This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Euthanasia And Ethics: Kant And Stewart Mill

1269 words - 6 pages

The issue of euthanasia is one surrounded by much controversy. Here we will look at the moral system of Immanuel Kant and John Stewart Mill, the argument for euthanasia, and how each philosopher would respond to that argument. Immanuel Kant and John Stewart Mill have different ethical views therefore they view the issue of Euthanasia differently.
Immanuel Kant holds a deontological, or duty based, ethical view. This means that for something to have moral value it must be done from duty. The basis of this view is the categorical imperative, which Kant explains is to, “Act only in accordance with that maxim through which you can at the same time will that it become a universal law” (412). We must be able to universalize the act and have no contradictions in order for it to be morally permissible. Another part of this view is the principle of humanity, which states, “Act that you use humanity, whether in your own person or in the person of any other, always at the same time as an end, never merely as a means” (415). An act that uses someone as a means to an end is automatically immoral in Kant’s perspective. This ethical system that is the basis for Kant’s view on Euthanasia is very different from Mill’s.
John Stewart Mill has a much different ethical view that Kant. Mill is a Utilitarian, which in the book is described that, “It claims that the morality of an action is determined by how well it promotes ‘utility’, which is defined as the greatest good for the greatest number” (417). This ethical view measures the morality of an act by what the outcome is. If it promotes the greatest good for the greatest number it is moral. This is also referred to as the greatest happiness principle. Happiness being pleasure and the absence of pain, and unhappiness being the opposite. On this, Mill bases his view about euthanasia.
There are two types of euthanasia: passive euthanasia and active euthanasia. Passive euthanasia (which is legal) is when the patient refuses medication and/or medical treatment and therefore dies from ailment or other natural causes. Active euthanasia (which is only legal in certain areas) is when a certain drug is administered to the patient causing death. In The Case for Euthanasia, by Margaret Battin, she gives her argument on this controversial subject. She states three claims that she believes makes this act moral. First being, the principle of mercy. Battin asserts, “This principle of mercy establishes two component duties: 1. the duty not to cause further pain or suffering; and 2. the duty to end pain or suffering already occurring” (491). We have these duties as part of the principle of mercy. The second claim Battin argues, is the principle of autonomy. This means respecting another person’s rational choice as long as it does not cause undue harm to oneself, to other people, or violate other moral obligations (493). There are many people that come to a point in their life where they are not really living but are still...

Find Another Essay On Euthanasia and Ethics: Kant and Stewart Mill

Compare Mill and Kant’s Ethics Essay

917 words - 4 pages Kant’s Ethics may best apply to modern business. Kant said right action based on a set of moral rules, and the right action is supposed to be the one that conforms with these rules, whereas certain other types of action are morally forbidden. He also suggests that people should be treated "with respect and as ends in their own right, not solely as means to other's ends." On the contrary, Mill’s ethics only concern about the happiness of majority

Moral Actions by Philosophers Immanuel Kant and John Stuart Mill

1174 words - 5 pages In the making of my own argument on the elements that justify a right or wrong action, I will reference two of the most influential philosophers, Immanuel Kant and John Stuart Mill. In order to make this paper easy to follow, I intend to focus on one of the arguments formed by each of these men. I will evaluate how both of Kant and Mill’s principles fits into the morals of right and wrong. Kant gives us a categorical imperative that urges one to

Ethics and Morality of Euthanasia

2233 words - 9 pages Outline I. Introduction II. Euthanasia III. Patients Right to Die IV. Legal Issues With Euthanasia V. Nursing Attitudes Toward Euthanasia VI. Contributing Factors for Nurses VII. Conclusion Ethics and Morality of Euthanasia Luke Westphal NSG 316 H003 February 24, 2007 The role of a healthcare professional is a very trying role. Nurses and doctors alike are faced with difficult decisions everyday that interfere with their own personal beliefs and

Ethics: Ayn Rand and John Stuart Mill

1367 words - 6 pages Ethics is defined as the study of moral standards and how they affect conduct in a society or individual. With such a definition it is not wonder that the idea of what is ethically right or wrong can be interpreted differently depending on whose moral compass you use. Though there are many scholars to choose from I chose two very specific doctrines to evaluate for the purpose of this class. Ayn Rand and John Stuart Mill are two scholarly writers

Immanuel Kant, John Stuart Mill, Plato, and Aristotle:Morals and Ethical Codes

1160 words - 5 pages What is the appropriate action? It is a controversial question that is a focal point for moral and ethical codes. Morals and ethics is, of course, a subject that runs deep in the discussion of philosophy. People are faced with moral dilemmas everyday, which many times society decides without thoroughly exploring their options. Immanuel Kant, John Stuart Mill, Plato, and Aristotle are philosophers that focus on the topic of ethics, yet all have

