Euthanasia Discussion Essay

1722 words - 7 pages

Whose responsibility is it to decide when, where, and under what conditions a person is to die? This question inevitably brings up discussion of spirituality, beliefs, and legislation. Euthanasia is an idea that has been around for decades yet as we progress in technology and medical competency the discussion screams to be addressed formally by passing legislature. Euthanasia must be taken out of the hands of lawmakers and put into the hands of the thousands fatally ill patients trapped in their own bodies and/or minds. It is our responsibility as a society of profound thinking individuals to discuss this difficult and troubling issue that has plagued the lives of families all over the entire world. We must debate on an issue that requires discussion of varying religious beliefs and facing uncomfortable truths.
When debating a topic so sensitive and misunderstood as euthanasia it is important to understand not only the terminology included in the discussion but both sides of the debate. First we must start with the definitions of Euthanasia and the other forms of assisted suicide. I call on Professor John Keown of Cambridge University to define euthanasia as such, “the active, intentional termination of a patient’s life by a doctor who thinks that death is a benefit to that patient.” That being said there are several forms of Euthanasia and assisted suicide and once again we look to Keown to settle any discrepancies. He states,
The most important aspect to the euthanasia debate like all debates is making sure the parties involved fully understand the facts and the opposing view points on this issue. First and foremost we must define Euthanasia and all of the possible forms it can take. Voluntary active euthanasia (VAE), generally understood to mean steps taken by another to terminate a patient’s life at the patient’s request; non-voluntary active euthanasia (NVAE), actions “performed on those who do not have the mental ability to request euthanasia (such as babies or adults with advanced dementia) or those who, though competent, are not given the opportunity to consent to it”; and involuntary active euthanasia (IVAE), meaning efforts undertaken against the expressed wishes of a competent patient.
As of right now there are two countries that have legalized euthanasia, The Netherlands and Belgium, along with Australia’s Northern Territory. In the United States there is only one state that has legalized PAS, which is Oregon. PAS is defined as “the prescription or supplying of drugs with the explicit intention of enabling the patient to end his or her life by an overdose” (Willems et al. 2000). The debate has multiple angles of support and opposition. The leading support groups for euthanasia center around the fact that it is their lives to control. As Dorothy Rasinski Gregory states,
Ask the average physician, attorney, or layperson what kind of death
he or she would prefer and a variety of responses might be heard: “in my
sleep; . . ....

Find Another Essay On Euthanasia Discussion

Euthanasia Should Not Be Legal Essay

1156 words - 5 pages a patient by making his death less painful. On the other side, voluntary euthanasia refers to the case of the conscientious patient, who voluntarily demands from the doctor to give up on treatments. In this case the patient is conscious that he will die soon and regardless that stops the treatments. In my discussion related to whether euthanasia should be legalized or not I will refer only to active and voluntary euthanasia arguments

Should Euthanasia be Legalised? A moral Perspective

2127 words - 9 pages reject treatment and the right of doctors to withdraw or withhold treatment (Sanders and Chaloner 2007). Conclusion Overall, these consequences give us reason to be cautious about euthanasia, but not a clear reason to avoid legalising it, as there are just as many arguments for it as there are against it. This leads to the conclusion that euthanasia should not be legalised as of yet, because there is strong need for further discussion and

Euthanasia

1793 words - 7 pages Euthanasia - Response to Anti Euthanasia Essay Euthanasia is a topic that provokes as much controversy as capital punishment, primarily because it is irreversible. The question of euthanasia being right or wrong is one that most would prefer left alone. However, recent publicity on changes to existing laws has ignited considerable discussion and has forced open the door to a much wider audience. The issues related to direct euthanasia have

The Controversy and Ethical Debate Surrounding Euthanasia

1436 words - 6 pages the different classes of it understood. The discussion itself has to be based on a method of reasoning and logic. One of the sources of ethical rationale, and probably the major method of reasoning in some parts of the world, is religion. Different religions differ in their view of euthanasia, some share similarities while others differ completely. According to the book titled “Euthanasia: a Reference Handbook” by McDougall and Gorman, the Merriam

Euthanasia

1681 words - 7 pages most of painless ways of dying involves assistance, Nowell-Smith states that the person has a very limited right to die when chooses so. He believes that person must have a right to die at a time and manner of his/her choice and that there is no moral difference between passive and active euthanasia. He also concludes that society should change their look at Death itself, not prohibiting its discussion as it once happened to Sex. Therefore he

Euthanasia in America

606 words - 2 pages                          Lately in America there have been a lot of discussion and debate on the topic of euthanasia and rather if its right or wrong. "Euthanasia is defined as the act or practice of killing or permitting the death of hopelessly sick or injured individuals in a relatively painless way for reasons of

Euthanasia or Continuous Sedation: Why the Conflict?

