This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Evidence Based Treatment Essay

873 words - 3 pages

A debate rages in psychology, but it is not one of the usual kind, dwelling on a specific aspect of the mind or a new drug, but a controversy dealing with the very foundations of psychology. The main issue is in determining what treatments for patients are valid. Some feel that they must be empirically- supported treatments, treatments backed by hard data and scientifically supported. Others feel that this standard for treatments is much too confining for the complex field of psychology. The American Psychological Association President Task Force on Evidence-Based Treatment came out with a plan for psychology that effectively maintains a high scientific standard but allows for a variety of research designs to be used in determining how to treat a patient. This plan of evidence-based practice in psychology (EBPP) is good because it allows patients to receive personalized science-backed treatment.
EBPP “is the integration of the best available research with clinical expertise in the context of patient characteristics, culture, and preferences” (book essay 1). The first major facet of EBPP is the use of the best available research. Opponents have argued that randomized clinical trials are too narrow a type of study for psychology. A very valid point, this had been addressed in the new EBPP standard. Multiple types of research are included, ranging from public health and ethnographic research, to systematic case studies, to qualitative research, to meta-analyses (book 1). Using research-backed treatments cuts down on bias in treatment. Some psychologists argue that their experience is enough to know what works (Kendall 1998). Unfortunately, a human can be biased on incorrect without any knowledge of it. Data-backed treatments help to eliminate error on the part of the clinician.
Backing psychology with scientific studies also benefits psychology itself. P. C. Kendall (1998) asks what would happen if this did not happen. “To what category would the professional practice of clinical psychology be assigned: to philosophy, psychic reader, advisor?” Patients who need psychological treatment want to go to a psychologist who they know will help them. In fact, to stay relevant in the modern health care climate, “evidence-based clinical practice will become essential” (Sanderson 2003). Empirically supported treatments provide a higher standard of care for patients.
Opponents of EPBB argue, though, that this data-backed plan removes the psychologist from the process of treating the patient. Mahrer (2005) argues that “[t]here is almost no wiggle room left for psychotherapists who try to cling to their own preferred ways of doing psychotherapy. The good old days are over.” Perhaps to Maher, unsupported...

Find Another Essay On Evidence-Based Treatment

Science or Pseudoscience Essay

713 words - 3 pages . Valid scientific treatments have the ability to be thoroughly examined. If a therapy or treatment cannot be tested, it is not credible. Many pseudoscience therapies claim to have proven and verifiable results. However, the claims are not founded on experiment based evidence (Fin, Bothe and Bramlett, 2005, p. 173). In their second claim, Fin, Bothe and Bramlett (2005) address the adaptability of a treatment method when conflicting evidence

Successful Drug Treatment Essay

882 words - 4 pages programs ("National Association of State Alcohol and Drug Abuse Directors."). NASADAD specific goals that consist of: promoting evidence and research-based optimum treatment practices and approaches, providing structured expansion and enhancement substance use disorder treatment, the dissemination of treatment related information, and the development of white papers on specific treatment topics and issues; and lastly, to maintain effective

Evidence-based Practice in Nursing Care

1182 words - 5 pages intervention nurses in Macedonian was motivated to implement evidence based into their practice and deliver a better care. After the training hand washing was available to all facilities, full implementation of antibiotics was implemented as one of treatment protocol for early and late onset of infection control. Modern resuscitation trolley was added, maintaining thermo homeostasis in neonate was upgraded, for example first bath was supposed to be

Alcohol and Deprssion and Dual Diagnosis

2985 words - 12 pages Alcohol dependence and depression are commonly diagnosed health problems throughout the world. This literature review will discuss the co-existing problem of depression and alcohol dependence and the importance that evidence based practice and treatment modalities have on the patients' recovery. It will firstly discuss the meaning of dual diagnosis, followed on by the different treatment modalities and their outcomes, the role of a mental health

Clinical Decision-Support System

793 words - 4 pages to optimize the use of Clinical Decision based support systems (CDSS). By utilizing such systems, better care at a cheaper rate can be provided to patients saving both time and money. Major components of a CDSS Looking into major components of a CDSS there are two major ones. These include diagnostic support tools, and treatment support tools. Diagnostic support helps physicians make a better diagnosis based on the patient symptoms

Federal Prison And Addiction: What Are The Treatment Options?