My study notes for final. Brief overview of Hume, Kant, and Mill

941 words - 4 pages - general rule which state what it is you think you're doing and your reasons for doing. It doesn't tell you what to do (tell the truth). b) formula of humanity - we are forced to treat people in certain way by laws or self choice. Mutual respect to others' lives- realm of ends where people make laws for themselves. c) formula of autonomy - always treat others as autonomous agents capable of self-directed rational action. 8. Mill: Hedonist - pleasure or

Martha Stewart and Martha Billes

2021 words - 9 pages of business approaches and personalities, Martha Stewart, a highly successful businesswoman, turned everyday household activities into a multi-million dollar empire and Martha Billes, also a richly successful businesswoman, fought hard to take ownership of Canadian Tire at the age of 61. Both entrepreneurs faced the adversities of being women growing up in the 1940’s, where society held negative views against them because they were expected to be

Moral and Ethics: Euthanasia and Physician-Assisted Suicide

2469 words - 10 pages solely to the incredibly complexity and gravity of the issue. Therefore, in this study I will suggest, explore, and discuss that part of the ethical problem with euthanasia is under what circumstances, if any, is euthanasia considered ethically appropriate? As such, this study will examine the ethics of euthanasia from three different perspectives: (1) ethically appropriate for the doctor; (2) ethically appropriate for the assisting non-doctor

Kant and Mill's Theories

2142 words - 9 pages Kant and Mill's TheoriesIn July of 1994, Paul J. Hill, a former Presbyterian minister and later a pro-life activist, was prosecuted for killing Dr. John Britton, an abortion performing doctor, and James Barrett, a volunteer, outside a clinic in Pensacola, Florida. Prior to this, Hill commented on the murder of Dr. David Gunn, another abortion performing doctor, stating that it was a "biblically justified homicide (P. 215)." This statement shows

Kant and Morality

1706 words - 7 pages on happiness is having pleasure and freedom from pain. This paper compares and contrasts Aristotle’s conception of happiness with that of Mill and Bentham. The paper concludes with establishing which concept on happiness, between Aristotle and Mill, is more convincing. Aristotle’s View on Happiness In the book Nicomachean Ethics by Aristotle, every activity that a person does is usually aimed at some final result, which is considered a good aim

Kant and Deontological Theory

1275 words - 5 pages Kant on the good will. (2008). Retrieved on April 19, 2009 from http://philosophy.tamu.edu/~gary/intro/paper.kant.goodwill.html website. Freeman, Stephen J. (2000). Ethics an introduction to philosophy and practice. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth/Thomson Learning. Johnson, R. (2008). Kant’s moral philosophy. Retrieved April 16, 2008 from http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/kant-moral/#GooWilMorWorDut

Similar Essays

"Ethics Affect Actions".Examines The Views Of Two Philosophers (Kant And Mill) On How Ethics Affect Appropriate Action. Great For A Philosophy Class And You Can Add Your Own Views And Opinions

1075 words - 4 pages "Ethics Affect Actions""What is the appropriate action?" It's a controversial question that is a focal point for moral and ethical code. Morals and ethics is, of course, a subject that runs deep in the discussion of philosophy. People are faced with moral dilemmas everyday, which often times they decide without thoroughly examining their options. Immanuel Kant and John Stuart Mill are two philosophers who focus on the topic of ethics, yet with

Comparing Kant And Mill Essay

915 words - 4 pages Comparing Kant and Mill Works Cited Missing Kant and Mill both articulate thoughts that praise the use of reason as the ultimate good, that which leads to enlightenment (in Kant’s terms) and a general understanding and certainty, as Mill would put it. The two political philosophers, while both striving to reach the same goal, ultimately achieve their goals in a different sense, and even demonstrate a slight discrepancy in what they

Business Ethics And Kant Essay

1821 words - 8 pages Introduction The purpose of this paper is to discuss how Adelphia Communications’ leadership, particularly the Rigas family, violated the trust of the public and its investors through unethical and illegal business practices. First, a synopsis of the Adelphia scandal will be presented. Next, a brief overview of ethics and how they apply to maintaining good business and public trust will be discussed. Following the ethics overview, an outline of

Kant Vs. Mill: Human Rights And Utilitarianism

2106 words - 8 pages , J. R. (2006). John Stuart Mill's political philosophy: Balancing freedom and the collective good. London [u.a.: Continuum. Gearon, L. (2006). Freedom of expression and human rights: Historical, literary and political contexts. Brighton [u.a.: Sussex Academic. Kant, I. (2008). The metaphysical elements of ethics. Rockville, Md: ARC Manor. Luban, D. (1980). Just War and Human Rights. Philosophy and Public Affairs 9 (2):160-81. Mill, J. S., Bentham, J., & Ryan, A. (1987). Utilitarianism and other essays. Harmondsworth, Middlesex, England: Penguin Books. Soccio, J. (1998). Archetypes of Wisdom. Belmont: Wadsworth Publishing Company.