This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Euthanasia Position Paper Against Euthanasia

2268 words - 9 pages

Assisted Suicide, mercy killing, euthanasia; whatever you call it or however we justified it is killing by all means. Euthanasia is a practice of ending a life to release an individual from an incurable disease or intolerable suffering. It is an action which brings intentional death to a patient. In the case of the elderly cancer patient, the family and the patient does not know whether or not to commit euthanasia. The author response in this case, is that the elderly cancer patient should not go for euthanasia, since she has a biographical life. He came to the right conclusion, even though he did not have a valid argument. The author should have advised the patient not to commit euthanasia by using the three main arguments against euthanasia, which are the Bible from a Christian prospective, the effective pain management, and the fear of abuse if euthanasia were legalized.Case History: A seventy one-year-old Christian woman developed cancer in her kidney. Physicians helped her by removing the kidney. However, now the cancer has spread to other parts of her body. The physicians say that she needs dialysis, since her second kidney is now failing. They believe that dialysis might keep her alive for six to nine months. Without dialysis, she would probably survive a couple of weeks. An experimental drug that might have some effect on her cancer is coming onto the market. The new drug might help her fight the cancer, if she could survive for six months. Despite her insurance policy, she is sending a tremendous amount of money from her life savings. Her son thinks death is unavoidable and wants to avoid dialysis. He thinks bankrupting the family for a long shot is meaningless. Her daughter is a Christian who feels bad about not doing everything she can to help her mother.The question that is presented at the end of this case history is what should one say to guide this family on whether or not the elderly cancer patient should go for euthanasia? Author's Response: According to the article "James Rachels and the Active Euthanasia Debate" by J. P. Moreland, the elderly cancer patient should not go for euthanasia. The author would defend his answer by stating that the personal biographic life of the elderly cancer patient is enough to prevent her from committing euthanasia. The author believes that the desire to die is rational only if one's lost his/her biographical life. He defines one's biographical life as "the sum of one's aspirations, decisions, activities, projects, and human relations". This means that a person biographical life is the interests that are important and worthwhile from the point view of the person himself. He argues that "the fact that something has biological life, whether human or non-human is relatively unimportant". What is important from his point of view is someone who has biographical life. He adds that all kinds of animals have a biographical life, since they have thoughts, emotions, goals, and cares. As a matter of fact an...

Find Another Essay On Euthanasia Position Paper - Against Euthanasia

Argument Against Euthanasia Essay

1884 words - 8 pages Euthanasia is the Greek word for “good death.” It is also known as mercy killing. It is the action of ending a life that suffers from a terminal illness or an incurable disease, usually by a lethal injection. Except for in the Netherlands and Belgium, euthanasia is illegal. Euthanasia has now been legalized in Oregon. Washington and Montana has only legalized assisted suicide, which is different from euthanasia. Advocates of euthanasia claim

Arguments For And Against Euthanasia Essay

2001 words - 8 pages expedite the dying process. This paper is going to explore how euthanasia is viewed from religious and ethical points. Arguments for and against euthanasia will be presented using published research articles. In the United States, euthanasia is illegal in all states except in the states of Oregon, Washington, and Montana. In 1998 the issue of euthanasia was triggered in America when Dr Jack Kevorkian, a pathologist from Michigan showed

Euthanasia: The cases for and against

1348 words - 5 pages severely punished. Euthanasia, however, occurs secretly in all societies, including those in which it is held to be immoral and illegal.Organizations supporting the legalization of voluntary euthanasia were established in Great Britain in 1935 and in the United States in 1938. They have gained some public support, but so far they have been unable to achieve their goal in either nation. In the last few decades, Western laws against passive and

The Fallacies of O'Shea's Argument against Euthanasia

2703 words - 11 pages with the law are protected from criminal prosecution. The physicians and health care systems in the states themselves are not required to participate in assisting the patient. Of course, there are still possible counterarguments that opponents have against my position. One major possible counterargument would be that euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide violate the Hippocratic Oath, the earliest set of medical ethical ideas written. The oath

Euthanasia: For, Against, or In The Middle

1836 words - 8 pages themselves, they would be considered to have assisted suicide. Assisted suicide is illegal under the terms of the Suicide Act (1961) and is punishable by up to 14 years' imprisonment. Attempting to commit suicide, however, is not a criminal act in itself. The fourth type of euthanasia is in-voluntary euthanasia which means euthanasia committed against a person’s wishes or the person is unable to give consent; it is more commonly considered murder

