Evaluate Empiricism As An Ideology And Methodology For Writing History.

1257 words - 5 pages

‘…Agreement among historians is remarkably difficult to achieve, and historical events are open to a multiplicity of interpretations.’1 When writing history, it is difficult to conspire up one, objective and truthful view upon an event. It is clearly evident that ‘historians down the ages have held widely differing views on the purposes to which these things were to be put, and the way in which the facts they presented were to be explained’2The problematic nature of reconstructing history can be attributed to the problems associated with the current trend of modern historians to challenge and question the past. Through the reconstruction of history over time, it is evident that the meaning of history, the way it is recorded and interpreted has changed over time. It is through this realisation that historians come to understand that each time period has its own influence on the ways in which composers interpret and choose to reconstruct the past. ‘In medieval and early modern times, many historians saw their function as chronicling the working-out of God’s purposes in the world’. 3Empiricism has its origins from the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. This time has been defined as the scientific revolution, a period in which science prospered. It is here where scientific enquiry became more so prevalent and this ideology was carried through the eighteenth century.Through the work of post-modernists, the theory of knowledge aspect has been argued. Leopold Von Ranke made a multiplicity of arguments regarding empirical values. Ranke himself ‘intended that each historical period should be understood on its own terms’4. This means that when studying the past, we must judge an historian’s opinion based on the context of their time. Through the examination of historical practices over time, it has proven difficult to provide society with an accurate portrayal of the truth.Each composer of history has utilised differing techniques to illustrate an interpretation of the past. For example, ancient historians such as Herodotus interpreted history through story telling, incorporating elements of myth, which is a reflection of that societies beliefs, values, customs and the audience he was writing to. This is a stark contrast to the techniques used by Von Ranke, who argued that historians should only use primary sources, therefore they should not use second hand accounts. Von Ranke also believed ‘that the past could not be judged by the standards of the present’5. This essentially means that historians should be impartial when interpreting history, not effected by beliefs or prejudices.These principles applied by Von Ranke gave history a definitive direction. It is essentially summarised in his quote ‘ Wie es eigentlich gewesen’, which means ‘how it essentially was’6. Von Ranke wanted to know the real truth, he wanted to understand the past in the differing contexts in which...

Find Another Essay On Evaluate empiricism as an ideology and methodology for writing history.

METHODOLOGY AND PROCEDURE: very good example of methodology chapter for Master Students

1611 words - 6 pages ), Schedule Adherence (SA) and both internal and external Parts Per Million Defect Rates (PPM).Respondents of the StudyThe general population for this study was composed of personnel who dealt with the implementation of the programme, numbering ten (10) respondents.Instruments to be usedTo determine whether the industry has developed sustainability mechanisms as an integral element of an effective and efficient lean manufacturing programme. The researcher

Communist China and North Korea: Shared History and Ideology

2051 words - 8 pages advocating North Korean communism. Communism in North Korea and China has been an interesting comparison as well as a captivating contrast. Though they both have shared history and ideology, they were only similar until the mid-1970s. After Mao’s reign, Deng’s triumphant reforms transformed communism in China and proved to be completely different with the North Korean’s communism centralized and inspired by the idea of Juche. Throughout the

Writing as Thing and Event

1120 words - 4 pages certainly different. To support that speech is an event Ong later makes the statement that speech is produced in a certain time, addressed by and for living persons, because the setting is “more than a context of words.” Writing has these characteristics as well, however, though Ong makes the distinction that writers must fictionalize an audience and a setting which disputes the claim that writing is an event. However, this is not a satisfactory

Shooting an Imperialistic Elephant This is an article critique of George Orwell's Shooting an Elephant. It was submitted as an assignment for a course in English Writing

1113 words - 4 pages with an emotional dilemma of being stuck between his own personal hatred towards his employers and his loath for the jeering locals, who put effort into making his employment particularly difficult. Psychologically, the officer wants to be accepted by the Burmese for who he is. Ironically, this is not possible as in the bigger picture, one that is more relevant to the locals, he represents the evil imperialistic British empowerment. He can do

Critically evaluate the extent to which the Literacy Hour enhances the teaching and learning of English as required by the National Curriculum for English.

