This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Evaluations Of The Oraibi Split. The 'oraibi' Was A Pueblo Of A Native American Culture Called The Hopi. This Essay Examines Why The Oraibi Split From Four Different Anthropologists Views.

1923 words - 8 pages

Evaluations for the Oraibi SplitThe split of the Third Mesa pueblo, Oraibi, occurred on September 7, 1906. The split immediately changed the lives of roughly 800 inhabitants of Oraibi who represented nearly half of the Hopi population. Those who left Oraibi were forced to start their lives over in a new location. From a long-term perspective, the split is consequential because it led to the establishment of other villages (e.g., Bacavi, Hotevilla, and Kykotsmovi) of Third Mesa that did not exist before the division (Waters 1977: 113). This eventually resulted in different versions of Hopi history and the Oraibi split from each village. Anthropologists have offered many different explanations of the Oraibi fissioning. These various proposals have caused the interpretation and understanding of the division of Oraibi to be very complex. This essay evaluates explanations of four different anthropologists: Mischa Titiev, Richard Bradfield, Richard Clemmer, and Peter Whiteley.Titiev provides the first explanation to consider. Taking all of Titiev's arguments together, he suggests that internal social structure pressures and instabilities led to the disintegration of the Oraibi pueblo (Titiev 1992: 48). Titiev's analysis of Oraibi disintegration is based on his view of Hopi social structure and social integration. For Titiev, three features of the traditional social structure of Hopi villages, including Oraibi, were essential.The first feature was the organization of Hopi matrilineal descent groups into households, lineages, clans, and phratries (Titiev 1992:51). In Titiev's view, Hopi clans were basically autonomous and corporate, owning land, rituals, and kivas. The second feature was the organization of religious societies and kiva groups. The chief priests of religious sodalities were drawn from the descent group that "owned" a particular religious ceremony (Page 1994: 47). These ceremonies were controlled by a particular descent group, the matrilineal clan. Common membership in the society that performed the ceremony was drawn from many descent groups throughout the pueblo, which suggests that one society's ceremony might be performed in a kiva controlled by a different descent group. For Titiev, such crossings of memberships provided social integration and unity within the Hopi villages. The third significant feature of Hopi social structure describes Hopi's political organization as "amorphous". It lacked powerful leadership positions and could not withstand pressures generated by the opposing interests of other descent groups. For Titiev, "a Hopi pueblo is like an object with a thin outer shell which holds together a number of firm, distinct segments- should the shell be cracked, the segments would fall apart" (Titiev 1992: 69).The Oraibi Split is, thus, to be understood within the context of the separatistic characteristics of Hopi clans and the weakness of phratry and village ties (James 1974: 60). Titiev's propositions suggest that as...

Find Another Essay On Evaluations of the Oraibi Split. The 'Oraibi' was a pueblo of a Native American culture called the Hopi. This essay examines why the Oraibi split from four different anthropologists views.

This essay is based on a short story called "the Edge" by R.K. Narayan. It is about how he was a product of his environment

584 words - 2 pages This essay is about a character named Ranga from "The Edge" by R.K. Narayan. Ranga was a product of his environment; being born into poverty he never really had a chance to be successful. He stayed in an abandoned building called Krishna's Hall while he worked at his knife sharpening business. He was a hard worker and did his best to bring home enough rupee's to maintain a living for his daughter and rather 'difficult' wife. He sharpened knives

Defend or Refute - "The Renaissance was a new development, strikingly different from the preceding Middle Ages." - This essay agrees with this quote, and gives many reason as to why

1323 words - 5 pages property of men. The lower class women could not receive the same education as the upper class, however they were still encouraged to learn from books because literacy and education was stressed by society. This treatment of women would set the standard for women until the 20th century.The characteristics of the middle ages were completely different from the ideas of the Renaissance expressed here. The social classes were strictly split among the

The Hobbit, by J.R.R. Tolkien, was a novel about manners. This essay helps define why manners was significant to the impact of the story

520 words - 2 pages treasure as a burglar. Bilbo's only requirements as a burglar was to help them steal back their treasure from the greedy dragon, Smaug. When the dwarves request that Bilbo should inspect Smaug's den, Bilbo accepts the duty out of politeness and kindness. Bilbo even goes as far as accepting the duty three times! When inspecting Smaug's den, Bilbo discovers that Smaug has a weak spot. With that information, The Bard slays Smaug and the treasure is now the

Why Macbeth Was A Tragedy. (Shakespeare) This essay describes the main aspects of macbeths downfall due to his excessive ambition

703 words - 3 pages milks me:I would, while it was smiling in my face,Have pluck'd my nipple from his boneless face,And dash'd the brains out, had I so swornAs you have done to this.Lady MacBeth. Act 1, Scene 7, Lines 59-64By the time MacBeth kills Banquo and MacDuff's family, MacBeth is acting independently of Lady MacBeth but were it not for her he would not have started this whirlpool that spiraled him down to his undoing. A greater man would have resisted the

This is a complex essay written about Karl Marx's 18th Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte. It describes why the revolution was doomed to failure from the outset and the travesty of Bonaparte's failure

