the planning process is necessary to improve the overall process to keep the company in line with the latest changes in the industry. Therefore, this paper will discuss how legal issues, ethics and corporate social responsibility impact management planning at (My company).Legal IssuesBusiness plans

Ethics and Corporate Social Responsibility in the Music Industry

1788 words - 7 pages uproar in the industry because this once again brought up the ethical issue of fair compensation. If this bill were to pass, it would cut profits of artist and songwriters and make it impossible for them to make a decent living. Some even argue that big time artists weren’t getting paid enough despite the astounding number of plays their songs had accumulated on internet radio. This caused many people to question Pandora’s ethics as well as

Similar Essays

Corporate Law Ethics Reflection University Of Sydney, Corporations Law Assignment

1691 words - 7 pages ) 6 Legal Education Review 195. ] [7: David Ronnegard, The Fallacy of Corporate Moral Agency (Springer, 2015) 42.] [8: David Millon, ‘New Directions in Corporate Law’ (1993) 50 Washington and Lee Law Review 1373.] 2. Jacinta confronts Simon. If Jacinta were to confront Simon with evidence of a consortium, between senior management and himself, in unethical import practices, Simon would in all likelihood elect to do one of two things – use

Sweat, Fire And Ethics By Bob Jeffcott

748 words - 3 pages It is often said that products made in sweatshops are cheap and that is why people buy those products, but why is it behind the clothes or shoes that we wear that make sweatshops bad? In the article Sweat, Fire and Ethics by Bob Jeffcott is trying to persuade the people and tell them how sweatshops are bad. Bob Jeffcott supports the effort of workers of the global supply chains in order to win improved wages and good working conditions and a

Influential Musicians From 1940 2003 ~Paul Simon, Bob Dylan And Jimi Hendrix~

4067 words - 16 pages Influential Musicians from 1940-2003~Paul Simon, Bob Dylan and Jimi Hendrix~The social and political climate of each era of American culture has been historically impacted not only by a recognizable music style from that era but also by lyrics of the musicians, and by the musical artists themselves. While some popular musicians are more celebrated than others there were unmistakably a few pioneers that have changed the course of music in America

Corporate Bailout And The Law Essay

1487 words - 6 pages issue citing that other forms of protectionism in addition to corporate bailouts have a long and distinguished history in the United States. For instance, in 1816, the government initiated the protection of the sugar industry against market forces (Bovard, p.71). Despite the fact that taxpayers stand a chance of losing close to $14 billion in the bailout of GM and Chrysler, supporters of the bailout, mostly the pro-Obama’s government, argue that