Evolution Essays Is Creation Science Really Science?

1193 words - 5 pages

Is "Creation Science" Really Science?

 
   "Creation science" fails two important tests of science: it neither makes predictions nor makes claims that can be empirically verified. It simply makes proclamations by faith. Furthermore, creation scientists have yet to offer any scientific evidence that proves the case of creationism; their efforts are almost entirely spent critiquing apparent contradictions within evolution. Finally, the scientific credentials of the creation scientists are what we might charitably describe as suspicious.

 

In the last few decades, a movement called "creation science" has gained considerable influence among Christian fundamentalists. According to Henry Morris, director of the Institute for Creation Research, their studies require "no reliance upon biblical revelation," but utilize "only scientific data to support and expound the creation model." (1) Specifically, this model is the literal interpretation of Genesis as it happened 6,000 years ago. Discoveries in both geology and biology were already deconstructing this model by the mid-19th century, and by the turn of the 20th century most fundamentalists had simply conceded the scientific fight to evolutionists. In recent times, however, creationists have become determined to resurrect their scientific case, and fight against evolutionists on their own ground.

 

By presenting the creation model as science, creationists have re-raised the question of what "science" is. Philosophers of science have worked out a commonly accepted list of criteria (produced well outside the debate between creationists and evolutionists). To be accepted as science, a theory must have predictive value, must be coherent (or internally consistent), must be falsifiable (or verifiable), and must explain at least those phenomena explained by the current theory.

 

Creation science fails to meet these criteria in several ways. First, its claims are not falsifiable. (This doesn't mean a theory has to be false -- only that if it were false, there would be some way of verifying it. It's the same thing as being vulnerable without actually being hurt.) If you were to claim that life exists on a planet orbiting the star Alpha Centauri, that would not qualify as science because there is no way of verifying it. It merely becomes an unsupported assertion. The claim that God made the earth is likewise unverifiable... no one has yet found any way to test this claim. Evolution, on the other hand, has made countless claims that have the capacity to be proven false, if indeed they are.

 

Second, creationism has no predictive value. A theory must be able to make predictions which can then be tested for accuracy. Creation science makes "predictions" that already happened in the past or are unfalsifiable. Evolutionary theory passes this test because it has made accurate predictions concerning population densities, physiologies, chemistries, fossil find forecasts, and many...

Find Another Essay On Evolution Essays - Is Creation Science Really Science?

Evolution: The debate of science and religion

843 words - 3 pages turn taken over belief. This has created a gap between science and religion. While Christians are dedicated in their belief of God, Fynman states that scientists are "atheist at heart". The only way to try fill this gap, which will ultimately help both the scientific view and the religious view coincide together, is to first examine evolution and second try to find a medium between the two view points. Even though, science may prove many natural

Science and Technology: Are they really a success?

762 words - 3 pages Science and technology are what shape society today and humans take great pride in the success they have had in technological and scientific developments.Many look upon science and technology as the secret of the worlds success. But is todays exceedingly advanced technology really a step towards success?? Or just a step towards the dehumanization of mankind.A success is defined as something that turns out satisfactorily.Lets take a look at some

Religion and Science: A Metaphysical Approach to Evolution

1487 words - 6 pages concepts, you have to let more in to ones frame rather than rejecting it and saying it has to work within the guidelines set down by Naturalism(sam) (Griffin). Is that idea no different than saying “God did it”, so shouldn’t these fallacies be stated to impressionable children before they learn it as fact. Creation “Science” Issues for teaching creation along side of evolution are many, the most obvious is the separation of church and state

Criticism of the journal ‘Creation of a Bacterial Cell Controlled by a Chemically Synthesized Genome’ by Gibson et al., published in Science on the 2nd of July 2010.

1528 words - 6 pages LIN1603 Assignment Critical Evaluation of a Scientific PaperIntroductionThe paper, chosen for critique is 'Creation of a Bacterial Cell Controlled by a Chemically Synthesized Genome' by Gibson et al., published in Science on the 2nd of July 2010.1Summary of PaperThe paper reports the experiment which was carried out by Craig Venter and his research team. Synthesis of the genome of a bacterial cell and the transplantation of such genome into

Science report on the creation of a small transistor radio

654 words - 3 pages cardTools:Soldering ironSolder wireClippersInsulating tapeMethodStep one: Making the coil aerialFirstly I took the thin card and wrapped it around the ferrite rod. Then wrapped the enameled copper wire around the ferrite rod approximately 55 times. Leaving about 10cm free at either end so that it could be attached to the circuit board easily. Because of the card the wire was able to slide up and down the rod. Which is essential if I am to

Scientific criticism of the journal ‘Creation of a Bacterial Cell Controlled by a Chemically Synthesized Genome’ by Gibson et al., published in Science on the 2nd of July 2010.

