Ewing V. California/ Andrade V. California

1565 words - 6 pages

A sample of inmates released during this period was drawn from a list obtained from the Florida Department of Correction, for a total sample of roughly 3,793 offenders. Careful attention was given to securing a representative sample from each offense group. The offenders chosen were released from public and private state prisons after expiration of their sentences. The centralized idea of this study was to determine the differentiation between public and private state prisons focusing on recidivism. I have chosen two cases that reflect on the central issue of this topic and how they are treated by the Courts which can hopefully shed some light on the research problem as it exists in present society. These cases are based on California's legislative system which relate to the problem of recidivism in Florida.

In 1994, California legislators and voters approved a major change in the state's criminal sentencing law, (commonly known as Three Strikes and You're Out). The law was enacted as Chapter 12, Statutes of 1994 by the Legislature and by the electorate in Proposition 184 (Mullin, 1998). As its name suggests, the law requires, among other things, a minimum sentence of 25 years to life for three-time repeat offenders with multiple prior serious or violent felony convictions. The Legislature and voters passed the Three Strikes law after several high profile murders committed by ex-felons raised concern that violent offenders were being released from prison only to commit new, often serious and violent, crimes in the community.

Repeat offenders are perhaps the most difficult of criminal offenders for state

and local criminal justice systems to manage. These offenders are considered unresponsive to incarceration as a means of behavior modification, and undeterred by the prospect of serving time in prison. For this reason, longer sentences for this group of offenders have a strong appeal to policy makers and the public. Supporters of Proposition 184 argued that imposing lengthy sentences on repeat offenders would reduce crime in two ways (Mullin, 1998). First, extended sentences, also referred to as sentence enhancements, would remove repeat felons from society for longer periods of time, thereby restricting their ability to commit additional crimes. Second, the threat of such long sentences would discourage some offenders from committing new crimes (Mullin, 1998).

In March 2000, the defendant Gary Ewing entered a golf shop at the El Segundo Golf Course in Los Angeles County, California. He was caught in the parking lot with three Calloway golf clubs in his pants, which were valued at $399 each, for a total theft of $1197 (Ewing v. California). A jury found the defendant guilty of grand theft. The defendant has a lengthy criminal record dating back to 1984, with numerous misdemeanor and felony convictions. In 1993 he was convicted of first-degree robbery and three separate burglary convictions. His record also includes...

Find Another Essay On Ewing V. California/ Andrade V. California

Please describe the current three (3) strikes law in California. Also, give any solutions you feel would correct the problems that are now occuring. Please attach a bibliography.

2133 words - 9 pages convictions. Ewing was on parole in 1994 when he walked into a pro-shop in Los Angeles, stuffed three golf clubs down his pants leg, and limped out of the store. An employee called police, who arrested Ewing in the parking lot. He was charged with felony grand theft of property worth more than $400; this charge has become known as a "wobbler" in California because it can be classified as either a felony or misdemeanor (EWING v. CALIFORNIA). Despite

Proposition 184 in California "Three Strikes and You're Out!"

3099 words - 12 pages in California: The Impact of Three Strikes and You're Out, Institute of Governmental Studies Press, UC Berkeley, 1999          9.         Proposition 66: Limitations on "Three Strikes" Law. Sex Crimes. Punishment. Initiative Statute. Prepared by the Attorney General. Copyright 2004, California Secretary of State. http://www.voterguide.ss.ca.gov/propositions/prop66-title.htm          10.         Ewing v. California, 123 S.Ct. 1179 (2003) 11.         Lockyer v. Andrade, 123 S.Ct. 1166 (2003)

The California Three-Stike Law

2842 words - 11 pages misdemeanor petty theft crime, punishable by a fine or a jail sentence of up to six months or less (California Penal Code-297 Ann. 490). “Petty theft with a prior conviction for a property offense” however is a felony (California Penal Code- 434 Ann. 666). Leandro Andrade was convicted in 1995 to 50 years to life for the theft of 9 children’s video tapes from two different K-marts on two different occasions. Andrade had 3 resident burglary arrests in

Revisiting Regulation Changing Cases

1264 words - 5 pages Throughout history, there have been numerous litigations that pertain to an individual’s Fourth Amendment rights; however, there are three proceedings that changed the way law enforcement is able to search and seize properties in order for it to be admissible in court. The outcomes of Weeks v. United States, Silverthorne Lumber Company, Inc. v. United States, and Mapp v. Ohio created regulations that gave the American citizens back their Fourth


