Evidence L Aw Assignment Paper

1011 words - 5 pages

In Attorney-General’s Reference (No.4 of 2002) , the Court of Appeal adopted an analogous approach. The court held that Art 6(2) requires the prosecution to prove the “true nature” or the “gravamen” of the offence. It appears that this requires the court to discover the rationale of the offence, including any elements of moral blameworthiness. The court took the view that the application is not dependant on a formal statutory separation of elements and defences. Some statutory defences might not form part of the “gravamen” of the offence, whereas others might. Lambert is a case of the latter where the issue of the defendant’s guilty knowledge of his possession of a controlled drug was part of the gravamen of the offence, but it appeared in the statute as a formal defence that imposed a reverse onus.
(3)Judicial deference
In relation to judicial deference, it is important to distinguish between the criteria of legitimacy and proportionality. The relevant questions to be ask is; (1) Is the reverse onus imposed in pursuance of a legitimate aim, and; (2) whether it is proportionate to the achievement of that aim.
For Laws L.J., deference is a way to resolve the tension between parliamentary sovereignty and fundamental rights created by the Human Rights Act. The question thus arises, how far should the court defer to the judgment of the Parliament? Dennis pointed to the statement of Lord Hope in R. v DPP Ex p. Kebilene where he said, “In some circumstances it will be appropriate for the courts to recognize that there is an area of judgment within which the judiciary will defer, on democratic grounds…” It appears that His Lordship recognized the need for judicial deference. After all, the courts are there to “assess the need for protection”. However, His Lordship failed to distinguish between the measures of legitimate aim and proportionality while identifying the limitations of judicial deference.
Similarly, in Johnstone, Lord Nicholls failed to distinguish between legitimacy and proportionality when he said, “…the court will reach a different conclusion from the legislature only when it is apparent the legislature has attached insufficient importance to the fundamental right of an individual to be presumed innocent until proven guilty.”
Dyson LJ once wrote an article in which he wondered if there is a need to question judicial deference. After all, all that matters is that the existence of deference or discretionary area of judgment is acknowledged by the courts and that it be applied with reasonable consistency. Dyson LJ also pointed out to the importance of deference in constitutional terms of ‘democratic principle’. According to Dyson LJ, ‘the democratic principle rationale is that deference is required to decisions made by the legislature and executive in relation to decisions which have serious potential results for the community’. He quoted Lord Hoffman in Secretary of State for the Home Department v Rehman , “such decisions...

Find Another Essay On Evidence LAw assignment paper

Reflective Argument Essay

2338 words - 10 pages now contain articles incorporating theories more so with utility in mind (A 6).” If this argument holds, then my assignment two demonstrates an ability to identify a change in conventions; as well as explaining why the change took place from a rhetorical position. The rationality for my assignment two paper demonstrating change within the journal relied on two important factors. First, the new rhetorical properties would be adopted by the authors

A Helpful Guide for Writers Essay

965 words - 4 pages A Helpful Guide for Writers Understanding the Assignment To fully understand your writing project, there are questions you should ask yourself when receiving it from the teacher. First, you should know when the assignment is due? What form is it due in? What the type of assignment it is? What are the goals and purpose in undertaking this assignment? Finally, how will your assignment be evaluated? Overview of Academic Essay- Thesis

The Argument Essay: Just Don't Do It!

612 words - 2 pages The Argument Paper: Just Don't Do It!   English 101 is incredibly challenging and overwhelming to the typical college student. A narrative reflective essay, an expository essay, a novel, and the Nelson-Denny Reading Comprehension test are all crammed into ten weeks of backbreaking work. However, the most intolerable assignment of all has not even been mentioned yet: the argument paper! Students run around shrieking and cursing when they

Assessment Issue Rubrics

639 words - 3 pages assist the students in properly completing an assignment. What the author of the articles says makes a lot of sense. A rubric shows a student exactly what is needed to obtain a high score on any given assignment. A good rubric will effectively do this task. The rubric can also serve as a reminder to a student that might be having difficulty recalling an item for an exam or for a paper. The author refers to rubrics as Instructional Rubrics

Anorexia: The Cheating Disorder, by Richard Murphy

1074 words - 4 pages training on how to handle the matter of plagiarism with his students because he accused her without any concrete evidence, just from a hunch. It is no wonder he is unsatisfied with the student’s confession. Murphy discovers the truth, that it had been her own experience, after reading her journal entries on the subject at the end of the semester, after he had interrogated and failed her on the assignment. Rightfully shocked, he notes that “Their