1535 words - 6 pages LIN1603 Assignment Critical Evaluation of a Scientific PaperIntroductionThe paper, chosen for critique is 'Creation of a Bacterial Cell Controlled by a Chemically Synthesized Genome' by Gibson et al., published in Science on the 2nd of July 2010.1Summary of PaperThe paper reports the experiment which was carried out by Craig Venter and his research team. Synthesis of the genome of a bacterial cell and the transplantation of such genome into

What Is Science; Is Medicine A Science?

3273 words - 13 pages What is science; is medicine a science? What is science? Distinctions In addressing this topic, the first question to focus on, is how one defines a science. Some would say that a more distinct line could be drawn between what is a science and what is definitely not a science (a non-science). Science is traditionally personified by objectivity. Ideally, bias has absolutely no place here, and it is through this objectivity one hopes to understand

Is There One Science, Western Science?

1484 words - 6 pages evolution of science would be ludicrous and amount to denying other contributors claim to ownership of their respective contributions to this process and is this claim to exclusive ownership that Okere finds troublesome (Okere, 2005: 26). 3. Science and Africa As mentioned, that which we know as science, owes credit to the ancient Egyptians. This scientific outlook should however not be limited to the Egyptian contributions to science

What is Science

846 words - 3 pages , science is the same it is subjective, it is contentious, it can be constructed, philosophers have different views on what science really is and how it should be.According to Karl Popper, Science is science if it can be falsified, science is science if it can be tested or if it is observable.Thus if it is not observable then is it not science?It goes to the debate of Science and Religion. Since religion cannot be tested, and since religion is by faith

What is Social Science?

1367 words - 5 pages model, factors such as individual clinical expertise, patient preferences, values and circumstances...” (Thyer & Myers, 2011, p.18). As the premise of the EBP indicates the boundaries of objectivity must be crossed in order to prescribe appropriate treatment programs for patients and thus the ideals of positivist research transition to coincide with that of non-positivism. It is evident that through the creation of a social science and the

Creationism is not Science

683 words - 3 pages Science by definition is the gathering of knowledge about the natural world through the use of observation, critical thinking, and experimentation. Pseudoscience is basically a belief or theory that acts as science but is not supported by the scientific method. It is used as a way to support non-evidence based beliefs which do not stand alone as truth. There are many examples of pseudoscience in our world today, but I intend to focus on the

Similar Essays

Evolution Essays Is There A Conspiracy To Suppress Creation Science?

591 words - 2 pages Is There a Conspiracy to Suppress "Creation Science"?   Two Works Cited   A frequent claim in creationist literature is that there is a wealth of scientific evidence to support creationism, but that secular, mainstream scientists are suppressing its publication in peer-reviewed journals. They are not giving creation-scientists a fair shake, they claim; they are being censored.  The fact is that creation scientists are

Evolution Of Science Essay

906 words - 4 pages The idea of a world progressing, or evolving, in science hasn’t been around forever. In fact, the Enlightenment period in the seventeen hundreds with scientists such as Isaac Newton the man who discovered gravity, Louis Pasteur the chemist who invented the vaccine to prevent rabies, Charles Darwin the father of evolution, Benjamin Franklin the first scientist to toy with the dangers and possibilities of electricity, and so many more wonderful

Whether The True Story Of Creation Is Religion Or Science

785 words - 3 pages Whether the True Story of Creation is Religion or Science For centuries, the battle has been raging between science and religion over the question of how man came into being. The two opposing forces have clashed countless times in history, with such violent conflicts as to result in bloodshed and death. Probably the most controversial issue debated by the two sides is the creation of everything in the universe, from stars and planets to

My Essay Is Called Science Verses Religion The Creation Dilemma. I Hope It Will Help You.

574 words - 2 pages Science verses religion - The Creation Dilemma Faith is believing in things when common sense tells you not to. - George Seaton Science verses Religion. It has always been this way since the beginning of time, literally. It is very difficult to choose one over the other because one is based on fact and logic while the other is built on faith and hope. That's exactly what the Creation theory is, beliefs in a superior supernatural being whereas