3352 words - 13 pages justifiably referred to as central parts of the basics as these tools are for further learning (Baber 1977 p 174). Very low levels of literacy are associated with unemployment and crime, it is therefore crucial that literacy skills should be aimed to be taught and learnt effectively, preventing such happenings.The framework for teaching the literacy hour, a key component of the NLS proposes an interpretation of literacy that emphasises reading

For the period between 1844 and the Civil War, evaluate the impact of slavery on the history of the Republicans, Whigs, Free-Soil

538 words - 2 pages fugitive slave laws and the Cotton Whigs was for the Compromise of the 1850 because of the new stricter fugitive slave laws. This separation within the party expanded through the Election of 1852. Virginian Winfield Scott was nominated as the Whig candidate for president. The Conscious Whigs supported him fully; however, the Cotton Whigs saw him as weak in enforcing the Compromise of 1850. This caused the Cotton Whigs to oppose the party candidate

Professor Ngugi and Writing as Social Communication

765 words - 3 pages Professor Ngugi and Writing as Social Communication During one of his Postcolonial African Literature classes, he stated that by adopting reading and writing as the chief form of social communication, a civilization is truly freeing itself to forget its own values, because those values no longer have to be part of a lived reality to have significance. A first-year undergraduate with a blind faith and deep passion for literature, I always

Religion as a Major Organizing Ideology to the Social and Political Reality of the Nineteenth-Century

3995 words - 16 pages Religious scholar, Stephen Prothero, sees religion as a major organizing ideology to the social and political reality of the nineteenth-century. For Prothero, there is a close and intimate ideological relation between theological beliefs and a culture; therefore, they are not separable from characterizing the religious mood of the nineteenth-century. Prothero argues that many Americans were, “inspired by [the] republican rhetoric of liberty

Creative Writing: My First Battle as an Ancient Warrior

977 words - 4 pages and neighed loudly. Calm yet alert, we waited them to come closer. I clenched my fist and got ready for my first battle. As the rising sun washed the field with a pale orange glow, both side left pother of dust behind and went toward the battle line. The mounted archers faded one other in the noisy battle lines. As an arrow got fired, the screaming of a horse yelled out. Both sides of the warlords were great. Our warlord?s crescent helmet

Evaluate the effectiveness of diction as an adjunct to meaning in John Updike's 'Player Piano'.

675 words - 3 pages Evaluate the effectiveness of diction as an adjunct to meaning in John Updike's 'Player Piano'. In 'Player Piano', John Updike uses personification to give life to a 'unhuman' piano. By using diction to communicate his ideas, he effectively allows the reader to explore the psyche of a 'Player Piano'. In the first couple lines of the poem, assonance and consonance are present. In line one, these musical devices dominate the

Evaluate the evidence for and against the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis.

1029 words - 4 pages a concept of time similar to the Western World’s, with a calendar. Whorf also never met an Indian, and his analysis is wholly based on his translation of their language, meaning he cannot generalize his argument.If Whorf’s hypothesis that language determines thought is taken as fact, then logically, those without language would not think. If this is the case, then how do babies learn and develop language without thought processes

Similar Essays

Feminism: An Ideology And Lifestyle Essay

1758 words - 7 pages Feminism is equality. Feminism is women and men on an identical playing field. Feminism, to me, is the right and the fight for women to be equal to men. Feminism is mostly acknowledged as an ideology, but it is incorporating these ideologies into one's lifestyle that will facilitate a change. One does not just think feminism, one is feminism. I believe that through feminism, through women acknowledging the issues, putting in the effort to ignite

Describe And Evaluate The Political Ideology Of Contemporary Al Qaeda.

3299 words - 13 pages 1. IntroductionThis essay aims to describe and evaluate the political ideology of contemporary al Qaeda. This will be achieved by providing a history of al Qaeda, as well as a brief explanation of the organizational structure of the group. There will be reference made to the goals and objectives of al Qaeda, and the names and positions of key figures within the group. The essay will then explain the concept of 'ideology' by providing a concise

Empiricism And Rationalism: Searching For God And Truth

890 words - 4 pages having is a true one (Come Reason Ministries, 1999). Works Cited Is There Such A Thing As Rational Faith. (1999). Retrieved from http://www.comereason.org/resources/articles/rationalfaith.pdf Nash, R. H. (1999). Life’s Ultimate Questions: An introduction to philosophy. Grand Rapids, MI.: Zondervan. Sunlyk, P. (n.d.). Locke, Hume, Empiricism and the existence of God. Retrieved from http://www.tektonics.org/guest/pslockhume.htm “Biblical Empiricism” And the Existence of God. (2011). Retrieved from http://www.pleaseconvinceme.com/index/%E2%80%9CBiblical_Empiricism%E2%80%9D_And_The_Existence_of_God

Discuss The Nature And Purpose Of The Hitler Youth Movement. How Did It Promote Nazi Ideology? How Effective Was The Hitler Youth As An Institute Promoting Nazi Ideology?

1304 words - 5 pages developing into strong and healthy mothers who knew the importance of blood purity. The Hitler Youth movement was incredibly effective while support for it lasted. Hitler successfully brainwashed a generation of young men and women into believing in his ideals and his greatness. Because of Hitler’s rigorous training and molding, the HJ members were strong, fit, loyal, and had an intense dislike of the Jewish race. These young Germans believed in