Evolution Vs Intelligent Design Essay

3380 words - 14 pages

The suggested separation between church and state in contemporary America is not what the framers of our constitution and our country had in mind as they wrote the words “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” After deconstructing the words, the most insignificant adjective “an,” tells us that the framers wanted to restrain Congress from installing any one religion as the official religion of the state. Those immortal words say nothing about religion informing congress or society on policy, education, or progress. I maintain that the first amendment’s establishment clause regarding religion was to protect citizens’ free exercise of religion from state interests and not to protect state interests from religion. So while the idea of separation between church and state is aged, it is also radically inaccurate and a misinterpretation of the first amendment. In fact the assumed existence and enactment of such a radical ideal has caused a violation of the ninth amendment as well which states, “The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people.” I ascertain that restriction in education against material because of its source, intelligent design’s (ID) link to creationism in this case, is a violation of the first amendment’s free speech clause and further misinterpretation of the first amendment to exclude material because of its arguably religious source is a violation of the ninth amendment. For these reasons in this document I am going to assess popular evolutionary theory versus the ID argument to expose both as religious worldviews that should be taught not in science class but in philosophy class at the primary level.

First comparing the two theories, I’ll first identify what the theories are. Darwinian evolution is the theory that life after appearance and over time endured mutation and adaptation through natural selection to eventually yield modern man from the same source, a single cell. ID is the theory that life exists in its present forms as the product of a purposeful design. Both theories use natural science to support their ideological conclusions such as embryology, genetics, and biochemistry. A key to these theories being comparable is that they both suggest that a preexisting being sparked life on Earth. Within evolution this point is highly debated and denied by many, however the father of evolution, Charles Darwin, expressed in the Origin of Species his belief that the first cell received its spark of life “by the Creator.” (Darwin 1900, 316) This will soon be important as a reason why evolution should not be taught in public education at all if you believe that the first amendment means a separation between church and state as evolution at its roots tells us that God created life on earth. ID at its roots also asserts that an entity also lit the initial sparks of life...

Find Another Essay On Evolution vs Intelligent Design

Evolution, Intelligent Design, and Creationism in Schools

822 words - 4 pages Evolution, Intelligent Design, and Creationism in Schools Human beings are curious by nature. Science exemplifies this inherent nature that most people feel at least to some extent. Science is the art of asking why. Why does the moon sometimes look like a perfect circle, a semi-circle, or disappears all together? Why do things fall to the ground when they are dropped? Why can a chair support a person against the force pulling him or her down

Position Paper: Should Intelligent Design and/or Creationism Be Taught Alongside Evolution in Public Schools?

901 words - 4 pages 2012. Web. 18 May 2014. . Defending the Teaching of Evolution and Climate Change . National Center for Science Education , 2012. Web. 18 May 2014. . Ruse, Michael. "Intelligent Design Should Be Taught in Religion Classes, Not Science." Intelligent Design vs. Evolution. Ed. Louise Gerdes. Detroit: Greenhaven Press, 2007. At Issue. Rpt. from "Keep

Time to Hit the Holy Books: Evolution and Intelligent Design in the Classroom

1386 words - 6 pages phenomena such as lightning, the rising and setting of the sun, and disease, the average person would be quickly convinced as to the validity of Intelligent Design. However, what Paley fails to recognize (mostly because science has advanced further than where it was in the 18th century, when Paley was alive) is that there are completely natural explanations for the origins of life. Consider the study of abiogenesis, or chemical evolution, which

Guided Evolution and Intelligent design: A Guide to the Jewish Perspective

1328 words - 6 pages potentia. Works Cited Daniel Dennett, "Truths That Miss Their Mark," Science and Religion: Are They Compatible, (New York, NY: Oxford University Press, 2011), 27. Alvin Plantinga, "Naturalism Against Science," IBID, 62. Alvin Plantinga, "Where the Conflict Really Lies," IBID, 4. Ira Robinson, "American Jewish Views of Evolution and Intelligent design," Modern Judaism, 27, no. 2 (2007): 173-192, http://mj.oxfordjournals.org/content

Intelligent Design vs. Natural Selection

1505 words - 6 pages Since the day that Charles Darwin imposed his theory of Evolution and therefore his idea of natural selections there has been a debate between the theory of evolution and the theory of creationism. The main part of the debate lays in the question: Where did we can from? What made or created the earth and all living thing around us? Was it an Intelligent Design by a God? Or simply was it evolution? I say the debate needed to end because it is

Intelligent Design: An Intelligent Way of Disguising Religion

1411 words - 6 pages . Vanessa Tovell. PBS. 13 Nov. 2007. Television. Transcript. Reuland, Steve. "Intelligent Design vs. Creationism." The Panda's Thumb. 9 Nov. 2005. Web. 15 Nov. 2011. . West, John G. "Intelligent Design Research Lab Highlighted in New Scientist." Evolution News & Views. Discovery Institute, 19 Dec. 2006. Web. 16 Nov. 2011.