1101 words - 5 pages about euthanasia to change lightly different. There must be a continuous discussion among the medical team for both practices. In case euthanasia is chosen, an independent physician (sometimes nurses also) must reassert euthanasia. This study conducted in Belgium shows that there are other factors to consider while choosing between euthanasia and sedation. Moral/Ethics may influence the most on the final verdict, such as the education received in

The History of Euthanasia

1426 words - 6 pages and early 20th centuries… California, for example, codified its assisted suicide prohibition in 1874, using language similar to the Field Code's." (ProCon.Org) In 1917, the discussion had turned from regular assisted suicide and euthanasia, to infant euthanasia. According to National Public Radio (NPR), the highly controversial film The Black Stork regards the work of Dr. Harry Haiselden, a Chicago surgeon who convinced the parents of a newborn

The Right to Life Includes the Right to Choose How Your Life Ends

1131 words - 5 pages In this paper, I will be arguing for the position that active euthanasia should be legal in the United States. A patient’s suffering should not be prolonged, doctors should be able to ease their suffering and help their patient to the fullest extent. I believe this issue is important for discussion because the suffering individual has rights and the right to live should give them the right to choose to end that suffering. I think that some of

Should Euthanazia Be Legalized in Australia?

760 words - 4 pages Euthanasia, currently a very controversial topic of discussion throughout Australia. The question is “should euthanasia be legalised, and if so who is legible to be euthanised?” It is currently illegal in Australia to be euthanised, however 86% of the public agrees that euthanasia should be administered to people who are willing to if they are terminally ill, and a surprising 54% of practitioners agree also. Even though this is the case, why is

euthanasia

1387 words - 6 pages prevent death. When talking about voluntary euthanasia, is the patient the one that makes the request to end his/her life. In involuntary euthanasia, someone else makes the decision to end the patient's life, usually because the patient is unable to make a request. For example, a patient that is in a coma or due to mental impediment. (Frey)Through the years, there has been an intense discussion between the meaning of euthanasia and assisted suicide

Similar Essays

Reserach Paper

1812 words - 8 pages focused on the desire for control over the timing and way of death. Equally, warnings about the possible abuse or harm of superseding societies established exclusions against assisting suicide or directly causing another person's death. Concurrent with this public dispute, but in many ways disconnect from it and has been the discussion of assisted suicide and euthanasia in the medical and ethical works. In this discussion, some assert that both

Euthanasia, A Controversial Issue In The Us

944 words - 4 pages . Before forming a defense in favor of euthanasia or opposing it we must evaluate the many factors and conditions involved.Let us open our discussion on euthanasia by creating a very simple hypothetical situation. Consider a situation made up by Olver, a husband and his wife are captured by ruthless spies and are sentenced to death. The wife and the husband are both strapped in a machine that administers electric shocks causing the wife to writhe in

Euthanasia And Divorce Essay

945 words - 4 pages social climate.In conclusion, the issues of divorce and euthanasia will continue to evoke discussion and emotion in Australian society. The ever increasing variety of cultures and religions that is Australia will constantly fuel debate over these issues. The fanatical religious devotees will continue to oppose divorce, euthanasia and many other controversial issues. However, through discussion with major religious groups and understanding of each others beliefs, a common ground may be sought that will ultimately effect the societal laws that are created.

Euthanasia Essay

1570 words - 6 pages active steps taken by another person. The euthanasia controversy is part of a larger issue concerning the right to die. Staunch defenders of personal liberty argue that all of us are morally entitled to end our lives when we see fit. Thus, according to these people, euthanasia is in principle morally permissible. Two additional concepts are relevant to the discussion of euthanasia. First, voluntary euthanasia refers to mercy killing that takes