Categories and Types of Evidence and their Use in the Courtroom

1551 words - 6 pages , parties and juries give out then closely inspect the different forms of proof ata court trial is all governed by the law of evidence. In a way, evidence forms an extension ofcriminal procedure. It also forms an extension of civil law. In the Unites States, the FederalRules of Evidence (FRE) are the rules the federal courts follow. Most of the laws of evidence areencompassed in the Federal Rules of Evidence. The Federal Rules of Evidence has played

How to dream

1484 words - 6 pages problem. If you see a red dot on your paper, I'm watching you. If this happens twice in the same exam, testing integrity has been compromised. You will fail the course and be subjected to further penalties under East Georgia State College policy on academic dishonesty.This syllabus is subject to change at the discretion of the instructor.APPENDIX - EGSC Critical Thinking InitiativeTenets of Critical ThinkingThe assignment should require an original

Research Paper

1638 words - 7 pages disciplines of history, political science, economics, law, and reading. The textbook has a large section on Greece and Ancient Greece. In fact, it has a detailed few pages regarding 3 Greek scholars. They focus in on Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle specifically and provides sufficient information on three’s background and ideas. Some limitations for this source includes its biasness and its broadness. The next source for the research paper is

Understanding Relevance Legal Standard

985 words - 4 pages fact (probative value)”(Britz, 2008, p. 344). In this paper, an examination of the legal standard of relevance evidence will be discussed. Furthermore, the rules of inclusion and exclusion of evidence based on the wording of the rules will be scrutinized. In the final section, examples of evidence will be presented that could be both relevant and irrelevant for certain crime. As mentioned earlier relevance evidence refers to any material fact

Critical Issues of Female Managers and International Assignments

6277 words - 25 pages might increase the expatriate failure risks, but it seems to have no empirical evidence support this common belief. Most of the expatriates to date are men; therefore we can safely assume that men also contributed a relatively larger proportion of the expatriate failure rates. This paper looks at the underlying reasons for why female managers are undesirable and desirable for international assignments. As we should be clearer now, MNEs have the

Freehills Antiques Pty Ltd Advise Prudent Bank Ltd and the Ferrari Dealer whether they can enforce the contracts

2214 words - 9 pages Untitled VICTORIA UNIVERSITY FACULTY OF BUSINESS SCHOOL OF LAW Education Centre of Australia BLO 2205 CORPORATE LAW ASSIGNMENT Semester 3 2012 Freddy and Fiona Freehill are officers and shareholders of Freehills Antiques Pty Ltd. The company specialises in expensive estate jewellery. The company has a credit facility with Prudent Bank Ltd, which the company uses regularly in its business. The company has a

Similar Essays

Social And Cultural Diversity Essay

1078 words - 4 pages using the research paper rubric criteria included below. Determine the level of achievement appropriate for each assignment criteria. (Levels of achievement range from 1 (Unsatisfactory) to 5 (Excellent), and are listed in italics across the top. Assignment criteria are found in bold on the left.)Assignment Criterion: Content Knowledge and Comprehension Criteria 1: Unsatisfactory 2: Less Than Satisfactory 3: Satisfactory 4: Good 5

Case Study

2496 words - 10 pages SECTION A: TO BE COMPLETED BY STUDENT This assignment cover sheet needs to be included with each assignment. Please complete all details clearly. If you are submitting your assignment on paper, please staple this sheet to the front of each assignment. If you are submitting your assignment online, please ensure this cover sheet is included in front your assignment. Please check your study guide for assignment submission deadline and

Independent Novel Project Essay

1074 words - 4 pages turnitin.com by the above deadline. If you are having trouble with the site, you should email your assignment to me as a Microsoft Word attachment by Thursday, December 18. If you send the document to me in another format, I will not be able to open it, and you will be subject to the fifty percent late penalty. Do not send the work in the body of the email either. If I do not have the electronic file, I cannot upload the paper to turnitin.com. It

Comparing Similarities And Differences Between Medieval Europe, China And Islamic Countries

1768 words - 7 pages errors. Where appropriate, sources for facts, quotations, statistics and ideas are given in in-text citations that follow MLA style rules. The paper is accompanied by a works cited page that conforms with MLA rules if called for in the assignment. The paper follows instructions for the assignment carefully.C = 70-79 percent: A satisfactory paper. The paper demonstrates a basic understanding of the topic but contains little evidence of the author's