2023 words - 9 pages maintained the philosophy of cognitive behavioral treatment, but adapts when new proven treatment models emerge, including moving programs from didactic to interactive, and implementing an evidence-based, modified therapeutic community. It has been found in the prison treatment system that therapeutic communities with aftercare, most of which have cognitive-behavioral components, are effective (Pelissier, Motivans and Rounds-Bryant, 2005). The

Evidence Based Practice in Nursing: Benefits and Barriers

815 words - 3 pages clinicians work to the best of their ability and knowledge in ensuring that the patient is receiving or has been advised about the best available treatment to them. Some patients may decide to decline the medication or treatment offered to them and although their autonomy should always be respected, they should always be informed of their choices. Professionally, Evidence Based Practice is paramount to nursing staff to enable them to achieve clinical

Gestational Diabetes Mellitus (GDM)

1636 words - 7 pages concentrations (utilizing a 75 g blinded 2 hour OGTT) and increasing birth weight, cord blood serum C-peptide levels and other adverse pregnancy outcomes. These associations were present at glucose levels currently lower than those used to diagnose GDM. 7 In spite of little evidence to support a treatment benefit to the identification and treatment of mild carbohydrate intolerance during pregnancy screening for GDM has been recommended for

Evidence Based Practice (EBP) in Juvenile Justice Systems

1164 words - 5 pages needs of those within the community, if they want to impact lives. Research will not identify the need of the people based off assumption, but through primary research, including client surveys on their reaction and benefits to services received. EBP is an approach to prevention and treatment, that has been scientifically proven to work (“Evidence-Based Programs for Juvenile Justice Reform in Louisiana,” 2010). EBP has the potential to

Drug & Abuse treatment in Corrections

1014 words - 4 pages that these interventions are not successful. It could even be argued that, given the complexity of the problems as well as the economic and social costs inherent in continued drug abuse after release from jail or prison, gains of the magnitude observed thus far more than justify the resources devoted to those programs.However, the evidence for treatment in general and treatment under legal pressure in particular is even more encouraging. For

Science or Pseudoscience

1522 words - 6 pages treatment. Valid scientific treatments have the ability to be thoroughly examined. If a therapy or treatment cannot be tested, it is not credible. Many pseudoscience therapies claim to have proven and verifiable results. However, the claims are not founded on experiment based evidence (Fin, Bothe and Bramlett, 2005, p. 173). In their second criterion, Fin, Bothe and Bramlett (2005) address the adaptability of a treatment method when conflicting

Similar Essays

Evidence Based Treatment Of Hot Flashes Related To Cancer Therapies

931 words - 4 pages article by Kaplan et al. (2011), articles were reviewed for evidence-based management of hot flashes. As far as pharmacologic interventions, the evidence-based review revealed that the drugs gabapentin and venlafaxine were the only measures likely to be effective (Kaplan et al., 2011). Gabapentin is an anticonvulsant, while venlafaxine is an antidepressant. Side effects of venlafaxine include nausea, nervousness, and constipation, while gabapentin’s

Inner Resources Mediation Protocol For Chronic Pain: Translation Research Of An Evidence Based Treatment Into A Community Setting

1366 words - 5 pages AIMS The principle goal of this study is to assess the feasibility of recruitment and adherence to an evidence-based, eight-session meditation program based on Dr. Lynn Waelde’s Inner Resources for Stress Relief for a community health clinic for adults with chronic pain, and to develop initial estimates of treatment effects of measures of pain and physical functioning. Based on literature review, we hypothesize that Inner Resources will

Helping People With Mental Ilness: What Are Evidence Based Practices

632 words - 3 pages . When a treatment is developed many times it is considered to be effective based on personal experiences or observations but not supported by empirical evidence. Evidence based practices are types of treatments or interventions that have reliable scientific evidence backing it up. The scientific evidence is proven reliable through the way it is collected, kind of information gathered, and tries to not have biased affecting the outcome. Scientific

Evidence Based Dentistry: A Paradigm Shift Essay

2354 words - 10 pages , prevention and treatment of oral disease, and newly discovered causes of disease. IMPORTANCE OF EVIDENCE-BASED DENTISTRY It is well known that implementation of research evidence into clinical practice is an important component of any health care practice , . However, research findings are inadequately disseminated and translated to practitioners, and practitioners tend to resist applying new information . Since the inception of EBM in the early 1990s