1069 words - 4 pages The revolution of 1848 was doomed to failure from its very beginnings. Marx states that historical events such as this draw their ideas from the past, thus the revolution of 1848 had nothing better to parody than the revolution of 1789. The fault here, however, is that the 1848 revolution sought to mirror a revolution that had failed. An absolute monarch led to a dictatorship. To follow such a trend it is easy to understand why conservative

This essay is a critique on how shrek depicts and discusses servral issues such as the theory of a utopia and how society view people who are different than the so called "norm"

1423 words - 6 pages The movie Shrek which starts like any other fairy tale with a once upon a time, a princess trapped in a tower and her knight in shining armour. But once we see who the hero of the story is it is made obvious that this is not your typical fairy tale. I found this movie to have amazing graphics that looked almost human, a hilarious plot which is a one of a kind. The most enjoyable part was the repartee between Shrek and Donkey from Ogres having

Fear Driven: this is an essay that explains the reasoning behind the first book of "Native Son" by Richard Wright being called Fear

592 words - 2 pages Fear is defined as an unpleasant feeling of distress. Fear is a good title for the first book of Native Son because Bigger Thomas is driven by his fear. Every action that he takes is dictated by fear. Bigger fights with Gus because he was afraid. He goes out with Mary and Jan out of fear. The suffocation of Mary was also caused by his fear of being caught.The first of Bigger’s actions that fear influenced was his fight with Gus.Gus had made

This paper was for a class called History of Mathematcis. Newton, Sir Isaac (1642-1727), Mathematician and physicist, one of the foremost scientific intellects of all time

791 words - 3 pages the German geographer Varenius in 1672. His own letters on optics appeared in print from 1672 to 1676. Then he published nothing until the Principia (published in Latin in 1687; revised in 1713 and 1726; and translated into English in 1729). This was followed by Opticks in 1704; a revised edition in Latin appeared in 1706. Posthumously published writings include The Chronology of Ancient Kingdoms Amended (1728), The System of the World (1728), the first draft of Book III of the Principia, and Observations upon the Prophecies of Daniel and the Apocalypse of St John (1733).

This essay discusses why Handel was a baroque musician as opposed to an Enlightened or Classical musician in the form of a letter

1270 words - 5 pages , and organs were used a lot less often, as the people moved away from the church. This period was also about history, as was the classical period, which is one thing that connects Handel to the classical period as well.Many of Handel's songs discuss the Greek and Roman emperors that existed many centuries prior to his existence, including the songs "Nero", "Agrippina" and "Tamerlano", which were all written before 1724. These songs reflect the lives

This book was about the first season of the television show 'Alias'. It was called "Alias: Declassified"

937 words - 4 pages the show Felicity when he had an idea, "Wouldn't be cool if Felicity were recruited by the CIA, because she could go on incredible missions and have kick-ass fights and stunts." He was only joking, but he wrote that idea down to work on later. Felicity was about a young woman dealing with adult life. This show is about a young woman dealing with her dysfunctional family. Sydney Bristow just happens to be a spy.A typical episode of a drama series

This is a creative writing piece about my friend almost drowning. It has four parts to it, each tells the same story from a different perspective

1449 words - 6 pages in her son's eyes. He didn't understand why his dad was like that and why his dad acted as though he didn't love him anymore. She looked down at her daughter and remembered why she lived. Red and blue lights flashed from outside.**** He sat there. The image of the blue baby and tearful mother followed by son ran through his mind but nothing registered. Colors rushed by leaving strikes like race cars. Noises and chaos created a pounding

Similar Essays

Living With A Split Culture In The Kitchen God’s Wife

1588 words - 7 pages . Throughout their lives, both Tan and Pearl exhibited their value towards American culture because they both married a white man. In 1974, Tan married Louis DeMattei and moved to San Francisco with him which was an unsupported decision from her mother. This proves that Tan wanted to incorporate American culture into her life by marrying an American man and moving with him to the United States. As for Pearl, she married a white man named Phil

Home Schooling This Essay Prove Gives The Many Different Views Of Home Schooling From Many Perspectives

1099 words - 4 pages a best friend and there will be fewer choices for the home-schooled child. A home-schooled child might also miss parties. High school is often referred to as the best time in a child's life. It is called this, because of the parties and events that a teen might attend. Another important factor that many parents do not consider is that when a home-schooled child goes away to college he or she may focus more on parties, than on his or her studies

Commanding Heights The Documentary Was Split Into 23 Chapters Of Which We Only Covered Up To Chapter 18. The Beginning Of The Documentary Focused On The Global Idea

963 words - 4 pages the cost.With the crossing of borders now in affect American investments poured into the poor nations of the world like Mexico, Thailand, China etc... This created a boom in the American market however many Americans lost their jobs to people thousands a miles away from where they lived. Now the American labor union was in competition with people who worked for pennies; there was basically no competition as there was no way they would be able to

Essay Concerns The 100th Birthday Bash Party Of Canada. Had To Write This Because Of A Course Called "Introduction To Canadian Culture". Received A 91% Grade

764 words - 3 pages like the Expo 67 which was held in Montreal from April 28 till October 27, which is nearly a full month or partying. Most activities were held in Ottawa, where an incredible sound and light show got projected onto the Canadian Parliament Buildings.The Expo 67 was the biggest and best event of Canada's 100th anniversary celebration and a great symbol of national pride for CanadiansHowever from the beginning on, the Canadian Prime Minister Lester