Intelligent Design Should be Taught in School as a Science

1587 words - 7 pages few generations intelligent design will be the mandatory science course for all students, while evolution is only taught in history class. Works Cited Dembiski,William. “Pandas and People” Theory of ID. Areginton,NC. Tom Mayer united. 2006. 3 www.intelligentdesign.org/ Green, Kim. “Evolution on the Clock”. EVO vs. ID. Georgebrook, IN. Gang Green Co. 2005. 3 www.intelligentdesignnetwork.org/ Greggory, Thomas. “ID Laws

Evolution Vs. Creationism

1374 words - 5 pages biological systems are so complex that they could have arisen only through the action of an intelligent force and not through purely random evolutionary processes" (Monastersky, 2004). Dr. Meyer's statement in support of the intelligent design theory shows that natural evolution could not have developed humans because we are too intelligent. The theistic view shows some aspects of religion and supports substantiate information yet does not jump to


633 words - 3 pages intelligent design or creationism says that the earth is young, less than ten-thousand years old. In the web article “Evolution vs. Creationism” published in Africa News Service it says, “Our planet dates back to about 4.5 billion years ago, and life started around 3.5 billion years ago. Life started in water bodies, as single celled living organisms. This alone refutes creation, which, at best, it puts our planet at 6000 years old.” When intelligent

Evolution Through the Influence of God

2052 words - 8 pages evolution in public schools” (“ID vs. Evolution”). Evolution should be taught in schools to allow students make independent decisions on choosing their faith. To accommodate those who believe in God and clear evidence of evolution, the intelligent design theory was established. Creation science or ID theory, attempts to justify the idea of creationism on scientific grounds (“Evolution”). “Intelligent design casts doubt on evolution by claiming

Entering the Discourse

978 words - 4 pages Evolution and Intelligent Design being taught in public schools is a growing controversy. Both supporters and augmenters have been clashing over different perspectives on wither intelligent design should replace evolution as part of the scientific curriculum. The controversy has lead to multiple court cases and religious dispute. The main issue when it comes to teaching this idea of science in our schools is the idea of conforming to an idea

Similar Essays

Evolution Vs. Intelligent Design In Public Schools

1520 words - 6 pages Historical Perspective on the Conflict over Teaching Evolution in the Schools." EbscoHost. MARHO, n.d. Web. 5 Nov. 2013. . Marjorie, George. "AND THEN GOD CREATED KANSAS? THE EVOLUTION/CREATIONISM DEBATE IN AMERICA'S PUBLIC SCHOOLS." 149.3 (2001): n. pag. EbscoHost. Web. 7 Nov. 2013. O'Keefe, John M.. "Intelligent Design Vs. Evolution." Personal interview. 13 Nov. 2013. Wellman, Jack. "Teaching Intelligent Design Is Not a Separation of Church and State." Gale Opposing Viewpoints in Context. Elm4you, 2012. Web. 12 Nov. 2013.

Evolution Versus Intelligent Design Essay

1087 words - 5 pages Evolution VS. Intelligent Design There is a main difference between a theory and a fact. A theory is a logically connected group of tested propositions that are regarded as correct. It can be used as an explanation for an occurrence. A fact is something that actually exists and can be proven using factual evidence. The theory of evolution defined by Darwin is descent with modification. What Darwin means by that is that as the descendants of a

Chance, Evolution Or Intelligent Design Essay

704 words - 3 pages Most people state that life was created by intelligent design, pure chance, or even evolution. Although some would argue that evolution is basically chance in a different form, the opposite is true. Even though it would take quite a bit of chance for evolution to work out perfectly how Darwin said it did, it is still one organism developing into another over a long period of time. Compared to evolution, intelligent design is the concept that

Origins Of Life: Evolution Or Intelligent Design

583 words - 3 pages Houston and professor of Law at Jerry Falwell’s Liberty University, fought and won the battle to introduce intelligent design in the classroom. Ousting the scientific theory of evolution, according to its proponents, of its proper place. However, to truly grasp the essence of the controversy, one must understand the terminology of what school boards consensus as guiding definitions for science, the theory of evolution, and intelligent design