"Euthanasia against the right to life"

1382 words - 6 pages drug. All the human beings have the right to liberty that implies tolerance, the acceptance of the liberty of others even when we do not like what they do. Obliging to live in suffering is worse than permitting to die in peace. Prohibiting the euthanasia means to legislate against the weakest one, the one that wants to die but cannot suicide, and causes the continuation of the suffering. The people that are against the legalization of the

Against Euthanasia

806 words - 4 pages The concept of a successful euthanasia program, even one that originated with good intentions, was squashed with the violent and repulsive turn that it took in Germany during the era of World War II. Arguments attempting to differentiate between the Nazi euthanasia program and intact and proposed programs today have stated that attempts to obtain consent, criteria for selecting patients, and dignity involved with today’s programs make them safer

Argumentive Essay Against Euthanasia

622 words - 2 pages Euthanasia The mind is a terrible thing to waste, stated by anti-drug commercials. We all will either appreciate or underrate our life based on certain experiences we live through. Many go through dramatic experiences that make life uncomfortable or more strenuous than surrounding patrons do. Religious beliefs often affect the reasoning of decisions and the importance of life. Some people live in a vegetable status since their body is

Against both voluntary and involuntary euthanasia

789 words - 3 pages inquiry into claims that health officials are practicing 'involuntary euthanasia' on elderly patients in an attempt to free up beds in over-crowded hospitals."Involuntary euthanasia is a practice in which doctors kill patients who are not in critical condition in order to free up hospital beds. In Canada involuntary euthanasia is hardly a topic of discussion, the reason for that is being here in Canada, this practice is not seen as necessary in order

Euthanasia goes against religious beliefs, ends a person's life prematurely, and could lead to the atrocities that were seen during the Nazi era

1184 words - 5 pages goes against religious beliefs, ends a person's life prematurely, and could lead to the atrocities that were seen during the Nazi era.If people are meant to die then they will. Many religions are against euthanasia. Being Protestant, I look to the bible. It says God has the right to terminate life, since God is the creator of it. Some may argue God wants people to live their life without pain. But doesn't everybody live everyday with pain? God's

Argumentative Paper: Legalizing Euthanasia

1736 words - 7 pages made legal. If appropriate advance directives were taken, mercy killing would never occur. By knowing what one would want under the given situation, the act would be active euthanasia. There are several reasons for the opposition of euthanasia. The first I would like to discuss is Natural Law. The argument is that killing ourselves goes against our very nature. I also think being in excruciating pain for the remainder of a short life is not very

Similar Essays

Against Euthanasia Essay

856 words - 3 pages not take mental and emotional sufferings as well? So at the end euthanasia is not better than committing suicide.An important argument against euthanasia is that it can be misused in numerous ways. For instance, if the patients' family is allowed to take a decision of killing the patient, they might misuse this situation for their own benefit (to inherit the patient's wealth for example). Supporters to euthanasia usually overlook that the policy

Arguments Against Euthanasia Essay

1962 words - 8 pages of a value judgement according to the Stases article. In terms of Perelman and Olbrechts-Tyteca's criteria for utilizing values as objects of agreement, May's thesis is a clear example of a preferable value-based argument, for there is a specific position taken against active euthanasia. Moreover, since May published his piece in a Christian magazine, but is also calling for social regulation, his particular audience includes both conservative

The Case Against Euthanasia Essay

1184 words - 5 pages A recent survey by the Canadian Medical Association discovered that “ . . . 44 per cent of doctors would refuse a request for physician-assisted dying . . . ” (Kirkey 2). Euthanasia is defined as assisting a terminally ill patient with dying early. In many countries the legalization of this practice is being debated in many countries. All doctors against assisted suicide, including the 44 percent in Canada, are on the right side of the argument

Argument Against Euthanasia Essay

2874 words - 11 pages A significant portion of society is in favor of euthanasia. They feel that as a democratic country, we as free individuals have the right to decide for ourselves whether or not to terminate one's life. The stronger and more widely held opinion is against euthanasia. This belief is that it is God's task to determine when one of his creations' time has come, and we as human beings are in no position to behave as God and end someone's life. When