970 words - 4 pages adopted in many states in the 1990's and early 2000's in the wake of the decision of the Hawaii Supreme Court in Baehr v. Lewin, supra and of Congress' enactment of the federal Defense of Marriage Act. Following the passage of Proposition 22, several lawsuits were filed seeking to have the new marriage laws declared unconstitutional because they violated the California Constitution. The lawsuits were consolidated into one case, In Re the Marriage

LAws are the solution

982 words - 4 pages should not be as harsh or punished as violent crime as they are not the same. However, under the mandatory minimum sentencing law, they are considered equal and should be punished equally. A study on 2010 showed that 344 people in California are serving a life sentence for shoplifting small amounts of merchandise and more than 650 people are also serving life sentences for possessing small quantities of drugs, (Chemerinsky, 2010). Such punishments

The Study of Affirmative Action

1740 words - 7 pages discrimination (Stewart 2014). His case first went to the Yolo County, California district court where the court ruled in favor of Bakke completely (Baldwin 2009). The use of race in admission processes was now not allowed in the state of California. It was appealed and accepted by the Supreme Court and is known as Regents of the University of California v. Bakke. Allan Bakke had a lot going against him with the United States just starting to

This is an essay that describes how the 4th ammendamant effects law enforcement in America. This was used in Criminal Justice 101.

1013 words - 4 pages the right to fight the grounds when the warrant was attained by means of a trial. In most situations, there are some exceptions. An officer is not allowed to get a search warrant if evidence to a crime is in plain view. In the case Horton v. California 1990, police entered a house with a warrant that was given to search the house for stolen jewelry. While searching the house they found illegal weapons in plain view. The officers seized weapons as

Brief Biography on Earl Warren, a United States Supreme Court Chief Justice.

712 words - 3 pages The "Superchief"Earl Warren is one of the most famous Chief Justice's to have ever served on the United States Supreme Court. His decisions made in court are those that still affect us to this very day. Throughout his life he held many offices of power. Besides being Chief Justice on the Supreme Court, he was the 30th Governor of the state of California and was also the California District Attorney.Earl Warren was born in Los Angeles, California

Illegal Immigrants Cause High Unemployment in Califorina

1280 words - 5 pages ): A3l. Preston, Julia. "Illegal Workers Swept from Jobs in ‘Silent Raids,’." New York Times (2010). Sumner, Daniel, José E. Bervejillo, and Nicolai V. Kuminoff. "The measure of California agriculture and its importance in the state’s economy." California Agriculture: Dimensions and Issues. J. Siebert (2003). Vergati, Jessica A., and Daniel A. Sumner. "Contributions of Agriculture to Employment and the Economy in Southern California." (2012).


520 words - 2 pages Asymptote je architektonické, dizajnérske a výskumné štúdio, ktoré v New Yorku založili v roku 1989manželia a architekti Hani Rashid a Lise Anne Couture. V štúdiu vznikajú projekty maximálne využívajúcesúčasné digitálne technólogie. Uznanie si táto dvojica získala realizáciou virtu&aacute

Similar Essays

Medina V California Essay

532 words - 2 pages Medina v. California (1992)The Area of Law that pertains to this case is Fourth and Fourteenth Amendment of the Constitution. The Due Process Clause permits a state to require that a defendant claiming incompetence to stand prove it through supporting evidence.The two parties involved in this case were the State of California and Teofilo Medina Jr. Medina is on trial for first degree murder.Previous decisions, such as Pate v. Robinson, Mathews v

Utah, California V. Secretary Of Transportation

1311 words - 5 pages and the conditions must be clearly identified to the states. Secondly, In the case Printz v. U.S., 521 U.S. 898, (1997), the courts decision found that Congress does not have the right to infringe upon states’ sovereign activities. Under the Tenth Amendment, Congress cannot “commandeer” either the legislative process of a state or the services of a state executive branch officials. California and Utah highways are involved in both intrastate and

Summary And Key Notes On The Case Of Regents Of The University Of California V. Bakke

845 words - 3 pages Regents of the University of California v. Bakke, 438 U.S. 265 (1978)Facts: Allan Bakke, a thirty-five-year-old white man, had twice applied for admission to the University of California Medical School at Davis. He was rejected both times. The school reserved sixteen places in each entering class of one hundred for "qualified" minorities, as part of the university's affirmative action program, in an effort to redress longstanding, unfair

Legal Brief Essay 3 Strikes Case

1078 words - 4 pages constantly committing crimes, no matter the seriousness, then they haven’t learned their lesson, and the punishments are not harsh enough for them to do so. It is the government’s job to take care of its nation, and ridding society of its criminals is doing just that. Andrade and Ewing both have a heavy criminal record, Andrade had five felonies, and Ewing was convicted of a violent robbery. They have been to prison and paid their dues